This paper investigates the effect of laminar-to-turbulent flame transition modeling on the prediction of cycle-to-cycle variations (CCVs) in large eddy simulation (LES) of spark-ignition (SI) engines. A laminar-to-turbulent flame transition model that describes the non-equilibrium sub-filter flame speed evolution during an early stage of flame kernel growth is developed. In the present model, the flame transition is characterized by the flame kernel size at which the flame transition ends, defined here as the flame transition scale. The proposed model captures the effects that variations in a turbulent flow field have on the evolution of early-stage burning rates, through variations in the flame transition scale. The proposed flame transition model is combined with the front propagation formulation (FPF) method and a spark-ignition model to predict CCVs in a gasoline direct injection SI engine. It is found that multi-cycle LES with the proposed flame transition model reproduces experimentally-observed CCVs satisfactorily. When the transition model is not considered or when variations in the transition process are neglected, CCVs are significantly under-predicted for the case considered here. These results indicate the importance of modeling the laminar-to-turbulent flame transition and the effect of turbulence on the transition process, when predicting CCVs, under certain engine conditions. The LES results are also used to analyze sources for variations in the flame transition. It is found, for the present engine case, that the most important source is the cycle-to-cycle variation in the turbulence dissipation rate, which is used to measure the strength of turbulence in the proposed model, near a spark plug. The large-scale velocity field and the variations of the laminar flame speed due to the mixture composition and thermal stratification are also found to be important factors to contribute to the variations in the flame transition.
HeywoodJB.Internal combustion engine fundamentals. New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 1988.
2.
OzdorNDulgerMSherE.Cyclic variability in spark ignition engines a literature survey. SAE Paper 940987, 1994.
3.
HillPG.Cyclic variations and turbulence structure in spark-ignition engines. Combust Flame1988; 72(1): 73–89.
4.
MatekunasFA.Modes and measures of cyclic combustion variability. SAE Paper 830337, 1983.
5.
YoungMB.Cyclic dispersion in the homogeneous-charge spark-ignition enginea literature survey. SAE Paper 810020, 1981.
6.
BodeJSchorrJKrügerCDreizlerABöhmB.Influence of three-dimensional in-cylinder flows on cycle-to-cycle variations in a fired stratified DISI engine measured by time-resolved dual-plane PIV. Proc Combust Inst2017; 36(3): 3477–3485.
7.
BuschbeckMBittnerNHalfmannTArndtS.Dependence of combustion dynamics in a gasoline engine upon the in-cylinder flow field, determined by high-speed PIV. Exp Fluids2012; 53(6): 1701–1712.
8.
DawCKennelMFinneyCConnollyF.Observing and modeling nonlinear dynamics in an internal combustion engine. Phys Rev E1998; 57(3): 2811.
9.
FinneyCEKaulBCDawCSWagnerRMEdwardsKDGreenJB.Invited review: a review of deterministic effects in cyclic variability of internal combustion engines. Int J Engine Res2015; 16(3): 366–378.
10.
DawCSFinneyCEATracyER.A review of symbolic analysis of experimental data. Rev Sci Instrum2003; 74(2): 915–930.
11.
HaworthDC.Large-eddy simulation of in-cylinder flows. Oil Gas Sci Technol1999; 54(2): 175–185.
12.
VermorelORichardSColinOAngelbergerCBenkenidaAVeynanteD.Towards the understanding of cyclic variability in a spark ignited engine using multi-cycle LES. Combust Flame2009; 156(8): 1525–1541.
13.
EnauxBGranetVVermorelOLacourdCPeradCAngelbergerdC.LES study of cycle-to-cycle variations in a spark ignition engine. Proc Combust Inst2011; 33(2): 3115–3122.
14.
KochJSchmittMWrightYMSteursKBoulouchosK.LES multi-cycle analysis of the combustion process in a small SI engine. SAE Int J Engine2014; 7(1): 269–285.
15.
FontanesiSdAdamoARutlandCJ.Large-Eddy simulation analysis of spark configuration effect on cycle-to-cycle variability of combustion and knock. Int J Engine Res2015; 16(3): 403–418.
