A randomized evaluation of the acute efficacy,acceptability and tolerability of Flutter and active cycle of breathing with and without postural drainage in non-cystic fibrosis bronchiectasis

Abstract

Airway clearance is integral to the management of bronchiectasis, yet there is no evidence as to the optimal modality. The aim of this randomized prospective study was to evaluate the acute efficacy, acceptability and tolerability of three airway clearance techniques in non-cystic fibrosis (non-CF) bronchiectasis. Flutter, active cycle of breathing technique (ACBT) and ACBT with postural drainage (ACBT-PD) were evaluated in random order over a week in 36 patients (mean age 62 years, range 33-83), with stable non-CF bronchiectasis. Total sputum wet weight for ACBT-PD was twice that of either ACBT alone or Flutter. No objective difference in treatment duration was noted. All three techniques were well accepted and tolerated. Patient preference was 16 (44%) for Flutter, eight (22%) ACBT and 12 (33%) for ACBT-PD. Patient demography, factors such as upper airways or reflux symptoms, previous use or acute efficacy did not predict preference. This is the first randomized systematic evaluation of acute efficacy, acceptability and tolerability of Flutter, ACBT and ACBT-PD in non-CF bronchiectasis. All three techniques were well tolerated but ACBT-PD proved superior in terms of acute efficacy. Patient preference for treatment modality could not be predicted.

Keywords

acceptability and tolerability active cycle of breathing technique airway clearance techniques bronchiectasis Flutter postural drainage

References

Kolbe J , Wells AU. Bronchiectasis: A neglected cause of respiratory morbidity and mortality. Respir 1996; 1: 221-225.

Cole P. Bronchiectasis. In Brewis RAL , Gibson GJ , Geddes DM eds. Respiratory medicine. Balliere Tindall, 1990: 726-759.

Kolbe J. Bronchiectasis in evidenced-based respiratory medicine. In Gibson GJ ed. BMJ Books Blackwell Publishing, 2005: 361-388.

Webber BA , Pryor JA. Physiotherapy skills: techniques and adjuncts. In Webber BA , Pryor JA eds. Physiotherapy for respiratory and cardiac problems. Churchill, Livingstone, 1993: 116-129.

Partridge C , Pryor JA , Webber B. Characteristics of the forced expira-tory technique. Physiotherapy 1989; 75: 193-194.

Valente AM , Gastaldi AC , Cravo SL et al. The effect of two techniques on the character and transport of sputum in patients with bronchiectasis: A pilot study. Physiotherapy 2004; 90: 158-164.

Cecins NM , Jenkins SC , Pengelley J et al.

The active cycle of breathing techniques - to tip or not to tip?

Respir Med 1999; 93: 660-665.

Patterson JE , Bradley JM , Hewitt O et al. Airway clearance in bronchiectasis: a randomized crossover trial of active cycle of breathing techniques versus Acapella. Respiration 2005; 72: 239-242.

Thompson CS , Harrison S , Ashley J et al. Randomised cross-over study of the Flutter device and the active cycle of breathing technique and non-cystic fibrosis bronchiectasis. Thorax 2002; 57: 446-448.

10.

Main E , Prasad A , van der Schans C. Conventional chest physiotherapy compared to other airway clearance techniques for cystic fibrosis (Cochrane Review), Volume 1. The Cochrane Library, 2006.

11.

O’Donnell AE , Barker AF , Ilowite JS et al. Treatment of idiopathic bronchiectasis with aerosolised recombinant human DN’ase I. Chest 1998; 113: 1329-1334.

12.

Currie DC , Munroe C , Gaskell D et al. Practice, problems and compliance with postural drainage: a survey of chronic sputum producers. B J Dis Chest 1986; 80: 249-253.

13.

Passero MA , Remor B , Salomon J. Patient-reported compliance with cystic fibrosis therapy. Clin Pediatr 1981; 20: 264-268.

14.

Carr L , Smith RE , Pryor JA et al. Cystic fibrosis patients’ views and beliefs about chest clearance and exercise - a pilot study. Physiotherapy 1996; 82: 621-627.

15.

Wilson CB , Jones PW , O’Leary CJ et al. Validation of the St. George’s Respiratory Questionnaire in Bronchiectasis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997; 156: 536-541.

16.

Wilson RC , Jones PW. Long term reproducibility of Borg scale estimates for breathlessness during exercise. Clin Sci 1991; 80: 309-312.

17.

Standardization of Spirometry, 1994 update. American Thoracic Society. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995;152: 1107-1136.

18.

Quanjer PH , Tammeling GJ , Cotes JE et al. Lung volumes and forced ventilatory flows. Report Working Party Standardisation of Lung Function Tests, European Community for Steel and Coal. Official Statement of the European Respiratory Society. Eur Respir J 1993; 16: S5-S40.

19.

Patterson JE , Bradley JM , Elborn JS.

Airway clearance in bronchiectasis: a randomized crossover trial of active cycle of breathing techniques (incorporating postural drainage and vibration) versus test of incremental respiratory endurance

Chron Respir Dis 2004; 1: 127-130.

20.

Kaptchuk TJ , Stason WB , Davis RB et al. Sham device versus inert pill: randomized controlled trial of two placebo treatments.Br Med J 2006; 332: 391-397.

21.

O’Neill B , Bradely J , McArdle N et al. The current physiotherapy management of patients with bronchiectasis: a UK survey. Int J Clin Pract 2002; 56: 34-35.

22.

van der Schans CP , Postma DS , Koeter GH et al. Physiotherapy and bronchial mucus transport. Eur Respir J 1999; 13: 1477-1486.