This article sets out a case for a revived sociology of media work. It suggests that
a certain sociological approach, neglected for some time, offers the promise of (a)
providing a more rounded sociological account of journalistic practice that (b) will
help us better understand what journalists do and how and why they do it, (c) will
ultimately help us better understand the process of news production and message
creation, and (d) may have wider applicability for the study of occupations in the
realm of cultural production.The article argues that there is still much to be
gained from sociologically informed empirical enquiry into the work of journalists.
The examples of journalists’ mistakes and the ways journalists regulate and
control each others’ work are used to illustrate the case. This involves an
analytical framework built on the concept of journalism as an occupational accomplishment.
Ackroyd, S.
,
Batt, R.
,
Thompson, P.
and
Tolbert, P.S.
(eds) (2005) The Oxford Handbook of Work and
Organization.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
2.
Aldridge, M.
and
Evetts, J.
(2003) `
Rethinking the Concept of Professionalism: The Case of Journalism'
, British Journal of Sociology54(4):
547—64
.
3.
Allan, S.
(1999) News Culture.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
4.
Altheide, D.L.
(1976) Creating Reality.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
.
5.
Bantz, C.R.
(1985) `
News Organizations: Conflict as a Crafted Cultural Norm
', Communication8(2):
225—44
.
6.
Becker, H.S.
(1970) Sociological Work: Method and Substance.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books
.
7.
Benson, R.
(2004a) `
Bringing the Sociology of the Media Back In
', Political Communication21(3):
275—92
.
8.
Benson, R.
(2004b) `
Why Conceptual Models and “Big” Institutions Matter:
A Response to David Altheide, Nina Eliasoph, William Gamson, and Todd Gitlin
', Political Communication21(3):
311—14
.
9.
Benson, R.
and
Neveu, E.
(2005) `Introduction: Field Theory as a Work in
Progress ', in
R. Benson
and
E. Neveu
(eds) (2005) Bourdieu and the Journalistic Field, pp.
1—28.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
10.
Blair, H.
(2001) `“
You're Only as Good as Your Last Job”: The Labour Process and
Labour Market in the British Film Industry'
, Work, Employment and Society15(1):
149—69
.
11.
Blair, H.
and
Rainnie, A.
(2000) `
Flexible Films?'
, Media, Culture & Society22(2):
187—204
.
12.
Blair, J.
(2004) Burning Down My Master's House: My Life at the New
York Times.
Beverly Hills, CA: New Millennium Press
.
13.
Born, G.
(2004) Uncertain Vision: Birt, Dyke and the Reinvention of
the BBC.
London: Secker and Warburg
.
14.
Boyd-Barrett, O.
(1995) `The Analysis of Media Occupations and
Professionals ', in
O. Boyd-Barrett
and
C. Newbold
(eds) Approaches to Media: A Reader , pp.
270—6.
London: Arnold
.
15.
Breed, W.
(1955) `
Social Control in the Newsroom: A Functional Analysis'
, Social Forces33(4):
326—55
.
16.
Bromley, M.
(1997) `The End of Journalism? Changes in Workplace Practices
in the Press and Broadcasting in the 1990s', in
M. Bromley
and
T. O'Malley
(eds) A Journalism Reader, pp.
330—50.
London: Routledge
.
17.
Casey, R.
and
Allen, C.
(2004) `
Social Housing Managers and the Performance Ethos: Towards a
“Professional Project of the Self”
', Work, Employment and Society18(2):
395—412
.
18.
Chalaby, J.K.
(1998) The Invention of Journalism.
London: Palgrave
.
19.
Cohen, S.
and
Young, J.
(eds) (1981) The Manufacture of News: Deviance, Social
Problems and the Mass Media.
London: Constable
.
20.
Cottle, S.
(1993) TV News, Urban Conflict and the Inner City.
Leicester: Leicester University Press
.
21.
Cottle, S.
with
Ashton, M.
(1999) `
From BBC Newsroom to BBC Newscentre: On Changing Technology and Journalist Practices
', Convergence5(3):
22—43
.
22.
Cottle, S.
(2000)
`New(s) Times: Towards a “Second Wave” of News Ethnography
', Communications: the European Journal of Communication Research25(1):
19—41
.
23.
Cottle, S.
