In this article, we review empirical evidence regarding the relationship between facial expression and emotion during infancy. We focus on differential emotions theory’s view of this relationship because of its theoretical and methodological prominence. We conclude that current evidence fails to support its proposal regarding a set of pre-specified facial expressions that invariably reflect a corresponding set of discrete emotions in infants. Instead, the relationship between facial expression and emotion appears to be more complex. Some facial expressions may have different meanings in infants than in children and adults. In addition, nonemotion factors may sometimes lead to the production of “emotional” facial expressions. We consider alternative perspectives on the nature of emotion and emotional expression in infancy with particular focus on differentiation and dynamical systems approaches.
Abelson, J.L., Young, E.A., & Khan, S. ( 2005). Cognitive modulation of the endocrine stress response to pharmacological challenge in normal and panic disorder subjects. Archive of General Psychiatry, 62, 668-675.
2.
Ackerman, B.P., Abe, J.A., & Izard, C.E. ( 1998). Differential emotions theory and emotional development: Mindful of modularity. In M. F. Mascolo & S. Griffin (Eds.), What develops in emotional development (pp. 85-106). New York: Plenum Press.
3.
Barrett, K.C., & Campos, J.J. ( 1987). Perspectives on emotional development: II. A functionalist approach to emotions. In J. Osofsky (Ed.), Handbook of infant development (2nd ed., pp. 555-578). New York: Wiley.
4.
Barrett, L.F. ( 2006). Are emotions natural kinds?Perspectives on Psychological Science, 28(1), 28-58.
5.
Bennett, D., Bendersky, M., & Lewis, M.D. ( 2002). Facial expressivity at 4 months: A context by expression analysis. Infancy, 3(1), 97-113.
6.
Bennett, D., Bendersky, M., & Lewis, M.D. ( 2005). Does the organization of emotional expression change over time? Facial expressivity from 4 to 12 months. Infancy , 8(2), 167-187.
7.
Bridges, K.M.B. ( 1932). Emotional development in early infancy. Child Development, 3, 324-341.
8.
Buss, K., & Kiel, E. ( 2004). Comparison of sadness, anger, and fear facial expressions when toddlers look at their mothers. Child Development , 75(6), 1761-1773.
9.
Camras, L.A. ( 1980). Animal threat displays and children’s facial expressions . In D. Freedman, D. Omark & F. Strayer (Eds.), Dominance relations: Ethological perspectives on human conflict (pp. 121-135) . New York: Garland publishing.
10.
Camras, L.A. ( 1991). Conceptualizing early infant affect: View II and reply . In K. Strongman (Ed.), International review of studies on emotion (pp. 16-28, 33-36). New York: John Wiley & Sons.
11.
Camras, L.A. ( 1992). Expressive development and basic emotions. Cognition & Emotion, 6(3-4), 269-284.
12.
Camras, L.A., & Fatani, S.S. ( 2008). The development of facial expressions: Current perspectives on infant emotions. In M. Lewis, J. Haviland-Jones & L. F. Barrett (Eds.), Handbook of emotions (3rd ed., pp. 291-303). New York: Guilford Press.
13.
Camras, L.A., Lambrecht, L., & Michel, G. ( 1996). Infant "surprise" expressions as coordinative motor structures . Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 20, 183-195.
14.
Camras, L.A., Malatesta, C., & Izard, C.E. ( 1991). The development of facial expressions in infancy . In R. Feldman & B. Rimé (Eds.), Fundamentals of nonverbal behavior (pp. 73-105). Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
15.
Camras, L.A., Meng, Z., Ujiie, T., Dharamsi, S., Miyake, K., Oster, H., et al. (2002). Observing emotion in infants: Facial expression, body behavior and rater judgments of responses to an expectancy-violating event. Emotion, 2, 178-193.
16.
Camras, L.A., Oster, H., Bakeman, R., Meng, Z., Ujiie, T., & Campos, J. ( 2007). Do infants show distinct negative facial expressions for fear and anger: Emotional expression in 11-month-old European-American, Chinese, and Japanese infants. Infancy, 11, 131-155.
17.
Camras, L.A., Oster, H., Campos, J.J., & Bakeman, R. ( 2003). Emotional facial expressions in European-American, Japanese, and Chinese infants. In P. Ekman , J. Campos, R. Davidson & F. de Waal (Eds.), Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences (Vol. 1000). Emotions Inside Out . New York: New York Academy of Sciences.
18.
Camras, L.A., Sullivan, J., & Michel, G. ( 1993). Do infants express discrete emotions?: Adult judgments of facial, vocal, and body actions. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior , 17(3), 171-186.
