The Scottish Executive recently announced a significant increase in secure accommodation, amongst a raft of measures aimed at tackling youth crime. These developments represent a marked and sudden change in political direction, away from an emphasis on community-based welfare disposals towards more institutionally-based correctional interventions. This article outlines the history and legal basis of secure accommodation in Scotland and examines recent reviews concerning the need or otherwise for its expansion. Such reviews have consistently failed to support a need to increase the number of secure places available and this raises questions about whether the Scottish Executive’s decision is based on sound evidence. The article contends that the decision to expand reflects a populist but erroneous conception of secure accommodation as ajusticeoriented disposal. It is argued that secure accommodation is and should remain, located firmly within a welfare framework. Implications for youth justice and for the residential child care system more generally are considered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Audit Scotland (2002) Dealing with Offending by Young Peoplewww.audit-scotland.gov.uk/publications/pdf/02pf06eag.pdfAuditor General Accounts Commission , retrieved 23 Aug 2003.
2.
Batchelor, S. and McNeill, F. (2004) The Young Person-Worker Relationship, in Bateman, T. and Pitts, J. (Eds.) The Russell House Companion to Youth Justice. London, Russell House Publishing .
3.
Butler, I. and Drakeford, M. (2001) Which Blair Project? Communitarianism, Social Authoritarianism and Social Work . Journal of Social Work. 1:1, 7-24 .
4.
Fulcher, L. and Ainsworth, F. (1985) Group Care Practice with Children. London, Tavistock .
5.
Goldson, B. (1995) A Sense of Security: Curricula for the Induction and Training of Staff in Secure Accommodation. London, NCB .
6.
Goldson, B. and Gabbidon, P. (1997) Securing Best Practice: An Induction Manual for Residential Staff Working in Secure Accommodation. London, NCB .
7.
Goldson, B. (2002) Vulnerable Inside: Children in Secure and Penal Settings. London, The Children’s Society .
8.
Harris, R. and Timms, N. (1993) Secure Accommodation in Child Care: Between Hospital and Prison or Thereabouts. London, Routledge .
9.
Heron, G. and Chakrabarti, M. (2002) Examining the Perceptions and Attitudes of Staff Working in Community Based Children’s Homes: Are Their Needs Being Met?Qualitative Social Work. 1:3, 341-358 .
10.
Hill, M. (2003) Fast Track Hearings Research, Interim Report. Scottish Executive. www.scotland.gov.uk/library5/education/fasttrack03.pdf, retrieved on 27/2/04.
11.
Hodgkin, R. (1995). Safe to Let Out? The Current and Future Use of Secure Accommodation for Children and Young People. London, National Children’s Bureau .
12.
Holloway, R. (2003) cited in society.guardian.co.uk/societyguardian/story Wednesday May 28, 2003, retrieved 19 Aug 2004.
13.
Kelly, B. and Littlewood, P. (1983) Factors Underlying the Referrals and Committals Processes Relating to a Secure Unit for Young People (1). Report to the Social Work Services Group. University of Glasgow, Department of Sociology .
14.
Kelly, B. and Littlewood, P. (1985a) Factors Underlying the Referrals and Committals Processes Relating to a Secure Unit for Young People (2). Report to the Social Work Services Group. University of Glasgow, Department of Sociology .
15.
Kelly, B. and Littlewood, P. (1985b) A Sociological Study of Life in a Secure Unit for Young People. Report to the Social Work Services Group. University of Glasgow, Department of Sociology .
16.
Kendrick, A. and Fraser, A. (1992) Summary of the Literature Review, in Another Kind of Home: A Review of Residential Child Care. Social Work Services Inspectorate. Edinburgh, HMSO .
17.
Kilbrandon, Lord (1964) The Report of the Committee on Children and Young Persons in Scotland. Edinburgh, HMSO .
18.
McGuire, J. (Ed.) (1995) What Works: Reducing Offending. Chichester, Wiley .
19.
McNeil, F. and Batchelor, S. (2004) Persistent Offending by Young People: Developing Practice Issues in Community and Criminal Justice. Monograph 3. London, NAPO .
20.
Millham, S. , Bullock, R. and Hosie, K. (1978) Locking Up Children: Secure Provision within the Child-care System. Farnborough, Saxon House .
21.
NCH Scotland (2003) www.nch.org.uk/kilbrandonnow, retrieved June 24 2004.
22.
Paterson, L. (2000) Scottish Democracy and Scottish Utopias: The First Year of the Scottish Parliament . Scottish Affairs. 33, 45-61 .
23.
Paterson, S. , Watson, D. and Whiteford, J. (2003). Let’s Face It! Care 2003: Young People Tell Us How It Is. Glasgow, Who Cares? Scotland .
24.
Pitts, J. (2001) Youth Justice, in Community Care Research Matters11.
25.
Petrie, C. (1980) The Nowhere Boys. Farnborough, Saxon House .
26.
Rose, J. (2002) Working with Young People in Secure Accommodation; From Chaos to Culture. Hove, Brunner Routledge .
Scottish Executive (2002d) Extra Secure Places for Young Offenders. Scottish Executive , press release 18 September 2002.
31.
Smith, M. (2003) Towards a Professional Identity: Is Residential Child Care Still Social Work?Journal of Social Work. 3:2, 235-252 .
32.
Smith, M. , McKay, E. and Chakrabarti, M. (2004) School Improvement in the Marketplace: the Case of Residential Special Education . Improving Schools. 7: 1 .
33.
Social Work Services Group . (1985) Code of Practice: The Use of Secure Accommodation for Children. Edinburgh, SWSG .
34.
Social Work Services Inspectorate for Scotland (1996). A Secure Remedy: A Review of the Role, Availability and Quality of Secure Accommodation for Children in Scotland. Edinburgh: SWSI .
35.
Social Work Services Inspectorate for Scotland . (1999) The Report of the National Planning Group on Care and Education Services for Young People with Behavioural Problems which include Offending. Edinburgh, SWSI .
36.
Stewart, G. and Tutt, N. (1987) Children in Custody. Aldershot, Avebury .
37.
Stevens, I. (2004). Cognitive-Behavioural Interventions in Residential Child Care in Scotland: An Examination of Practice and Lessons for Research . Child and Family Social Work. 9: 237-324 .
38.
Sunday Herald (15 February 2004) Why Labour has the young in its sights.
