Exploring the literature on music participation and social connectedness for young people with intellectual disability: A critical interpretive synthesis

Abstract

Background:

This article explores the literature on social connectedness and music for young people with disability. It then critically examines the level of congruence between the reported literature to date and current rights-based disability studies discourse.

Method:

A critical interpretive synthesis was used to examine 27 articles referencing the use of music for social connectedness. Areas of focus in the review are the nature of connections being fostered in music programs, the use of voice and collaboration.

Results:

The majority of music programs reported on closed groups. Outdated ‘expert’ models of working persist. The use of participants’ voice in the literature is growing, although there is a lack of collaboration and negative reporting.

Conclusion:

A shift in thinking heralds greater collaboration with participants, although this could be broadened to include decisions on research agendas, planning and evaluation. There is also need for active fostering of broader socio-musical pathways.

Keywords

disability music social connectedness young person

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adkins

Summerville

Knox

. (2012) Digital technologies and musical participation for people with intellectual disabilities. New Media & Society 15: 501–518.

Agrotou

(1994) Isolation and the mulit-handicapped patient: an analysis of the muisc therapist-patient affects and processes. The Arts in Psychotherapy 21: 359–365.

Agrotou

(1998) Psychodynamic Group Music Therapy with Profoundly Learning Disabled Residents and Their Carers: Developing a Theory and Practice for the Realization of Therapeutic Aims for Residents and the Acquirement of Therapist’s Skills by Carers. Department of Music. UK: University of Sheffield.

Aigen

(2012) Community music therapy. The Oxford Handbook of Music Education 2: 138–150.

Amado

(1993) Friendships and Community Connections between People with and without Developmental Disabilities. Baltimore: Paul H Brookes Publishing Co.

Annandale

Harvey

Cavers

. (2007) Gender and access to helathcare in the UK: A critical interpretive synthesis of the literature. Evidence and Policy 3: 463–486.

Ansdell

(2002) Community music therapy and the winds of change. Voices: A World Forum for Music Therapy 2.

Bos

(2012) Music theatre transforming lives. Journal of Singing 69: 57–59.

Cacioppo

Patrick

(2008) Loneliness. Human Nature and the Need for Social Connection. New York: W. W. Norton and Company Inc.

10.

Charlton

(1998) Nothing About Us Without Us: Disability Oppression and Empowerment. Los Angeles: University of California Press.

11.

Charmaz

(2006) Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide Through Qualitative Analysis. London: Sage.

12.

Clarkson

(1991) Music therapy for a nonverbal autistic adult. In: Brucia

(ed.) Case Studies in Music Therapy. Phoenixville: Barcelona Publishers, pp. 373–385.

13.

Crow

(2010) Renewing the social model of disability. In: Rix

Nind

Sheehy

Simmons

Walsh

(eds) Equality, Participation and Inclusion 1: Diverse Perspectives. Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 124–140.

14.

Curtis

Mercado

(2004) Community music therapy for citizens with developmental disabilities. Voices: A World Forum for Music Therapy 4.

15.

Dingle

Brander

Ballantyne

. (2012) ‘To be heard’: the social and mental health benefits of choir singing for disadvantaged adults. Psychology of Music 41: 405–421.

16.

Dixon-Woods

Cavers

Agarwal

. (2006) Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups. BMC Medical Research Methodology 6: 35.

17.

Elefant

(2010) Whose voice is heard? Performances and voices of the Renanim Choir in Israel. In: Stige

Ansdell

Elefant

. (eds) Where Music Helps. Community Music Therapy in Action and Reflection. Surrey: Ashgate, pp. 189–198.

18.

Ely

Scott

(1994) Integrating clients with an intellectual disability into the community through music therapy. The Australian Journal of Music Therapy 5: 7–18.

19.

Fillingham

(2007) Friendship and group work. In: Watson

(ed.) Music Therapy with Adults with Learning Disbabilities. New York: Routlage, pp. 71–84.

