Meta-Analysis of Multiple-Task Performances: Cumulating the First two Decades of Research Findings across Studies

Abstract

Meta-analytic procedures were used to cumulate research findings across studies of multiple-task performances published between 1965 and 1985 (inclusive). Exhaustive literature search yielded 94 reports of studies of multiple-task performances that were sufficiently detailed to be statistically combined using the Hunter-Schmidt-Jackson procedure. These studies yielded a total of 202 statistical values and a total subject N of 3091. Meta-analysis was performed overall (resulting in a significant test statistic) and then as a function of secondary task (13 types), primary task (18 types), and specific secondary-primary task combination. (The secondary tasks were Choice Reaction Time (CRT), Classification, Detection, Memory, Mental Math, Monitoring, Motor Response, Problem Solving, Reaction Time, Shadowing, Speech, Task Battery (Multiple Tasks), and Tracking; the primary tasks were Association, CRT, Classification, Decision Making, Detection, Driving, Flight (Simulation), Memory, Mental Math, Monitoring, Motor Response, Problem Solving, Reading, Shadowing, Sketching, Speech, Tapping, and Tracking.) Ten external variables (Carbon Monoxide, Control-Display Compatibility, Drug Use, Feedback, Intelligence Tests, Neuroticism, Noise, Rating of Job Performance, Sinus Arrhythmia, and Temperature) as correlates of multiple-task performances were also examined. A generally positive relationship between secondary task performance alone and in combination with the primary task was found, along with moderating effects of secondary task type and primary task type. No substantial variation of results within a given combination of secondary and primary task types occurred in most cases, although four external variables (Carbon Monoxide, Feedback, Noise, and Temperature) displayed within-factor variation of results. All results were discussed in terms of integration of the past literature and directions for future research.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brown

I.D.

(1965). A comparison of two subsidiary tasks used to measure fatigue in car drivers. Ergonomics, 8, 467–473.

Chiles

W.D.

(1977). Objective methods for developing indices of pilot workload (Rept. No. FAA-AM-77-15). Oklahoma City, OK: FAA Civil Aeromedical Institute.

Fournier

B.A.

Stager

(1976). Concurrent validation of a dual-task selection test. Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 589–595.

Glass

G.V.

(1976). Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research. Educational Researcher, 5, 3–8.

Glass

G.V.

(1977). Integrating findings: The meta-analysis of research. Review of Research in Education, 5, 351–379.

Glass

G.V.

Stanley

J.C.

(1970). Statistical methods in education and psychology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Green

B.F.

Hall

J.A.

(1984). Quantitative methods for literature review. Annual Review of Psychology, 35, 37–53.

Hays

W.L.

(1973). Statistics for the social sciences (2nd ed.). New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.

Huddleston

H.F.

Wilson

R.V.

(1971). An evaluation of the usefulness of four secondary tasks in assessing the effect of a lag in simulated aircraft dynamics. Ergonomics, 14, 371–380.

10.

Hunter

J.E.

Schmidt

F.L.

Jackson

G.B.

(1982). Meta-analysis: Cumulating research findings across studies. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

11.

Kendall

M.G.

Stuart

(1967). The advanced theory of statistics. Vol. 2: Inference and relationship (2nd ed.). New York: Hafner.

12.

Knowles

W.B.

(1963). Operator loading tasks. Human Factors, 5, 155–161.

13.

Kruskal

W.H.

(1958). Ordinal measures of association. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 53, 814–861.

14.

Ogden

G.D.

Levine

J.M.

Eisner

E.J.

(1979). Measurement of workload by secondary tasks. Human Factors, 21, 529–548.

15.

Orwin

R.G.

Cordray

D.S.

(1985). Effects of deficient reporting on meta-analysis: A conceptual framework and reanalysis. Psychological Bulletin, 97, 134–147.

16.

Rolfe

J.M.

(1971). The secondary task as a measure of mental load. In Singleton

W. T.

Fox

J. G.

Whitfield

(Eds.), Measurement of man at work: An appraisal of physiological and psychological criteria in man-machine systems (pp. 135–148). London: Taylor & Francis.

17.

Rosenthal

(1983). Meta-analysis: Toward a more cumulative social science. Applied Social Psychology Annual, 4, 65–93.

18.

Schmidt

F.L.

Hunter

J.E.

(1977). Development of a general solution to the problem of validity generalization. Journal of Applied Psychology, 62, 529–540.

19.

Wierwille

W.W.

Williges

R.C.

(1978). Survey and analysis of operator workload techniques (Rept. No. S-78-101). Blacksburg, VA: Systemetrics.

20.

Zeitlin

L.R.

Finkelman

J.M.

(1975). Research note: Subsidiary task techniques of digit generation and digit recall as indirect measures of operator loading. Human Factors, 17, 218–220.