The aim in this paper is to investigate the contribution personal initiative theory makes in understanding the consultant nurse role. The role was introduced in the UK in 2000 to improve patient outcomes, clinical leadership and retention of experienced clinicians. A larger study used a multi-method approach to collect quantitative and qualitative data from focus groups, interviews and a questionnaire administered nationally at two time points. Findings from longitudinal telephone interviews with 30 consultant nurses are the focus of this paper.
Three consultant nurses were selected as case studies to examine the potential of personal initiative theory when applied to new nursing roles. The activities of two of the three demonstrated a high level of personal initiative in the job. They persisted in overcoming problems faced in improving practice. The third scored lower: she emerged as a reactive conformist and less likely than the other two to pursue initiatives of her own.
Personal initiative theory has potential as a framework for evaluating the consultant nurse role, although further research is needed to test it. The longitudinal analysis revealed a determination to stay in the job and overcome difficult challenges when consultants show initiative and are making progress in achieving change.
Aranda K., Jones A. ( 2008) Exploring new advanced practice roles in community nursing: a critique. Nurs Inq15(1): 3-10.
2.
Atsalos C., O’Brien L., and Jackson D. ( 2007) Against the odds: experiences of nurse leaders in Clinical Development Units (Nursing) in Australia. J Adv Nurs58(6): 576-584.
3.
Blackford J., Street A. ( 2001) The role of the palliative care nurse consultant in promoting continuity of end-of-life care. Int J Palliat Nurs7(6): 273-278.
4.
Booth J., Hutchison C., Beech C., and Robertson K. ( 2006) New nursing roles: the experience of Scotland’s consultant nurses/ midwives. J Nurs Manage14: 83-89.
5.
Bridges J., Meyer J. ( 2007) Policy on new workforce roles: a discussion paper . Int J Nurs Stud44: 635-644.
6.
Browne AJ, Tarlier DS ( 2008) Examining the potential of nurse practitioners from a critical social justice perspective. Nurs Inq15(2): 83-93.
7.
Burton CR, Bennett B., and Gibbon B. ( 2008) Embedding nursing and therapy consultantship: the case of stroke consultants. J Clin Nurs18(2): 246-254.
8.
Callaghan L. ( 2008) Advanced nursing practice: an idea whose time has come . J Clin Nurs17(2)): 205-213.
9.
Carryer J., Gardner G., Dunn S., and Gardner A. ( 2007) The core role of the nurse practitioner: practice, professionalism and clinical leadership. J Clin Nurs16(10): 1818-1838.
10.
Chalder G., Nolan P. ( 2001) The role of the forensic nurse consultant observed . Br J Forensic Pract13(3): 23-30.
11.
Charters S., Knight S., Currie J., Davies-Gray M., Ainsworth-Smith M., Smith S., et al. (2005) Learning from the past to inform the future - a survey of consultant nurses in emergency care. Accid Emerg Nurs13(3): 186-193.
Chummun H., Tiran D. ( 2008) Increasing research evidence in practice: a possible role for the consultant nurse. J Nurs Manage16: 327-333.
14.
Coster S., Redfern S., Wilson-Barnett J., Evans A., Peccei R., and Guest D. ( 2006) Impact of the role of nurse, midwife and health visitor consultant. J Adv Nurs55(3): 352-363.
15.
Dawson D., McEwan A. ( 2006) The influence of outreach in the development of the nurse consultant role in critical care: cause or effect? Intensive Crit Care Nurs22(1): 4-11.
16.
Department of Health (1999) Health Service Circular 1999/217. London: department of Health.
17.
Department of Health (2006) Modernising Nursing Careers. London: Department of Health .
18.
Duke S. ( 2008) Commentary on McSherry R, Mudd D, Campbell S (2007) Evaluating the perceived role of the nurse consultant through the lived experience of healthcare professionals. J Clin Nurs16: 2066-2080. J Clin Nurs17(10): 1397-1399.
19.
Fairley D., Closs SJ ( 2006) Evaluation of a nurse consultant’s clinical activities and the search for patient outcomes in critical care. J Clin Nurs15(9): 1106-1114.
20.
Fletcher CE, Baker SJ, Copeland LA, Reeves PJ, and Lowery JC ( 2007) Nurse practitioners’ and physicians’ views of NPs as providers of primary care to veterans. J Nurs Sch39(4): 358-362.
21.
Frese M., Fay D. ( 2001) Personal initiative: an active performance concept for work in the 21st century. Res Organ Behav23: 133-187.
22.
Frese M., Fay D., Hilburger T., Leng K., and Tag A. ( 1997) The concept of personal initiative: operationalization, reliability and validity in two German samples. J Occup Organ Psychol70: 139-161.
23.
Frese M., Kring W., Soose A., and Zempel J. ( 1996) Personal initiative at work: differences between East and West Germany. Acad Manag J39(1): 37-63.
24.
Frese M., Teng E., and Widjen CJD ( 1999) Helping to improve suggestion systems: predictors of giving suggestions in companies. J Organ Behav20: 1139-1155.
25.
Gardner A., Hase S., Gardner G., Dunn SV, and Carryer J. ( 2008) From competence to capability: a study of nurse practitioners in clinical practice. J Clin Nurs17(2): 250-258.
26.
