Numerical simulation of Sewol ferry capsize

Abstract

In this study, numerical simulations are conducted in order to analyze the capsizing of roll-on/roll-off passenger ship, Sewol, which occurred on 16 April 2014. Since little is known about the reason of ship capsize, numerical simulation aims to the finding of possible scenarios which can cause this tragic accident. To this end, 4-degree-of-freedom (surge, sway, yaw, and roll motions) maneuvering equations are solved. The hydrodynamic coefficients obtained from a similar ship are applied and the WISH-Maneuver program of Seoul National University is used to perform the numerical simulation. The present analysis utilizes the probabilistic approach, which considers various physical variables and involves the simulation of a large number of cases using different combinations of the variables. The total number of simulation cases is over 70 millions, and the simulation results that are close to the conditions of the actual accident situation are selected. Through this process, the effects of the simulation variables are investigated and the potential causes of the accident are identified. The results show the hydrostatic instability of the ship in the operational condition owing to cargo overload and insufficient ballast water, which raised the vertical center of gravity. The reduced stability combined with large starboard steering angle and cargo movement during large heel may have been the decisive reason of capsizing.

Keywords

Sewol ferry ship capsize ship stability ferry accident marine safety ship maneuvering

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kijima

Tanaka

Furukawa

et al . On a prediction method of ship manoeuvring characteristics. In: Proceedings of the international conference on marine simulation and ship maneuverability (MARSIM ’93), St. John’s, NL, Canada, 26 September–2 October 1993, vol. 1, pp.285–294. MARSIM (International Conference on Marine Simulation and Ship Manoeuverability).

Lee

Kim

. Prediction of maneuverability of a ship in the initial design stage. Trans SNAK 1995; 32(4): 19–26.

Kijima

Nakiri

. On the practical prediction method for ship manoeuvring characteristics. In: Proceedings of the international conference on marine simulation and ship maneuverability (MARSIM ’03), Kanazawa, Japan, 25–28 August 2003, vol. 1, p.RC-6. MARSIM (International Conference on Marine Simulation and Ship Manoeuverability).

Lee

Shin

. Approximate technique for ship’s manoeuvrability prediction. J Soc Naval Arch Korea 1998; 35(4): 19–26.

Hwang

. Application of system identification to ship maneuvering. PhD Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Cambridge, MA, 1980.

Kang

Suh

Kim

. Maneuverability analysis of a ship by system identification technique. J Soc Naval Arch Korea 1984; 21(4): 10–20.

Kim

. Parameter identifications of roll maneuvering coefficients based on sea trial data. J Soc Naval Arch Korea 1998; 35(2): 29–37.

Yoon

Rhee

. Identification of hydrodynamic coefficients in ship maneuvering equations of motion by Estimation-Before-Modeling technique. Ocean Eng 2003; 30: 2379–2404.

Seo

Kim

. Numerical analysis on ship maneuvering coupled with ship motion in waves. Ocean Eng 2011; 38: 1934–1945.

10.

Yasukawa

Hirata

Tanaka

et al . Hydrodynamic force characteristics on maneuvering of a twin-propeller twin-rudder ship with bow thruster. J Jpn Inst Navig 2011; 125: 209–219.

11.

Yasukawa

Hirata

. Maneuverability and hydrodynamic derivatives of ships traveling in heeled condition. J Jpn Soc Nav Archit Ocean Eng 2013; 17: 19–29.

12.

BBC News. South Korea Sewol ferry: what we know, http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-27342967 (15 May 2014, accessed 12 June 2017).

13.

You

. Development of ship collision avoidance algorithm using the collision ratio. PhD Thesis, Seoul National University (SNU), Seoul, South Korea, 2013.

14.

MAIB. Report on the investigation into the listing, flooding and grounding of Hoegh Osaka Bramble Bank, The Solent, UK, on 3 January 2015. Report no. 6/2016, 2015. Southampton, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/56e9a7afe5274a14d9000000/MAIBInvReport6_2016.pdf