The manual handling of people and objects is integral to the provision of nursing care to patients globally. Despite over 30 years of research intended to guide improvements for nurses’ safety, substantial rates of manual handling injuries persist internationally within the nursing profession. This paper reviews the contemporary international literature regarding manual handling interventions noting the unique context for injury prevention strategies within healthcare. The review includes the recognition of underlying assumptions inherent in the conceptualisation of manual handling and its management, and the preponderance of the post-positivist paradigm in this field.
The complexity of manual handling in healthcare has resulted in a theoretical shift from single factor interventions based on technique training towards an emerging multidimensional approach. However the key elements for sustainable solutions to reduce nurses’ manual handling injuries have not yet been identified and consensus is lacking regarding the implementation and appropriate evaluation of injury prevention programmes. Furthermore, whilst the literature is replete with data derived from surveys or insurance industry records of compensation claims, there is a dearth of literature exploring nurses’ manual handling experiences. The in-depth investigation of nurses’ perspectives on manual handling may uncover new knowledge critical to improvement of the manual handling issues.
AllenRJacksonSMarsdenH (2002) Transferring people safely with manual handling equipment. Clinical Rehabilitation16: 329–337.
2.
ASCC (2007) National Code of Practice for Prevention of Musculoskeletal Disorders caused from Performing Manual Tasks, Canberra: Australian Safety and Compensation Council.
3.
ASCC (2008) Occupational Exposure in Australian Nurses, Canberra: Australian Safety and Compensation Council.
4.
ASCC (2009) National Hazard Exposure Worker Surveillance (NHEWS) Survey, Canberra: Australian Safety and Compensation Council.
5.
BadiiMKeenDYuS (2006) Evaluation of a comprehensive integrated workplace-based program to reduce occupational musculoskeletal injury and its associated morbidity in a large hospital. Journal of Occupational & Environmental Medicine48: 1159–1165.
6.
BaptisteABodaSNelsonA (2006) Friction-reducing devices for lateral patient transfers: A clinical evaluation. AAOHN Journal54: 173–180.
7.
BestM (1997) An evaluation of manutention training in preventing back strain and resultant injuries in nurses. Safety Science25: 207–222.
8.
BewickNGardnerD (2000) Manual handling injuries in health care workers. International Journal of Occupational Safety And Ergonomics: JOSE6: 209–221.
9.
BirdP (2009) Reducing manual handling workers compensation claims in a public health facility. Journal of Occupational Health & Safety - Australia & New Zealand25: 451–459.
10.
BraceT (2005) The dynamics of pushing and pulling in the workplace. AAOHN Journal53: 224–229.
11.
BuckleP (1987) Epidemiological aspects of back pain within the nursing profession. International Journal of Nursing Studies24: 319–324.
12.
BurtonAKSymondsTLZinzenE (1997) Is ergonomic intervention alone sufficient to limit musculoskeletal problems in nurses?Occupational Medicine47: 25–32.
13.
CharneyWDSchirmerJMS (2007) Nursing injury rates and negative patient outcomes-connecting the dots. AAOHN Journal55: 470–475.
14.
CharneyWDSimmonsBLaryMA (2006) Zero lift programs in small rural hospitals in Washington State: Reducing back injuries among health care workers. AAOHN Journal54: 355–358.
15.
ChhokarREngstCMillerA (2005) The three-year economic benefits of a ceiling lift intervention aimed to reduce healthcare worker injuries. Applied Ergonomics36: 223–229.
16.
ClemesSAHaslamCOHaslamRA (2010) What constitutes effective manual handling training? A systematic review. Occupational Medicine60: 101–107.
17.
CollinsJMenzelN (2006) Scope of the problem. In: NelsonA (eds) Safe Patient Handling and Movement, New York, NY: Springer, pp. 3–26.
18.
CollinsJWolfLBellJ (2004) An evaluation of ‘best practices' musculoskeletal injury prevention program in nursing homes. Injury Prevention10: 206–211.
19.
CornishJJonesA (2007) Evaluation of moving and handling training for pre-registration nurses and its application to practice. Nurse Education in Practice7: 128–134.
20.
