This study defines organizational learning as greater cognizance of action-outcome
relationships and the effects that environmental events have on these relationships.
It shows that two learning mechanisms, adaptation-in-use and change catalysis, are
key factors inrealizing gains from the implementation of administrative innovations.
Adaptation-in-use denotes ongoing adjustment of the innovation to the organizational
context. Change catalysis means that implementation is an occasion for rethinking
the way the organization does business and an opportunity to introduce additional
new practices and to innovate. A total of 1150 facilities belonging to 885 companies
that implemented the worldwide quality standard ISO 9000 participated in this study.
Results demonstrate that the effects of implementation of this administrative
innovation on performance are curvilinear; both too little and too much
implementation have a negative effect on performance. The two learning mechanisms
moderate the relationship between implementation of the administrative innovation
and subsequent performance, such that implementation is associated with higher
performance when adaptation-in-use and change catalysis are high rather than low.
Abrahamson, E.
(1997)
‘The Emergence and Prevalence of Employee Management Rhetorics:
The Effects of Long Waves, Labor Unions, and Turnover, 1875 to 1992’
, Academy of Management Journal40:
491-533
.
2.
Adams, M. E.
,
Day, G. S.
and
Dougherty, D.
(1998)
‘Enhancing New Product Development Performance: An Organizational
Learning Perspective’
, Journal of Product Innovation Management15:
403-422
.
3.
Adler, P. S.
and
Borys, B.
(1996)
‘Two Types of Bureaucracy: Enabling and Coercive’
, Administrative Science Quarterly41:
61-89
.
4.
Aiken, L. S.
and
West, S. G.
(1991) Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting
Interactions.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
5.
Aiman-Smith, L.
and
Green, S. G.
(2002)
‘Implementing New Manufacturing Technology: The Related Effects
of Technology Characteristics and User Learning Activities’
, Academy of Management Journal45:
421-430
.
6.
Anderson, J. C.
,
Rungtusanatham, M.
and
Schroeder, R. G.
(1994)
‘A Theory of Quality Management Underlying the Deming Management Method’
, Academy of Management Review19:
472-510
.
7.
Argote, L.
(1999) Organizational Learning: Creating, Retaining, and
Transferring Knowledge.
Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers
.
8.
Argote, L.
and
Ingram, P.
(2000)
‘Knowledge Transfer: A Basis for Competitive Advantage in Firms’
, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes82:
50-169
.
9.
Argyris, C.
and
Schön, D. A.
(1978) Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action
Perspective.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
10.
Armstrong, J. S.
and
Overton, T. S.
(1977)
‘Estimating Non Response Bias in Mail Surveys’
, Journal of Marketing Research14:
396-402
.
11.
Baer, M.
and
Frese, M.
(2003)
‘Innovation is not Enough: Climates for Innovative and
Psychological Safety, Process Innovations, and Firm Performance’
, Journal of Organizational Behavior24:
45-68
.
12.
Bagchi, T. P.
(1996) ISO 9000: Concepts, Methods, and Implementation,
2nd edn.Wheeler Publishing, New Delhi
.
13.
Bardach, E.
(1977) The Implementation Game: What Happens after a Bill
Becomes a Law.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
14.
Barney, J.
(1986)
‘Organizational Culture: can it be a Source of Sustained
Competitive Advantage?’
, Academy of Management Review11:
656-665
.
15.
Barrett, F. J.
(1998)
‘Creativity and Improvisation in Jazz and Organizations:
Implications for Organizational Learning’
, Organization Science9:
605-622
.
16.
Batchelor, C.
(1992)
‘Badges of Quality’
, Financial Times, 1 September.
17.
Benner, M. J.
and
Tushman, M. L.
(2002)
‘Process Management and Technological Innovation: A Longitudinal
Study of the Photography and Paint Industries’
, Administrative Science Quarterly47:
676-706
.
18.
Beyer, J. M.
and
Trice, H. M.
(1978) Implementing Change: Alcoholism Policies in Work
Organizations.
New York: The Free Press
.
19.
Bossidy, L.
and
Charan, R.
(2002) Execution: The Discipline of Getting Things
Done.
New York: Crown Business
.
20.
Boulding, W.
,
Morgan, R.
and
Staelin, R.
