This paper examines leadership development in the public, private and not-for-profit sectors and assesses the extent that they constitute distinctive contexts for leadership approaches and practices. The results of an empirical survey issued in one country provides some evidence for sector differences whereby leadership is conceptualized and practised with a greater emphasis placed on normative, ethical considerations in the public and not-for-profit sectors. Leadership development in the private sector is more strongly motivated by instrumental economic concerns. Whilst this sector difference is not new or surprising, the potential for greater sectoral distinctiveness in leadership approaches and their development warrants more discussion by academics and practitioners in leadership development.
This study of leadership development examines five leadership approaches (charismatic, transformational, authentic, servant and spiritual) and six common leadership development practices (360 degree feedback, mentoring, coaching, networks, job assignment and action learning). Leadership development practices are similar across the private, public and not-for-profit sectors. Furthermore, charismatic and transformational approaches do not appear to discriminate effectively between private and public sector leadership. However, interpretation of the data strongly suggests that leadership theories and practices should be more flexible to the sectoral contexts.
Private sector models of leadership development superficially appear to be adequate in so far as they share substantial commonality with the public and not-for-profit sectors in their development practices. However, respondents from the public and not-for-profit sectors are less convinced by the importance of some of the private sector 's approaches and its dominant values such as preparedness to facilitate the leaders’ confidence and power to create effective leadership. This distinction requires further investigation in future research on theories, practices and contexts for leadership development.
Adler PS, Kwon S-W. and Heckscher C. ( 2008) Professional work: The emergence of collaborative community . Organization Science19(2): 359-376. (March-April).
2.
Ahsan N. ( 2007) Evaluating leadership efforts for neighborhood transformation . In: Murphy SE and Riggio RE (eds). The Future of Leadership Development. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 403-426.
3.
Alban-Metcalfe J. and Alimo-Metcalfe B. ( 2007) Development of a private sector version of the (Engaging) transformational leadership questionnaire. Leadership & Organization Development Journal28(2): 104-121.
4.
Alimo-Metcalfe B. and Alban-Metcalfe J. ( 2005) The crucial role of leadership in meeting the challenges of change. Vision-The Journal of Business Perspective9(2): 27-39. (April-June).
5.
Alimo-Metcalfe B., Ford J., Harding N. and Lawler J. ( 2000) British Companies at the Beginning of the 21st Century: Factors that Impede Leadership Development Initiatives. Careers Research Forum: London.
6.
Argyris C. ( 1980) Some limitations of the case method: Experiences in a management development program. Academy of Management Review5(2): 291-298.
7.
Atwater LE and Brett JF ( 2006) 360-degree feedback to leaders: Does it relate to changes in employee attitudes?Group & Organization Management31(5): 578-600. (October).
8.
Atwater LE, Brett JF and Charles AC ( 2007) Multisource feedback: Lessons learned and implications for practice. Human Resource Management46(2): 286-307. (Summer).
9.
Atwater LE, Brett JF and Waldman D. ( 2003) Understanding the benefits and risks of multisource feedback within the leadership development process. In: Susan E. Murphy and Ronald E Riggio (eds). The Future of Leadership Development. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 89-106.
10.
Audit Scotland ( 2005) Leadership Development: How Government Works. Report prepared for the Auditor General, Scotland. November, Edinburgh : Audit Scotland.
11.
Avolio BJ ( 2007) Promoting more integrative strategies for leadership theory-building . American Psychologist62(1): 25-33. (January).
12.
Avolio BJ and Bass BM ( 1998) You can drag a horse to water but you can’t make it drink unless it is thirsty. The Journal of Leadership Studies4(1): 393-399.
13.
Avolio BJ and Bass BM ( 2002) Developing potential across a full range of leadership: Cases on transactional and transformational leadership. New York: Taylor and Francis Group/Psychology Press .
14.
Avolio BJ and Gardner WL ( 2005) Authentic leadership development: Getting to the root of positive forms of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly16(3): 315-493.
15.
Avolio BJ, Zhu W., Koh W. and Bhatia P. ( 2004) Transformational leadership and organizational commitment: mediating role of psychological empowerment and moderating role of structural distance. Journal of Organizational Behaviour25(8): 951-968.
16.
Ayman R., Adams A., Fisher B. and Hartman E. ( 2003) Leadership development in higher education institutions: A present and future perspective. In: Murphy SE and Riggio RE (eds). The Future of Leadership Development. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 201-222.
17.
Bach S. and Kessler I. ( 2007) HRM and the New Public Management. In: Boxall P, Purcell J and Wright PThe Oxford Handbook of Human Resource Management, Chapter23 (ed). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 469-488.
18.
Barker RA ( 1997) How can we train leaders if we do not know what leadership is? Human Relations50(4): 343-362.
19.
Barker RA ( 2001) The Nature of Leadership. Human Relations54(4): 469-494.
20.
Barling J., Weber T. and Kelloway EK ( 1996) Effects of transformational leadership training on attitudinal and financial outcomes: A field experiment. Journal of Applied Psychology81(6): 827-832.
21.
Bass BM, Avolio BJ, Jung DI and Berson Y. ( 2003) Predicting unit performance by assessing transformational and transactional leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology88(2) April. 207-218.