19.
Camras, L.A., & Witherington, D.C. (2005). Dynamical systems approaches to emotional development. Developmental Review, 25, 328-350.
20.
Dickerson, S.S., Gruenewald, T.L., & Kemeny, M.E. ( 2004). When the social self is threatened: Shame, physiology, and health. Journal of Personality, 72(6), 1191-1216.
21.
Dickerson, S.S., & Kemeny, M.E. ( 2004). Acute stressors and cortisol responses: A theoretical integration and synthesis of laboratory research. Psychological Bulletin, 130(3), 355-391.
Ekman, P., Friesen, W.V., & Hager, J. ( 2002). Investigator’s guide: Facial action coding system . Salt Lake City, UT: Research Nexus .
24.
Ekman, P., Hager, J., Irwin, W., & Rosenberg, E. ( 1998). FACSAID: Facial Action Coding System Affect Information Database. Formerly available from: http://www.nirc.com .
25.
Emde, R.N. ( 1980). Levels of meaning for infant emotions: A biosocial view . In W. Collins (Ed.), Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology (pp. 1-37). Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum.
26.
Emde, R.N., Izard, C.E., Huebner, R., Sorce, J.F., & Klinnert, M. ( 1985). Adult judgments of emotions: Replication studies within and across laboratories. Infant Behavior and Development , 8, 79-88.
27.
Emde, R.N., & Koenig, K. ( 1969). Neonatal smiling and rapid eye movement states . American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 11(2), 117-200.
28.
Fogel, A., & Thelen, E. ( 1987). The development of early expressive and communicative action. Developmental Psychology, 23, 747-761.
29.
Fridlund, A. ( 1994). Human facial expression. San Diego , CA: Academic Press.
30.
Hiatt, S., Campos, J., & Emde, R. ( 1979). Facial patterning and infant emotional expression: Happiness, surprise, and fear. Child Development, 50, 1020-1035.
31.
Holodynski, M., & Friedlmeier, W. (2006). Development of emotions and emotion regulation. Boston: Kluwer Academic.
32.
Huebner, R.R., & Izard, C.E. ( 1988). Mothers’ responses to infant’s facial expressions of sadness, anger, and physical distress. Motivation and Emotion , 12, 185-196.
33.
Izard, C.E. ( 1971). The face of emotion. New York : Appleton-Century-Crofts.
34.
Izard, C.E. ( 1979). The maximally discriminative facial movement coding system (MAX). Newark, DE: Instructional Resources Center, University of Delaware.
35.
Izard, C.E. ( 1991). The psychology of emotions. New York : Plenum Press.
36.
Izard, C.E. ( 1995). The maximally discriminative facial movement coding system. Unpublished manuscript, Instruction Resources Center, University of Delaware, Newark, DE.
37.
Izard, C.E. ( 2004). The generality-specificity issue in infants’ emotion responses: A comment on Bennett, Bendersky, and Lewis (2002). Infancy, 6(3), 417-423.
38.
Izard, C.E., & Abe, J.A. ( 2004). Developmental changes in facial expressions of emotions in the strange situation during the second year of life. Emotion, 4(3), 251-265.
39.
Izard, C.E., Dougherty, L., & Hembree, E. ( 1983). A system for identifying affect expressions by holistic judgments (AFFEX). Newark, DE: Instructional Resources Center, University of Delaware.
40.
Izard, C.E., Fantauzzo, C.A., Castle, J.M., Haynes, O.M., Rayias, M.F., & Putnam, P.H. ( 1995). The ontogeny and significance of infants’ facial expressions in the first 9 months of life. Developmental Psychology , 31(6), 997-1013.
41.
Izard, C.E., Hembree, E., Dougherty, L., & Spirrizi, C. ( 1983). Changes in 2- to 19-month-old infants’ facial expressions following acute pain. Developmental Psychology , 19(3), 418-426.
42.
Izard, C.E., Hembree, E., & Huebner, R. ( 1987). Infants’ emotional expressions to acute pain: Developmental changes and stability of individual differences. Developmental Psychology, 23, 105-113.
43.
Izard, C.E., Huebner, R.R., Risser, D., McGinnes, G.C., & Dougherty, L.M. (1980). The young infant’s ability to produce discrete emotion expressions. Developmental Psychology, 16, 132-140.
44.
Izard, C.E., & Malatesta, C. ( 1987). Perspectives on emotional development: I. Differential emotions theory of early emotional development. In J. Osofsky (Ed.), Handbook of infant development (2nd ed., pp. 494-554). New York: Wiley.
45.
