Approving the Prosecution of Young Children in China: A Dangerous Choice?

Abstract

In criminal research, there exists an enduring question: ‘How old should a person be in order to be treated as an adult for purposes of criminal prosecution?’ The recent Amendment XI to the Criminal Law of China has not only lowered the minimum age of criminal responsibility but also established a procedure for the prosecution of young children. This article conducts a detailed examination of China’s minimum age of criminal responsibility and the procedures for the recent approval of prosecuting young children. It contends that China’s Amendment XI is an important measure that should be adopted to ensure the safety and well-being of society.

Keywords

Amendment XI to the criminal law of the PRC approving the prosecution of young children juvenile delinquency minimum age of criminal responsibility

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aguilar

MVG

Gumiran

ACS

(2020) On lowering the age of criminal responsibility: Perspectives from Philippine local government officials. Journal of BIMP-EAGA Regional Development 6(1): 1–18.

Amnesty International (2018) The Sky Is the Limit: Keeping Children Out of Prison by Raising the Age of Criminal Responsibility. London: Amnesty International.

Australian Human Rights Commission (2021) The Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Australian Human Rights Commission.

Australian Medical Association (2019) AMA calls for age of criminal responsibility to be raised to 14 years of age, 25 March. Available at: https://www.ama.com.au/media/ama-calls-age-criminal-responsibility-be-raised-14-years-age#:~:text=The%20AMA%20is%20calling%20for,by%20the%20criminal%20justice%20system.

Badaru

(2023) An analysis of the implementation of diversion in the juvenile criminal court system. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development 11(12): e2081.

Beijing Youth Daily (2020) 低龄未成年人刑责范围拟再调整 [Adjustment Proposed Again for the Scope of Criminal Responsibility of Young Minors], 22 December. Available at: https://emxpert.net/sageedit/journals/?token=FFBC164B-C45F-457E-A

Binder

Geis

Bruce

Jr (1988) Juvenile Delinquency: Historical, Cultural & Legal Perspectives. New York: Routledge.

Brown

Charles

(2021) The minimum age of criminal responsibility: The need for a holistic approach. Youth Justice 21(2): 153–171.

CE Noticias Financieras (2022) A minister of Horacio Rodriguez Larreta called for lowering the age of criminal responsibility to 14 years of age, 21 July. Available at: https://www.proquest.com/wire-feeds/minister-horacio-rodriguez-larreta-called/docview/2693020895/se-2

10.

Cipriani

(2016) Children’s Rights and the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A Global Perspective. New York: Routledge.

11.

Clarke

(2022) Order and law in China. University of Illinois Law Review 2022: 541–596.

12.

Crofts

(2016) The common law influence over the age of criminal responsibility in Australia. The Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 67: 283–300.

13.

Crofts

(2019) Will Australia raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility? Criminal Law Journal 43(1): 26–40.

14.

Crofts

(2023) Act now: Raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility. Current Issues in Criminal Justice 35(1): 118–138.

15.

Cunneen

(2020) Arguments for Raising the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Jumbunna Institute for Indigenous Education and Research, UTS.

16.

Fowler

Kurlychek

(2018) Drawing the line: Empirical recidivism results from a natural experiment raising the age of criminal responsibility. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice 16(3): 263–278.

17.

Goldson

(2013) Unsafe, unjust and harmful to wider society: Grounds for raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales. Youth Justice 13(2): 111–130.

18.

Goldson

(ed.) (2019) Youth Justice: Contemporary Policy and Practice. New York: Routledge.

19.

Guo

(2016) 未成年人犯罪低龄化问题之应对——以 ‘恶意补足年龄’规则为借鉴 [Responding to the issue of juvenile crime at a younger age: Taking the ‘malicious age supplement’ rule as a reference]. 青年研究 [Youth Studies] 6: 51–59 (in Chinese).

20.

Gupta-Kagan

(2021) Beyond ‘children are different’: The revolution in juvenile intake and sentencing. Washington Law Review 96(2): 425–492.

21.

Haysom

(2022) Raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility to 14 years. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health 58(9): 1504–1507.

22.

Jiang

(2022) 联合国成员国最低刑事责任年龄研究 [Study on the minimum age of criminal responsibility of United Nations member states]. 法律科学 (西北政法大学学报) [Legal Science Magazine (Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law)] 40(2): 89–100 (in Chinese).

23.

