Measuring the Burden of Indirect Taxation Including Consumption Tax in Japan by Income Group †

Abstract

A consumption tax was introduced in Japan as a means to secure financing for social security programs. Japan introduced this as a value-added tax in April 1989 in response to its aging society. the tax has increased from 3% in 1989 to 5% in April 1997 and 8% in April 2014. A further rate rise to 10% is planned for April 2017. While consumption taxes are regressive, excise taxes also place a burden on household finances. in this study, we estimate the portion of income captured by consumption and excise taxes for different income groups, considering the proportion of the tax burden associated with excise taxes. the results indicate that regressivity is present for both consumption and excise taxes. in particular, indirect taxes on food are considered highly regressive, giving grounds for measures aimed at reducing the tax burden of low-income earners. Accordingly, we quantify the redistributive effects of several policy patterns aimed at lessening indirect tax burdens. For taxes on food, the redistributive effects of reduced taxes, zero rates of taxation, and tax refunds were not significant. This is because these measures lower the tax burden across all income groups and do not target only low-income earners. As a result, alleviating the regressivity of indirect taxes requires social security policies closely targeted at low-income earners.

Keywords

indirect taxation consumption tax excise taxes regressivity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andrew

B. Lyon

and Schwab

Robert M.

(1995) “Consumption taxes in a life-cycle framework: Are sin taxes regressive?”, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 77(3):389–406.

Chernick

, and Recshovsky

(1997) “Who pays the gasoline tax?”, National Tax Journal, 50(2):233–259.

Davies

, St-Hilaire

and Whalley

(1991) “Some calculations of lifetime tax incidence”, The American Economic Review, 74(4):633–649.

DeCicca

, and McLeod

(2008) “Cigarette taxes and older adult smoking: Evidence from recent large tax increase”, Journal of Health Economics, 27(4): 918–929.

Decoster

, Loughrey

, O'Donoghue

and Verwerft

(2010) “How regressive are indirect taxes? A microsimulation analysis for five European countries”, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 29(2):326–350.

Fullerton

, and Rogers

(1991) “Lifetime versus annual perspectives on tax incidence”, National Tax Journal, Vol. XLIV, 3:277–287.

S. D.

, Kearney

Robinson

and Thierfelder

(2005) “An analysis of South Africa's value added tax”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3671.

Hayashi

, and Hashimoto

(1993) “The effective rates of indirect taxes in Japan”, The Journal of Yokkaichi University, 5(2):1–10 (in Japanese).

Iwamoto

, Ozaki

and Maekawa

(1995) “The divergence of the household savings trends between ‘Family income and expenditure survey’ and ‘national accounts’ part 1”, Financial Review, 35:51–82. (in Japanese).

10.

Iwamoto

, Ozaki

and Maekawa

(1996) “The divergence of the household savings trends between ‘family income and expenditure survey’ and ‘National Accounts’ part 2”, Financial Review, 37:82–112. (in Japanese).

11.

Mathur

and Morris

Adele C.

(2014) “Distributional effects of a carbon tax in broader U.S. fiscal reform”, Energy Policy, 66:326–334.

12.

Adam

, Besley

, Blundell

, Bond

, Chote

, Gammie

, Johnson

, Myles

and Poterba

(2010) “Dimensions of tax design”, The Mirrlees Review, Oxford University Press for Institute for Fiscal Studies.

13.

Adam

, Besley

, Blundell

, Bond

, Chote

, Gammie

, Johnson

, Myles

and Poterba

(2011) “Tax by design”, The Mirrlees Review, Oxford University Press for Institute for Fiscal Studies.

14.

Murasawa

, Yuda

, and Iwamoto

(2005) “A trade-off between efficiency and equity in adopting differential rates to the consumption tax”, The Economic Analysis, 176:19–41, The Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) (in Japanese).

15.

Poterba

J. M.

(1991) “Is the gasoline tax regressive?”, NBER Working Paper, No. 3578.

16.

Rogers

D. L.

(1994) “Distributional effects of corrective taxation: Assessing lifetime incidence from cross sectional data”, National Tax Association-Tax Institute of America, 87:192–202.

17.

Saitoh

, and Uemura

(2011) “Indirect tax burden of income groups in Japan”, The Journal of the Board of Audit, 44:27–40. (in Japanese).

18.

Uemura

(2006) “Household indirect tax burden and the future of the consumption tax in Japan”, The Journal of the Board of Audit, 33:11–29 (in Japanese).