Archetype-theory gained prominence in the literature dealing with the ‘‘managerialization’’ of professional organizations. However, this theory has been criticized. Due to its functionalist legacy it underplays the role of agency in the organizational structure or in its change. Following this critique we develop a political perspective on the relation profession — management. Such a view stresses the interlocking of organization and domination. However, control does not just apply to workers and work, a ‘rule by rules’ implies rulers are also object of regulation. Agency will be directed at having an impact on rule creation. In the end organizational structure is designed to control the agency of both profession and management. The elaboration of structure is not to be seen as a function of the qualities of work, or of organizational performance. Rather our analysis of the genesis of the medical council in Belgian hospitals suggest that it results out of agency within a specific policy process.
Abbott, A.ndrew. 1988. The system of professions: an essay on the division of expert labor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
2.
---. 1992. From Causes to Events: Notes on Narrative Positivism. Sociological Methods & Research20 (4):428-455.
3.
Abell, Peter.2004. Narrative Explanation: An Alternative to Variable-Centered Explanation? Annual Review of Sociology30 (1):287-310.
4.
Abrams, Philip.1980. History, Sociology, Historical Sociology. Past & Present (87):3-16.
5.
---. 1982. Historical sociology. Near Shepton Mallet, Somerset, England: Open Books.
6.
Ackroyd, Stephen.1996. Organization Contra Organizations: Professions and Organizational Change in the United Kingdom. Organization Studies17 (4):599-621.
7.
Ackroyd, Stephen, and Daniel Muzio.2007. The Reconstructed Professional Firm: Explaining Change in English Legal Practices. Organization Studies28 (5):729-747.
8.
Alter, Norbert.1993. Innovation et organisation: Deux légitimités en concurrence. Revue française de sociologie34 (2):175-197.
Beniger, James R.1986. The control revolution: technological and economic origins of the information society. Cambridge (Mass.): Harvard university press.
11.
Blank, Robert H., and Viola Desideria Burau.2004. Comparative health policy. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire ; New York: Palgrave Macmillan .
12.
Brock, David M.2006. The changing professional organization: A review of competing archetypes. International Journal of Management Reviews8:157-174.
13.
Brock, David M., Michael J. Powell, and C.R. Hinings.2007. The changing professional organization . In Restructuring the Professional Organization. Accounting, health care and law edited by D. Brock , M. Powell and C. R. Hinings.London ; New York : Routledge.
14.
Brock, David. M., and Michael Powell.2005. Radical strategic change in the global professional network: the "Big Five" 1999-2001. Journal of Organizational Change Management18 (5):451-468.
15.
Buchner-Jeziorska, Anna, and Julia Evetts.1997. Regulating Professionals: The Polish Example. International Sociology12 (1):61-72.
16.
Callens, Stefaan, and Jan Peers.2003. Organisatie van de gezondheidszorg. Antwerpen: Intersentia.
17.
Clegg, Stewart R., David Courpasson, and Nelson Philips.2006. Power in organizations, Foundations for organizational science. Thousand Oaks (Calif.) : Sage.
18.
Cooper, David J., Bob Hinings, Royston Greenwood, and John L. Brown .1996. Sedimentation and Transformation in Organizational Change: The Case of Canadian Law Firms. Organization Studies17 (4):623-647.
19.
Courpasson, David.2000a. L’action contrainte : organisations libérales et domination, Sciences sociales et sociétés. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.
20.
---. 2000b. Managerial Strategies of Domination. Power in Soft Bureaucracies . Organization Studies21 (1):141-161.
21.
Crozier, Michel, and Erhard Friedberg .1981. L’acteur et le système. Les contraintes de l’action collective. Paris: Editions du Seuil.
22.
D’Cruz, Premilla, and Ernesto Noronha .2006. Being Professional: Organizational Control in Indian Call Centers. Social Science Computer Review24 (3):342-361.
23.
Deferme, Jo.2007. Uit de ketens van de vrijheid: het debat over de sociale politiek in België 1886-1914., Kadoc-StudiesLeuven: Universitaire Pers.
24.
Degadt, Peter, and Gustaaf Van Herck .2003. Financiering van ziekenhuizen en het arenamodel. Tijdschrift voor economie en management48 (1):119-132.
25.
Degeling, P., K. Zhang, B. Coyle, L. Xu, Q. Meng, J. Qu, and M. Hill.2006. Clinicians and the governance of hospitals: a cross-cultural perspective on relations between profession and management . Social Science and Medicine63 (3):757-775.
26.
Derber, Charles, and William Schwartz .1988. Des hiérarchies à l’intérieur de hiérarchie. Le pouvoir professionnel à l’oeuvre. Sociologie et sociétés20 (2):55-76.
27.