Langsdorf, P., Izard, C.E., Rayias, M., & Hembree, E. ( 1983). Interest expression, visual fixation and heart rate change in 2- to 8-month-old infants. Developmental Psychology , 19(3), 375-386.
46.
Lazarus, R.S. ( 1991). Emotion and adaptation. New York: Oxford University Press.
47.
Lewis, M.D., Alessandri, S.M., & Sullivan, M.W. (1990). Violation of expectancy, loss of control and anger expressions in young infants. Developmental Psychology, 26(5), 745-751.
48.
Lewis, M.D., & Ramsay, D. ( 2005). Infant emotional and cortisol responses in goal blockage . Child Development, 76(2), 518-530.
49.
Lewis, M.D., Ramsay, D., & Sullivan, M.W. (2006). The relation of ANS and HPA activation to infant anger and sadness response to goal blockage. Developmental Psychobiology, 48(5), 397-405.
50.
Matias, R., & Cohn, J. ( 1993). Are MAX-specified infant facial expressions during face-to-face interaction consistent with Differential Emotions Theory? Developmental Psychology, 29(3), 524-531.
51.
Messinger, D.S. ( 2002). Positive and negative: Infant facial expressions and emotions. Current Directions in Psychological Science , 11(1), 1-6.
52.
Messinger, D.S., & Fogel, A. ( 2007). The interactive development of social smiling . In R. Kail (Ed.), Advances in child development and behavior (Vol. 35, pp. 327-366). Oxford: Elsevier.
53.
Messinger, D.S., Fogel, A., & Dickson, K. ( 2001). All smiles are positive, but some smiles are more positive than others. Developmental Psychology, 37(5), 642-653.
54.
Michel, G., Camras, L., & Sullivan, J. ( 1992). Infant interest expressions as coordinative motor structures . Infant Behavior and Development, 15, 347-358.
55.
Oster, H. ( 1982). Pouts and horseshoe-mouth faces: Their determinants, affective meaning and signal value in infants. Paper presented at the International Conference on Infant Studies, Austin, TX.
56.
Oster, H. ( 2005). The repertoire of infant facial expressions: An ontogenetic perspective. In J. Nadel & D. Muir (Eds.), Emotional development (pp. 261-292). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
57.
Oster, H. ( 2007). BabyFACS: Facial Action Coding System for infants and young children. Unpublished monograph and coding manual, New York University.
58.
Oster, H., Hegley, D., & Nagel, L. ( 1992). Adult judgments and fine grained analysis of infant facial expressions: Testing the validity of a priori coding formulas. Developmental Psychology, 28(6), 1115-1131.
59.
Russell, J.A. ( 1994). Is there universal recognition of emotion from facial expression? A review of the cross-cultural studies. Psychological Bulletin, 115(1), 102-141.
60.
Saarni, C., Campos, J., Camras, L.A., & Witherington, D. (2006). Emotional development . In W. Damon (Series Ed.) & N. Eisenberg (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 3, Social, emotional and personality development (6th ed., pp. 226-299). New York: Wiley .
61.
Sroufe, L.A. ( 1996). Emotional development. New York: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Sullivan, M.W., & Lewis, M.D. ( 1988). Facial expressions during learning in 1-year-old infants . Infant Behavior and Development, 11(3), 369-373.
63.
Sullivan, M.W., & Lewis, M.D. ( 1989). Emotion and cognition in infancy: Facial expressions during contingency learning. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 12(2), 221-237.
64.
Sullivan, M.W., & Lewis, M.D. ( 2003). Contextual determinants of anger and other negative expressions in young infants. Developmental Psychology, 39(4), 693-705.
65.
Weinberg, K., & Tronick, E. ( 1994). Beyond the face: An empirical study of infant affective configurations of facial, vocal, gestural, and regulatory behaviors . Child Development, 65, 1503-1515.
66.
Widen, S.C., & Russell, J.A. ( 2003). A closer look at preschoolers’ freely produced labels for facial expressions. Developmental Psychology, 39, 114-128.
67.
Widen, S.C., & Russell, J.A. ( 2008). Young children’s understanding of others’ emotions. In M. Lewis, J. Haviland-Jones & L. Feldman Barrett (Eds.), Handbook of emotions (3rd ed., pp. 348-363). New York: Guilford Press.
68.
Wolff, P. ( 1987). The development of behavioral states and the expression of emotions in early infancy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
69.
Zeman, J., Dougan-Klimes, B., Cassano, M., & Adrian, M. ( 2007). Function, structure, and process as independent dimensions in research on emotion. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice , 14(4), 377-402.
