Predictors of public support for the death penalty in the Americas: A comparative analysis

Abstract

The primary purpose of this study was to explore public support for capital punishment in seven Latin and North American countries to determine factors that influence citizens’ support for the death penalty. Currently, most of the countries examined in the study do not have death penalty for ordinary crimes, but do have it for cases involving murder, war crimes, genocides, terrorism, and crimes against humanity. Our analysis made several important observations that enhance our understanding of citizens’ attitudes toward the death penalty in the Americas. For instance, we found that a significant majority of citizens from the countries under review support the death penalty even though it currently does not exist in practice. With regard to factors, we found that nationality, religiosity, prior experience with victimization, residential stability, quality of life, life satisfaction, age, and gender were among the factors that heavily predict support for the death penalty in this part of the world. The findings of this study have serious implications for research and practice.

Keywords

Americas capital punishment comparative approach death penalty

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akhtar

(2010) Murder most foul: The death penalty and the disadvantaged. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1638564

Amidon

(2018) Politics and the death penalty: 1930–2010. American Journal of Criminal Justice 43(4): 831–860.

Amnesty International (2021a) Global Report: Death Sentences & Executions 2020. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/en/wpcontent/uploads/2021/05/ACT5037602021ENGLISH.pdf (accessed 5 October 2021).

Amnesty International (2021b) Venezuela 2020 Report. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/en/location/americas/south-america/venezuela/report-venezuela/ (accessed 6 October 2021).

Anderson

Lytle Schwadel

(2017) Age, period, and cohort effects on death penalty attitudes in the United States, 1974–2014. Criminology 55(4): 833–868.G

Antillano

Arias

Zubillaga

(2020) Violence and territorial order in Caracas, Venezuela. Political Geography 82: 102221.

Bartman

(2018) Murder in Mexico: Are journalists victims of general violence or targeted political violence? Democratization 25(7): 1093–1113.

Bedau

(Ed.) (1982) The Death Penalty in America, 3rd edn. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Berg

Carranza

(2018) Organized criminal violence and territorial control: Evidence from northern Honduras. Journal of Peace Research 55(5): 566–581.

10.

Boateng

(2018) Police legitimacy in Africa: A multilevel multinational analysis. Policing and Society 28(9): 1105–1120.

11.

Boateng

Buckner

(2019) Police legitimacy in Asia: Findings from a multilevel hierarchical non-linear analysis. Policing and Society 29(7): 765–782.

12.

Boateng

Dzordzormenyoh

(2022) Capital punishment in Brazil: Exploring factors that predict public support for the death penalty. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 38(1): 56–71.

13.

Bobo

Hutchings

(1996) Perceptions of racial group competition: Extending Blumer’s theory of group position to a multiracial social context. American Sociological Review 61(6): 951–972.

14.

Bohm

(2011) Deathquest: An Introduction to the Theory and Practice of Capital Punishment in the United States, 4th edn. Amsterdam: Anderson Publications/Elsevier.

15.

Bright

(2002) Race, poverty, the death penalty, and the responsibility of the legal profession. Seattle Journal for Social Justice 1: 73.

16.

Brown

Benedict

Buckler

(2010) Support for the death penalty in developing democracies: A binational comparative case study. International Criminal Justice Review 20(4): 398–416.

17.

Ceccato

Melo

Kahn

(2018) Trends and patterns of police-related deaths in Brazil. In: Carrington

Hogg

Scott

, et al (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Criminology and the Global South. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 521–550.

18.

Chavez

(2004) An anatomy of violence in El Salvador. NACLA Report on the Americas (1993) 37(6): 31–37.

19.

Chiricos

Delone

(1992) Labor surplus and punishment: A review and assessment of theory and evidence. Social Problems (Berkeley, Calif.) 39(4): 421–446.

20.

Coronil

Skurski

(1991) Dismembering and remembering the nation: The semantics of political violence in Venezuela. Comparative Studies in Society and History 33(2): 288–337.

21.

Costelloe

Chiricos

Gertz

(2009) Punitive attitudes toward criminals: Exploring the relevance of crime salience and economic insecurity. Punishment & Society 11(1): 25–49.

22.

Cullen

Fisher

Applegate

(2000) Public opinion about punishment and corrections. Crime and Justice 27: 1–79.

23.

Dennis

(2001) Death in Byzantium. Dumbarton Oaks Papers 55: 1–7.

24.

Falco

Freiburger

(2011) Public opinion and the death penalty: A qualitative approach. The Qualitative Report 16(3): 830–847.

25.

Garland

(2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

26.

Heidensohn

(1992) Women in Control? The Role of Women in Law Enforcement. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

27.

Hessing

de Keijser

Elffers

(2003) Explaining capital punishment support in an abolitionist country: The case of the Netherlands. Law and Human Behavior 27: 605–622.

28.

Hood

(2001) Capital punishment: A global perspective. Punishment & Society 3(3): 331–354.

29.

Hood

Hoyle

(2009) Abolishing the death penalty worldwide: The impact of a “new dynamic.” Crime and Justice 38(1): 1–63.

