Rolling resistance,vertical load and optimal number of wheels in human-powered vehicle design

Abstract

Even if it makes a smaller contribution than aerodynamic drag, rolling resistance plays a non-negligible role in the efficiency of human-powered vehicles, whether they are designed for daily commuting or to set speed records. The literature, experimental evidence and models show that the rolling resistance coefficient of cycling wheels strongly depends on the supported load, suggesting that the number of wheels and the load distribution could play a role in vehicle design and in road-test data analysis. Starting with an in-depth look at the relationship between a single wheel and overall vehicle rolling resistance coefficients, an analysis is proposed and discussed with the aim of minimizing the rolling resistance of a vehicle. Finally, a parametric surface response model for rolling resistance is obtained as a function of wheel size and the number of wheels. The overall analysis overturns the popular assumption according to which ‘the more wheels, the more rolling resistance’, at least according to a strict definition of the phenomenon.

Keywords

Rolling resistance cycling tires coast-down human-powered vehicle design optimization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barry

Burton

Sheridan

. Aerodynamic performance and riding posture in road cycling and triathlon. Proc IMechE, Part P: J Sports Engineering and Technology2015; 229: 28–38.

Capelli

Rosa

Butti

. Energy cost and efficiency of riding aerodynamic bicycles. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol1993; 67: 144–149.

Davies

. Effect of air resistance on the metabolic cost and performance of cycling. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol1980; 45: 245–254.

Grappe

Candau

Belli

. Aerodynamic drag in field cycling with special reference to the Obree’s posture. Ergonomics1997; 40: 1299.

Grappe

Candau

Barbier

. Influence of tyre pressure and vertical load on coefficient of rolling resistance and simulated cycling performance. Ergonomics1999; 42(10): 1361–1371.

Ryschon

Stray-Gundersen

. The effect of tyre pressure on the economy of cycling. Ergonomics1993; 36: 661–666.

Schuring

. The rolling loss of pneumatic tyres. Rubber Chem Technol1980; 53: 600.

Callens

Bignonnet

. Fatigue design of welded bicycle frames using a multiaxial criterion. Proced Eng2012; 34: 640–645.

Höchtl

Hein

Klug

. On the effect of chain stay impact on the structural safety of CFRP structures in mountain biking. Proced Eng2012; 34: 664–669.

10.

Hölzel

Hoechtl

Senner

. Operational loads on sport bicycles for possible misuse. Proced Eng2011; 13: 75–80.

11.

Lessard

Nemes

Lizotte

. Utilization of FEA in the design of composite bicycle frames. Composites1995; 26(1): 72–74.

12.

Liu

TJC

. Fiber direction and stacking sequence design for bicycle frame made of carbon/epoxy composite laminate. Mater Design2010; 31(4): 1971–1980.

13.

Meijaard

Papadopoulos

Ruina

. Linearized dynamics equations for the balance and steer of a bicycle: a benchmark and review. P Roy Soc A: Math Phy2007; 463(2084): 1955–1982.

14.

Astrom

Klein

Lennartsson

. Bicycle dynamics and control: adapted bicycles for education and research. IEEE Contr Syst2005; 25(4): 26–47.

15.

Basu-Mandal

Chatterjee

Papadopoulos

. Hands-free circular motions of a benchmark bicycle. P Roy Soc A: Math Phy2007; 463(2084): 1983–2003.

16.

Le Henaff

. Dynamical stability of the bicycle. Eur J Phys1987; 8(3): 207.

17.

Fajans

. Steering in bicycles and motorcycles. Am J Phys2000; 68(7): 654–659.

18.

Moore

. Human control of a bicycle. PhD Thesis, University of California, Davis, 2009.

19.

Hess

Moore

Hubbard

. Modeling the manually controlled bicycle. IEEE T Syst Man Cy A2012; 42(3): 545–557.

20.

Prebble

. Recumbents on the rise according to leisure trends group, http://goo.gl/Ap6Aio (2012, accessed on 5 November 2015).

21.

Prebble

. More positive data from leisure trends group, http://goo.gl/sBHdMd (2012, accessed on 5 November 2015).

22.

Prebble

. Recumbent journal cycle trends – trikes are the wave of the future, http://goo.gl/cnVuOF (2013, accessed on 5 November 2015).

23.

Capelli

Ardigò

Schena

. Energy cost and mechanical efficiency of riding a human-powered recumbent bicycle. Ergonomics2008; 51(10): 1565–1575.

24.

Reiser

II Peterson

Broker

. Anaerobic cycling power output with variations in recumbent body configuration. J Appl Biomech2001; 17(3): 204–216.

25.

Epema

van den Brand

Gregoor

. Bicycle design: a different approach to improving on the world human powered speed records. Procedia Eng2012; 34: 313–318.

26.

Kyle

. The aerodynamics of helmets and handlebars. Cycling Sci1989; 1: 22.

27.

Patterson

Leone

. The application of handling qualities to bicycle design. In: Proceedings, bicycle and motorcycle dynamics, Delft, The Netherlands, 20–22 October 2010, pp.1–10.

28.

Wilson

. Bicycling science. 3rd ed.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2004.

29.

Popov

Cole

Winkler

. Laboratory measurement of rolling resistance in truck tyres under dynamic vertical load. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineering2003; 217(12): 1071–1079.

30.

Candau

Grappe

Ménard

. Simplified deceleration method for assessment of resistive forces in cycling. Med Sci Sports Exerc1999; 31: 1441–1447.

31.

Heine

. Optimizing your tire pressure for your weight. Bicycl Q2007; 5(4): 2.

32.

Samuel

Weir

. Introduction to engineering design (page 94, figure 2.44). Oxford: Elsevier Science, 1999.