22.
Behrens TR and Benham Mkp ( 2007) Evaluating community leadership programs. The Handbook of Leadership Development Evaluation. In: Hannum KM, Martineau JW and Reinelt C, The Handbook of Leadership Development Evaluation, Josey ed. Bass and Center for Creative Leadership. New York: John Wiley, 284-314.
23.
Blackler F. and Kennedy A. ( 2004) The design and evaluation of a leadership programme for experienced chief executives from the public sector. Management Learning35(2): 181-203.
24.
Bolden R. ( 2004) What is Leadership?. Exeter: Leadership South West Report 1, Centre for Leadership Studies, University of Exeter (UK).
25.
Bolden R.What is Leadership Development? Purpose and Practice. Leadership South West: Research Report 2. Centre for Leadership Studies, University of Exeter (UK).
26.
Bolden R. ( 2006) Customer focussed leadership. In: Richard BoldenLeadership Development in Context. Exeter : Leadership South West Report3, Centre for Leadership Studies, University of Exeter (UK), 16-19.
27.
Brock DM, Powell MJ and Hinings CR (Bob) (eds.), (1999) Restructuring the Professional Organization: Accounting, Health Care and Law. London: Routledge .
28.
Chhokar JS, Brodbeck FC and House RJ ( 2007) Series in Organization and Management. Culture and leadership across the world: The GLOBE book of in-depth studies of 25 societies. London: Routledge.
29.
Cohn JM, Khurana R. and Reeves L. ( 2005) Growing talent as if your business depended on it. Harvard Business Review83(10): 62-70. (October).
30.
Conger JA ( 1992) Learning to Lead: The Art of Transforming Managers into Leaders. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass .
31.
Conger JA and Toegel G. ( 2003) Action learning and multirater feedback: Pathways to leadership development? In: SE and Riggio RE (eds). The Future of Leadership DevelopmentMahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 107-125.
32.
Day DV ( 2001) Leadership Development: A Review in Context. The Leadership Quarterly11(4): 581-613.
33.
Day DV and Harrison MM ( 2007) A multilevel, identity-based approach to leadership development . Human Resource Management Review17: 360-373.
34.
Debrah Y. and Rees C. ( 2010) The development of global leaders and expatriates . In: Anne-Wil Harzing and Ashly Pinnington. (eds) International Human Resource Management , 3rd edition. London: Sage, 377-414.
35.
Donaldson T. and Preston LE ( 1995) The stakeholder theory of the corporation: Concepts, evidence and implications. Academy of Management Review20(1): 65-91.
36.
Edwards G. and Gill R. ( 2005) Evaluating leadership across organizations. In: Roger GillLeadership under the Microscope. Ross-on-Wye: The Leadership Trust, 23-34.
37.
Fry LW, Vitucci S. and Cedillo M. ( 2005) Spiritual leadership and army transformation: Theory, measurement, and establishing a baseline. The Leadership Quarterly16: 835-862.
38.
Gemmill G. and Oakley J. ( 1992) Leadership: An alienating social myth? Human Relations45: 113-129.
39.
Goh JWP ( 2010) ‘Parallel leadership in an ‘‘unparallel’’ world’: Cultural constraints on the transferability of Western educational leadership theories across culture. International Journal of Leadership in Education12(4): 319-345.
40.
Graham JW ( 1991) Servant-leadership in organizations: Inspirational and moral. The Leadership Quarterly2(2): 105-119.
41.
Green ME ( 2002) Ensuring the organization’s future: A leadership development case study. Public Personnel Management31(4): 431-439. (Winter).
42.
Hinings CR, (Bob), Greenwood R. and Ranson S. ( 1975) Contingency theory and the organization of local authorities: Part II. Contingencies and structure. Public Administration53(2): 169-190.
43.
Howard KA and Reinelt C. ( 2007) Evaluating leadership development for social change . In: Hannum KM, Martineau JW and Reinelt CThe Handbook of Leadership Development Evaluation. New York: John Wiley/Josey-Bass and Center for Creative Leadership, 343-376.
44.
James R. ( 2008) Leadership development inside-out in Africa. Nonprofit Management & Leadership18(3): 359-375. (Spring).
45.
James K. and Burgoyne J. ( 2001) Leadership Development: Best Practice Guide for Organizations . London: The Council for Excellence in Management and Leadership (CEML).
46.
Javidan M., Dorfman PW, Sully de Luque M. and House RJ ( 2006) In the eye of the beholder: Cross cultural lessons in leadership from Project GLOBE. Academy of Management Perspectives67-90. (February).
47.
Judge WQ and Ryman JA ( 2001) The shared leadership challenge in strategic alliances: Lessons from the U.S. healthcare industry. Academy of Management Executive15(2): 72-79.
48.
Kellerman B. ( 2008) Followership: How Followers are Creating Change and Changing Leaders. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Press.
49.
Kelloway EK, Barling J. and Helleur J. ( 2000) Enhancing transformational leadership: the roles of training and feedback. Leadership & Organization Development Journal21(3): 145-149.
50.