20.

Finlay

WML

Lyons

(2001) Methodological issues in interviewing and using self-report questionnaires with people with mental retardation. American Psychological Association 13: 319–335.

21.

Gooding

(2009) Enhancing Social Competence in the Music Classroom. General Music Today 23: 35–38.

22.

Goodley

(2014) Dis/ability Studies. Theorizing Disablism and Abelism. New York: Routledge.

23.

Graham

(2004) Communicating with the uncommunicative: music therapy with pre-verbal adults. British Journal of Learning Disabilities 32: 24–29.

24.

Gregory

(2010) Collaborative approaches: putting colour in a grey area. International Journal of Community Music 3: 387–397.

25.

Hadley

(2014) Shifting frames: are we really embracing diversity? Voices: A World Forum for Music Therapy 14.

26.

Hadley

(ed.) (2014) Special issue on music therapy and disabiltiy studies. Voices: A World Forum for Music Therapy 14.

27.

Hargreaves

North

(2008) The Social and Applied Psychology of Music. New York: Oxford University Press.

28.

Hillier

Greher

Poto

. (2011) Positive outcomes following participation in a music intervention for adolescents and young adults on the autism spectrum. Psychology of Music 40: 201–215.

29.

Hooper

(2001) Overcoming the problems of deinstitiutionalization: using music activities to encourage interaction between four adults with a developmental disability. Music Therapy Perspectives 19: 121–127.

30.

Kohut

Stepansky

(1984) In: Goldberg

(ed) How Does Analysis Cure? Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 3–12.

31.

Lapka

(2006) Students with disabilities in a high school band: “we can do It!”. Music Educators Journal 92: 54–59.

32.

Lee

(2014) In: Keith

(ed) Qualitative Inquiries in Music Therapy: A Monograph Series. University Part IL Barcelona Publishers, pp. 44–86.

33.

Lee

(2014) A Phenomenological Study of the Interpersonal Relationships Between Five Music Therpaists and Adults with Profound Intellectual and Multiple Disabilites.

34.

Lee

Robbins

(1995) Measuring belongingness: The social connectedness and the social assurance scales. Journal of Counseling Psychology 42: 232–241.

35.

Lee

Robbins

(1998) The relationship between social connectedness and anxiety, self-esteem, and social identity. Journal of Counselling Psychology 45: 338–345.

36.

Lewis

Porter

(2004) Interviewing children and young people with learning disabilities. British Journal of Learning Disabilities 32: 191–197.

37.

Lippold Burns

(2009) Social support and intellectual disabilities: a comparison between social networks of adults with intellectual disability and those with physical disability. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 53: 463–473.

38.

Lubet

(2009) The inclusion of music/the music of inclusion. International Journal of Inclusive Education 13: 727–739.

39.

MacDonald

O’Donnell

Davies

(1999) An Empirical Investigation into the Effects of Structured Music Workshops for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities 12: 225–240.

40.

McFerran

(2008) Who Says I Can’t SIng? Musical Justice for People with Intellectual Disabilities. Brunswick: Melbourne University, Salvation Army.

41.

McFerran

Garrido

Saarikallio

(2016) A critical interpretive synthesis of the literature linking music and adolescent mental health. Youth & Society 48: 521–538.

42.

McFerran

Shoemark

(2013) How musical engagement promotes well-being in education contexts: the case of a young man with profound and multiple disabilities. International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-Being 8: 20570.

43.

McVilly

Stancliffe

Parmenter

. (2006) Self-advocates have the last say on friendship. Disability and Society 21: 693.

44.

Morris

(2003) Including all children: finding out about the experiences of children with communication and/or cognitive impairments Children and Society 17: 337–348.

45.

National Disabilities and Carer Council (2009) Shut out. The experience of people with disabilites and their families in Australia. In: Report NDSC (ed). Australia . Canberra: Australian Government.

