Conflictual relations between language groups make Belgium a fruitful ground to study the interplay between historical knowledge, importance, collective memory and social identity related to historical events. This study compared German-speaking and French-speaking Belgians on the these dimensions for a historical event for which contrasted responses were expected, the centenary of Armistice on 11 November 2018. We also focused on generational differences by comparing senior, intermediate, and junior age cohorts. Results showed no generational differences but revealed that German-speakers construct their social identity differently than French-speakers. Namely, German-speaking Belgians integrated political with non-political events in their collective memory and relied more on school as source of knowledge and nationally relevant memories. In contrast, French-speaking Belgians relied on family and friends as source of knowledge, intertwined more personally and nationally relevant memories, and showed a strong association of national identity with the importance attributed to World War I.
AbelMUmanathSFairfieldB, et al. (2019) Collective memories across 11 nations for World War II: similarities and differences regarding the most important events. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition8: 178–188.
2.
AssmannJ (1995) Collective memory and cultural identity. New German Critique65: 125–133.
3.
AssmannJ (2011) Communicative and cultural memory. In: MeusburgerPHeffernanMWunderE (eds) Cultural Memories: The Geographical Point of View. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 15–27.
4.
BeckPVerhoeyenE (2009) Agents secrets à la frontière belgo-allemande: Des services de renseignements alliés et allemands entre 1920 et 1940 dans la région d’Eupen [Secret agents at the Belgian-German border: Allied and German Secret services between 1920 and 1940 in the region]. Cahiers d’Histoire du Temps Present21: 93–134.
5.
BenvindoBMajerusB (2021) Histories and memories: recounting the Great War in Belgium, 1914–2018. In: CornelissenCWeinrichA (eds) Writing the Great War: The Historiography of World War I From 1918 to the Present. New York: Berghahn Books, pp. 50–94.
6.
BenvindoBMajerusBVrintsA (2014) La Grande Guerre des historiens belges, 1914–2014 [The Great War of Belgian historians, 1914–2014]. Belgisch Tijdschrift voor Nieuwste Geschiedenis/ Revue Belge de Histoire Contemporaine44(2–3): 170–196.
7.
BerntsenD (2018) Flashbulb memory and social identity. In: LuminetOCurciA (eds) Flashbulb Memories: New Issues and New Perspectives. London: Routledge, pp. 182–200.
8.
BerntsenDThomsenDK (2005) Personal memories for remote historical events: accuracy and clarity of flashbulb memories related to World War II. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General134: 242–257.
9.
BohnABerntsenD (2007) Pleasantness bias in flashbulb memories: positive and negative flashbulb memories of the fall of the Berlin Wall among East and West Germans. Memory & Cognition35: 565–577.
10.
BorghiM (2021) On war and memory: First World War memorials and collective memory in Britain, France and Germany. National Identities23: 555–571.
11.
BouchatPLicataLRosouxV, et al. (2017) A century of victimhood: antecedents and current impacts of perceived suffering in World War I across Europe. European Journal of Social Psychology47(2): 195–208.
12.
BouchatPLicataLRosouxV, et al. (2019) 100 years after: what is the relation between pacifist attitudes and social representations of the Great War?Peace and Conflict25(2): 129–139.
13.
BouchatPLuminetORosouxV, et al. (2020) A social psychological perspective on World War II collaboration in the 21st century: a Belgian case. European Journal of Social Psychology50(7): 1406–1424.
14.
BreslinCWSaferMA (2011) Effects of event valence on long-term memory for two baseball championship games. Psychological Science22: 1408–1412.
15.
CamiaCFalysCScheiderJ, et al. (2020) What is still known about 11 November 1918 by German-speaking Belgians? In: SumartojoS (ed.) Experiencing 11 November 2018: Commemoration and the First World War Centenary. New York: Taylor & Francis, pp. 199–209.
16.
CamiaCMotianiSWatersTEA (2022) On the way to adult identity: an evaluation of identity status and narrative identity models of development. Journal of Research in Personality101: 104304.
17.
ChampelySEkstromCDalgaardP, et al. (2017) Pwr: basic functions for power analysis.
18.
ComanAHirstW (2015) Social identity and socially shared retrieval-induced forgetting: the effects of group membership. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General144: 717–722.
19.
ComanAStoneCBCastanoE, et al. (2014) Justifying atrocities: the effect of moral-disengagement strategies on socially shared retrieval-induced forgetting. Psychological Science25: 1281–1285.
20.
CordonnierABouchatPHirstW, et al. (2021) Intergenerational transmission of World War II family historical memories of the resistance. Asian Journal of Social Psychology24: 302–314.
21.
De GuissméLLastregoSMélotteP, et al. (2017) Attitudes towards World War II collaboration in Belgium: effects on political positioning towards the amnesty issue in the two main linguistic communities. Psychologica Belgica57(3): 32–51.
22.
GriffinLJ (2004) “Generations and collective memory” revisited: race, region, and memory of civil rights. American Sociological Review69: 544–557.
23.
HalbwachsM (1925) Les Cadres Sociaux de La Memoire. Paris: Félix Alcan.
24.
HirstWComanA (2018) Building a collective memory: the case for collective forgetting. Current Opinion in Psychology23: 88–92.
25.
HirstWFinebergIA (2012) Psychological perspectives on collective memory and national identity: the Belgian case. Memory Studies5(1): 86–95.