CornishJJonesA (2010) Factors affecting compliance with moving and handling policy: Student nurses' views and experiences. Nurse Education in Practice10: 96–100.
21.
DawsonAPMcLennanSNSchillerSD (2007) Interventions to prevent back pain and back injury in nurses: A systematic review. Occupational and Environmental Medicine64: 642–650.
22.
de Ruiter H-P (2008) To lift or not to lift: An institutional ethnography of patient handling practices. Faculty of the Graduate School. University of Minnesota.
23.
de RuiterH-PLiaschenkoJ (2011) To lift or not to lift: Patient handling practices. AAOHN Journal59: 337–343.
24.
DenisDSt-VincentMImbeauD (2008) Intervention practices in musculoskeletal disorder prevention: A critical literature review. Applied Ergonomics39: 1–14.
25.
DHS (2004) Victorian Nurses' Back Injury Prevention Project Evaluation Report 2004. Melbourne: Department of Human Services.
26.
EdlichRFHudsonMABuschbacherRM (2005) Devastating injuries in healthcare workers: Description of the crisis and legislative solution to the epidemic of back injury from patient lifting. Journal of Long-Term Effects of Medical Implants15: 225–241.
27.
EngkvistI-L (2004) The accident process preceding back injuries among Australian nurses. Safety Science42: 221–235.
28.
EngkvistI-L (2006) Evaluation of an intervention comprising a No Lifting Policy in Australian hospitals. Applied Ergonomics37: 141–148.
29.
EngkvistI-L (2007) Nurses' expectations, experiences and attitudes towards the intervention of a ‘No Lifting' policy. Journal of Occupational Health49: 294–304.
30.
EngkvistI-L (2008) Back injuries among nurses - A comparison of the accident processes after a 10-year follow-up. Safety Science46: 291–301.
31.
EngkvistI-LKjellbergAWigaeusH (2001) Back injuries among nursing personnel - identification of work conditions with cluster analysis. Safety Science37: 1–18.
32.
FlinR (2007) Measuring safety culture in healthcare: A case for accurate diagnosis. Safety Science45: 653–667.
33.
FlinRMearnsKO'ConnorP (2000) Measuring safety climate: Identifying the common features. Safety science34: 177–192.
34.
FreshwaterDCahillJ (2010) Care and compromise: Developing a conceptual framework for work-related stress. Journal of Research in Nursing15: 173–183.
35.
GargAOwenBD (1992) Reducing back stress to nursing personnel: An ergonomic intervention in a nursing home. Ergonomics35: 1353–1375.
36.
Geiger-BrownJTrinkoffANielsenK (2004) Nurses' perception of their work environment, health, and well-being: A qualitative perspective. AAOHN Journal52: 16–22.
37.
GreenC (1996) Study of moving and handling practices on two medical wards. British Journal of Nursing5: 303–304, 306–308, 310–311.
38.
GreenCA (2002) Reflecting on reflection: Students' evaluation of their moving and handling education. Nurse Education in Practice2: 4–12.
39.
GropelliTMPCorleK (2011) Nurses' and therapists' experiences with occupational musculoskeletal injuries. AAOHN Journal58: 159–166.
40.
HaneyLWrightL (2007) Sustaining staff nurse support for a patient care ergonomics program in critical care. Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America19: 197–204.
41.
HaslamR (2002) Targeting ergonomics interventions - learning from health promotion. Applied Ergonomics33: 241–249.
42.
Health and Safety Executive (1992) Manual handling of loads - guideline to the manual handling operations regulations, London, UK: HSMO.
43.
HignettS (1996) Work-related back pain in nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing23: 1238–1246.
44.
HignettS (2001) Embedding ergonomics in hospital culture: Top-down and bottom-up strategies. Applied Ergonomics32: 61–69.
45.
HignettS (2003) Intervention strategies to reduce musculoskeletal injuries associated with handling patients: A systematic review. Occupational and Environmental Medicine60: e6.
46.
HignettSCrumptonE (2007) Competency-based training for manual handling. Applied Ergonomics38: 7–17.
