Human-Machine symbiosis in educational leadership in the era of artificial intelligence (AI): Where are we heading?

Abstract

The issue of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and educational leadership has become a central topic following the shift to knowledge technology and digital literacy in recent years. Despite increasing attention to the topic among scholars and policymakers during the last decade, we lack a comprehensive review of AI and educational leadership. Therefore, by using bibliometric analysis of data derived from the Scopus database, this paper represents a systematic scoping of AI and educational leadership, tracing its development, characteristics, and knowledge accumulation within broad perspectives. Results identify key trends, geographic representation, topical foci, main concepts, themes, and their interconnections, including their implications for targeted Sustainable Development Goals. Implications, limitations, and future research reviewed in the studies are fully discussed.

Keywords

Artificial intelligence technology digital leadership decision-making administration organization future of work

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aldridge

McLure

(2023) Preparing schools for educational change: Barriers and supports – A systematic literature review. Leadership and Policy in Schools 23: 486–511.

Arar

Chen

(2021) The future of higher education: A new paradigm shift addressing students’ diversity. In: The promise of higher education: Essays in honour of 70 years of IAU, 369–376.

Arar

Saiti

Guajardo

(2023a) Redesigning and recomputing the future of education: The role of technology, the learning process, personality traits, and diversity in learning systems. Power and Education 15(2): 243–258.

Arar

Guajardo

Saiti

Abo-Zaed Arar

(2023b) Relational assurance in higher education in the knowledge technology era: The case of postgraduate program of educational leadership. Power and Education: 17577438231218376.

Aria

Cuccurullo

(2017) Bibliometrix: An R-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. Journal of Informetrics 11(4): 959–975.

Azer

Guerrero

APS

(2023) The challenges imposed by artificial intelligence: Are we ready in medical education?. BMC Medical Education 23(1): 680.

Bohr

Memarzadeh

(2020) The rise of artificial intelligence in healthcare applications. Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare: 25–60. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-818438-7.00002-2

Bryant

Christine

Saurabh

Dilip

(2020) How artificial intelligence will impact K-12 teachers. McKinsey & Company, January 2020. https://www.mckinsey.com/∼/media/McKinsey/Industries/Social%20Sector/Our%20Insights/How%20artificial%20intelligence%20will%20impact%20K%2012%20teachers/How-artificial-intelligence-will-impact-K-12-teachers.pdf

Buolamwini

Gebru

(2018, January) Gender shades: Intersectional accuracy disparities in commercial gender classification. In: Conference on Fairness, Accountability and Transparency. New York, NY, USA: PMLR, 77–91.

10.

Bushweller

(2020) Teachers, the robots are coming. But that's not a bad thing. Education Week 39(7): 8–9.

11.

Chartier-Rueg

Zweifel

(2017) Blockchain, leadership and management: Business as usual or radical disruption? EUREKA: Social and Humanities 4: 76–110.

12.

Chen

Lin

(2020) Artificial intelligence in education: A review. IEEE Access 8: 75264–75278.

13.

Chen

Gong

Jie Xiong

(2023) Can AI chatbots help retain customers? The impact of AI service quality on customer loyalty. Internet Research 33(6): 2205–2243.

14.

Chryssolouris

Alexopoulos

Arkouli

(2023) A perspective on artificial intelligence in manufacturing (Vol. 436). Cham, Switzerland: Springer Nature.

15.

Cockburn

Henderson

Stern

(2018) The impact of artificial intelligence on innovation. Working Paper 2339, National Bureau of Economic Research. http://www.nber.org/papers/w24449.

16.

Coyle

Weller

(2020) “Explaining” machine learning reveals policy challenges. Science 368(6498): 1433–1434.

17.

Currall

Epstein

(2003) The fragility of organizational trust: Lessons from the rise and fall of Enron. Organizational Dynamics 32: 193–206.

18.

Denden

Tlili

Essalmi

Jemni

Chang

, Kinshuk and Huang R (2019) imoodle: An intelligent gamified moodle to predict “at-risk” students using learning analytics approaches. In: Data analytics approaches in educational games and Gamification systems, 113–126.

19.

Dubin

(1978) Theory Building. New York: Free Press.

20.

Dagli

Muhtaroglu

Bastas

Altinay

(2023) Evaluation of primary school managers’ duties in digital transformation. Revista de Gestão e Secretariado (Management and Administrative Professional Review) 14(9): 15227–15249.

21.

de Vreede

Briggs

(2019) A program of collaboration engineering research and practice: Contributions, insights, and future directions. Journal of Management Information Systems 36(1): 74–119.

22.

Dellermann

Ebel

Söllner

Leimeister

(2019) Hybrid intelligence. Business & Information Systems Engineering 61: 637–643.

23.

