Experiences with recruitment and retention of adolescents and emerging adults in a weight loss intervention trial

Abstract

Background/Aims:

Efficient and effective participant recruitment is key for successful clinical research. Adolescent and emerging adult recruitment into clinical trials can be particularly challenging, especially when targeting underrepresented groups. This study aimed to determine the most successful recruitment strategies from those employed during a pediatric trial testing the efficacy of a behavioral intervention on adiposity and cardiovascular disease risk.

Methods:

We determined the effectiveness, cost, and diversity of the final research population by each recruitment method utilized in the EMPower trial, a randomized clinical trial designed to test the effect of a technology-delivered behavioral Healthy Lifestyle intervention on adiposity, blood pressure, and left ventricular mass among adolescents and emerging adults with overweight or obesity. Effectiveness was determined by respondent yield (RY; number of respondents/number contacted), scheduled yield (SY; number scheduled for a baseline visit/number of respondents), enrollment yield (EY; number enrolled/number of respondents), and retention (number completed/number enrolled). Cost-effectiveness of each recruitment method was calculated and demographics of participants recruited via each method was determined.

Results:

A minimum of 109,314 adolescents and emerging adults were contacted by at least one recruitment method (clinic, web-based, postal mailing, electronic medical record (EMR) messaging) leading to 429 respondents. The most successful strategies in terms of RY were clinic-based recruitment (n = 47, 61% RY), community web-postings (n = 109, 5.33% RY), and EMR messaging (n = 163, 0.99% RY); however, website, postal mailings, and EMR recruitment led to more successful SY and EY. Postal mailings were the most costly strategy to employ (US$3261/completed participant) with EMR messaging the second most costly (US$69/completed participant). Community web-postings were free of charge. Clinic-based recruitment did not add additional costs, per se, but did require a substantial amount of personnel time (63.6 h/completed participant). Final cohort diversity primarily came from postal mailings (57% Black) and EMR messages (50% female).

Conclusion:

Electronic medical record messaging and web-based recruitment were highly successful and cost-effective strategies in a pediatric clinical trial targeting adolescents and emerging adults, but was less successful in recruiting a diverse cohort. Clinic recruitment and postal mailings, despite being costly and time-consuming, were the strategies that enrolled a greater proportion of underrepresented groups. While online forms of trial recruitment are growing in popularity, clinic-based recruitment and non-web-based strategies may be required to ensure participant diversity and representation.

Keywords

Pediatric clinical trial recruitment underrepresented groups electronic health record recruitment electronic medical record recruitment clinic-based recruitment pediatrics youth

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Huang

Bull

Johnston McKee

, et al. Clinical trials recruitment planning: a proposed framework from the clinical trials transformation initiative. Contemp Clin Trials 2018; 66: 74–79.

Nguyen

McGregor

O’Connor

, et al. Recruitment challenges and recommendations for adolescent obesity trials. J Paediatr Child Health 2012; 48(1): 38–43.

Miller

Charleston

, et al. Use of electronic recruitment methods in a clinical trial of adults with gout. Clin Trials 2021; 18(1): 92–103.

Donovan

Rooshenas

Jepson

, et al. Optimising recruitment and informed consent in randomised controlled trials: the development and implementation of the Quintet Recruitment Intervention (QRI). Trials 2016; 17: 283.

Liu

Cox

Jr Washburn

, et al. The effects of requiring parental consent for research on adolescents’ risk behaviors: a meta-analysis. J Adolesc Health 2017; 61(1): 45–52.

Grape

Rhee

Wicks

, et al. Recruitment and retention strategies for an urban adolescent study: lessons learned from a multi-center study of community-based asthma self-management intervention for adolescents. J Adolesc 2018; 65: 123–132.

Thompson

Mercado

Martinko

, et al. Novel Interventions and assessments using patient portals in adolescent research: confidential survey study. J Med Internet Res 2018; 20: e101.

Cantrell

Hair

Smith

, et al. Recruiting and retaining youth and young adults: challenges and opportunities in survey research for tobacco control. Tob Control 2018; 27(2): 147–154.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Child & Teen BMI. Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2021.

10.

Gleason

Ford

Gumas

, et al. Development and preliminary evaluation of a patient portal messaging for research recruitment service. J Clin Transl Sci 2018; 2(1): 53–56.

11.

Plante

Gleason

Miller

, et al. Recruitment of trial participants through electronic medical record patient portal messaging: a pilot study. Clin Trials 2020; 17(1): 30–38.

12.

Cui

Seburg

Sherwood

, et al. Recruitment and retention in obesity prevention and treatment trials targeting minority or low-income children: a review of the clinical trials registration database. Trials 2015; 16: 564.

13.

Villarruel

Jemmott

, et al. Recruitment and retention of Latino adolescents to a research study: lessons learned from a randomized clinical trial. J Spec Pediatr Nurs 2006; 11(4): 244–250.