Gerrish K., Guillaume L., Kirschbaum M., McDonnell A., Nolan M., Read S., et al. (2007) Empowering front-line staff to deliver evidence-based care: the contribution of nurses in advanced practice roles. Report to the Department of Health. Sheffield: Sheffield Hallam University.
27.
Graham IW ( 2007) Consultant nurse-consultant physician: a new partnership for patient care? J Clin Nurs16(10): 1809-1817.
28.
Guest D., Peccei R., Rosenthal P., Redfern S., Wilson-Barnett J., Dewe P., et al. (2004) An evaluation of the impact of nurse, midwife and health visitor consultants. London: King’s College London.
29.
Hekkink CF, Wigersma L., Yzermans CJ, and Bindels PJ ( 2005) HIV nursing consultants: patients’ preferences and experiences about the quality of care. J Clin Nurs14(3): 327-333.
30.
Hewitt J., Tellier L. ( 1996) A description of an occupational reproductive health nurse consultant practice and women’s occupational exposures during pregnancy . Public Health Nurs13(5): 365-373.
31.
Horrocks S., Anderson E., and Salisbury C. ( 2002) Systematic review of whether nurse practitioners working in primary care can provide equivalent care to doctors. Br Med J324: 819-823.
32.
Humphreys A., Johnson S., Richardson J., Stenhouse E., and Watkins M. ( 2007) Evaluating the effectiveness of nurse, midwife/allied health professional consultants: a systematic review and metasynthesis. J Clin Nurs16(10): 1792-1808.
33.
Jannings W., Armitage S. ( 2001) Informal education: a hidden element of clinical nurse consultant practice. J Contin Educ Nurs32(2): 49-54.
34.
Jennings N., O’Reilly G., Lee G., Cameron P., Free B., and Bailey M. ( 2008) Evaluating outcomes of the emergency nurse practitioner role in a major urban emergency department, Melbourne, Australia. J Clin Nurs17(8): 1044-1050.
35.
Jinks AM, Chalder J. ( 2007) Consensus and diversity: an action research study designed to analyse the roles of a group of mental health consultant nurses . J Clin Nurs16(7): 1323-1332.
36.
Latham GP, Saari LM ( 1984) Do people do what they say? Further studies on the situational interview. J Appl Psychol69: 569-573.
37.
Lathlean J. ( 2007) Researching the implementation of pioneering roles in nursing and midwifery: empirical insights about lecturer practitioners, consultant nurses and nurse registrars. J Res Nurs12(1): 29-39.
38.
Lewis R., Neal RD, Williams NH, France B., Wilkinson C., Hendry M., et al. (2009) Nurse-led vs. conventional physician-led follow-up for patients with cancer: systematic review. J Adv Nurs65(4): 706-723.
39.
Manley K., Webster J., Hale N., Hayes N., and Minardi H. ( 2008) Leadership role of consultant nurses working with older people: a co-operative inquiry. J Nurs Manage16(2): 147-158.
40.
McKenna H., Richey R., Keeney S., Hasson F., Poulton B., and Sinclair M. ( 2008) The managerial and development issues of nurses and midwives in new roles. Scand J Caring Sci22(2): 227-235.
41.
Middleton S., Allnutt J., Griffiths R., McMaster R., O’Connell J., and Hillege S. ( 2007) Identifying measures for evaluating new models of nursing care: a survey of NSW nurse practitioners. Int J Nurs Pract13(6): 331-340.
42.
O’Baugh J., Wilkes L., Vaughan K., and O’Donohue R. (2007) The role and scope of the clinical nurse consultant in Wentworth area health service, New South Wales, Australia. J Nurs Manage15: 12-21.
43.
Popejoy LL, Rantz MJ, Conn V., Wipke-Tevis D., Grando VT, and Porter R. ( 2000) Improving quality of care in nursing facilities: gerontological clinical nurse specialist as research nurse consultant. J Gerontol Nurs26(4): 6-13.
44.
Redfern S., Christian S. ( 2003) Achieving change in health care practice. J Eval Clin Pract9(2): 225-238.
45.
Redfern S., Norman I. ( 1999) Quality of nursing care perceived by patients and their nurses: an application of the critical incident technique. Parts 1 and 2. J Clin Nurs8: 407-421.
46.
Reed J., Inglis P., Cook G., Clarke C., and Cook M. ( 2007) Specialist nurses for older people: implications for UK development sites. J Adv Nurs58(4): 368-376.
47.
Turner C., Keyser D., and Rudge T. ( 2007) Spheres of influence or autonomy? A discourse analysis of the introduction of Nurse Practitioners in rural and remote Australia. J Adv Nurs59(1): 38-46.
48.
Van de Ven A., Polley D., Garud R., and Venkataraman S. (1999) The innovation journey . New York: Oxford University Press.
49.
Williams A., Jones M. ( 2006) Patients assessments of consulting a nurse practitioner . J Adv Nurs53(2): 188-195.
50.
Williamson G., Webb C., Abelson-Mitchell N., and Cooper S. ( 2006) Change on the horizon: issues and concerns of neophyte advanced healthcare practitioners. J Clin Nurs15(9): 1091-1098.
51.
Wilson A., Shifaza F. ( 2008) An evaluation of the effectiveness and acceptability of nurse practitioners in an adult emergency department. Int J Nurs Pract14(2): 149-156.
52.
Woodward V., Webb C., and Prowse M. ( 2006) Nurse consultants: organisational influences on role achievement . J Clin Nurs15(3): 272-280.
