Despite the increasing numbers of women given community sentences in the UK and in other jurisdictions in recent years, there has been relatively little research into women’s experiences of these disposals. This is particularly surprising given what is known about the distinctive characteristics of women in conflict with the law and the gendered nature of pathways to crime. This article draws upon the experiences of women made subject to a range of community sentences to identify recurring themes including the complexity of women’s problems, the significance of stigma, trauma and abuse, the importance to women of their supervisory relationships, the relevance of self-efficacy and the nature of barriers to compliance. The article considers the consequences of the discourses of ‘penality’ when underpinned by ideological assumptions and expectations based on gender relations. The implications for the supervision of women in the community are considered, while acknowledging that community sanctions are unlikely in themselves to be capable of addressing broader issues that bring women into and retain them in the criminal justice system.
Anderson T. ( 2008) Neither Villain nor Victim: Empowerment and Agency among Women Substance Abusers. New Brunswick: Rutgers International Press.
2.
Barker M. ( 1993) Community Service and Women Offenders. London: Association of Chief Officers of Probation .
3.
Barry M. and McIvor G. ( 2008) Chaotic Lives: A Profile of Women in the Criminal Justice System in Lothian and Borders. Edinburgh: Lothian and Borders Community Justice Authority.
4.
Barry M. and McIvor G. ( 2010) Professional decision-making and women offenders: Containing the chaos. Probation Journal57(1): 27-40.
5.
Bartky SL ( 1990) Femininity and Domination: Studies in the Phenomenology of Oppression. London: Routledge .
6.
Beaumont B. and Mistry T. ( 1996) Doing a good job under duress. Probation Journal43(4): 200-204.
7.
Bloom B., Owen B. and Covington S. ( 2003) Gender-Responsive Strategies: Research, Practice, and Guiding Principles for Women Offenders Project Guiding Principles and Strategies Draft Document. Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections.
8.
Boyd S. ( 2004) From Witches to Crack Moms: Women, Drug Law and Policy . Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.
9.
Carlen P (ed.) (2002) Women and Punishment: The Struggle for Justice. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
10.
Convery U. ( 2009) Addressing Offending by Women: A Literature Review. Belfast: Northern Ireland Office.
11.
Cook S and Davies S (eds) (1999) Harsh Punishment: International Experiences of Women’s Imprisonment. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
12.
Corston Baroness ( 2007) The Corston Report: A Review of Women with Particular Vulnerabilities in the Criminal Justice System. London : Home Office.
13.
Eley S., Gallop K., McIvor G., Morgan K. and Yates R. ( 2002) Drug Treatment and Testing Orders: Evaluation of the Scottish Pilots. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Social Research.
14.
Falk G. ( 2001) Stigma: How We Treat Outsiders. New York: Prometheus Books.
15.
Foucault M. ( 1977) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. London: Allen Lane.
16.
Frost NA, Greene J. and Pranis K. ( 2006) Hard Hit: The Growth in the Imprisonment of Women, 1977-2004 . New York: Institute on Women and Criminal Justice.
17.
Gelsthorpe L., Sharpe G. and Roberts J. ( 2007) Provision for Women Offenders in the Community. London: Fawcett Society and Nuffield Foundation.
18.
Goffman E. ( 1963) Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
19.
Goodwin K. and McIvor G. ( 2001) Women’s Experiences of Community Service Orders . Stirling: Social Work Research Centre, University of Stirling.
20.
Hannah-Moffat K. ( 2001) Punishment in Disguise: Penal Governance and Federal Imprisonment of Women in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
21.
Hedderman C., Palmer E. and Hollin C. ( 2008) Implementing Services for Women Offenders and Those ‘At Risk’ of Offending: Action Research with Together Women. London: Ministry of Justice.
22.
Horn R. and Evans M. ( 2000) The effect of gender on Pre-Sentence Reports. Howard Journal39(2): 184-197.
23.
Howe A. ( 1994) Punish and Critique: Towards a Feminist Analysis of Penality . London: Routledge.
24.
Hutter B and Williams G (eds) (1981) Controlling Women: The Normal and the Deviant. London: Croom Helm.
25.
Jamieson J., McIvor G. and Murray C. ( 1999) Understanding Offending among Young People. Edinburgh: The Stationery Office.
26.
Leverntz AM ( 2006) The love of a good man? Romantic relationships as a source of support or hindrance for female ex-offenders. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency43(4): 459-488.
27.
Loucks N. ( 2004) Women in prison. In: McIvor G (ed.) Women Who Offend: Research Highlights in Social Work44. London: Jessica Kingsley.
28.
Loucks N., Malloch M., McIvor G. and Gelsthorpe L. ( 2006) Evaluation of the 218 Centre. Edinburgh : Scottish Executive Social Research, 142-158.
29.