(2003a) `Media Organization and Production: Mapping the
Field', in
S. Cottle
(ed.) Media Organization and Production, pp.
3—24.
London: Sage
.
24.
Cottle, S.
(ed.) (2003b) Media Organization and Production.
London: Sage
.
25.
Curran, J.
and
Seaton, J.
(1997) Power Without Responsibility. The Press, Broadcasting
and New Media in Britain.
London: Routledge
.
26.
De Burgh, H.
(2005) Making Journalists.
London: Routledge
.
27.
Delano, A.
and
Henningham, J.
(1995) The News Breed: British Journalism in the 1990s
.
London: London Institute
.
28.
Dex, S.
,
Willis, J.
,
Paterson, R.
and
Sheppard, E.
(2000) `
Freelance Workers and Contract Uncertainty: The Effects of Contractual
Changes in the Television Industry'
, Work, Employment and Society14(2):
283—305
.
29.
Dingwall, R.
(1976) `
Accomplishing Profession'
, The Sociological Review24(2):
331—49
.
30.
Dyke, G.
(2004) Inside Story.
London: Harper Perennial
.
31.
Eliasoph, N.
(1988) `
Routines and the Making of Oppositional News'
, Critical Studies in Mass Communication5(4):
313—34
.
32.
Eliasoph, N.
(1998) Avoiding Politics: How Americans Produce Apathy in
Everyday Life.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
33.
Ericson, R.V.
,
Baranek, P.M.
and
Chan, J.B.L.
(1987) Visualizing Deviance: A Study of News
Organization .
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
34.
Ericson, R.V.
,
Baranek, P.M.
and
Chan, J.B.L.
(1989) Negotiating Control: A Study of News Sources.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
35.
Fishman, M.
(1980) Manufacturing News.
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
36.
Forde, E.
(2003) `Journalists with a Difference: Producing Music
Journalism', in
S. Cottle
(ed.) Media Organization and Production, pp.
113—30.
London : Sage
.
37.
Fournier, V.
(1999) `
The Appeal to “Professionalism” as a Disciplinary Mechanism
', The Sociological Review47(2):
280—307
.
38.
Franklin, B.
(1997) Newszak and News Media.
London : Arnold
.
39.
Franklin, B.
(2003) `A Good Day to Bury Bad News? Journalists, Sources and
the Packaging of Politics', in
S. Cottle
(ed.) News, Public Relations and Power, pp.
45—62.
London: Sage
.
40.
Freidson, E.
(1962) `Dilemmas in the Doctor-Patient Relationship',
in
A.M. Rose
(ed.) Human Behaviour and Social Processes: An Interactionist
Approach, pp. 207—24.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
41.
Freidson, E.
(1975) Doctoring Together. A Study of Professional Social
Control.
Oxford: Elsevier
.
42.
Freidson, E.
(1986) Professional Powers: A Study of the
Institutionalization of Formal Knowledge.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
43.
Gall, G.
(1998) `
The Changing Relations of Production: Union Derecognition in the UK
Magazine Industry
', Industrial Relations Journal29(2):
151—61
.
44.
Gall, G.
(2002) `
The Return of the National Union of Journalists to the Provincial Newspaper
Industry in Britain
?', Media, Culture & Society24(5):
673—92
.
45.
Gall, G.
(2005) `
Back from the Brink or Still on the Margins? The National Union of
Journalists in the Provincial Newspaper Industry in Britain
', Journalism6(4):
422—41
.
46.
Gamson, J.
(1994) Claims to Fame. Celebrity in Contemporary
America .
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
47.
Gamson, J.
(1996) Freaks Talk Back: Tabloid Talk Shows and Sexual NonconformityChicago: University of Chicago Press
.
48.
Gans, H.J.
(1979) Deciding What's News.
New York : Pantheon
.
49.
Gans, H.J.
(2003) Democracy and the News.
Oxford : Oxford University Press
.
50.
Gieber, W.
(1964) `News is What Newspapermen Make It', in
L.A. Dexter
and
D. Manning White
(eds) People, Society and Mass Communications, pp.
173—80.
New York: Free Press
.
51.
Gitlin, T.
(2002) Media Unlimited. How The Torrent of Images and Sounds
Overwhelms Our Lives.
New York: Owl Books
.
52.
