Affective disorders, particularly depression, are common in adults with intellectual disabilities. However the detection of these disorders is hindered by the varied presentation of depressive symptoms across the range of intellectual disability. We undertook a systematic review of the available English-language diagnostic instruments for depressive disorders for adults with all levels of intellectual disability. We appraised the studies based on the instruments' psychometric properties, sensitivity and specificity. We included 21 of 28 identified studies which contained original data on validity and reliability; the `gold standard' ranged from clinical opinion to other established instruments, some of which had limited validation in people with intellectual disability. In view of the benefits of psychological treatments for common mental disorders, it is important to develop instruments to be used in monitoring cognitive as well as behavioural outcomes for people with intellectual disability and depressive disorders.
Borthwick-Duffy, S.A. & Eyman, R.K. (1990) `Who Are the Dually Diagnosed?', American Journal on Mental Retardation94: 586-95.
2.
Bouras, N. & Drummond, C. (1992) `Behaviour and Psychiatric Disorders in People with Mental Handicaps Living in the Community', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research36: 349-57.
3.
Clarke, D. & Gomez, G. (1999) `Utility of Modified DCR-10 Criteria in the Diagnosis of Depression Associated with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research43: 413-20.
4.
Collacott, R., Cooper, S.A. & Mcgrother, C. (1992) `Differential Rates of Psychiatric Disorders in Adults with Down's Syndrome Compared with Other Mentally Handicapped Adults' , British Journal of Psychiatry161: 671-4.
5.
Cooper, S.A. & Collacott, R.A. (1994) `Clinical Features and Diagnostic Criteria of Depression in Down's Syndrome', British Journal of Psychiatry165: 399-403.
6.
Cooper, S.A., Melville, C. & Enfield, S. (2003) `Psychiatric Diagnosis, People with Intellectual Disabilities and DC-LD', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research47 (1): 3-15.
Cuthill, F., Espie, C. & Cooper, S.A. (2003) `Development of Psychometric Properties of the Glasgow Depression Scale for People with a Learning Disability', British Journal of Psychiatry182: 347-53.
9.
Deb, S., Thomas, M. & Bright, C. (2001) `Mental Disorder in Adults with Intellectual Disability, 1: Prevalence of Functional Psychiatric Illness Among a Community-based Population Aged Between 16 and 64 Years', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research45(6): 495-505.
10.
Esbensen,A.,Rojahn,J.,Aman,M. &Ruedrich,S.( 2003) `Reliabilityand Validity of an Assessment Instrument for Anxiety, Depression, and Mood among Individuals with Mental Retardation', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders33 (6): 617-29.
11.
Esbensen, A.J., Marsha, M.S. & Jan, S.G. (2005) `Psychometric Evaluation of a Self-Report Measure of Depression for Individuals with Mental Retardation', American Journal on Mental Retardation110 (6): 469-81.
12.
Gustafsson, C. & Sonnander, K. (2002) `Psychometric Evaluation of a Swedish Version of the Reiss Screen for Maladaptive Behaviour', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research46: 218-29.
13.
Helsel, W. & Matson, J.L. (1988) `The Relationship of Depression to Social Skills and Intellectual Functioning in Mentally Retarded Adults', Journal of Mental Deficiency Research32: 411-18.
14.
Jacobson, J.W. (1990) `Do Some Mental Disorders Occur Less Frequently amongst Persons with Mental Retardation?', American Journal Of Mental Retardation94: 596-602.
15.
Kazdin, A., Matson, J. & Senatore, V. (1983) `Assessment of Depression in Mentally Retarded Adults', American Journal of Mental Retardation140: 1040-3.
16.
Kishore, M., Nizamie, A., Nizamie, S.H. & Jahan, M. (2004) `Psychiatric Diagnoses in Persons with Intellectual Disability in India', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research48: 19-24.
17.
Lowry, M.A. & Sovner, R. (1992) `Severe Behaviour Disorders Associated with Rapid Cycling Bipolar Disorders in Two Adults with Profound Mental Retardation' , Journal of Intellectual Disability Research36: 269-81.
18.
Lunsky, Y. & Palucka, A. (2004) `Depression in Intellectual Disability', Current Opinion in Psychiatry17: 359-63.
19.
Marston, G.M., Perry, D.W. & Roy, A. (1997) `Manifestations of Depression in People with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41 (6): 476-80.
20.
Matson, J.L. & Bamburg, J.W. (1998) `Reliability of the Assessment of Dual Diagnosis (ADD)', Research in Developmental Disabilities19 (1): 89-95.
21.
Matson, J., Kazdin, A. & Senatore, V. (1984) `Diagnosis and Drug Use in Mentally Retarded, Emotionally Disturbed Adults', Applied Research in Mental Retardation5: 513-19.
22.
Matson,J.L.,Rush,K.,Hamilton,M. &Anderson,S.( 1999) `Characteristics of Depression as Assessed by the Diagnostic Assessment for the Severely Handicapped II (DASH-II)', Research in Developmental Disabilities20: 305-13.
23.
Maughan, B., Collishaw, S. & Pickles, A. (1999) `Mild Mental Retardation: Psychosocial Functioning in Adulthood', Psychological Medicine29: 351-66.
24.
Mcbrien, A. (2003) `Assessment and Diagnosis of Depression in People with Intellectual Disabilities', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research47: 1-13.
25.