26.
HirstWManierD (2008) Towards a psychology of collective memory. Memory16: 183–200.
27.
JaumainSVaesenJBenvindoB, et al. (2017) A comparative look at a centenary. A review of World War I commemorative events in Brussels. Brussels Studies116: 1–33.
28.
KestelootCVan YperseleL (2021) 11 November 2018: Liège, Mons and Brussels commemorate the Great War. In: SumartojoS (ed.) Experiencing 11 November 2018: Commemoration and the First World War Centenary. New York: Routledge, pp. 19–30.
29.
KleinOLicataLVan der LindenN, et al. (2012) A waffle-shaped model for how realistic dimensions of the Belgian conflict structure collective memories and stereotypes. Memory Studies5(1): 16–31.
30.
KokaislPKokaislováP (2015) Belgian Germans or East-Belgians?Journal of Social Research & Policy6(1): 31–43.
31.
KollJ (2005) Preußischer Westen—belgischer Osten. Eupen, Malmedy und St. Vith zwischen Reichsgründung und Zweitem Weltkrieg [Prussian West—Belgian East. Eupen, Malmedy and St. Vith between foundation of the German Empire and World War II]. Comparativ15: 101–125.
32.
LeksanaGSubektiA (2023) Remembering through fragmented narratives: third generations and the intergenerational memory of the 1965 anti-leftist violence in Indonesia. Memory Studies16: 465–480.
33.
LiuJHPaezDHankeK, et al. (2012) Cross-cultural dimensions of meaning in the evaluation of events in world history? Perceptions of historical calamities and progress in cross-cultural data from thirty societies. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology43: 251–272.
34.
LuminetOSpijkermanR (2017) “11 November 1918, an exceptional day!”: flashbulb memories of the World War I Armistice in Belgium from a psychological and a historical perspective. Memory Studies10: 347–362.
35.
LuminetORosouxVBremsE, et al. (2020) Dialogues Sur La Belgique: Souvenirs, Images, Questions [Dialogues About Belgium: Memories, Images, Questions]. Louvain-la-Neuve: Presses Universitaires de Louvain.
36.
MutlutürkATekcanAİBodurogluA (2023) The structure and organization of collective memory representations. Memory Studies16: 1343–1359.
37.
O’ConnellV (2018) The Annexation of Eupen-Malmedy: Becoming Belgian, 1919–1929. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
PennebakerJWPaezDDeschampsJ-C (2006) The social psychology of history: defining the most important events of the last 10, 100, and 1000 years. Psicología Política32: 15–32.
40.
RoedigerHLZerrCL (2022) Who Won World War II? Conflicting Narratives Among the Allies. 1st ed. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
41.
RosouxVVan YperseleL (2012) The Belgian national past: between commemoration and silence. Memory Studies5: 45–57.
42.
SahdraBRossM (2007) Group identification and historical memory. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin33(3): 384–395.
43.
SchumanHAkiyamaHKnäuperB (1998) Collective memories of Germans and Japanese about the past half-century. Memory6: 427–454.
44.
SchumanHScottJ (1989) Generations and collective memories. American Sociological Review54(3): 359–381.
45.
StoneCBLuminetOJayACV, et al. (2022) Do public speeches induce “collective” forgetting? The Belgian King’s 2012 summer speech as a case study. Memory Studies15: 713–730.
46.
StoneCBMercyALicataL, et al. (2013) Mnemonic differences and similarities across opposing social groups: the linguistic conflict at the university of Leuven as a case study. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition2: 166–172.
47.
StoneCBVan der HaegenALuminetO, et al. (2014) Personally relevant vs. nationally relevant memories: an intergenerational examination of World War II memories across and within Belgian French-speaking families. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition3: 280–286.
48.
SumartojoS (2021) Experiencing 11 November 2018: Commemoration and the First World War Centenary. New York: Routledge.
49.
TalaricoJMMooreKM (2012) Memories of “the rivalry”: differences in how fans of the winning and losing teams remember the same game. Applied Cognitive Psychology26: 746–756.
50.
VannesteDRamshawG (2021) 2018 Armistice day in Flanders fields: how complex is commemoration at the end of an era? In: SumartojoS (ed.) Experiencing 11 November 2018: Commemoration and the First World War Centenary. New York: Routledge, pp. 31–44.
51.
Van YperseleL (2014) À l’ombre du soldat inconnu: les pratiques mémorielles autour de la colonne du Congrès à Bruxelles au 20e siècle [In the shadow of the unknown soldier: memorial practices around the congress column in Brussels in the 20th century]. Revue du Nord96: 331–346.
52.
Van YperseleLTixhonA (2000) Celebrations de Novembre 1918 au royaume de Belgique [Celebrations of November 1918 in the Kingdom of Belgium]. Vingtième Siècle. Revue d’histoire67: 61–78.
53.
WelzerHMollerSTschuggnallK (2002) “Opa War Kein Nazi” : Nationalsozialismus Und Holocaust Im Familiengedächtnis [Grandfather Wasn’t a Nazi: National Socialism and Holocaust in Family Remembrance]. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer-Taschenbuch-Verlag.
54.
WertschJV (2008) Collective memory and narrative templates. Social Research75: 133–156. Available at: www.jstor.org/stable/40972055