(1997)
‘Pulling the Plug to Stop the New Product Drain’
, Journal of Marketing Research34:
164-176
.
21.
Brown, S. L.
and
Eisenhardt, K. M.
(1997)
‘The Art of Continuous Change: Linking Complexity Theory and
Time-Paced Evolution in Relentlessly Shifting Organizations’
, Administrative Science Quarterly42:
1-34
.
22.
Brown, A.
and
Loughton, W. T.
(1998)
‘Smaller Enterprises’ Experiences with ISO 9000’
, International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management15:
273-285
.
23.
Brown, J. S.
and
Duguid, P.
(2001)
‘Knowledge and Organization: A Social-Practice Perspective’
, Organization Science12:
198-213
.
24.
Brunsson, N.
,
Jacobsson, B.
and
Associates
(2000) A World of Standards.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
25.
Carroll, J. S.
,
Rudolph, J. W.
and
Hatakenaka, S.
(2003) ‘Learning from Organizational
Experience’, in
M. Easterby-Smith
and
M. A. Lyles
(eds) The Blackwell Handbook of Organizational Learning and Knowledge
Management, pp. 575-600.
Oxford: Blackwell Publishing
.
26.
Chelariu, C.
,
Johnston, W. J.
and
Young, L.
(2001)
‘Learning to Improvise, Improvising to Learn: A Process of
Responding to Complex Environments’
, Journal of Business Research55:
141-147
.
27.
Cohen, J.
(1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral
Sciences, 2nd edn.New York: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
28.
Cole, R. E.
(1999) Managing Quality Fads.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
29.
Cooper, R.
and
Zmud, R.
(1990)
‘Information Technology Implementation’
, Management Science36:
123-139
.
30.
Corbett, C. J.
,
Montes-Sancho, M. J.
and
Kirsch, D. A.
(2005)
‘The Financial Impact of ISO 9000 Certification in the United
States: An Empirical Analysis’
, Management Science51:
1046-1060
.
31.
Crossan, M. M.
,
Lane, H. W.
and
White, R. E.
(1999)
‘An Organizational Learning Framework: From Intuition to Institution’
, Academy of Management Review24:
522-537
.
32.
Detert, J. R.
,
Schroeder, R. G.
and
Mauriel, J. J.
(2000)
‘A Framework for Linking Culture and Improvement Initiatives in Organizations’
, Academy of Management Review25:
850-863
.
33.
Dierickx, I.
and
Cool, K.
(1989)
‘Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive Advantage’
, Management Science35:
1504-1511
.
34.
DiMaggio, P. J.
and
Powell, W. W.
(1983)
‘The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and
Collective Rational in Organizational Fields’
, American Sociological Review48:
147-160
.
35.
Douglas, T. J.
and
Judge, W. Q., Jr
(2001)
‘Total Quality Management Implementation and Competitive
Advantage: The Role of Structural Control and Exploration’
, Academy of Management Journal44:
158-169
.
36.
Edmondson, A. C.
, (2002)
‘The local and variegated nature of learning in organizations: A
group-level perspective’
, Organization Science13,
128-146
.
37.
Edmondson, A. C.
(2003)
‘Framing for Learning: Lessons in Successful Technology Implementation’
, California Management Review45:
34-53
.
38.
Edmondson, A. C.
,
Bohmer, R. M.
and
Pisano, G. P.
(2001)
‘Disrupted Routines: Team Learning and New Technology
Implementation in Hospitals’
, Administrative Science Quarterly46:
685-716
.
39.
Elmuti, D.
and
Kathawala, Y.
(1997)
‘An Investigation into the Effect of ISO 9000 on
Participants’ Attitudes and Job Performance’
, Production and Inventory Management Journal38:
52-55
.
40.
Feldman, M. S.
(2004)
‘Resources in Emerging Structure and Processes of Change’
, Organization Science15:
295-309
.
41.
Fidler, L. A.
and
Johnson, J. D.
(1984)
‘Communication and Innovation Implementation’
, Academy of Management Review9:
704-711
.
42.
Flynn, B. B.
,
Schroeder, R. G.
and
Sakikabara, S.
(1994)
‘A Framework for Quality Management Research and an Associated
Measurement Instrument’
, Journal of Operations Management11:
339-366
.
43.
Gersick, C. J. G.
and
Hackman, J. R.