Mohr, C., Tonge, B.J. & Einfeld, S.L. (2005) `The Development of a New Measure for the Assessment of Psychopathology in Adults with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research49(7): 469-80.
26.
Morrison, A.S. (1992) Screening in Chronic Disease. New York: Oxford University Press.
27.
Moss, S. (1995) `Methodological Issues in the Diagnosis of Psychiatric Disorders in Adults with Learning Disability', Thornfield Journal (University of Dublin) 18: 9-18.
28.
Moss, S., Ibbotson, P., Prosser, H. & Goldberg, D. (1997) `Validity of the PAS-ADD for Detecting Psychiatric Symptoms in Adults with Learning Disability', Psychiatric Epidemiology32: 344-54.
29.
Moss, S., Patel, P., Prosser, H., Goldberg, D., Simpson, N., Rowe, S. & Luccino, R. (1993) `Psychiatric Morbidity in Older People with Moderate and Severe Learning Disability: 1: Development and Reliability of the Patient Interview (PAS-ADD)', British Journal of Psychiatry163: 471-80.
30.
Moss, S., Prosser, H., Costello, H., Simpson, N., Patel, P., Rowe, S., Turner, S. & Hatton, C. (1998) `Reliability and Validity of the PAS-ADD Checklist for Detecting Psychiatric Disorders in Adults with Intellectual Disability' , Journal of Intellectual Disability Research42: 173-83.
31.
Moss,S.,Emerson,E.,Kiernan,C.,Turners,S.,Hatton,C. &Alborza,A. (2000) `Psychiatric Symptoms in Adults with Learning Disability and Challenging Behaviour', British Journal of Psychiatry177: 452-6.
32.
Nezu, C.M., Nezu, A.M. & Rothenberg, J.L. (1995) `Depression in Adults with Mild Mental Retardation: Are Cognitive Variables Involved?', Cognitive Therapy and Research19 (2): 227-39.
33.
Patel, P., Goldberg, D. & Moss, S. (1993) `Psychiatric Morbidity in Older People with Moderate and Severe Learning Disability. II: The Prevalence Study', British Journal of Psychiatry163: 481-91.
34.
Pawlarcyzk, D. & Beckwith, B.E. (1987) `Depressive Symptoms Displayed by Persons with Mental Retardation', Mental Retardation25: 323-30.
35.
Powell, R. (2003) `Psychometric Properties of the Beck Depression Inventory and the Zung Self Rating Depression Scale in Adults with Mental Retardation', Mental Retardation41: 88-95.
36.
Prosser,H.,Moss,S.,Costello,H.,Simpson,N.,Patel,P.&Row,S.( 1998) `Reliability Journal of Intellectual Disability Research and Validity of the Mini PAS-ADD for Assessing Psychiatric Disorders in Adults with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research42: 264-72.
37.
Reiss, S. (1990) `Prevalence of Dual Diagnosis in Community Based Day Programmes in the Chicago Metropolitan Area', American Journal of Mental Retardation94: 578-85.
38.
Reynolds, W. & Baker, J. (1988) `Assessment of Depression in Persons with Mental Retardation', American Journal on Mental Retardation93 (1): 93-103.
39.
Richards,M.,Maughan,B.,Hardy,R.,Hall,I.,Strydom,A.& Wadsworth, M. (2001) `Long-Term Affective Disorder in Mild Learning Disability', British Journal of Psychiatry179: 523-7.
40.
Ross, E. & Oliver, C. (2002) `The Relationship Between Levels of Mood, Interest and Pleasure and `Challenging Behaviour' in Adults with Severe and Profound Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research46(3): 191-7.
41.
Royal College Of Psychiatrists (2001) Diagnostic Criteria for Psychiatric Disorders for Use with Adults with Learning Disabilities (DC-LD). London: Gaskell .
42.
Smiley, E. (2005) `Epidemiology of Mental Health Problems in Adults with Learning Disability: An Update', Advances in Psychiatric Treatment11: 214-22.
43.
Smiley, E. & Cooper, S.A. (2003) `Depressive Episodes and DC-LD', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research47: 62-71.
44.
Strydom, A., Livingston, G., King, M. & Hassiotis, A. (2007) `Prevalence of Dementia in Intellectual Disability Using Different Diagnostic Criteria', The British Journal of Psychiatry191: 150-7.
45.
Sturmey, P. (1995) `DSM-III-R and People with Dual Diagnoses: Conceptual Issues and Strategies for Future Research', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research39: 357-64.
46.
Sturmey, P. (2005) `Against Psychotherapy with People who have Mental Retardation', Mental Retardation43: 55-7.
47.
Sturmey, P., Reed, J. & Corbett, J. (1991) `Psychometric Assessment of Psychiatric Disorders in People with Learning Difficulties', Psychological Medicine21: 143-55.
48.
Taylor,J.L.,Hatton,C.,Dixon,L.&Douglas,C.( 2004) `Screeningfor Psychiatric Symptoms: PASP-ADD Checklist Norms for Adults with Intellectual Disabilities', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research48: 37-41.
49.
Tsiouris, J., Mann, R., Patti, P. & Sturmey, P. (2003) `Challenging Behaviours Should Not Be Considered as Depressive Equivalents in Individuals with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research47: 14-21.
50.
Wing, J.K., Cooper, J.E. & Sartorius, N. (1974) Present State Examination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