Hignett S and Fray M (2010) Manual handling in healthcare. 1st Conference of the Federation of the European Ergonomics Societies (FEES). Bruges, Belgium, Institute of Ergonomics and Human Factors, on behalf of FEES/ECE. Available at: https://hdl-handle-net.web.bisu.edu.cn/2134/7175.
49.
HignettSFrayMRossiMA (2007) Implementation of the Manual Handling Directive in the healthcare industry in the European Union for patient handling tasks. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics37: 415–423.
50.
HignettSLuJ (2010) Space to care and treat safely in acute hospitals: Recommendations from 1866 to 2008. Applied Ergonomics41: 666–673.
51.
HignettSRichardsonB (1995) Manual handling human loads in a hospital: An exploratory study to indetify nurses' perceptions. Applied Ergonomics26: 221–226.
HolmanG (2006) Decision factors in patient handling. In: BloswickDSHegmannKTSesekRF (eds) Proceedings of Fourth Annual Regional National Occupational Research Agenda (NORA) Young/New Investigators' Symposium, Salt Lake City: University of Utah, pp. 51–65. Available at: http://www.mech.utah.edu/ergo/pages/NORA/2006/51-66%20Holman,%20Talley.pdf.
54.
HolmanGTEllisonKJMaghsoodlooS (2010) Nurses' perceptions of how job environment and culture influence patient handling. International Journal of Orthopaedic and Trauma Nursing14: 18–29.
55.
HughesNLNelsonAMatzMW (2011) AORN Ergonomic Tool 4: Solutions for prolonged standing in perioperative settings. AORN Journal93: 767–774.
56.
IakovouG (2008) Implementation of an evidence-based safe patient handling and movement mobility curriculum in an associate degree nursing program. Teaching and Learning in Nursing3: 48–52.
57.
IlmarinenJ (2009) Work ability - a comprehensive concept for occupational health research and prevention. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health35: 1–5.
58.
JohnssonACEKjellbergALangerströmMI (2006) Evaluation of nursing students' work technique after proficiency training in patient transfer methods during undergraduate education. Nurse Education Today26: 322–331.
59.
JohnssonCKjellbergKKjellbergA (2004) A direct observation instrument for assessment of nurses' patient transfer technique. Applied Ergonomics35: 591–601.
60.
Kay K and Glass N (2011) Debunking the manual handling myth: An investigation of manual handling knowledge and practices in the Australian private health sector. International Journal of Nursing Practice 17: 231–237.
61.
KilgariffCBestM (1999) An investigation of manual handling training in Victorian health education programs. Journal of Occupational Health & Safety - Australia & New Zealand15: 475–481.
62.
KjellbergKJohnnsonCProperK (2000) An observation instrument for assessment of work technique in patient transfer tasks. Applied Ergonomics31: 139–150.
63.
KjellbergKLangerströmMHagbergM (2003) Work technique of nurses in patient transfer tasks and associations with personal factors. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health29: 468–477.
64.
KneafseyR (2000) The effect of occupational socialization on nurses' patient handling practices. Journal of Clinical Nursing9: 585–593.
65.
KneafseyRHaighC (2007) Learning safe patient handling skills: Student nurse experiences of university and practice based education. Nurse Education Today27: 832–839.
66.
KnibbeHKnibbeNKlaassenA (2007) Safe patient handling program in critical care using peer leaders: Lessons learned in The Netherlands. Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America19: 205–211.
67.
LangerströmMJosephsonMPingelB (1998) Evaluation of the implementation of an education and training programme for nursing personnel at a hospital in Sweden. Industrial Ergonomics21: 79–90.
68.
LangfordE (1997) Buried but not dead: A survey of occupational illness and injury incurred by nurses in the Victorian health service industry, Melbourne: The Australian Nursing Federation (Victorian Branch).
69.
LareseFFioritoA (1994) Musculoskeletal disorders in hospital nurses: A comparison between two hospitals. Ergonomics37: 1205–1211.
70.
LimHJBlackTRShahSM (2011) Evaluating repeated patient handling injuries following the implementation of a multi-factor ergonomic intervention program among health care workers. Journal of Safety Research42: 185–191.
71.