Donthu

Kumar

Mukherjee

Pandey

Lim

(2021) How to conduct a bibliometric analysis: An overview and guidelines. Journal of Business Research 133: 285–296.

24.

Eke

Wakunuma

Akintoye

(2023) Responsible AI in Africa: Challenges and Opportunities. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan Cham.

25.

Ellegaard

Wallin

(2015) The bibliometric analysis of scholarly production: How great is the impact? Scientometrics 105: 1809–1831.

26.

Elo

Uljens

(2023) Theorising pedagogical dimensions of higher education leadership—a non-affirmative approach. Higher Education 85(6): 1281–1298.

27.

European Commission (2022) Ethical guidelines on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and data in teaching and learning for Educators. Retrieved November 30, 2023, from https://education.ec.europa.eu/news/ethical-guidelines-on-the-use-of-artificial-intelligence-and-data-in-teaching-and-learning-for-educators.

28.

European Commission (2019) European Commission Independent High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence. Ethics guidelines for trustworthy AI. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/futurium/en/ai-alliance-consultation.

29.

Frick

(2009) Principals’ value-informed decision making, intrapersonal moral discord, and pathways to resolution: The complexities of moral leadership praxis. Journal of Educational Administration 47(1): 50–74.

30.

Fullan

Azorín

Harris

Jones

(2023) Artificial intelligence and school leadership: Challenges, opportunities and implications. School Leadership & Management 44: 339–346.

31.

Gonzales

(2023) Implications of AI innovation on economic growth: A panel data study. Economic Structures 12: 13. DOI: 10.1186/s40008-023-00307-w

32.

Gümüş

Arar

Oplatka

(2021) Review of international research on school leadership for social justice, equity and diversity. Journal of Educational Administration and History 53(1): 81–99.

33.

Gamarra

Girotto

(2022) Ethical behavior in leadership: A bibliometric review of the last three decades. Ethics & Behavior 32(2): 124–146.

34.

Gerpott

Lehmann-Willenbrock

Silvis

Vugt

(2018) In the eye of the beholder? An eye-tracking experiment on emergent leadership in team interactions. The Leadership Quarterly 29(4): 523–532.

35.

Ghamrawi

Shal

Ghamrawi

(2024) Exploring the impact of AI on teacher leadership: Regressing or expanding? Education and Information Technologies 29: 8415–8433.

36.

Goldfarb

Lindsay

(2022) Prediction and judgment: Why artificial intelligence increases the importance of humans in war. International Security 46(3): 7–50.

37.

Gracias

Parnell

Specking

Pohl

Buchanan

(2023) Smart cities—A structured literature review. Smart Cities 6(4): 1719–1743.

38.

Greene

(2013) Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap between Us and Them. New York, NY: Penguin Press.

39.

Griffiths

(1959) Administrative Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

40.

Hallinger

Kovačević

(2019) A bibliometric review of research on educational administration: Science mapping the literature, 1960 to 2018. Review of Educational Research 89(3): 335–369.

41.

Huang

Tlili

Chen

Zheng

Metwally

Chang

Wang

Mason

Stracke

(2023) Educational futures of intelligent synergies between humans, digital twins, avatars, and robots-the iSTAR framework. Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching: 1–16.

42.

Halff

(1986) Instructional applications of artificial intelligence. Educational Leadership 43(6): 24–31.

43.

Hallinger

Kovačević

(2021) Science mapping the knowledge base in educational leadership and management: A longitudinal bibliometric analysis, 1960 to 2018. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 49(1): 5–30.

44.

Hallinger

Gümüş

Bellibaş

MŞ

(2020) ‘Are principals instructional leaders yet?'A science map of the knowledge base on instructional leadership, 1940–2018. Scientometrics 122(3): 1629–1650.

45.

Harris

Jones

(2023) Compassionate leadership. School Leadership & Management 43(3): 185–188.

46.

Herold

(2019) Forty percent of elementary school teachers’ work could be automated by 2030, McKinsey Global Institute Predicts. Education Week, 4 June, available at: https://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/DigitalEducation/2019/06/women_future_of_work_mckinsey.html (accessed 8 September 2023).

47.

Herse

(2021) The hidden strategy treasure—If the company knew what the company all knows. Evolutionizer. https://www.evolutionizer.com/en-strategy-development-content/strategy-treasure-ai.

48.

Hodgkinson

(1978) Towards a philosophy of administration. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

49.

Holmes

Porayska-Pomsta

(eds) (2023) The ethics of artificial intelligence in education: Practices, challenges, and debates. London, UK: Routledge.

50.

Hong

(2022) Predictions without futures*. History and Theory 61(3): 371–390.

51.

Hsieh

Tai

(2023) A bibliometric review of ethical leadership research: Shifting focuses and theoretical insights. AERA Open 9: 23328584231209266.