Mair G. and May C. ( 1997) Offenders on Probation. Home Office Research Study167. London: Home Office.
30.
Mair G., Cross N. and Taylor S. ( 2007) The Use and Impact of the Community Order and the Suspended Sentence Order. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
31.
Malloch M. ( 1999) Drug use, prison and the social construction of femininity . Women’s Studies International Forum22(3): 349-358.
32.
Malloch M. ( 2004) Missing out: Gender, drugs and justice. Probation Journal51(4): 295-308.
33.
Malloch M., McIvor G. and Loucks N. ( 2008) ‘Time out’ for women: Innovation in Scotland in a context of change. Howard Journal47(4): 383-399.
34.
Maruna S. ( 2001) Making Good: How Ex-Inmates Reform and Rebuild Their Lives . Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
35.
McIvor G. ( 2007) The nature of female offending. In: Sheehan R, McIvor G and Trotter C (eds) What Works with Women Offenders . Cullompton: Willan Publishing , 1-22.
36.
McIvor G. and Barry M. ( 1998) Social Work and Criminal Justice Volume 6: Probation. Edinburgh: The Stationery Office.
37.
McIvor G., Barnsdale L., Malloch M., Eley S. and Yates R. ( 2006) The Operation and Effectiveness of the Scottish Drug Court Pilots. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Social Research.
38.
Mckeganey N. and Barnard M. ( 1996) Sex Work on the Streets: Prostitutes and Their Clients . Buckingham: Open University Press .
39.
Ministry of Justice (2009) A Report on the Government’s Strategy for Diverting Women Away from Crime . London: Ministry of Justice.
40.
Norland S. and Mann PJ ( 1984) Being troublesome: Women on probation. Criminal Justice and Behavior11(1): 115-135.
41.
Patel S. and Stanley S. ( 2008) The Use of the Community Order and the Suspended Sentence Order for Women. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
42.
Rex S. ( 1999) Desistance from offending: Experiences of probation. Howard Journal38(4): 366-383.
43.
Rumgay J. ( 2004) Scripts for safer survival: Pathways out of female crime . Howard Journal43(4): 405-419.
44.
Scottish Consortium on Crime and Criminal Justice (SCCCJ) ( 2006) Women in Prison in Scotland: An Unmet Need. Edinburgh: SCCCJ.
45.
Scottish Executive (2002) A Better Way: The Report of the Ministerial Group on Women’s Offending. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
46.
Scottish Government (2007) Reforming and Revitalising: Report of the Review of Community Penalties. Edinburgh: Scottish Government.
47.
Scottish Government (2008) Protecting Scotland’s Communities: Fair, Fast and Flexible Justice. Edinburgh: Scottish Government.
48.
Scottish Government (2009) Prison Statistics Scotland, 2008/09. Edinburgh: Scottish Government.
49.
Scottish Government (2010a) Criminal Proceedings in Scottish Courts, 20087/09. Edinburgh : Scottish Government.
50.
Scottish Government (2010b) Criminal Justice Social Work Statistics, 2008/09. Edinburgh : Scottish Government.
51.
Scottish Office (1998) Women Offenders - a Safer Way: A Review of Community Disposals and the Use of Custody for Women in Scotland. Edinburgh: The Scottish Office.
52.
Scottish Office (2002) A Better Way: The Report of the Ministerial Group on Women’s Offending. Edinburgh: Scottish Office.
53.
Scottish Prisons Commission (2008) Scotland’s Choice: Report of the Prisons Commission. Edinburgh: Blackwell.
54.
Sharpe G. ( 2011) Beyond youth justice: Working with girls and young women who offend. In: Sheehan R, McIvor G and Trotter C (eds) Working with Women Offenders in the Community. Cullompton: Willan Publishing, 151-172.
55.
Sheehan R, McIvor G and Trotter C (eds) (2007) What Works with Women Offenders. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
56.
Skeggs B. ( 1997) Formations of Class and Gender: Becoming Respectable. London: SAGE.
57.
Smart C (ed.) (1992) Regulating Womanhood: Historical Essays on Marriage, Motherhood and Sexuality. London: Routledge.
58.
Szasz T. ( 2003) Ceremonial Chemistry: The Ritual Persecution of Drugs, Addicts and Pushers. New York: Syracuse University Press.
59.
Stanley L. and Wise S. ( 1993) Breaking Out Again: Feminist Ontology and Epistemology . London: Routledge.
60.
Thom B. ( 2010) Women in recovery. In: Yates R, Malloch M (eds) Tackling Addiction: Pathways to Recovery. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 52-69.
61.
Tombs J. ( 2004) From ‘a safer to a better way’. In: McIvor G (ed.) Women Who Offend. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 66-81.
62.
Wright L. and Kemshall H. ( 1994) Feminist probation practice: Making supervision meaningful . Probation Journal41(2): 73-80.