LloydJBaptisteA (2006) Friction-reducing devices for lateral patient transfers: A biomechanical evaluation. AAOHN Journal54: 113–119.
72.
LoveC (1996) Injury caused by lifting: A study of the nurse's viewpoint. Nursing Standard10: 34–39.
73.
McGillSMKavcicNS (2005) Transfer of the horizontal patient: The effect of a friction reducing assistive device on low back mechanics. Ergonomics48: 915–929.
74.
MarrasWSDavisKGKirkingBC (1999) A comprehensive analysis of low-back disorder risk and spinal loading during the transferring and repositioning of patients using different techniques. Ergonomics42: 904–926.
75.
MarrasWSKnapikGGFergusonS (2009) Lumbar spine forces during manoeuvring of ceiling-based and floor-based patient transfer devices. Ergonomics52: 384–397.
76.
MarrasWLavenderSFergusonS (2010) Quantitative dynamic measures of physical exposure predict low back functional impairment. Spine35: 914–923.
77.
MartimoK-PVerbeekJKarppinenJ (2008) Effect of training and lifting equipment for preventing back pain in lifting and handling: Systematic review. bmj336: 429–431.
78.
MartinPJHarveyJTCulvenorJF (2009) Effect of a nurse back injury prevention intervention on the rate of injury compensation claims. Journal of Safety Research40: 13–19.
79.
Massy-WestroppMRoseD (2004) The impact of manual handling training on work place injuries: A 14 year audit. Australian Health Review27: 80–87.
80.
MenzelNN (2008) Underreporting of musculoskeletal disorders among health care workers: Research needs. AAOHN Journal56: 487–494.
81.
MitchellTO'SullivanPBBurnettAF (2008) Low back pain characteristics from undergraduate student to working nurse in Australia: A cross-sectional survey. International Journal of Nursing Studies45: 1636–1644.
82.
MitchellTO'SullivanPBSmithA (2009) Biopsychosocial factors are associated with low back pain in female nursing students: A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Nursing Studies46: 678–688.
83.
MoodyJMcGuireTHansonM (1996) A study of nurses' attitudes towards mechanical aids. Nursing Standard11: 37–42.
84.
NelsonA (2006) Safe Patient Handling and Movement, New York: Springer.
85.
NelsonABaptisteAS (2006) Evidence-based practices for safe patient handling and movement. Orthopaedic Nursing25: 366–379.
86.
NelsonACollinsJSiddharthanK (2008) Link between safe patient handling and patient outcomes in long-term care. Rehabilitation Nursing33: 33–43.
87.
NelsonAFragalaGMenzelN (2003) Myths and facts about back injuries in nursing. American Journal of Nursing103: 32–40.
88.
NelsonAMatzMChenF (2006) Development and evaluation of a multifaceted ergonomics program to prevent injuries associated with patient handling tasks. International Journal of Nursing Studies43: 717–733.
89.
OwenBD (1989) The magnitude of low-back problem in nursing. Western Journal of Nursing Research11: 234–242.
90.
OwenBD (2000) Preventing injuries using an ergonomic approach. AORN72: 1031–1036.
91.
OwenBDKeeneKOlsonS (2002) An ergonomic approach to reducing back/shoulder stress in hospital nursing personnel: A five year follow up. International Journal of Nursing Studies39: 295–302.
92.
PalumboMRamburBMcIntoshB (2010) Registered nurses' perceptions of health and safety related to their intention to leave. AAOHN Journal58: 95–103.
93.
PassfieldJMarshallEAdamsR (2003) ‘No Lift' patient handling policy implementation and staff injury rates in a public hospital. Journal of Occupational Health and Safety - Australia and New Zealand19: 73–85.
94.
RetsasAPinikahanaJ (2000) Manual handling activities and injuries among nurses: An Australian hospital study. Journal of Advanced Nursing31: 875–883.
95.
SmallwoodJA (2006) Patient handling: Student nurses' views. Learning in Health & Social Care5: 208–219.
96.
SmedleyJInskipHTrevelyanF (2003) Risk factors for incident neck and shoulder pain in hospital nurses. Occupational and Environmental Medicine60: 864–869.
97.
