Previously, burst and linear theories for periodontal disease progression were proposed based on different but limited statistical methods of analysis. Multilevel modeling provides a new approach, yielding a more comprehensive model. Random coefficient models were used to analyze longitudinal periodontal data consisting of repeated measures (level 1), sites (level 2), teeth (level 3), and subjects (level 4). Large negative and highly significant correlations between random linear and quadratic time coefficients indicated that subjects and teeth with greater-than-average linear change experienced decelerated variation. Conversely, subjects and teeth with less-than-average linear change experienced accelerated variation. Change therefore exhibited a dynamic regression to the mean at the tooth and subject levels. Since no equilibrium was attained throughout the study, changes were cyclical. When considered as a multilevel system, the "linear" and "burst" theories of periodontal disease progression are a manifestation of the same phenomenon: Some sites improve while others progress, in a cyclical manner.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allen KM, Hausmann E -1995-. Model fit and measurement outcome in attachment measurements: a simulation study. J Periodontal Res30:15–22.
2.
Blomqvist N -1987-. On the bias caused by regression toward the mean in studying the relation between change and initial value. J Clin Periodontol14:34–37.
3.
Cohen ME, Ralls SA -1988-. Distributions of periodontal attachment levels. Mathematical models and implications. J Periodontol59:254–258.
4.
Eaton KA, Duffy S, Griffiths GS, Gilthorpe MS, Johnson NW -2001-. The influence of partial and full-mouth recordings on estimates of prevalence and extent of lifetime cumulative attachment loss: a study in a population of young male military recruits. J Periodontol72:140–145.
5.
Egelberg J -1989-. The impact of regression towards the mean on probing changes in studies on the effect of periodontal therapy. J Clin Periodontol16:120–123.
6.
Gilthorpe MS, Cunningham SJ -2000-. The application of multilevel, multivariate modelling to orthodontic research data. Community Dent Health17:236–242.
7.
Gilthorpe MS, Maddick IH, Petrie A -2000a-. Introduction to Bayesian modelling in dental research. Community Dent Health17:218–221.
8.
Gilthorpe MS, Maddick IH, Petrie A -2000b-. Introduction to multilevel modelling in dental research. Community Dent Health17:222–226.
9.
Gilthorpe MS, Griffiths GS, Maddick IH, Zamzuri AT -2000c-. The application of multilevel modelling to periodontal research data. Community Dent Health17:227–235.
10.
Gilthorpe MS, Griffiths GS, Maddick IH, Zamzuri AT -2001-. An application of multilevel modelling to longitudinal periodontal research data. Community Dent Health18:79–86.
11.
Gilthorpe MS, Mayhew MT, Bulman JS -2002-. Multilevel survival analysis of amalgam restorations amongst RAF personnel. Community Dent Health19:3–11.
12.
Goldstein H -1995-. Multilevel statistical models. London: Edward Arnold.
13.
Griffiths GS, Sterne JAC, Wilton JM, Eaton KA, Johnson NW -1992-. Associations between volume and flow rate of gingival crevicular fluid and clinical assessments of gingival inflammation in a population of British male adolescents. J Clin Periodontol19:464–470.
14.
Griffiths GS, Duffy S, Eaton KA, Gilthorpe MS, Johnson NW -2001-. Prevalence and extent of lifetime cumulative attachment loss -LCAL- at different thresholds and associations with clinical variables: changes in a population of young male military recruits over 3 years. J Periodontol28:961–969.
15.
Hujoel PP, Leroux BG -1998-. Evaluating the burst hypothesis at a site-specific level using the lack-of-fit test. J Periodontol69:357–362.
16.
Jeffcoat MK, Reddy MS -1991-. Progression of probing attachment loss in adult periodontitis. J Periodont Res62:185–189.
17.
Lewsey JD, Gilthorpe MS, Bulman JS, Bedi R -2000-. Is modelling dental caries a ’normal’ thing to do? Community Dent Health17:212–217.
18.
Lewsey JD, Gilthorpe MS, Gulabivala K -2001-. An introduction to meta-analysis within the framework of multilevel modelling using the probability of success of root canal treatment as an illustration. Community Dent Health18:131–137.
19.
Löe H, Anerud A, Boysen H, Smith M -1978-. The natural history of periodontal disease in man. The rate of periodontal disease destruction before 40 years of age. J Periodontol49:607–620.
20.
Machtei EE, Norderyd J, Koch G, Dunford R, Grossi S, Genco RJ -1993-. The rate of periodontal attachment loss in subjects with established periodontitis. J Periodontol64:713–718.
21.
McCullagh P, Nelder JA -1989-. Generalized linear models. 2nd ed. London: Chapman & Hall.
22.
Miller AJ -1990-. Subset selection in regression. London: Chapman & Hall.
23.
Ralls SA, Cohen ME -1986-. Problems in identifying "bursts" of periodontal attachment loss. J Periodontol57:746–752.
24.
Rasbash J, Browne W, Cameron B, Charlton C -2000-. MLwiN version 1.10.0006. London: Multilevel Models Project, Institute of Education.
25.
Slinker BY, Glantz SA -1985-. Multiple regression for physiological data analysis: the problem of multicollinearity. Am J Physiol249:R1–R12.
26.
Socransky SS, Haffajee AD, Goodson JM, Lindhe J -1984-. New concepts of destructive periodontal disease. J Clin Periodontol11:21–32.
27.
Sterne JA, Curtis MA, Gillett IR, Griffiths GS, Maiden MF, Wilton JM, et al. -1990-. Statistical models for data from periodontal research. J Clin Periodontol17:129–137.
28.
Sterne JAC, Kingman A, Löe H -1992-. Assessing the nature of periodontal disease progression—an application of covariance structure estimation. Appl Statist41:539–552.
29.
Yang MC, Marks RG, Clark WB, Magnusson I -1991-. Evaluation of statistical methods for monitoring periodontal disease. Stat Med10:1089–1097.
30.
Yang MC, Namgung YY, Marks RG, Magnusson I, Clark WB -1993-. Change detection on longitudinal data in periodontal research. J Periodontal Res28:152–160.