(1990)
‘Habitual Routines in Task-performing Groups’
, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes47(1):
65-97
.
44.
Greve, R. H.
(2002)
‘Sticky Aspirations: Organizational Time Perspective and Competitiveness’
, Organization Science13:
1-17
.
45.
Greve, H. R.
and
Taylor, A.
(2000)
‘Innovations as Catalysts for Organizational Change: Shift in
Organizational Cognition and Search’
, Administrative Science Quarterly45:
54-80
.
46.
Guler, I.
,
Guillen, M. F.
and
Muir, J.
(2002)
‘Global Competition, Institutions, and the Diffusion of
Organizational Practices: The International Spread of ISO 9000 Quality Certificates’
, Administrative Science Quarterly47:
207-233
.
47.
Hackman, J. R.
and
Wageman, R.
(1995)
‘Total Quality Management: Empirical, Conceptual and Practical Issues’
, Administrative Science Quarterly40:
309-342
.
48.
Hamilton, B. H.
and
Nickerson, J. A.
(2003)
‘Correcting for Endogeneity in Strategic Management Research’
, Strategic Organization1(1):
51-78
.
49.
Helfat, C. E.
and
Raubitschek, R. S.
(2000)
‘Product Sequencing: Co-evolution of Knowledge, Capabilities and Products’
, Strategic Management Journal21:
961-979
.
50.
Hu, L.-T.
and
Bentler, P.
(1999)
‘Cutoff criteria for Fit Indexes in Covariance Structure
Analysis: Conventional Criteria Versus New Alternatives’
, Structural Equation Modeling6:
1-55
.
51.
Hunt, J.
(1997)
‘Evaluation of the Tradeoffs: ISO 9000 Registration or Compliance’
, Quality36:
42-45
.
52.
Ingram, P.
and
Baum, J. A. C.
(1997)
‘Opportunity and Constraint: Organizations’ Learning
from the Operating and Competitive Experience of Industries’
, Strategic Management Journal18:
75-98
.
53.
International Standard Organization
(2006) 2005 Survey.
Geneva: ISO
.
54.
ISO 9000 Survey (1996).
New York: McGraw-Hill
.
55.
James, L. R.
,
Demaree, R. G.
and
Wolf, G.
(1984)
‘Rwg: An Assessment of Within-Group Interrater Agreement’
, Journal of Applied Psychology78:
306-309
.
56.
Katz-Navon, T.
,
Naveh, E.
and
Stern, Z.
(2005)
‘Safety Climate in Healthcare Organizations: A Multidimensional Approach’
, Academy of Management Journal48:
1075-1089
.
57.
Kelly, D.
and
Amburgey, T. L.
(1991)
‘Organizational Inertia and Momentum: A Dynamic Model of
Strategic Change’
, Academy of Management Journal34(3):
591-612
.
58.
Klein, K. J.
,
Conn, A. B.
and
Sorra, J. S.
(2001)
‘Implementing Computerized Technology: An Organizational Analysis’
, Journal of Applied Psychology86:
811-824
.
59.
Klein, K. J.
and
Sorra, J. S.
(1996)
‘The Challenge of Innovation Implementation’
, Academy of Management Review21:
1005-1081
.
60.
Kolb, D. A.
(1984) Experimental Learning: Experience as the Source of
Learning and Development.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
.
61.
Kostova, T.
(1999)
‘Transnational Transfer of Strategic Organizational Practices: A
Contextual Perspective’
, Academy of Management Review24:
308-324
.
62.
Leonard-Barton, D.
(1995) Wellsprings of Knowledge: Building and Sustaining the
Sources of Innovation.
Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press
.
63.
Levin, D. Z.
(2000)
‘Organizational Learning and the Transfer of Knowledge: An
Investigation of Quality Improvement’
, Organization Science11:
630-647
.
64.
Levinthal, D. A.
and
March, J. G.
(1993)
‘The Myopia of Learning’
, Strategic Management Journal14:
95-112
.
65.
Levitt, B.
and
March, J. G.
(1988)
‘Organizational Learning’
, Annual Review of Sociology14:
319-340
.
66.
Lewin, K.
(1952) ‘Group Decision and Social
Change’, in
E. E. Maccoby
,
T. M. Newcomb
and
E. L. Hartley
(eds) Readings in Social Psychology, pp.