Dingwall, Robert W.J.2004. Professions and Social Order in a Global Society. Revista Electrónica de InvestigaciónEducativa (1), http://redie.uabc.mx/vol6no1/contents-dingwall.html .
28.
Dion, Stéphane.1982. Pouvoir et conflits dans l’organisation: grandeur et limites du modèle de Michel Crozier. Canadian Journal of Political Science / Revue canadienne de science politique15 (1):85-101.
29.
European Observatory on Health Care Systems.2000. Health Care Systems in Transition - Belgium. In Health Care Systems in Transition, edited by E. O. o. H. C. Systems: European Observatory on Health Care Systems.
30.
Evan, William M.1965. Superior-Subordinate Conflict in Research Organizations . Administrative Science Quarterly10 (1):52-64.
31.
Evetts, Julia.2006. Short Note: The Sociology of Professional Groups: New Directions. Current Sociology54 (1):133-143.
32.
Farrell, Catherine, and Jonathan Morris .2003. The ‘Neo-Bureaucratic’ State: Professionals, Managers and Professional Managers in Schools, General Practices and Social Work. Organization10 (1): 129-156.
33.
Faulconbridge, James, and Daniel Muzio.2008. Organizational professionalism in globalizing law firms. Work Employment Society22 (1):7-25.
34.
Filc, Dani.2006. Physicians as ‘Organic Intellectuals’: A Contribution to the Stratification versus Deprofessionalization Debate. Acta Sociologica49 (3):273-285.
35.
Fitzgerald, Louise, and Ewan Ferlie.2000. Professionals: Back to the Future? Human Relations53 (5): 713-739.
36.
Fleming, Peter, and Andre Spicer.2008. Beyond Power and Resistance: New Approaches to Organizational Politics. Management Communication Quarterly21 (3):301-309.
37.
Flynn, Rob.1992. Structures Of Control In Health Management. London; New York: Routledge .
38.
Fournier, Valérie.1999. The Appeal to ‘Professionalism’ as a Disciplinary Mechanism. The Sociological Review47 (2):280-307.
39.
Franckson, Marcel.2008. Evolution de la condition médicale dans les hôpitaux universitaires de la CAP de Bruxelles 1946-1985 n.d [cited November 27 2008]. Available from http://www.bon-a-tirer.com/ducotedebrugmann/evolutionconditionmedicale.pdf.
40.
Freidson, Eliot.2001. Professionalism : the third logic. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
41.
Friedman, A.L.1977. Industry and labour: Class struggle at work and monopoly capitalism. London: MacMillan.
42.
Gourdin, Gregory, and Rita Schepers.2009. Hospital governance and the medical practitioner in Belgium. Journal of Health Organization and Management23 (3):319-331.
43.
Greenwood, Royston, C.R. Hinings, and John Brown.1990. "P2-Form" Strategic Management: Corporate Practices in Professional Partnerships. The Academy of Management Journal33 (4):725-755.
44.
Hinings, C.R., and Royston Greenwood .2002. Disconnects and Consequences in Organization Theory? Administrative Science Quarterly47 (3):411-421.
45.
Hull, David L.1975. Central Subjects and Historical Narratives. History and Theory14 (3):253-274.
46.
Jacobs, Kerry.2005. Hybridisation or Polarisation: Doctors and Accounting in the UK, Germany and Italy. Financial Accountability & Management21 (2):135-162.
47.
Kirkpatrick, Ian, and Stephen Ackroyd .2003a. Archetype Theory and the Changing Professional Organization: A Critique and Alternative. Organization10 (4):731-750.
48.
---. 2003b. Transforming the professional archetype? Public Management Review5 (4):511-531.
49.
Kirkpatrick, Ian, Stephen Ackroyd, and Richard Walker.2005. The New Managerialism and Public Service Professions : Developments in Health, Social Services and Housing. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
50.
Kirkpatrick, Ian, Mike Dent, Peter Kragh Jespersen, and Indy Neogy.2007. Professional strategies and the New Public Management in Health Care: comparing Denmark and the UK. In 2007 Critical Management Studies Conference: CMS5. Manchester, United Kingdom.
51.
Kirkpatrick, Ian, Peter Kragh Jespersen, Mike Dent, and Indareth Neogy.2009. Medicine and management in a comparative perspective: the case of Denmark and England. Sociology of Health & Illness31 (5):642-658.
52.
Kitchener, Martin.2000. The ‘bureaucratization’ of professional roles: the case of clinical directors in UK hospitals. Organization7 (1):129-154.
53.
Kurunmäki, Liisa.2004. A hybrid profession--the acquisition of management accounting expertise by medical professionals. Accounting, Organizations and Society29 (3-4):327-347.
54.
Lammers, C.J., A.A. Mijs, and W. J. van Noort .2000. Organisaties vergelijkenderwijs : ontwikkeling en relevantie van het sociologisch denken over organisaties . 8e bijgew. druk ed. Utrecht: Spectrum.
