This paper presents a microanalysis of the media representation of victimhood in key public narratives. It builds on Peelo's account of the `mediated witness' as part of the struggle for control of the crime agenda. To extend Peelo's analysis to other areas of public policy making, the paper uses the example of an iconic welfare `scandal' (the Maria Colwell case) and focuses particularly on the role of victims themselves in the struggle to own and exploit victimhood. The paper argues that ambiguity in the ascription of victimhood can reveal points of unresolved tension in the emerging public narrative that the scandal (or crime) is meant to signify, explain and incorporate.
Drakeford, M. and I. Butler (2007) `Everyday Tragedies: Justice, Scandal and Young People in Contemporary Britain', Howard Journal.
32.
Guardian (1973) `I was her Mum - I Loved her' , 1 December.
33.
Hendrick, H. (1994) Child Welfare: England 1872-1989. London: Routledge.
34.
HMG (2003) Every Child Matters . TSO: London.
35.
Independent (2005) `Children Left to Starve Were "Failed by Care Workers"', 22 December.
36.
Innes, M. (2004) `Crime as a Signal, Crime as a Memory', Journal for Crime, Conflict and the Media1(2): 15-22.
37.
Katz, J. (1987) `What Makes Crime "News"?', Media, Culture and Society9: 47-75.
38.
News of the World (1973) `What could Mrs Kepple do?', 22 April.
39.
Parton, N. (2004) `From Maria Colwell to Victoria Climbié: Reflections on Public Inquiries into Child Abuse a Generation Apart', Child Abuse Review31: 80-94.
40.
Peelo, M. (2006) `Framing Homicide Narratives in Newspapers: Mediated witness and the Construction of Virtual Victimhood', Crime Media Culture2(2): 159-75.
41.
Public Record Office: file 2/5197/1: Papers of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
42.
Public Record Office: file 2/5198: Papers of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
43.
Reder, P. and S. Duncan (2004) `From Colwell to Climbié: Inquiring into Fatal Child Abuse', in N. Stanley and J. Manthorpe (eds) The Age of the Inquiry: Learning and Blaming in Health and Social Care, pp. 92-115. London : Routledge.
44.
Reder, P., S. Duncan and M. Gray (1993) Beyond Blame - Child Abuse Tragedies Revisited . London: Routledge.
45.
Soothill, K., M. Peelo, B. Francis, J. Pearson and E. Ackerley (2002) `Homicide and the Media: Identifying Top Cases in The Times', The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice41(5): 401-21.
46.
Soothill, K., M. Peelo, J. Pearson and B. Francis (2004) `The Reporting Trajectories of Top Homicide Cases in the Media: A Case Study of The Times', Howard Journal43(1): 1-14.
47.
Sun (1973a) `I'm so Scared, Says Maria's Mum' , 2 November.
48.
Sun (1973b) `Kepple: I Want A Divorce', 6 December.
49.
Sun (1973c) `The Torment of Maria's Mother: Tears as Inquiry Hears of a Poison Pen Campaign', 7 December.
50.
Sun (1973d) `The Tragic Pawn: Battle over Maria's love', 17 November.
51.
Sun (2004) `Another Child Dies. Another Inquiry is Published. More Lessons are Supposedly Learned', 5 May.
52.
Sun Special Investigation (1973) `Scandal of Murdered Step-Daughter', 17 April.
53.
Sunday Mirror (1973) `Brute Moved to New Jail' , 28 October.
54.
Sunday Times (1973) `Battered Maria: Neighbours "Tried to Warn Official''', 21 October.
55.
The Primary Review (2007) Children's Lives and Voices: Research on Children at Home and School. University of Cambridge: Cambridge.
56.
Times Educational Supplement (2005) `Abuse Sums May Be Fatal Distraction', 15 July.
57.
Unicef (2007) `Child Poverty in Perspective: An Overview of Child well-being in Rich Countries', Innocenti Report Card7, 2007UNICEF: Innocenti Research Centre, Florence.