459-473.
New York: Henry Holt and Company
.
67.
Lewis, L. K.
and
Seibold, D. R.
(1993)
‘Innovation Modification During Intraorganizational Adoption’
, Academy of Management Review18:
322-354
.
68.
McClelland, G. H.
and
Judd, C. M.
(1993)
‘Statistical Difficulties of Detecting Interaction and Moderator Effects’
, Psychological Bulletin114:
376-390
.
69.
March, J. G.
(1981)
‘Footnotes to Organizational Change’
, Administrative Science Quarterly26:
563-578
.
70.
March, J. G.
(1991)
‘Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning’
, Organization Science2:
71-87
.
71.
March, J. G.
and
Olsen, J. P.
(1976) Ambiguity and Choice in Organizations.
Bergen, Norway: Universitetsforlaget
.
72.
Marcus, A. A.
(1988)
‘Implementing Externally Induced Innovations: A Comparison of
Rule-bound and Autonomous Approaches’
, Academy of Management Journal31:
235-258
.
73.
Marcus, A. A.
and
Nichols, M. L.
(1999)
‘On the edge: Heeding the warning of unusual events’
, Organization Science, 10,
482-499
74.
Marcus, A. A.
and
Naveh, E.
(2005)
‘How a New Rule is Adjusted to Context: Implementation of the ISO 9000’
, International Journal of Organizational Analysis13(2):
106-126
.
75.
Matusik, S. F.
and
Hill, C. W. L.
(1998)
‘The Utilization of Contingent Work, Knowledge Creation, and
Competitive Advantage’
, Academy of Management Review23:
118-131
.
76.
Meyer, A. D.
and
Goes, J. B.
(1988)
‘Organizational Assimilation of Innovations: A Multilevel
Contextual Analysis’
, Academy of Management Journal31:
897-923
.
77.
Miner, A. S.
,
Bassoff, P.
and
Moorman, C.
(2001)
‘Organizational Improvisation and Learning: A Field Study’
, Administrative Science Quarterly46:
304-337
.
78.
Naveh, E.
and
Erez, M.
(2004)
‘Innovation and Attention-to-detail in the Quality Improvement Paradigm’
, Management Science50:
1576-1586
.
79.
Naveh, E.
,
Marcus, A.
,
Allen, G.
and
Moon, H.
(1999) ISO 9000 Survey ’99: An Analytical Tool to
Assess the Costs, Benefits and Savings of ISO 9000 Registration.
New York: McGraw-Hill
.
80.
Naveh, E.
,
Marcus, A.
and
Moon, H.
(2004)
‘Implementing ISO 9000: Performance Improvement by First and
Second Movers’
, International Journal of Production Research42:
1843-1863
.
81.
Nonaka, I.
(1994)
‘A Dynamic Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation’
, Organization Science5:
14-38
.
82.
Nord, W. R.
and
Tucker, S.
(1986) Implementing Routine and Radical Innovations.
Lexington, MA: Lexington Books
.
83.
Nutt, P. C.
(1986)
‘Tactics of Implementation’
, Academy of Management Journal29:
230-261
.
84.
Nutt, P. C.
(1989)
‘Selecting Tactics to Implement Strategic Plans’
, Strategic Management Journal10:
145-157
.
85.
Orlikowski, W. J.
(2002)
‘Knowing in Practice: Enacting a Collective Capability in
Distributed Organizing’
, Organization Science13:
249-273
.
86.
Pfeffer, J.
and
Sutton, R. I.
(1999) The Knowing-Doing Gap: How Smart Companies Turn
Knowledge into Action.
Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press
.
87.
Pisano, G. P.
(1996)
‘Learning-before-doing in the Development of New Process Technology’
, Research Policy25:
1097-1119
.
88.
Polley, D.
and
Van de Ven, A.
(1996)
‘Learning by Discovery Innovation Development’
, International Journal of Technology Management11:
871-882
.
89.
Postrel, S.
and
Rumelt, R. P.
(1992)
‘Incentives, Routines, and Self-control’
, Industrial and Corporate Change1:
397-425
.
90.
Powell, T. C.
(1995)
‘Total Quality Management as Competitive Advantage: A Review and
Empirical Study’
, Strategic Management Journal16:
15-37
.