Kempster S. ( 2009) How Managers Have Learnt to Lead. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
51.
Kirkpatrick I. and Ackroyd S. ( 2003) Transforming the professional archetype?: The new managerialism in UK social services. Public Management Review5(4): 511-531.
52.
Kluger AN and Denisi A. ( 1996) The effects of feedback on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention. Psychological Bulletin199: 254-284.
53.
Kolb DA ( 1996) Management and the learning process. In: Ken StarkeyHow Organizations Learn. London: International Thomson Business Press, 270-287.
54.
Kuhnert KW and Russell CJ ( 1990) Using constructive developmental theory and biodata to bridge the gap between personnel selection and leadership. Journal of Management16(3): 595-607.
55.
Levay C. ( 2010) Leadership in resistance to change. The Leadership Quarterly21: 127-143.
56.
Levay C. and Waks C. ( 2009) Professions and the pursuit of transparency in healthcare: two cases of soft autonomy. Organization Studies30(05): 509-527.
57.
Lucio MM and MacKenzie R. ( 2010) The politics and economics of IHRM: Regulation and change in global employment relations. In: Harzing A-W and Pinnington (eds.), AInternational Human Resource Management, 3rd edition. London: Sage, 559-582.
58.
McGurk P. ( 2009) Developing ‘middle leaders’ in the public services? The realities of management and leadership development for public managers. International Journal of Public Sector Management22(6): 464-477.
59.
McLean A., Sims D., Mangham I. and Tuffield D. ( 1982) Organization Development in Transition: Evidence of an Evolving Profession. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
60.
Morgan G. ( 1988) Riding the Waves of Change: Developing Managerial Competences for a Turbulent World. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
61.
Mumford MD and Manley GD ( 2003) Putting the development in leadership development: Implications for theory and practice. In: Murphy SE and Riggio REThe Future of Leadership Development. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 237-261.
62.
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).Public Sector Modernization. OECD : Policy Brief, October 2003.
63.
Offermann LR, Hanges PJ and Day DV ( 2001) Leaders, followers, and values: Progress and prospects for theory and research. The Leadership Quarterly12: 129-131.
64.
Pahl J. ( 1994) Like the job - But hate the organization: Social workers and managers in social services. Social Policy Review6: 190-210.
65.
Petrov G., Bolden R. and Gosling J. ( 2006) Developing Collective Leadership in Higher Education . Exeter: Centre for Leadership Studies, University of Exeter (UK), 16-19.
66.
Riggio RE, Chaleff I. and Lipman-Blumen J. ( 2008) The Art of Followership: How Great Followers Create Great Leaders and Organizations. San Francisco, CA: Wiley imprint, Jossey-Bass.
67.
Scott WR ( 1965) Reactions to supervision in a heteronomous professional organization. Administrative Science Quarterly19: 65-82.
68.
Scottish Executive.Delivery through leadership: NHS Scotland Leadership Development Framework. Edinburgh : Blackwell.
69.
Sorell T. ( 2007) Ethics and work in emergencies: The UK fire service strike 2002-3. In: Pinnington A, Macklin R andCampbell T (eds.), Human Resource Management : Ethics and Employment. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 209-219.
70.
Spreitzer GM ( 2003) Leadership development in the virtual workplace . In: Murphy SE and Riggio REThe Future of Leadership Development . Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 71-86.
71.
Storey J. ( 2004) Changing theories of leadership and leadership development . In: Storey JLeadership in Organizations: Current Issues and Key Trends. London : Routledge, 11-37.
72.
The Work Foundation (2008) Leadership beyond boundaries. London: The Work Foundation. Available at http://www.theworkfoundation.com/Assets/Docs/lead_beyond.pdf (accessed 18th October 2008).
73.
Toegel G. and Conger JA ( 2003) 360-degree assessment: Time for reinvention. Academy of Management Learning and Education2(3): 297-311.
74.
Tourish DJ and Pinnington AH ( 2002) Transformational leadership, corporate cultism and the spirituality paradigm: An unholy trinity in the workplace? Human Relations , February55(2): 147-172.
75.
Turnbull S. and Edwards G. ( 2005) Roger Gill. Developing leaders for organizational change in a ‘new’ university. In: Roger Gill (ed.). Leadership under the Microscope. Ross-on-Wye: The Leadership Trust, 68-82.
76.
Van Marrewijk A. ( 2007) Managing project culture: The case of Environ Megaproject . International Journal of Project Management25: 290-299.
77.
Van Zwanenberg ZLeadership in Social Care. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
78.
Walumbwa FO, Lawler JJ and Avolio BJ ( 2007) Leadership, individual differences, and work-related attitudes: A cross-culture investigation. Applied Psychology56(2): 212-230.
79.
Walumbwa FO, Lawler JJ, Avolio BJ, Wang P. and Shi K. ( 2005) Transformational leadership and work-related attitudes: The moderating effects of collective and self-efficacy across cultures. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies11(3): 2-16.
80.
Yeung A., Warner M. and Rowley C. ( 2008) Guest editors’ introduction Growth and globalization: Evolution of human resource management practices in Asia. Human Resource Management47(1): 1-13. (Spring).
