Subjective Assessment of the Ergonomic Quality of a Keyboard for Vdu-Workplaces

Abstract

At an ergonomically optimized VDU-workstation, a group of 10 test subjects (Ss) carried out a test task, i.e., typing both at the test keyboard and a reference keyboard. The participants' personal subjective assessments concerning the working conditions with the two keyboards and the layout of the ergonomic model were recorded via specially designed questionnaires. They were given prior to and after the working tests and, therefore, reflected ratings without and with working experience. The posture of the hand, the lower and the upper arm, and the shoulder during text input were evaluated quite differently as a consequence of using the two keyboards. The working posture associated with the conventional keyboard was never assessed positively. The ratings always reached positive values when operating the ergonomic model. The handling of the keyboard and the overall impression were also in favor of the test model with increasing and decreasing values, respectively, for the two keyboards as a result of the working tests. Comfort and effort while typing at the keyboards also differed very clearly and were in favor of the test keyboard. Similar was true for altogether 10 items of the questionnaire aimed at evaluating details of the ergonomic keyboard and its overall appearance.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

DIN 2137-2 E, Text and Office Systems — Keyboards — Part 2: German Keyboard for Data and Text Processing, Key Arrangement and Allocation of Graphic Characters to Keys (German Standard, Draft, 1999).

DIN 2137-13 E, Text and Office Systems — Alphanumeric Keyboards — Part 13: German Keyboard for Data and Text Processing, Key Arrangement and Allocation for Split and Tilted Keyboards (German Standard, Draft, 1995).

Keller

Fleischer

Strasser

, Assessment of the Ergonomic Quality of a Keyboard for VDU-Operators. Unpublished Report, Ergonomics Division, University of Siegen 1996.

Marklin

R.W.

Simoneau

G.G.

, An Ergonomics Study of Alternative Keyboard Designs. Final Performance Report, submitted to NIOSH, CDC and NIH, 1997.

Müller

K.W.

: Effects of Ergonomic Keyboards on Static and Dynamic Components of Electromyographic Activity. In: Mital

Krueger

Kumar

Menozzi

Fernandez

J.E.

(Eds.): Advances in Occupational Ergonomics and Safety I. ISOES Cincinnati, Ohio/USA, 502–507 (1996).

Rempel

Honan

Serina

Tal

: Wrist Postures while Typing on a Standard and a Split Keyboard. Advances in Industrial Ergonomics & Safety VII, Seattle, 619–622 (1995).

Rosenblad

Claridge

Synnerman

: Conformance Test of the Microsoft Natural Keyboard against ISO 9241, part 4.2 (draft). Nomos Management AB, Stockholm, 1995.

Smutz

Serina

Rempel

. A System for Evaluating the Effect of Keyboard Design on Force, Posture, Comfort and Productivity. Ergonomics, 37(10) 1649–1660 (1994).

Strasser

Fleischer

Keller

, Electromyographic Evaluation of Muscle Strain of the Hand-Arm-Shoulder System during Alternating Typing at a Conventional and an Ergonomic Keyboard. Proceedings of the International Ergonomics Association XIVth Triennial Congress and Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 44th Annual Meeting, San Diego, 2000.