Golding, P.
and
Elliott, P.
(1979) Making the News.
London: Longman
.
53.
Granger, B.
,
Stanworth, J.
and
Stanworth, C.
(1995) `
Self-Employment Career Dynamics — The Case of Unemployment Push
in UK Book Publishing'
, Work, Employment and Society9(3):
499—516
.
54.
Hallin, D.C.
(1994) We Keep America on Top of the World: Television
Journalism and the Public Sphere.
London: Routledge
.
55.
Hannerz, U.
(2004) Foreign News: Exploring the World of Foreign
Correspondents .
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
56.
Hughes, E.C.
(1964[1958]) Men and their Work.
Glencoe, IL: Free Press
.
57.
Hughes, E.C.
(1994[1951]) `Work and the Self', in
E.C. Hughes
(ed.) On Work, Race and the Sociological Imagination, pp.
57—66.
Chicago : The University of Chicago Press
. [First published in
J. Rohrer
and
M. Sherif
(eds) (1951) Social Work at the Crossroads , pp.
313—23.
New York: Harper
.]
58.
Hutton, Lord
(2004) `Investigation into the circumstances surrounding the
death of Dr David Kelly', URL (consulted March 2006): http://www.the-hutton-inquiry.org.uk/
59.
Jacobs, R.
(1996) `
Producing the News, Producing the Crisis: Narrativity, Television and News Work
', Media Culture & Society18(3):
373—98
.
60.
Lloyd, J.
(2004) What the Media Do to Our Politics.
London: Constable and Robinson
.
61.
MacGregor, B.
(1997) Live, Direct and Biased? Making Television News in the
Satellite Age.
London: Arnold
.
62.
McNair, B.
(1998) The Sociology of Journalism.
London: Arnold
.
63.
McNair, B.
(2000) Journalism and Democracy: an Evaluation of the
Political Public Sphere.
London: Routledge
.
64.
McQuail, D.
(1992) Media Performance: Mass Communication and the Public
Interest.
London: Sage
.
65.
McQuail, D.
(2003) Media Accountability and Freedom of Publication
.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
66.
Mancini, P.
(2000) `Political Complexity and Alternative Models of
Journalism: The Italian Case', in
J. Curran
and
M.J. Park
(eds) De-Westernizing Media Studies, pp.
265—78.
London: Routledge
.
67.
Manning, P.
(2001) News and News Sources: A Critical Introduction .
London: Sage
.
68.
Marr, A.
(2004) My Trade. A Short History of British Journalism
.
London: Macmillan
.
69.
Matthews, J.
(2003) `Cultures of Production: The Making of Children's
News', in
S. Cottle
(ed.) Media Organization and Production, pp.
131—46.
London : Sage
.
70.
Miller, D.
(1993) `
Official Sources and “Primary Definition”: The Case
of Northern Ireland
', Media, Culture & Society15(3):
385—406
.
71.
Molotch, H.
and
Lester, M.
(1974) `
News as Purposive Behaviour'
, American Sociological Review39(1):
101—12
.
72.
Morrison, D.M.
and
Tumber, H.
(1988) Journalists at War.
London: Sage
.
73.
Moynihan, D.
(1993) `
Defining Deviancy Down'
, The American Scholar62(1):
17—30
.
74.
Neil, R.
(2004) `The BBC's Journalism After Hutton: The Report of the
Neil Review Team', URL (consulted February 2006): http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/policies/neil_report.shtml
75.
O'Malley, T.
and
Soley, C.
(1998) Regulating the Press.
London : Pluto Press
.
76.
Palmer, J.
(2000) Spinning into Control: News Values and Source
Strategies .
London: Leicester University Press
.
77.
Palmer, M.
(2003) `
Parisian Newsrooms in the Late Nineteenth Century: How to Enter from the
Agency Back Office, Or Inventing News Journalism in France
', Journalism Studies4(4):
479—87
.
78.
Schlesinger, P.
(1978) Putting `Reality' Together: BBC News.
London: Constable
.
79.
Schlesinger, P.
and
Tumber, H.
(1994) Reporting Crime: The Media Politics of Criminal
Justice.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
80.
Schudson, M.
(2003) The Sociology of News.
New York : Norton
.
81.
Schudson, M.