46.

National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 9th Quarterly Report Dashboards. Canberra: Australian Government.

47.

Nierse

Abma

TA.

(2011) Developing voice and empowerment: the first step towards a broad consultation in research agenda setting. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 55: 411–421.

48.

Pavlicevic

Ansdell

(2004) Community Music Therapy. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

49.

Pavlicevic

O’Neil

Powell

. (2014) Making music, making friends: Long-term music therapy with young adults with severe learning disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disability 18: 5–19.

50.

Rabiee

Sloper

Beresford

(2005) Doing research with children and young people who do not use speech for communication. Children and Society 19: 385–396.

51.

Rhongzhi

(2010) The effect of community based group music therapy on quality of life for individuals with developmental disabilties. Master’s Thesis, School of Music, East Carolina University, USA.

52.

Rickson

(2003) Music therapy to promote prosocial behaviors in adolescent boys — A pilot study. Journal of Music Therapy 40: 283–301.

53.

Rickson

(2014) Stepping into the spotlight: collaborative efforts towards musical participation. Approaches: Music Therapy & Special Music Education 6(2): 99–112.

54.

Robertson

Richardson

Youngson

(1984) Social skills training with mentally handicapped people: a review. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 23: 241–264.

55.

Rolvsjord

(2014) The competent client and the complexity of dis-ability. Voices: A World Forum for Music Therapy 14.

56.

Rongzhi

(2010) The effect of community-based group music therapy on quality of life for individuals with developmental disbiltiies. Master’s Thesis, The Faculty of the School of Music, East Carolina University, USA.

57.

Stevens

(2015) Making friends. In: Having a say conference, Deakin University, Geelong, Victoria, 4–6 February 2015.

58.

Stickley

Crosbie

Hui

(2012) The stage life: promoting the inclusion of young people through participatory arts. British Journal of Learning Disabilities 40: 251–258.

59.

Stige

(2002) Culture-centred Music Therapy. Gilsum: Barcelona Publishers.

60.

Stige

(2010a) Reflection. Musical participation, social space, and everyday ritual. In: Stige

Ansdell

Elefant

. (eds) Where Music Helps: Community Music Therapy in Action and Reflection. Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Limited, pp. 125–147.

61.

Stige

(2010b) A society for all? The cultural festival in Sogn og Fjordance, Norway. In: Stige

Ansdell

Elefant

. (eds) Where Music Helps: Community Music Therapy in Action and Reflection. Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Limited, pp. 115–124.

62.

Stige

Ansdell

Elefant

. (2010) Where Music Helps. Commuity Music Therapy in Action and Reflection. Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Company.

63.

Stokes

Turnbull

Wyn

(2013) Young People with a Disability: Independence and Opportunity. A Literature Review. Melbourne Graduate School of Education.

64.

Toolan

Coleman

(1994) Music therapy, a description of process: engagement and avoidance in five people with learning disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disabilty Research 38: 433–444.

65.

United Nations (2006) Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. New York: UN.

66.

Warner

(2005) Music Therapy with Adults with Learning Difficulties and ‘Severe Challenging Behaviour’ Faculty of Health and Social Care. Bristol: University of the West of England.

67.

Warner

(2007) Challenging behaviour: working with the blindingly obvious. In: Watson

(ed.) Music Therapy with Adults with Learning Disabilties. Hove: Routledge, pp. 47–57.

68.

Williams

Galliher

(2006) Predicting depression and self-esteem from social connectedness, support and competence. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 25: 855–874.

69.

Young

(1999) Ruling norms and the politics of difference: a comment on Seyla Benhabib. Yale Journal of Criticism 12: 415–421.

70.

Young

(2012) Embrace and celebrate the Paralympic spotlight. In: Young

(ed.) Ramp up. Canberra, Australia: Australian Broadcasting Commission. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-03/young-paralympics-no-need-for-integration/4239168.