SmithDLeggatP (2004) Musculoskeletal disorders among rural Australian nursing students. Australian Journal of Rural Health12: 241–245.
98.
SperaPLloydJHernandezE (2011) AORN Ergonomic Tool 5: Tissue Retraction in the Perioperative Setting. AORN Journal94: 54–58.
99.
SpiegelJYassiARonaldL (2002) Implementing a resident lifting system in an extended care hospital: Demonstrating cost-benefit. AAOHN Journal50: 128–134.
100.
StengerKMontgomeryLABriesemeisterE (2007) Creating a culture of change through implementation of a safe patient handling program. Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America19: 213–222.
101.
StrakerLBurgess-LimerickRPollockC (2004) A randomized and controlled trial of a participative ergonomics intervention to reduce injuries associated with manual tasks: Physical risk and legislative compliance. Ergonomics47: 166–188.
102.
StubbsDABucklePWHudsonMP (1986) Backing out: Nurse wastage associated with back pain. International Journal of Nursing Studies23: 325–336.
103.
SwainJPufahlEWilliamsonG (2003) Do they practise what we teach? A survey of manual handling practice amongst student nurses. Journal of Clinical Nursing12: 297–306.
104.
TrinkoffAMLeRGeiger-BrownJ (2006) Longitudinal relationship of work hours, mandatory overtime, and on-call to musculoskeletal problems in nurses. American Journal of Industrial Medicine49: 964–971.
105.
TrinkoffAMLipscombJAGeiger-BrownJ (2003) Perceived physical demands and reported musculoskeletal problems in registered nurses. American Journal of Preventive Medicine24: 270–275.
106.
van der MolenHSluiterJHulshofC (2005) Effectiveness of measures and implementation strategies in reducing physical work demands due to manual handling at work. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health31: 75–87.
107.
Verbeek J, Martimo K-P, Karppinen J, et al. (2011) Manual material handling advice and assistive devices for preventing and treating back pain in workers (Review). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 6: 1--74. Available at: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD005958.pub3/pdf.
108.
WardellHMHA (2007) Reduction of injuries associated with patient handling. AAOHN Journal55: 407–412.
109.
WarmingSJuul-KristensenBEbbehøjN (2004) An observation instrument for the description and evaluation of patient transfer technique. Applied Ergonomics35: 603–614.
110.
WatersTBaptisteAShortM (2011a) AORN Ergonomic Tool 1: Lateral transfer of a patient from a stretcher to an OR bed. AORN Journal93: 334–339.
111.
WatersTBaptisteAShortM (2011b) AORN Ergonomic Tool 6: Lifting and carrying supplies and equipment in the perioperative setting. AORN Journal94: 173–179.
112.
WatersTLloydJDHernandezE (2011c) AORN Ergonomic Tool 7: Pushing, pulling, and moving equipment on wheels. AORN Journal94: 254–260.
113.
WatersTNelsonAProctorC (2007) Patient handling tasks with high risk for musculoskeletal disorders in critical care. Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America19: 131–143.
114.
WatersTRPutz-AndersonVGargA (1993) Revised NIOSH equation for the design and evaluation of manual lifting tasks. Ergonomics36: 749–776.
115.
WatersTShortMLloydJ (2011d) AORN Ergonomic Tool 2: Positioning and repositioning the supine patient on the OR bed. AORN Journal93: 445–449.
116.
WatersTSperaPPetersenC (2011e) AORN Ergonomic Tool 3: Lifting and holding the patient's legs, arms, and head while prepping. AORN Journal93: 589–592.
117.
WestgaardRHWinkelJ (1997) Ergonomic intervention research for improved musculoskeletal health: A critical review. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics20: 463–500.
118.
WorkSafe Victoria (2000) Code of Practice for Manual Handling, Melbourne: Victorian Workcover Authority.
119.
Wright L, Evitt P and Baptiste A (2005) Protocol for safe use of patient handling slings- does one size fit all? Association of Occupational Health Professionals in Healthcare. Fall, pp. 28–35.
120.
YeungSSYuanJ (2011) Low back pain among personal care workers in an old age home: Work-related and individual factors. AAOHN Journal59: 345–353.