(2005) `Four Approaches to the Sociology of News', in
J. Curran
and
M. Gurevitch
(eds) Mass Media and Society (4th Edition), pp.
172—97.
London: Arnold
.
82.
Sigelman, L.
(1973) `
Reporting the News: An Organizational Analysis'
, American Journal of Sociology79(1):
132—51
.
83.
Smith, J.
(2004) Fifth Report — Safeguarding Patients:
Lessons from the Past — Proposals for the Future. Command Paper
Cm 6394. 9 December 2004.
84.
Snow, J.
(2004) Shooting History: A Personal Journey.
London: Harper Collins
.
85.
Solomon, D.N.
(1970) `Role and Self Conception: Adaptation and Change in
Occupations', in
T. Shibutani
(ed.) Human Nature and Collective Behaviour: Papers in Honor of Herbert
Blumer, pp. 286—300.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
86.
Splichal, S.
and
Sparks, C.
(1994) Journalists for the 21st Century.
Norwood, NJ: Ablex
.
87.
Tuchman, G.
(1972) `
Objectivity as Strategic Ritual: An Examination of Newsmen's Notions of Objectivity'
, American Journal of Sociology77(4):
660—79
.
88.
Tuchman, G.
(1973) `
Making News by Doing Work: Routinizing the Unexpected'
, American Journal of Sociology79(1):
110—31
.
89.
Tuchman, G.
(1978) Making News: A Study in the Construction of
Reality .
New York: Free Press
.
90.
Tuchman, G.
(2003) `The Production of News', in
K.B. Jensen
(ed.) A Handbook of Media and Communication Research: Qualitative and
Quantitative Methodologies, pp. 78—90.
London: Routledge
.
91.
Tumber, H.
and
Palmer, J.
(2004) Media at War: The Iraq Crisis.
London: Sage
.
92.
Tunstall, J.
(1971) Journalists at Work.
London : Constable
.
93.
Tunstall, J.
(1993) Television Producers.
London : Routledge
.
94.
Tunstall, J.
(1996) Newspaper Power: The New National Press in
Britain .
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
95.
Tunstall, J.
(2001) `Introduction', in
J. Tunstall
(ed.) Media Occupations and Professions: A Reader , pp.
1—22.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
96.
Ursell, G.
(1998) `
Labour Flexibility in the UK Commercial Television Sector'
, Media, Culture & Society20(1):
129—53
.
97.
Ursell, G.
(2000) `
Television Production: Issues of Exploitation, Commodification and
Subjectivity in UK Television Labour Markets
', Media, Culture & Society22(6):
805—26
.
98.
Ursell, G.
(2003) `
Creating Value and Valuing Creation in Contemporary UK Television: Or
“Dumbing Down” the Workforce
', Journalism Studies4(1):
31—46
.
99.
Waisbord, S.
(2000) Watchdog Journalism in South America: News,
Accountability, and Democracy.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
100.
Watkins, A.
(2000) A Short Walk Down Fleet Street. From Beaverbrook to
Boycott.
London: Duckworth
.
101.
Weaver, D.
(ed.) (1998) The Global Journalist: News People Around the
World.
London: Hampton Press
.
102.
Weaver, D.
and
Wilhoit, G.C.
(1996) The American Journalist in the 1990s: US News People
at the End of an Era.
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
.
103.
Welch, M.R.
,
Xu, Y.
,
Bjarnason, T.
,
Petee, T.
,
O'Donnell, P.
and
Magro, P.
(2005) `
“But Everybody Does It…”: The Effects of
Perceptions, Moral Pressures, and Informal Sanctions on Tax Cheating
', Sociological Spectrum25(1):
21—52
.
104.
Wells, M.
(2005) `
Have I Got News for You
', Guardian , 12 September 2005.
105.
Wells, M.
and
Ramesh, R.
(2004) `
BBC Reputation Hit by Bhopal Interview Hoax
', Guardian, 4 December 2004.
106.
White, D.M.
(1950) `
The Gatekeeper: A Case Study in the Selection of News
', Journalism Quarterly27(3):
383—90
.
107.
Younge, G.
(2004) `
The Man Who Took the New York Times for a Ride
', Guardian, 6 March 2004.
108.
Zelizer, B.
(2004) Taking Journalism Seriously. News and the
Academy .
London: Sage
.
