Using Multiple Criteria To Evaluate Public Policies

Abstract

This article suggests a framework by which to organize information and evaluate policy alternatives. In this framework, equity, efficiency, effectiveness, and political feasibility are criteria for choosing policy alternatives. In addition, the framework includes strategies—the policy formulation and the compliance structure—for achieving these values. Among the three major types of school desegregation policy alternatives implemented since Brown v. Board of Education —freedom of choice, mandatory reassignment, and magnet—voluntary—the magnet-voluntary alternative appears to achieve the greatest equity, efficiency, and effectiveness because it relies primarily on market-like incentives and an incremental decision-making approach.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armor, D. 1980. White flight and the future of school desegregation . In School desegregation: Past, present and future edited by Walter G. Stephan and Joseph R. Feagan , 187-226. New York: Plenum .

—. 1989. After busing: Education and choice. Public Interest 95 (Spring). 24-37.

— 1990. Survey of public school parents in Worcester, Massachusetts .

Armor, D. , and C.H. Rossell. 1986. Survey of public and private school parents in Savannah-Chatham County, Georgia.

—. 1989. Survey of public school parents in Natchez, Mississippi .

—. 1990a. Survey of public school parents in DeKalb County, Georgia .

— 1990b. Survey of public school parents in Topeka, Kansas .

—. 1990c. Survey of public school parents in Stockton, California .

Bardach, E. 1977. The implementation game. Cambridge : MIT Press.

10.

Bobrow, D.B. , and J.S. Dryzek. 1987. Policy analysis by design. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

11.

Braybrooke, D. , and C.E. Lindblom. 1970. A strategy of decision. New York: Free Press.

12.

Choran, C. 1974. Political science and the public interest. Journal of Politics 36:327-55.

13.

Cnudde, C.F. , and D.J. McCrone. 1969. Party competition and welfare policies in the American states. American Political Science Review 63:858-66.

14.

Cochran, C.E. , L.C. Mayer , T.R. Carr , and N.J. Cayer. 1990. American public poltcy: An introduction . 3d ed. New York: St. Martin.

15.

Coleman, J. , S. Kelly , and J. Moore. 1975. Trends in school segregation, 1968-1973 . Washington, DC: Urban Institute .

16.

Cooper, K.J. (1982). Parents take new busing tack. Boston Globe, February 21, p. 107.

17.

Dror, Y. 1968. Public policymaking reexamined. Scranton, PA: Chandler.

18.

Edmonds, J. , and J.M. Reilly. 1985. Global energy: Assessing the future . New York: Oxford University Press .

19.

Elkin, S. , and B. Cook. 1985. The public life of economic incentives . Policy Studies Journal 13:797-813.

20.

Heidenheimer, A.J. , H. Heclo , and C.T. Adams. 1990. Comparative public policy: The politics of social choice in America, Europe, and Japan. 3d ed. New York: St. Martin.

21.

Hochschild, J. 1981. What's fair? American beliefs about distributive justice . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

22.

—. 1984. The new American dilemma: Liberal democracy and school desegregation. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

23.

Hofferbert, R.I. 1966. The relations between public policy and some structural and environmental variables in the American states. American Political Science Review 60:73-82.

24.

—. 1977. The study of public policy. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill.

25.

Keeping Boston whole. 1992. Boston Globe. September 25, p. 20.

26.

Kelman, S. 1981. What price incentives? Economists and the environment . Boston: Aubura House.

27.

Kingdon, J. 1981. Congressmen's voting decisions. 2nd ed. New York: Harper & Row .

28.

Kirp, D.L. 1982. Just schools: The idea of racial equality in American education. Berkeley: University of California Press.

29.

Kiser, L. , and E. Ostrom. 1982. The three worlds of action. In Strategies of political inquiry edited by E. Ostrum , 179-222. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

30.

Kluegel, J.R. 1985. If there isn't a problem, you don't need a solution . American Behavioral Scientist 28:761-84.

31.

Lasswell, H.D. 1950. The policy orientation. In The policy sciences , edited by D. Lerner and H. D. Lasswell. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

32.

Levitan, S.A. 1985. Programs in aid of the poor. 5th ed. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

33.

Lewis-Beck, M.S. 1977. The relative importance of socioeconomic and political variables for public policy. American Political Science Review 71:559-66.

34.

Lindblom, C. 1959. The science of muddling through. Public Administration Review 19:79-89.

35.

—. 1979. Still muddling, not quite through. Public Administration Review 39:517-26.

36.

Lineberry, R.L. , and E.P. Fowler. 1967. Reformism and public policies in American cities. American Political Science Review 61:169-95.

37.

Lowi, T.J. 1964. American business, public policy, case-studies, and political theory. World Politics 16:677-715.

38.

Mantell, E. 1985. On the economics and the politics of environmental protection . American Journal of Economics and Sociology 44:433-46.

39.

Marmor, T.R. (1983). Political analysis and American medical care. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

40.

Martin, C.J. 1991. Shifting the burden: The struggle over growth and corporate taxation Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

41.

May, P.J. 1986. Politics and policy analysis. Political Science Quarterly 101(1): 109-25.

42.

Mazmanian, D.A. , and P.A. Sabatier. 1989. Implementation and public policy. Lanham, MD: University Press of America .

43.

Okun, A.M. 1975. Equality and efficiency: The big tradeoff. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

44.

Pressman, J.L. , and A. Wildavsky. 1973. Implementation. Berkeley: University of California Press.

45.

Reagan, M.D. 1987. Regulation. Boston: Little, Brown.

46.

Rodgers, H.R., Jr. 1986. Poor women, poor families: The economic plight of America's female-headed families. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.

47.

Rossell, C.H. 1988. Is it the busing or the blacks? Urban Affairs Quarterly 24:138-148.

48.

—. 1990a. The carrot or the stick for school desegregation policy . Urban Affairs Quarterly 25:474-99.

49.

—. 1990b. The carrot or the stick for school desegregation policy: Magnet schools or forced busing. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

50.

—. 1992. The effectiveness of controlled choice desegregation plans: Does more control over choice produce more desegregation? Unpublished report.

51.

Rossell, C.H. , and R.L. Crain. 1982. The importance of political factors in explaining Northern school desegregation. American Journal of Political Science 26:772-96.

52.

Sabatier, P. 1991a. Toward better theories of the policy process: Political science and public policy. Political Science & Politics 24:144-47.

53.

—. 1991b. Toward better theories of the policy process. Political Science & Politics 24:147-56.

54.

Salisbury, R.H. 1968. The analysis of public policy: A search for theories and roles. In Political science and public thought, edited by A. Ranney , 151-75. Chicago: Markham.

55.

Sharkansky, R. , and R.I. Hofferbert . 1969. Dimensions of state politics, economics, and public policy. American Political Science Review 63:867-79.

56.

Stokey, E. , and R. Zeckhauser. 1978. A primer for policy analysis. New York: W. W. Norton.

57.

Stone, D. 1988. Policy paradox and political reason. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman.

58.

Taylor, D.G. 1986. Public opinion & collective action. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

59.

Tobin, J. 1970. On limiting the domain of inequality. Journal of Law and Economics 13:263-77.

60.

Uslaner, E.M. 1985. Energy, issue agendas, and policy typologies. In Public policy and the natural environment, edited by M. Ingram and R. Kenneth Godwin , 101-22. New York: JAI.

61.

Welch, F. , and A. Light. 1987. New evidence on school desegregation . Washington, DC: U.S. Commission on Civil Rights.

62.

Wilson, J.Q. 1984. Thinking about crime. 2d ed. New York: Basic Books.