More Than “A Room of Antiquities” at the Global Museum: Constructing New Meanings Through the Provenance Research of an Ancient Egyptian Legacy Collection
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2022
More Than “A Room of Antiquities” at the Global Museum: Constructing New Meanings Through the Provenance Research of an Ancient Egyptian Legacy Collection
Non-systematically excavated archaeological legacy collections of antiquities are often undervalued or overlooked by museums because of their unknown provenience and questionable or problematic provenance. This article describes how extensive research into the provenance of an ancient Egyptian legacy collection purchased in Egypt in 1884 by Adolph Sutro that is now stewarded by the Global Museum at San Francisco State University exposes a new expansive research potential for the collection, enabling Museum Studies students and faculty and museum staff to construct innovative interpretive frameworks through integrated Museum Studies curriculum, educational public programming, and exhibitions of the collection in the museum. This case study underscores the importance of provenance research for contextualizing legacy collections and illustrates how this research can be a catalyst for important discussions of the antiquities trade, colonial collecting practices, public educational significance, and ethical collection stewardship, curation, and display.
“Among the Mummies: The Specimens That Mr. Sutro Brought from Egypt.”The Morning Call. August23, 1885, Vol. LVIII, No. 83 edition.
2.
ArgyropoulosVasilikeAloupi-SiotisEleniPolikretiKyriakiApostolidesReaEl SaddikWafaaGottschalkRaymundel NazeerMona Abd, et al. 2014. “Museum Education and Archaeological Ethics: An Approach to the Illicit Trade of Antiquities.”Journal of Conservation and Museum Studies12 (1): 1–8. doi:10.5334/jcms.1021210.
3.
BaberTessa T.2016. “Ancient Corpses as Curiosities: Mummymania in the Age of Early Travel.”Journal of Ancient Egyptian Interconnections8: 60–93.
4.
Becker-ColonnaAndreina L.1967. Ancient Egypt: An Exhibition of the Sutro Egyptian Collection. San Francisco, CA: University of California Extension Center.
5.
Becker-ColonnaAndreina L.1975. “The Wooden Coffins of Nes-Per-Nub, Doorkeeper of the Temple of Amen (XXI-XXVI Dynasties?).” In Archaeological Institute of America. Washington, D.C: Archaeological Institute of America.
6.
Becker-ColonnaAndreina L.1976. “Two Ancient Egyptian Coffins From the Sutro Collection of San Francisco State University.” San Francisco, CA: San Francisco State University.
7.
Becker-ColonnaAndreina L.1979. “Myths and Symbols in a Cartonnage Coffin of the XXIst Dynasty from the Sutro Collection at San Francisco State University.” In Proceedings of the First International Congress of Egyptology (Cairo, October 2–10, 1976), edited by ReinekeWalter F., 95–101. Schriften Zur Geschichte and Kultur Des Alten Orients 14. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag.
8.
Morris L.Bierbrier, ed. 2012. Who Was Who in Egyptology. 4th ed.London: Egypt Exploration Society.
9.
BlackGraham. 2012. Transforming Museums in the Twenty-First Century. Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: Routledge.
10.
BlaisdellMarilyn. 1987. San Francisciana: Photographs of Sutro Baths. San Francisco, CA: M. Blaisdell.
11.
BoardmanJohn. 2009. “Archaeologists, Collectors, and Museums.” In Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities, edited by JamesCuno 107–24. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
BrodyChristina K.2009. “Studying the Skeletons in the Closet: Unprovenienced Archaeological Collections in Museums.”Collections: A Journal for Museum and Archives Professionals5 (3): 199–208.
13.
CahailKevin M.2000. Museum of Ancient Civilizations: Adolph Sutro and Carl Rietz Collections of Egyptian Antiquities: Catalogue of Hieroglyphic Texts and Markings. unpublished. San Francisco, CA: Global Museum at SFSU.
14.
California Department of Education. 2017. History and Social Science Framework for California Public Schools, Kindergarten Through Grade Twelve. Sacramento, CA: California Department of Education.
15.
CapartJean. 1936. Travels in Egypt [December 1880 to May 1891] Letters of Charles Edwin Wilbour. Brooklyn, NY: Brooklyn Museums.