55.
Litwak, Eugene.1961. Models of Bureaucracy Which Permit Conflict. The American Journal of Sociology67 (2):177-184.
56.
Llewellyn, Sue.2001. ‘Two-Way Windows’: Clinicians as Medical Managers . Organization Studies22 (4):593-623.
57.
Lorenz, Chris.1987. De constructie van het verleden : een inleiding in de theorie van de geschiedenis. Meppel: Boom.
58.
Lounsbury, Michael, and Marc Ventresca.2003. The New Structuralism in Organizational Theory. Organization10 (3):457-480.
59.
Mintzberg, Henry.1996. Structure et dynamique des organisations. Translated by P. Romelaer. Paris: Editions d’organisation . Original edition, 1979.
60.
Moran, Michael.2000. Understanding the welfare state:the case of health care . British Journal of Politics and International Relations2 (2):135-160.
61.
Moran, Michael, and Bruce Wood.1993. States, regulation, and the medical profession, Law and political change. Buckingham ; Philadelphia: Open University Press.
62.
Ong, Bie Nio, Margaret Boaden, and Steve Cropper.1997. Analysing the medicine-management interface in acute trusts. Journal of Management in Medicine11 (2):88-95.
63.
Pasture, Patrick T.1993. The April 1944 ‘Social Pact’ in Belgium and Its Significance for the Post-War Welfare State. Journal of Contemporary History28 (4):695-714.
64.
Perkin, Harold2002. The rise of professional society: England since 1880. London & New York: Routledge .
65.
Perrow, Charles.1961. The Analysis of Goals in Complex Organizations. American Sociological Review26 (6):854-866.
66.
---. 1963. Goals and authority structures. In The hospital in modern society, edited by E. Freidson.New York: Free Press.
67.
---. 1965. Hospitals: technology, goals and structures. In Handbook of Organizations, edited by J. March.Chicago: Randy McNally .
68.
---. 1967. A Framework for the Comparative Analysis of Organizations . American Sociological Review32 (2):194-208.
69.
Prims, André.1997. En de boer...hij ploegde voort : de memoires van André Prims. Leuven: Ceuterick.
70.
Reynaud, Jean-Daniel.1988. Les régulations dans les organisations: Régulation de contrôle et régulation autonome. Revue française de sociologie29 (1):5-18.
71.
Ricoeur, Paul.1983. Temps et récit. 1 : L’intrigue et le récit historique, L’ordre philosophique. Paris: Seuil.
72.
Saks, Mike.1995. Professions and the public interest : medical power, altruism and alternative medicine. London: Routledge.
73.
Schepers, Rita.1993. The Belgian medical profession, the order of physicians and the sickness funds (1900-1940). Sociology of Health & Illness15 (3):375-392.
74.
---. 1995. The Belgian medical profession since the 1980s: dominance and decline. In Health professions and the state in Europe , edited by T. Johnson, G. Larkins and M. Saks.London; New York: Routledge.
75.
Sermeus, Walter.2003. De Belgische ziekenhuisfinanciering ontcijferd. Leuven: Acco.
76.
Simpson, Richard L.1985. Social Control of Occupations and Work. Annual Review of Sociology11:415-436.
77.
Stinchcombe, Arthur L.1959. Bureaucratic and Craft Administration of Production: A Comparative Study. Administrative Science Quarterly4 (2):168-187.
78.
Strauss, Anselm.1985. Work and the Division of Labor. The Sociological Quarterly26 (1):1-19.
79.
Vercauteren, Gregory.2007. In naam van de sociale vooruitgang : de rol van de overheid in het sociaal overleg in België (1944-1981). Leuven : Acco.
80.
Waring, Amanda, and Justin Waring.2009. Looking the Part: Embodying the Discourse of Organizational Professionalism in the City. Current Sociology57 (3):344-364.
81.
Weber, Max.1999. Politiek als beroep. Translated by J. M. M. de Valk. Baarn: Agora. Original edition, 1919.
82.
Weber, Max, and Stephen Kalberg .2005. Max Weber : readings and commentary on modernity, Modernity and society3. Malden, MA: Blackwell Pub.
83.
Weeden, Kim A.2002. Why Do Some Occupations Pay More than Others? Social Closure and Earnings Inequality in the United States. American Journal of Sociology108 (1):55-101.
84.
White, Hayden V.1987. The content of the form : narrative discourse and historical representation. Baltimore (Md.): Johns Hopkins university press.
85.
Witte, Els, Jan Craeybeckx, and Alain Meynen.2005. Politieke geschiedenis van België van 1830 tot heden. 7de, herziene uitgave. ed. Antwerpen : Standaard.
86.
Zaleznik, Abraham.1970. Power and politics in organizational life. Harvard Business Review48 (3):47-60.