16.
TruffinKAngelbergerCRichardSPeraC.Using large-eddy simulation and multivariate analysis to understand the sources of combustion cyclic variability in a spark-ignition engine. Combust Flame2015; 162(12): 4371–4390.
17.
SchmittMHuRWrightYMSolticPBoulouchosK.Multiple cycle LES simulations of a direct injection natural gas engine. Flow Turbul Combust2015; 95(4): 645–668.
18.
ZhaoLMoizAASomSFoglaNBybeeMWahiduzzamanS, et al. Examining the role of flame topologies and in-cylinder flow fields on cyclic variability in spark-ignited engines using large-eddy simulation. Int J Engine Res2018; 19(8): 886–904.
19.
RutlandC.Large-eddy simulations for internal combustion engines–a review. Int J Engine Res2011; 12(5): 421–451.
20.
ColinOBenkenidaAAngelbergerC.3D modeling of mixing, ignition and combustion phenomena in highly stratified gasoline engines. Oil Gas Sci Technol2003; 58(1): 47–62.
21.
GranetVVermorelOLacourCEnauxBDuguéVPoinsotT.Large-eddy simulation and experimental study of cycle-to-cycle variations of stable and unstable operating points in a spark ignition engine. Combust Flame2012; 159(4): 1562–1575.
22.
LacourCPeraC.An experimental database dedicated to the study and modelling of cyclic variability in spark-ignition engines with LES. SAE Paper 2011-01-1282, 2011.
23.
PitschH.A consistent level set formulation for large-eddy simulation of premixed turbulent combustion. Combust Flame2005; 143(4): 587–598.
24.
BerettaGRashidiMKeckJ.Turbulent flame propagation and combustion in spark ignition engines. Combust Flame1983; 52: 217–245.
25.
KalghatgiGT.Spark ignition, early flame development and cyclic variation in IC engines. SAE Paper 870163, 1987.
26.
SchiffmannPReussDLSickV.Empirical investigation of spark-ignited flame-initiation cycle-to-cycle variability in a homogeneous charge reciprocating engine. Int J Engine Res2018; 19(5): 491–508.
27.
KeckJCHeywoodJBNoskeG.Early flame development and burning rates in spark ignition engines and their cyclic variability. SAE Paper 870164, 1987.
28.
ZengWKeumSKuoTWSickV.Role of large scale flow features on cycle-to-cycle variations of spark-ignited flame-initiation and its transition to turbulent combustion. Proc Combust Inst2019; 37(4): 4945–4953.
29.
AbrahamJBraccoFReitzR.Comparisons of computed and measured premixed charge engine combustion. Combust Flame1985; 60(3): 309–322.
30.
BoudierPHenriotSPoinsotTBaritaudT.A model for turbulent flame ignition and propagation in spark ignition engines. Proc Combust Inst1992; 24(1): 503–510.
31.
TanZReitzRD.Modeling ignition and combustion in spark-ignition engines using a level set method. SAE Paper 2003-01-0722, 2003.
32.
TanZReitzRD.An ignition and combustion model based on the level-set method for spark ignition engine multidimensional modeling. Combust Flame2006; 145(1–2): 1–15.
33.
RichardSColinOVermorelOBenkenidaAAngelbergerCVeynanteD.Towards large eddy simulation of combustion in spark ignition engines. Proc Combust Inst2007; 31(2): 3059–3066.
34.
ColinOTruffinK.A spark ignition model for large eddy simulation based on an FSD transport equation (ISSIM-LES). Proc Combust Inst2011; 33(2): 3097–3104.
35.
ColinODucrosFVeynanteDPoinsotT.A thickened flame model for large eddy simulations of turbulent premixed combustion. Phys Fluids2000; 12(7): 1843–1863.
36.
CharletteFMeneveauCVeynanteD.A power-law flame wrinkling model for LES of premixed turbulent combustion part I: non-dynamic formulation and initial tests. Combust Flame2002; 131(1-2): 159–180.
37.