52.

Kaber

(2018) Issues in human–automation interaction modeling: Presumptive aspects of frameworks of types and levels of automation. Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making 12(1): 7–24.

53.

Khan

Pattnaik

Ashraf

Ali

Kumar

Donthu

(2021) Value of special issues in the journal of business research: A bibliometric analysis. Journal of Business Research 125: 295–313.

54.

Kouzes

Posner

(2007) The leadership challenge, 4th ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

55.

Yan

Yang

(2022) Artificial intelligence capability and organizational creativity: The role of knowledge sharing and organizational cohesion. Frontiers in psychology 13: 845277. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.845277

56.

Lipshaw

(2020) Governance≠ Leadership: What Blockchain and AI won't do for corporate lawyers. The Journal of Corporation Law 46: 4.

57.

Makridis

Mishra

(2020) (How) Does Artificial Intelligence Raise Well-being? Evidence from Cities in the United States. Evidence from Cities in the United States (August 17, 2020).

58.

Marion

Uhl-Bien

(2001) Leadership in complex organizations. The Leadership Quarterly 12(4): 389–418.

59.

McCarthy

Minsky

Rochester

Shannon

(1955) A proposal for Dartmouth summer research project on artificial intelligence. AI Magazine 27: 12.

60.

Mikalef

Islam

Parida

Singh

Altwaijry

(2023) Artificial intelligence (AI) competencies for organizational performance: A B2B marketing capabilities perspective. Journal of Business Research 164: 113998.

61.

Milton

Al-Busaidi

AA-B

(2023) New role of leadership in AI era: Educational sector. SHS Web of Conferences 156: 09005.

62.

Moore

(1965) Cramming more components onto integrated circuits. Electronics 38(8): 114–117. https://newsroom.intel.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/11/2018/05/moores-law-electronics.pdf .

63.

Murphy

(2019) Artificial intelligence applications to support K–12 teachers and teaching: A review of promising applications, challenges, and risks. Rand Corporation PE-315-RC.

64.

Mhlanga

(2021) Financial inclusion in emerging economies: The application of machine learning and artificial intelligence in credit risk assessment. International Journal of Financial Studies 9: 39. DOI: 10.3390/ijfs9030039

65.

Morgan

(2021) Howard Gardner’s multiple intelligences theory and his ideas on promoting creativity. In Reisman

(Ed.) Celebrating giants and trailblazers: A-Z of who’s who in creativity research and related fields. London, UK: KIE Publications, 124–141.

66.

Mukherjee

Lim

Kumar

Donthu

(2022) Guidelines for advancing theory and practice through bibliometric research. Journal of Business Research 148: 101–115.

67.

Nass

Fogg

Moon

(1996) Can computers be teammates? International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 45(6): 669–678.

68.

Neher

Petersson

Nygren

Svedberg

Larsson

Nilsen

(2023) Innovation in healthcare: Leadership perceptions about the innovation characteristics of artificial intelligence-a qualitative interview study with healthcare leaders in Sweden. Implementation Science Communications 4(1): 81.

69.

Nelson

(1989) Artificial intelligence knowledge acquisition techniques for instructional development. Educational Technology Research and Development 37(3): 81–94.

70.

Okunlaya

Syed Abdullah

Alias

(2022) Artificial intelligence (AI) library services innovative conceptual framework for the digital transformation of university education. Library Hi Tech 40(6): 1869–1892.

71.

Page

McKenzie

Bossuyt

Boutron

Hoffmann

Mulrow

Shamseer

Tetzlaff

Akl

Brennan

Chou

Glanville

Grimshaw

Hróbjartsson

Lalu

Loder

Mayo-Wilson

McDonald

McGuinness

Stewart

Thomas

Tricco

Welch

Whiting

Moher

(2021) The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71.

72.

Papa

Jackson

(2022) Artificial intelligence, human agency and the educational leader. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

73.

Peifer

Jeske

Hille

(2022) Artificial intelligence and its impact on leaders and leadership. Procedia Computer Science 200: 1024–1030.

74.

Raisch

Krakowski

(2021) Artificial intelligence and management: The automation–augmentation paradox. The Academy of Management Review 46(1): 192–210.

75.

Rožman

Tominc

Milfelner

(2023) Maximizing employee engagement through artificial intelligent organizational culture in the context of leadership and training of employees: Testing linear and non-linear relationships. Cogent Business & Management 10: 2.

76.

Schöbel

Saqr

Janson

(2021) Two decades of game concepts in digital learning environments–A bibliometric study and research agenda. Computers & Education 173: 104296.

77.

Shafiabady

Hadjinicolaou

Din

Bhandari

Vakilian

(2023) Using artificial intelligence (AI) to predict organizational agility. PloS one 18(5): e0283066.