Katherine Times (2022) Opinion: Raising age of criminal responsibility won’t make community safer, 15 October. Available at: https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/7941923/raising-age-of-criminal-responsibility-wont-make-community-safer/

24.

Kean

(1937) The history of the criminal liability of children. Law Quarterly Review 53: 364–370.

25.

Law Council of Australia (2021) Consideration of raising minimum age of criminal responsibility doesn’t go far enough. Media Release, 16 November. Available at: https://lawcouncil.au/media/media-releases/consideration-of-raising-minimum-age-of-criminal-responsibility-doesn-t-go-far-enough#:~:text=%E2%80%9CThe%20minimum%20age%20of%20criminal,begins%20a%20cycle%20of%20criminalisation.

26.

Liu

(2020) 论降低刑事责任年龄起点的不可行性 [On the infeasibility of lowering the starting point of the age of criminal responsibility]. 法学杂志 [Law Science Magazine] 41(7): 121–131 (in Chinese).

27.

Maeda

(2016) The deterrent effects of the revised juvenile offender laws in Japan. Southern Illinois University at Carbondale. Available at: https://opensiuc.lib.siu.edu/theses/2035/

28.

Man

(2021) 未成年人利益最佳与刑事责任年龄的降低——兼评《刑法修正案(十一)》第一条 [The best interests of minors and the reduction of the age of criminal responsibility: A review of Article 1 of the Criminal Law Amendment (XI)]. 河北法学 [Hebei Law Science] 39(7): 91–110 (in Chinese).

29.

McAra

McVie

(2023) Raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility: Lessons from the Scottish experience. Current Issues in Criminal Justice. Epub ahead of print 25 October. DOI: 10.1080/10345329.2023.2272362.

30.

McKenzie

(2018) Bid to raise age of criminal responsibility: MSPs back raising age from eight to 12 after country criticised by UN. The Scotsman, 8 November. Available at: https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/msps-unanimously-back-move-to-raise-criminal-age-of-responsibility-to-12-217005

31.

Mingxuan

(2020) 中华人民共和国刑法的孕育和诞生 [The Birth and Development of the Criminal Law of the People’s Republic of China]. Beijing, China: Peking University Press, 10–11 (in Chinese).

32.

Murray

Carr

(2021) The criminal justice system in Northern Ireland. In: Case

Case

Manlow

, et al (eds) The Oxford Textbook on Criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 4–5.

33.

National Legal Aid (2020) Council of attorneys-general – Age of criminal responsibility working group review. Submission from National Legal Aid, 28 February. Available at: https://www.publicguardian.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/656502/council-of-attorneys-general-age-of-criminal-responsibility-working-group-review-opg-submission.pdf

34.

O’Brien

Fitzgibbon

(2017) The minimum age of criminal responsibility in Victoria (Australia): Examining stakeholders’ views and the need for principled reform. Youth Justice 17(2): 134–152.

35.

Párkányi

(2019) Three faces of the ‘post-socialist’ juvenile justice systems. Youth Justice 19(3): 222–237.

36.

Petoft

Abbasi

(2022) Children’s criminal perception; lessons from neurolaw. Child Indicators Research 15(5): 1905–1920.

37.

Pillay

(2019) The minimum age of criminal responsibility, international variation, and the dual systems model in neurodevelopment. Journal of Child & Adolescent Mental Health 31(3): 224–234.

38.

Platt

Diamond

(1966) The origins of the right and wrong test of criminal responsibility and its subsequent development in the United States: An historical survey. California Law Review 54: 1227–1260.

39.

Putri

Hartiwiningsih

Handayani

IGAKR

(2024) Implications of restorative justice in juvenile criminal law and the state economy. In: International conference on law, economic & good governance (IC-LAW 2023), 22 February, 528–533. Tengah Indonesia, Amsterdam: Atlantis Press.

40.

Rahmadani

Hartiwiningsih

Sulistyanta

(2024) The law enforcement against teenagers as perpetrators of bullying from the perspective of victim justice. In: International conference on law, economic & good governance (IC-LAW 2023), 22 February, 185–190. Tengah Indonesia, Amsterdam: Atlantis Press.

41.

Royal Commission (2017) The protection and detention of children in the Northern territory. Available at: https://www.royalcommission.gov.au/child-detention

42.

Schwarzenegger

(2003) The debate about the reform of the juvenile law in Japan. In: Foljanty-Jost

(ed.) Juvenile Delinquency in Japan. Leiden: Brill, 173–198.

43.