KeumSZhuGRonald GroverJZengWRutlandCKuoT-W.A semi-empirical laminar-to-turbulent flame transition model coupled with G equation for early flame kernel development and combustion in spark-ignition engines. Int J Engine Res. Epub ahead of print 19 July 2019. DOI:10.1177/1468087419864748 .
38.
PetersN.Turbulent combustion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
39.
PopeSB.Turbulent Flows. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
40.
KimSH.A front propagation formulation for under-resolved reaction fronts. J Comput Phys2015; 285: 193–207.
41.
KimSHSuY.Front propagation formulation for large eddy simulation of turbulent premixed flames. Combust Flame2020; 220: 439–454.
42.
PetersN.The turbulent burning velocity for large-scale and small-scale turbulence. J Fluid Mech1999; 384: 107–132.
43.
GülderOL. Correlations of laminar combustion data for alternative S.I. Engine fuels. SAE Paper 841000, 1984.
44.
RichardsKJSenecalPKPomraningE.CONVERGE manual version 2.3. Madison, WI: Convergent Science Inc., 2017.
45.
MetghalchiMKeckJC.Burning velocities of mixtures of air with methanol, isooctane, and indolene at high pressure and temperature. Combust Flame1982; 48: 191–210.
46.
LawCK.Combustion physics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
47.
PopeSB.CEQ: A Fortran library to compute equilibrium compositions using gibbs function continuation. http://tcg.mae.cornell.edu/CEQ (2003, accessed 02 March 2020).
48.
SzybistJPSplitterDA.Pressure and temperature effects on fuels with varying octane sensitivity at high load in SI engines. Combust Flame2017; 177: 49–66.
49.
BoronatVSplitterDChuahyFDF. Achieving diesel-like efficiency on a high stroke-to-bore ratio DISI engine under stoichiometric operation. SAE Paper 2020-01-0293, 2020.
50.
SzybistJPWagnonSWSplitterDPitzWJMehlM.The reduced effectiveness of EGR to mitigate knock at high loads in boosted SI engines. SAE Int J Engines2017; 10(5): 2305–2318.
PomraningE.Development of large eddy simulation turbulence models. PhD Thesis, University of WisconsinMadison, 2000.
53.
ReitzRD.Modeling atomization processes in high-pressure vaporizing sprays. Atom Spray Technol1987; 3(4): 309–337.
54.
ReitzRDDiwakarR.Structure of high-pressure fuel sprays. SAE Paper 870598, 1987.
55.
JosephDDBelangerJBeaversG.Breakup of a liquid drop suddenly exposed to a high-speed airstream. Int J Multiphas Flow1999; 25(6–7): 1263–1303.
56.
LiuABMatherDReitzRD.Modeling the effects of drop drag and breakup on fuel sprays. SAE Paper 930072, 1993.
57.
AmsdenAAO’RourkePJButlerTD.KIVA-2: A computer program for chemically reactive flows with sprays. Technical Report LA-11560-MS, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM, 1989.
58.
AmsdenAA.KIVA-3V: A block structured kiva program for engines with vertical or canted valves. Technical Report LA-13313-MS, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM, 1997.
59.
WernerHWengleH. Large-eddy simulation of turbulent flow over and around a cube in a plate channel. In: DurstFFriedrichRLaunderBEet al. (eds) Turbulent Shear Flows 8. Berlin: Springer, pp. 155–168.
60.
MouriauxSColinOVeynanteD.Adaptation of a dynamic wrinkling model to an engine configuration. Proc Combust Inst2017; 36(3): 3415–3422.
61.
AmeenMMMirzaeianMMilloFSomS.Numerical prediction of cyclic variability in a spark ignition engine using a parallel large eddy simulation approach. J Energy Resour Technol2018; 140(5): 052203.
62.
LumleyJL.Engines: an introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999.
63.
SzybistJPSplitterD.Effects of fuel composition on EGR dilution tolerance in spark ignited engines. SAE Int J Engines2016; 9(2): 819–831.
64.
SheatherS.A modern approach to regression with R. New York: Springer Science & Business Media, 2009.