16.
ChatterjeeHelen J.Leonie Hannan, and Linda Thomson. “An Introduction to Object-Based Learning and Multisensory Engagement.” In Engaging the Senses: Object-Based Learning in Higher Education, edited by ChatterjeeHelen J.HannanLeonie, 1–20. London and New York: Routledge, 2016.
17.
S. TerryChilds, ed. 2004. Our Collective Responsibility: The Ethics and Practice of Archaeological Collections Stewardship. Washington, D.C.: Society for American Archaeology.
18.
CunoJames. 2009. Whose Culture?: The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
19.
DavidsonRuss. 2012. “Adolph Sutro as Book Collector.”California State Library Foundation Bulletin104: 6–37.
20.
DayJasmine. 2014. “‘Thinking Makes It So’: Reflections on the Ethics of Displaying Egyptian Mummies.”Papers on AnthropologyXXIII (1): 29–44.
21.
FalkJohn H.DierkingLynn D.. 2018. Learning from Museums. 2nd ed.Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
22.
FalkJohn H.DierkingLynn D.FoutzSusan. 2007. In Principle, In Practice: Museums as Learning Institutions. Lanham, MD; New York, NY; Toronto, ON; Plymouth: AltaMira Press.
23.
FuhrmeisterChristianHoppMeike. 2019. “Rethinking Provenance Research.”Getty Research Journal11 (January): 213–31. doi:10.1086/702755.
GyllenhaalEd.2010. “From Parlor to Castle: The Egyptian Collection at Glencairn Museum.” In Millions of Jubilees: Studies in Honor of David P. Silverman, edited by HawassZahiWegnerJennifer Houser, 175–203. Supplément Aux Annales Du Service Des Antiquités de L’Egypte 39. Cairo: Publications du Conseil Suprême des Antiquités de l’Egypte.
32.
HagenFredrikRyholtKim. 2016. The Antiquities Trade in Egypt 1880-1930: The H. O. Lange Papers. Vol. Humanistica 4 vol. 8. Scientia Danica, Series H. Copenhagen: Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab.
33.
HirzyEllen. 2007. Transforming Museum Volunteering: A Practical Guide for Engaging 21st Century Volunteers. Bloomington, IN: AuthorHouse.
34.
HubschmannCaroline. 2018. “The Curation of Ancient Egypt in the Twenty-First Century: How Should the Present Engage with the Past?”Australasian Journal of Popular Culture7 (1): 75–91.
35.
International Provenance Research Colloquium, and American Association of Museums. 2005. Vitalizing Memory: International Perspectives on Provenance Research. Washington, D.C.: American Association of Museums.
36.
JohnsonAnnaHuberKimberly A.CutlerNancyBingmannMelissaGroveTim. 2017. The Museum Educator’s Manual: Educator’s Share Successful Techniques. 2nd ed.Lanham, MD; Boulder, CO; New York, NY; London: Rowman & Littlefield.
37.
KingJulia A.2016. “Comparative Colonialism and Collections-Based Archaeological Research: Dig Less, Catalog More.”Museum Worlds: Advances in Research4 (1): 4–17.
38.
KurutzGary F.2012. “The Sutro Library Now Open in a Sparkling New Location.”California State Library Foundation Bulletin104: 2–5.
39.
LubyEdward M.LightfootKent G.BradshawVictoria L.. 2013. “Archaeological Curation and the Research Value of Archaeological Collections: A Case Study from California.”Collections: A Journal for Museum and Archives Professionals9 (3): 255–82.
40.
MacDonaldSally. 2009. “Lost in Time and Space: Ancient Egypt in Museums.” In Consuming Ancient Egypt, edited by MacDonaldSallyRiceMichael, 87–100. Encounters with Ancient Egypt. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.
41.
MarstineJanet. 2011. The Routledge Companion to Museum Ethics. 1st ed. Florence: Routledge.
42.
MartiniJohn A.2014. Sutro’s Glass Palace: The Story of Sutro Baths. Bodega Bay, CA: Hole in the Head Press.
43.
MeechamPam. 2016. “Talking About Things: Internationalisation of the Curriculum Through Object-Based Learning.” In Engaging the Senses: Object-Based Learning in Higher Education, edited by ChatterjeeHelen J.HannanLeonie, 77–94. London and New York, NY: Routledge.