30.

Hood

Hoyle

(2015) The Death Penalty: An International Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

31.

Howard

Newman

Pridemore

(2000) Theory, method, and data in comparative criminology. In: Duffee

(ed.) Criminal Justice 2000: Measurement and Analysis of Crime and Justice. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice, pp. 139–211.

32.

Jacobs

Carmichael

(2004) Ideology, social threat, and the death sentence: Capital sentences across time and space. Social Forces 83(1): 249–278.

33.

Jiang

Lambert

Nathan

(2009) Reasons for death penalty attitudes among Chinese citizens: Retributive or instrumental? Journal of Criminal Justice 37(3): 225–233.

34.

Johnson

(2009) Anger about crime and support for punitive criminal justice policies. Punishment & Society 11(1): 51–66.

35.

Johnson

(2001) Poverty and the death penalty. Journal of Economic Issues 35(2): 517–523.

36.

Keil

Vito

Andreescu

(1999) Perceptions of neighborhood safety and support for the reintroduction of capital punishment in Romania: Results from a Bucuresti survey. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 43(4): 514–534.

37.

Kleck

Jackson

(2017) Does crime cause punitiveness? Crime and Delinquency 63(12): 1572–1599.

38.

Lane

Rader

Henson

, et al. (2014) Fear of Crime in the United States: Causes, Consequences, and Contradictions. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.

39.

Lee

(2017) Taking deterrence seriously: The wide-scope deterrence theory of punishment. Criminal Justice Ethics 36(1): 2–24.

40.

Lenski

(1963) The Religious Factor. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books.

41.

Maxwell

Rivera-Vazquez

(1998) Assessing the instrumental and symbolic elements in attitudes toward the death penalty using a sample of Puerto Rican students. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice 22: 329–339.

42.

Melossi

(1993) Gazette of morality and social whip: Punishment, hegemony, and the case of the USA, 1970–1992. Social & Legal Studies 2(3): 259–279.

43.

Miethe

Deibert

(2005) Cross-national variability in capital punishment: Exploring the sociopolitical sources of its differential legal status. International Criminal Justice Review 15(2): 115–130.

44.

Phillips

(2009) Status disparities in the capital of capital punishment. Law & Society Review 43(4): 807–838.

45.

Quillian

Pager

(2001) Black neighbors, higher crime? The role of racial stereotypes in evaluations of neighborhood crime. The American Journal of Sociology 10(3): 717–767.

46.

Reiman

(1985) Justice, civilization, and the death penalty: Answering van den Haag. Philosophy and Public Affairs 14: 115–148.

47.

Roberts

Indermaur

(2007) Predicting punitive attitudes in Australia. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 14(1): 56–65.

48.

Roelofse

(2015) Comparative policing: Theory and praxis. Internal Security 7(2): 245–265.

49.

Ronderos

(2011) Poverty reduction, political violence and women’s rights in Honduras. Community Development Journal 46(3): 315–326.

50.

Silvee

(2021) Death penalty in South Asia: A comparative study between India and Bangladesh. Journal of Asian and African Studies 56(3): 415–433.

51.

Sims

Johnston

(2004) Examining public opinion about crime and justice: A statewide study. Criminal Justice Policy Review 15(3): 270–293.

52.

Singer

Chouhy

Lehmann

, et al. (2020) Economic anxieties, fear of crime, and punitive attitudes in Latin America. Punishment & Society 22(2): 181–206.

53.

Stack

(2004) Public opinion on the death penalty. International Criminal Justice Review 14(1): 69–98.

54.

Thompson

Garfin

Holman

, et al. (2020) National opinions on death penalty punishment for the Boston marathon bomber before vs. after sentencing. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 26(4): 455–462.

55.

Thorp

Caumartin

Gray-Molina

(2006) Inequality, ethnicity, political mobilisation and political violence in Latin America: The cases of Bolivia, Guatemala and Peru. Bulletin of Latin American Research 25(4): 453–480.

56.

Tilley

(2014) Social Class and Capital Punishment: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis. Doctoral Dissertation, Eastern Kentucky University, Richmond, KY.

57.

Tyler

Weber

(1982) Support for the death penalty; instrumental response to crime, or symbolic attitude? Law & Society Review 17(1): 21–45.

58.

Unnever

(2010) Global support for the death penalty. Punishment & Society 12(4): 463–484.

59.

Unnever

Cullen

(2009) Public opinion and the death penalty. In: Oswald

Beineck

Hupfeld-Heinemann

(eds) Social Psychology of Punishment of Crime. West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons.

60.

Unnever

Cullen

Fisher

(2007) “A liberal is someone who has not been mugged”: Criminal victimization and political beliefs. Justice Quarterly 24(2): 309–334.

61.

Wacquant

LJD

(2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

62.

Wallace

(ed.) (2019) Caribbean Perspectives on Criminology and Criminal Justice. Vol. 1. Washington, DC: Westphalia Press.

63.

Young

(1992) Religious orientation, race and support for the death penalty. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 31(1): 76–87.