78.

Soni

(2020) Emerging roles of artificial intelligence in ecommerce. Int. J. Trend Res. Dev 4(5): 223–225.

79.

Sparks

(2017) “Teachers’ jobs aren't going away, but they could be different”. available at: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2017/09/27/how-intelligent-tutors-could-transform-teaching.html (accessed 8 September 2022).

80.

Standley

(1999) Building technology leadership skills. 7^th International Conference on Computers in Education (ICCE 99), 799-800. CHIBA, JAPAN.

81.

Salha

Affouneh

(2023) The state of art of educational leadership in Palestine: The two faces of the coin. In Kh. Arar et al. (Eds). Demystifying educational leadership and administration in the Middle East and North Africa. 1st ed., Routledge, 153–165. DOI: 10.4324/9781003334835-9

82.

Tarter

Hoy

(1998) Toward a contingency theory of decision making. Journal of Educational Administration 36(3): 212–228.

83.

Thurmond

(2001) The point of triangulation. Journal of Nursing Scholarship 33(3): 253–258.

84.

Tlili

Denden

Abed

Huang

(2024) Artificial intelligence ethics in services: Are we paying attention to that? The Service Industries Journal: 1–24.

85.

Turing

(1950) Computing machinery and intelligence. Mind A Quarterly Review of Psychology and Philosophy 236: 433–460.

86.

Tlili

Burgos

Huang

Mishra

Sharma

Bozkurt

(2021a) An analysis of peer-reviewed publications on open educational practices (OEP) from 2007 to 2020: A bibliometric mapping analysis. Sustainability 13(19): 10798.

87.

Tlili

Chang

Moon

Liu

Burgos

Chen

(2021b) A systematic literature review of empirical studies on learning analytics in educational games. International Journal of Interactive Multimedia and Artificial Intelligence (IJIMAI) 7(2): DOI: 10.9781/ijimai.2021.03.003

88.

Ullman

(2019) Using neuroscience to develop artificial intelligence. Science 363(6428): 692–693.

89.

UNESCO (2015) Incheon Declaration and framework for action. http://uis.unesco.org/sites/default/files/documents/education-2030-incheon-framework-for-action-implementation-of-sdg4-2016-en_2.pdf.

90.

UNESCO (2019) Artificial Intelligence in Education: Challenges and Opportunities for Sustainable Development. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000366994.

91.

UNICEF (2021) Policy guidance on AI for children. https://www.unicef.org/globalinsight/media/2356/file/UNICEF-Global-Insight-policy-guidance-AI-children-2.0-2021.pdf.

92.

van den Besselaar

Heimeriks

(2006) Mapping research topics using word-reference co-occurrences: A method and an exploratory case study. Scientometrics 68: 377–393. DOI: 10.1007/s11192-006-0118-9

93.

van Eck

Waltman

(2017) Citation-based clustering of publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewer. Scientometrics 111: 1053–1070. DOI: 10.1007/s11192-017-2300-7

94.

Vogel

Reichard

Batistič

Černe

(2021) A bibliometric review of the leadership development field: How we got here, where we are, and where we are headed. The Leadership Quarterly 32(5): 101381.

95.

Wagner

(2024) Toward a shared conception of children’s content area identities in literacy, math, and science: A systematic integrative review. Review of Educational Research 94(3): 343–375.

96.

Walczak

(2016) Artificial neural networks and other AI applications for business management decision support. International Journal of Sociotechnology and Knowledge Development 8(4): 1–20.

97.

Wang

(2021a) Artificial intelligence in educational leadership: A symbiotic role of human-artificial intelligence decision-making. Journal of Educational Administration 59(3): 256–270.

98.

Wang

(2021b) When artificial intelligence meets educational leaders’ data-informed decision-making: A cautionary tale. Studies in Educational Evaluation 69: 100872.

99.

Wang

Tlili

Huang

Cai

Cheng

Yang

Zhu

Fei

(2023) Examining the applications of intelligent tutoring systems in real educational contexts: A systematic literature review from the social experiment perspective. Education and Information Technologies: 1–36.

100.

Whetten

(1989) What constitutes a theoretical contribution? Academy of Management Review 14: 490–495.

101.

Yang

Ouyang

Gao

Zeng

(2022) Social-path embedding-based transformer for graduation development prediction. Applied Intelligence 52: 14119–14136.

102.

Zhang

Zhou

(2017) Multiple human EEG synchronous analysis in group interaction-prediction model for group involvement and individual leadership. In: Augmented Cognition. Neurocognition and Machine Learning: 11^th International Conference, AC 2017, Held as Part of HCI International 2017, Vancouver, BC, Canada, July 9-14, 2017, Proceedings, Part I 11. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing, 99–108.