Shoebridge

(2021) Children (Criminal Proceedings) Amendment (Age of Criminal Responsibility) Bill 2021. Sydney NSW, Australia: Second Reading Speech, NSW, Legislative Council, Hansard.

44.

Singh

(2023) Old enough to offend but not to buy a hamster: The argument for raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 30(1): 51–67.

45.

Song

(2022) 儿童利益最大化原则在刑事诉讼中的贯彻. [The principle of maximizing children’s interests in criminal proceedings]. 中国青年社会科学 [Chinese Youth Social Science] 41(1): 117–129 (in Chinese).

46.

Squires

(2004) The criminal responsibility of children and young persons: A comparison of English and German law. International Criminal Justice Review 14(1): 196–198.

47.

Suzuki

Takeuchi

(2020) Future of youth justice in Japan. Youth Justice 20(3): 183–198.

48.

Tang

(2024) China’s criminal justice reforms against youth violence: Punishment with leniency? Journal of Youth Studies. Epub ahead of print 22 April. DOI: 10.1080/13676261.2024.2343721.

49.

Telford

(2012) The criminal responsibility of children and young people: An analysis of compliance with international human rights obligations in England and Wales. International Journal of Private Law 5: 107–120.

50.

Terry

(2022) Why we should not rush to raise the age of criminal responsibility in Australia. The Conversation, 1 September. Available at: https://theconversation.com/why-we-should-not-rush-to-raise-the-age-of-criminal-responsibility-in-australia-189463

51.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (1997) Concluding Observations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child: Australia (UN Doc Crc/c/15/add.79). New York: United Nations.

52.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2005) Concluding Observations: Australia (UN Doc Crc/c/15/add.268). New York: United Nations.

53.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2012) Concluding Observations: Australia (UN Doc CRC/C/AUS/CO/4). New York: United Nations.

54.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2019) General Comment No 24 (UN Doc CRC/C/GC/24). New York: United Nations.

55.

Velásquez

Medina

Yamada

Lavado

Nunez-del-Prado

Alatrista-Salas

Morzán

(2020) I read the news today, oh boy: The effect of crime news coverage on crime perception. World Development 136: 105111.

56.

Wong

(2024) Can lowering the minimum age of criminal responsibility be justified? A critical review of China’s recent amendment. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice 63(1): 3–21.

57.

Xiong

(2023) 刑事责任年龄的法理依据 [On the jurisprudential basis of the age of criminal responsibility]. 青少年犯罪问题 [Issues in Juvenile Crimes and Delinquency] 5: 122–139 (in Chinese).

58.

(2020) 降低刑事责任年龄否定论 [The negation of lowering the criminal responsibility age]. 当代青年研究 [Contemporary Youth Research] 2: 112–120 (in Chinese).

59.

Yao

(2023) 不教而刑：下调刑事责任年龄的立法反思 [Punishment without education: Legislative reflections on lowering the age of criminal responsibility]. 中外法学 [Peking University Law Journal] 35(5): 1203–1223 (in Chinese).

60.

Yin

(2020) China lowers age of criminal responsibility. China Daily, 28 December. Available at: https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202012/28/WS5fe919c6a31024ad0ba9ecd3.html

61.

Youth Justice Review Team (YJRT) (2011) A Review of the Youth Justice System in Northern Ireland. Belfast: DoJ.

62.

Zhang

(2020) Da Qing Xing Lv (the criminal law of great Qing): A new chapter reflecting the civilization of modern criminal law. In: Yan

Zhang

, et al (eds) The History of Chinese Legal Civilization. Singapore: Springer, 371–428.

63.

Zhang

(2017) 最低刑事责任年龄弹性化之提倡 [Advocating for the flexibility of the minimum age of criminal responsibility]. 青少年犯罪问题 [Issues in Juvenile Crimes and Delinquency] 2: 52–58 (in Chinese).

64.

Zhu

(2022) 舆论与刑法的偏差式互动:刑事责任年龄个别下调的中国叙事 [Public opinion and the deviant interaction with criminal law: The Chinese narrative on the individual reduction of the age of criminal responsibility]. 法学家 [Jurists Review] 1: 68–83 (in Chinese).

65.

Zuo

(2019) Should a 12-year-old who killed his mother face the courts? China debates age of criminal responsibility: While some want age of criminal responsibility to be lowered, experts say this will not tackle cause. South China Morning Post, 31 Mar. Available at: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3003839/killers-aged-12-and-13-go-unpunished-china-asks-hard-questions