When is Less More? Attention and Workload in Auditory,Visual,and Redundant Patient-Monitoring Conditions

Abstract

Auditory signals can take the form of “auditory displays” that communicate information redundant to visual displays. These redundant displays may allow offloading some visual workload to the auditory channel. The current study examines the effect of visual, auditory and redundant displays on the performance of a dual-task simulation of patient monitoring. Subjects performed manual compensatory tracking task while monitoring six vital signs of a simulated patient, detecting deviations from normal levels. Monitoring was presented in three display conditions: auditory only, visual only, and redundant. Results indicate that the detection of deviations in visual and redundant conditions were not significantly different, but faster than the auditory display. However, performance in the tracking task was degraded least in the auditory condition, and the redundant display resulted in poorest performance—an example of a negative redundancy-gain. Reasons for this finding are examined through data from eye-movement recordings. This negative redundancy gain is also discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alpern

(1969). Types of Movement. In Davison

(Ed.), The Eye. 3 (2nd ed.). New York: Academic Press.

Botney

Gaba

D.M.

(1995). Human Factors Issues in Monitoring. In Blitt

C. D.

Hines

R.L.

(Eds.) Monitoring in Anesthesia and Critical Care Medicine (3rd Ed.). pp. 23–54. New York: Churchill Livingstone.

Breznitz

1984. Cry Wolf: the Psychology of False Alarms. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, New Jersey.

Broadbent

D. E.

(1977). The hidden preattentive processes. American Psychologist, 32(2), 109–118.

Carbonell

J. R.

(1966). A queueing model of many-instrument visual sampling. IEEE Transactions on Human Factors in Electronics, HFE-7(4), 157–164.

Fitch WTS (1998) Sonification system using synthesized realistic body sounds modified by other medically-important variables for physiologic monitoring. U. S. Patent Number 5730140.

Fitch

W. T.

Kramer

(1994): Sonifying the Body Electric: Superiority of an Auditory over a Visual Display in a Complex, Multi-Variate System. In: “Auditory Display: Sonification, Audification, and Auditory Interfaces” (Ed. Kramer

). Santa Fe Institute, Studies in the Sciences of Complexity, Vol 18. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

Gopher

(1993). The skill of attention control: Acquisition and execution of attention strategies. In Meyer

D. E.

Kornblum

(Eds.), Attention and Performance XIV (pp. 299–322). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Helleberg

Wickens

(2001) Effects of data link modality on pilot attention and communications effectiveness. In Jensen

(Ed) Proceedings of 11th International Symposium on Aviation Psychology. Columbus Ohio: Ohio State Univ.

10.

Kramer

, (Ed.) (1994). Auditory Display: Sonificanton, Audification, and Auditory Interfaces. Reading, MA: Addison Wesley.

11.

Loeb

R. G.

Fitch

W. T.

(2000). Laboratory evaluation of an auditory display designed to enhance intraoperative monitoring. Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing, 16, 63–64.

12.

McIntyre

J. W. R.

(1982). Man-machine interface: The position of the anesthetic Machine in the operating room. Canadian Anesthesia Society Journal, 29, 74–78.

13.

Seagull

F. J.

Sanderson

P. M.

(2001). Anesthesia alarms in context: An observational study. Human Factors, 45(1), 66–78.

14.

Sorkin

(1987). Design of Auditory and Tactile Displays. In Salvendy

(Ed.) Handbook of Human Factors.

15.

Tzelgov

Srebro

Henik

Kushelevsky

(1987). Radiation search and detection by ear and by eye. Human Factors, 29(1), 87–95.

16.

Wickens

C. D.

Hollands

J. G.

(2000). Engineering psychology and human performance (3rd Ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

17.

Wickens X.

Helleberg

Marsh

(2001). Pilot visual workload in free flight: a visual scanning study. In Jensen

(Ed) Proceedings 11th International Symposium on Aviation Psychology: Columbus Ohio: Ohio State.

18.

Woods

D. D.

(1995). The alarm problem and directed attention in dynamic fault management. Ergonomics, 38(11), 2371–2394.