Utility of Visual and Auditory Warning Alerting for Traffic Avoidance during UAS Operations

Abstract

Minimum Operational Performance Standards (MOPS) are being developed to support the integration of Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) in the National Airspace System (NAS). Input from subject matter experts and multiple research studies have informed display requirements for Detect-and-Avoid (DAA) systems aimed at supporting timely and appropriate pilot responses to collision hazards. DAA alerting is designed to inform pilots of potential threats to “DAA well clear”; the two highest alert levels – caution and warning – indicate how soon pilot action is required and whether there is adequate time to coordinate with the air traffic controller (ATC). Additional empirical support is needed to clarify the extent to which warning-level alerting impacts DAA task performance. The present study explores the differential effects of the auditory and visual cues provided by the DAA Warning alert, and performance implications compared to caution-only alerting are discussed.

References

Bell

Drury

Estes

Reynolds

. (2012). GDTI: A ground station display of traffic information for use in sense and avoid operations. Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), 2012 IEEE/AIAA 31st, Williamsburg, VA.

Code of Federal Regulations (2004). 14 CFR, Part 91, Sec. 91.113.

Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) (2010). Advisory circular no. 25.1322.1: flightcrew alerting. FAA, Washington, D.C.

Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) (2013). Integration of civil UAS in the NAS roadmap, first edition. FAA, Washington, D.C.

Feitshans

G. L.

Rowe

A. J.

Davis

J. E.

Holland

Berger

. (2008). Vigilant spirit control station (VSCS)—‘The face of COUNTER’. In Proceedings of AIAA Guidance, Navigation and Control Conf. Exhibition, Honolulu, HI. AIAA Paper (No. 2008-6309).

Fern

Rorie

R.C.

Pack

Shively

R.J.

Draper

. (2015). An evaluation of detect and avoid (DAA) displays for unmanned aircraft systems: the effect on information level and display location on pilot performance. Proceedings of the 15th Annual AIAA Aviation, Technology, Integration and Operations Conference, Dallas, TX.

Fern

Rorie

R.C

. (2015). “An Examination of Unmanned Aircraft Systems Pilots’ Interaction with Air Traffic Control while Responding to Detect and Avoid Conflicts,” Air Traffic Control Quarterly, 23(2-3), pp.113-135.

Fern

. (2016). SC-228 inclusion of DAA warning alert for TCAS interoperability. NASA Technical Report (Document ID: 20160012547). Moffett Field, CA.

Friedman-Berg

Rein

Racine

. (2014). Minimum visual information requirements for detect and avoid in unmanned aircraft systems. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 58th Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL.

10.

Monk

K.J.

Roberts

Z.S

. (2017). Maintain and Regain Well Clear: An Examination of Maneuver Guidance Designs for Pilots Performing the Detect-and-Avoid Task, Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Applied Human Factors and Ergonomics, Los Angeles, CA.

11.

Rorie

R.C.

Fern

. (2015). The impact of integrated maneuver guidance information on UAS pilots performing the detect and avoid task. Proceedings of the 59th Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, CA.

12.

Rorie

R. C.

Fern

Shively

J . (2016). The impact of suggestive maneuver guidance on UAS pilot performing the detect and avoid function. AIAA Infotech @ Aerospace, San Diego, CA.

13.

Rorie

R.C.

Fern

Monk

K.J.

Roberts

Santiago

Shively

R.J

. (2017). Validation of Minimum Display Requirements for a UAS Detect and Avoid System, Proceedings of 17th AIAA Aviation Technology, Integration, and Operations Conference, Denver, CO.

14.

RTCA. (2013). Terms of reference RTCA special committee 228 minimum performance standards for unmanned aircraft systems, paper No. 109-13/PMC-1089. RTCA Inc., Washington, DC.

15.

RTCA (2017) “DO-365 – Minimum operational performance standards (MOPS) for detect and avoid (DAA) systems,” RTCA Inc., Washington, D.C.

16.

RTCA Special Committee 228 (2013). “Detect and avoid (DAA) Whitepaper,” RTCA-SC228-WG1-WP01-01.