44.
MillerMeaganLubyEdward M.. 2004. “A Survey of World War II-Era Provenance Research in American Art Museums.”Collections: A Journal for Museum and Archives Professionals1 (4): 365–80. doi:10.1177/155019060400100406.
45.
National Docent Symposium Council. 2017. The Docent Handbook 2, Revised Edition. Hollis, NH: Puritan Press.
46.
QuirkeStephen. 2014. “Lyricism and Offence in Egyptian Archaeology Collections.” In Extreme Collecting: Challenging Practices for 21st Century Museums, edited by WereGraemeKingJ. C. H., 37–48. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
47.
RenfrewColin. 2000. Loot, Legitimacy, and Ownership: The Ethical Crisis in Archaeology. London: Duckworth.
48.
RiggsChristina. 2010. “Ancient Egypt in the Museum: Concepts and Constructions.” In A Companion to Ancient Egypt, edited by LloydAlan B., Vol. II, 1129–53. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
49.
RiggsChristina. 2014. Unwrapping Ancient Egypt. London; New Delhi: New York, NY; Sydney: Bloomsbury.
50.
RiggsChristina. 2018. “Loose Bodies: Reserve Collections, Curatorial Reservations, and the Ancient Egyptian Dead.” In BrusiusMirjamSinghKavita (eds) Museum Storage and Meaning: Tales from the Crypt, 253–62. Routledge Research in Museum Studies. London and New York, NY: Routledge.
51.
RitchhartRon. 2007. “Cultivating a Culture of Thinking in Museums.”The Journal of Museum Education32 (2): 137–53.
52.
SaidEdward W.2003. Orientalism. London: Penguin.
53.
SaundersDavidBarrJudithBudrovichNicole. 2016. “The Antiquities Provenance Project at the Getty.”Observations of the Collections Analysis Collaborative1: 1–8.
54.
Smithsonian. 2021. “German /American Provenance Research Exchange Program for Museum Professionals (PREP), 2017-2019 | Smithsonian Institution,” June 8, 2021. https://www.si.edu/events/prep.
StevensonAliceLibonatiEmmaWilliamsAlice. 2016. “‘A Selection of Minor Antiquities’: A Multi-Sited View on Collections from Excavations in Egypt.”World Archaeology48 (2): 282–95.
58.
StevensonAliceBainesJohnLibonatiEmmaWilliamsAlicePinarelloMassimilianoel GawadHeba AbdGloverSarah. 2015. “Artefacts of Excavation.”https://egyptartefacts.griffith.ox.ac.uk/.
59.
StewartRobert Ernest. 1962. Adolph Sutro: A Biography. Berkeley, CA: Howell-North.
60.
SullivanLynne P.ChildsS. Terry. 2003. Curating Archaeological Collections: From the Field to the Repository. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.
61.
SutroAdolph. 1884a. “Letter to Adamson and Moore, March 6, 1884.” Box 2, Folder 83, M000001. Papers of Adolph Sutro, Sutro Library, California State Library, San Francisco, CA.
62.
SutroAdolph. 1884b. “Letter to Adamson and Moore, March 23, 1884.” Box 2, Folder 83, M000001. Papers of Adolph Sutro, Sutro Library, California State Library, San Francisco, CA.
TigertJohanna M.KirshbaumSheila. 2019. “How Museum Teachers Scaffold Emergent Bilingual Learners’ Meaning-Making During Field Trips.”Journal of Museum Education44 (4): 439–47.
68.
TubbKathryn Walker. 2014. “Extreme or Commonplace: The Collecting of Unprovenanced Antiquities.” In Extreme Collecting: Challenging Practices for 21st Century Museums, edited by WereGraemeKingJ. C. H., 57–74. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
69.
GraemeWereKingJonathan C. H., eds. 2014. Extreme Collecting: Challenging Practices for 21st Century Museums. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
70.
WillardRuth. 1979. “Mummies at Macys.”Nob Hill Gazette. May.
71.
YeideNancy H.2001. The AAM Guide to Provenance Research. Washington, D.C.: American Association of Museums.