91.
Reger, R. K.
,
Gustafson, L. T.
,
Demarie, S. M.
and
Mullane, J. V.
(1994)
‘Reframing the Organization: Why Implementing Total Quality Is
Easier Said Than Done’
, Academy of Management Review19:
565-584
.
92.
Repening, N. P.
(2002)
‘A Simulation-based Approach to Understanding the Dynamics of
Innovation Implementation’
, Organization Science13:
109-127
.
93.
Robin, M.
and
Dennis, K.
(1994)
‘An Evaluation of the Effects of Quality Improvement Activities
on Business Performance’
, International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management11:
29-45
.
94.
Rogers, E. M.
(1995) Diffusion of Innovations, 4th edn.New York: The Free Press
.
95.
Salancik, G. R.
(1977a) ‘Commitment and the Control of
Organizational Behavior and Belief’, in
B. M. Staw
and
G. R. Salancik
(eds) New Directions in Organizational Behavior, pp.
1-54.
Malabar, FL: Robert E. Krieger
.
96.
Salancik, G. R.
(1977b)
‘Commitment is Too Easy!’
, Organizational Dynamics6(3):
62-80
.
97.
Schneider, B.
,
White, S. S.
and
Paul, M. C.
(1998)
‘Linking Service Climate and Customer Perceptions of Service
Quality: Test of a Causal Model’
, Journal of Applied Psychology83:
150-163
.
98.
Schön, D. A.
(1983) The Reflective Practitioner.
New York: Basic Books
.
99.
Sitkin, S. B.
,
Sutcliffe, K. M.
and
Schroeder, R. G.
(1994)
‘Distinguishing Control from Learning in Total Quality
Management: A Contingency Perspective’
, Academy of Management Review19:
537-564
.
100.
Staw, B. M.
and
Epstein, L. D.
(2000)
‘What Bandwagons Bring: Effects of Popular Management Techniques
on Corporate Performance, Reputation, and CEO Pay’
, Administrative Science Quarterly45:
523-556
.
101.
Szulanski, G.
and
Cappetta, R.
(2003) ‘Stickiness: Conceptualizing, Measuring,
and Predicting Difficulties in the Transfer of Knowledge within
Organizations’, in
M. Easterby-Smith
and
M. A. Lyles
(eds) The Blackwell Handbook of Organizational Learning and Knowledge
Management, pp. 513-534.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
102.
Terziovski, M.
,
Samson, D.
and
Dow, D.
(1997)
‘The Business Value of Quality Management Systems Certification
Evidence from Australia and New Zealand’
, Journal of Operations Management15:
1-18
.
103.
Thomas, J. B.
,
Sussman, S. W.
and
Henderson, J. C.
(2001)
‘Understanding “Strategic Learning”: Linking
Organizational Learning, Knowledge Management, and Sense making’
, Organization Science12:
331-345
.
104.
Tushman, M. L.
and
O’Reilly, C. A.
(1996)
‘The Ambidextrous Organization: Managing Evolutionary and
Revolutionary Change’
, California Management Review38:
8-30
.
105.
Tyre, M. J.
and
Orlikowski, W. J.
(1994)
‘Windows of Opportunity: Temporal Patterns of Technological
Adaptation in Organizations’
, Organization Science5:
98-119
.
106.
Wayhan, V. B.
,
Kirche, E. T.
and
Khumawala, B. M.
(2002)
‘ISO 9000 Certification: The Financial Performance Implications’
, Total Quality Management13:
217-231
.
107.
Westphal, J. D.
,
Gulati, R.
and
Shortell, M. S.
(1997)
‘Customization or Conformity? An Institutional and Network
Perspective on the Content and Consequences of TQM Adoption’
, Administrative Science Quarterly42:
366-394
.
108.
Winter, S. G.
and
Szulanski, G.
(2001)
‘Replication as Strategy’
, Organization Science12:
730-743
.
109.
Yin, R. K.
(1977)
‘Production Efficiency Versus Bureaucratic Self-interest: Two
Innovative Processes?’
, Policy Science8:
381-399
.
110.
Zbaracki, M. J.
(1998)
‘The Rhetoric and Reality of Total Quality Management’
, Administrative Science Quarterly43:
602-636
.
