Abstract
Dementia is a syndrome in which there is deterioration in memory, thinking, behaviour and the ability to perform everyday activities. An accurate and timely diagnosis of dementia provides opportunity for early treatment, proactive support and advance care planning. However, there is evidence that GPs lack confidence in diagnosing dementia, in part because patients with dementia present in many different ways. Researchers believe that early detection of Alzheimer’s disease, the most common cause of dementia, is necessary if ways to prevent, slow and stop the disease are to be found. This article highlights the common presenting complaints in dementia and offers how GPs can work towards a diagnosis and refer to specialist services appropriately.
The GP curriculum and dementia
Understand the management of the conditions and problems commonly associated with old age, such as Parkinson’s disease, falls, gait disorders, stroke, confusion, dementia and cancer Know the epidemiology of older people’s problems presenting in primary care, such as dementia and cancers as well as their risk factors Understand the special features of psychiatric diseases in old age, including dementia. This incorporates an appreciation of the effects of these conditions on the person, the family and community, and the effects of physical function on the patient's mental state. This understanding should be framed within an understanding of the law relating to mental capacity Understand the ability of an elderly person to carry out all the activities commensurate with their mental competence (e.g. exercise, travel, sexual activity and independence, etc.) Recognise the importance of a problem-based approach, taking in the ‘big picture’, rather than a disease-based approach to the care of older people, who often have complex physical, psychological and social problems
Epidemiology and pathophysiology
In 2013, there were 815 827 people with dementia in the UK; 94% of whom were 65 years old or older. This represents 1.3% of the entire UK population and 7% of the population aged 65 years and over. The prevalence is rapidly increasing, and the global burden of dementia is expected to reach 115 000 000 people by 2050 (King’s College London and London School of Economics, 2014).
Alzheimer’s dementia is by far the most common form of dementia, followed by vascular dementia and dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) (see Fig. 1). Increasingly patients are found to have a mixed dementia, predominantly consisting of Alzheimer’s and vascular types. Researchers are making significant progress with new diagnostic techniques, but presently a true diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease is only made if pathologically proven through brain biopsy (McKhann et al., 2011). As such the true prevalence of each dementia subtype may be different from the clinically identified numbers. Less commonly occurring dementias are Huntington’s disease and fronto-temporal dementia (also known as Pick’s disease). These more frequently present in younger adults.
Percentages of patients diagnosed with each type of dementia 2014.
The cause and pathophysiology of dementia is still poorly understood. In Alzheimer’s disease, beta-amyloid (protein) plaques accumulate outside neurons, and tau tangles accumulate within the neurons. These are thought to ultimately lead to memory loss and impaired cognitive functioning through inflammation, impaired synaptic transfer and destruction of neurons. The pathogenesis of DLB has significant overlap with Alzheimer’s disease, both having amyloid plaques and similar risk factors, but in DLB there are Lewy bodies and neurites in the cortex. Lewy bodies comprise of round, eosinophilic, intracytoplasmic neuronal processes that contribute to neuronal and synaptic loss. Vascular dementia is a poorly defined heterogeneous disorder that is contributed to by combinations of large artery infarctions, lacunar infarctions and chronic small vessel ischaemia causing cerebral damage (Kalaria, 2012).
Who is at risk?
Risk factors for dementia.
Source: NICE (2016).
Signs and symptoms
Presentation of dementia can be very variable, and brain changes are thought to occur as many as 20 years prior to symptoms developing (Reiman et al., 2012). The most common presenting complaint is difficulty remembering new information. Patients with dementia will demonstrate a measurable cognitive decline that interferes with everyday independence (American Psychiatric Association, 2013).
When to suspect dementia.
Presentation, clinical and radiological findings of common types of dementia.
Adapted from Seeley and Miller (2013).
Normal cognitive decline, mild cognitive impairment and dementia
Normal age-related cognitive decline includes mild memory deficits and slower information processing, but progression is gradual and daily functioning unaffected. Common complaints may be of difficulty with name recall, losing things, temporarily forgetting things such as words, the day of the week, or monthly payments (Petersen, Smith, Kokmen, Ivnik, & Tangalos, 1992). Self-reported cognitive problems are thought to be an insensitive and nonspecific marker of mild cognitive impairment and dementia, and should be interpreted with care in the absence of objective findings (Mitchell, 2008). However, subjective memory complaints have been shown to predict future cognitive decline in those with measurably normal cognitive function (Geerlings, Jonker, Bouter, Ader, & Schmand, 1999). It may be beneficial to follow-up these patients periodically, but there is limited evidence.
Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is a noticeable and measureable deterioration in cognitive abilities, for example, memory, speech, language, judgment, reasoning, planning and other thinking abilities. Importantly, the individual’s ability to carry out everyday activities independently is unaffected, in contrast with dementia, where activities of daily living must be affected in order to make a diagnosis. Patients often self-present and can be particularly troubled by their symptoms.
Sixty-percent of people with MCI develop dementia over 10 years. Identifying MCI allows the clinician to establish a cognitive baseline, highlight risk in medical records and monitor if necessary. It may be appropriate to prompt the patient to identify a proxy decision maker or give someone close to them power of attorney, and think about advanced decisions, such as a statement of wishes and preferences or advance directive for refusal of treatment (Robinson, Tang, & Taylor, 2015).
Differential diagnosis
One meta-analysis reported that 9% of people with dementia-like symptoms did not have dementia, but rather had other conditions which were potentially reversible (Clarfield, 2003). The extent to which these are truly reversible is unclear, but early recognition and treatment of reversible causes of dementia will at best lead to an improvement in cognition and at worst lead to a timely diagnosis of dementia.
Differential diagnosis of cognitive disturbance.
The relationship between depression and cognitive impairment is complicated. Depression can present like dementia and cognitive impairment may be a presenting symptom of depression - so-called pseudo-dementia. Depression may also be an early manifestation of cognitive impairment (Geda et al., 2008). It is important to identify those with mood and behavioural changes, as they may warrant closer follow-up. Typically, those with depression may have subjective memory complaints greater than the objective findings and vice versa for those with dementia. In patients with suspected pseudo-dementia it can be prudent to offer a trial of antidepressants and repeat cognitive testing to elicit any improvement.
Investigations to consider in patients presenting with cognitive impairment.
Making a diagnosis
The diagnostic process in primary care.
When taking the history, effects on activities of daily living and specific cognitive deficits should be explored. It is important to identify relevant risk factors, particularly vascular risk factors. A brief past medical history, family history and psychiatric history should be obtained. Examination should include a neurological examination looking for localising deficits or parkinsonism. Stigmata of liver disease, autoimmune disease and vascular insufficiency should be identified.
Brief cognitive assessment tools.
Adapted from Yokomizo, Simon, and Bottino (2014).
Referral to specialist memory assessment services is often indicated, particularly in cases where the diagnosis is unclear, or where the dementia subtype needs to be identified in order to inform management. These services should be provided by designated clinics or local mental health teams, and should offer assessment, diagnosis, therapeutic and rehabilitation services for the patient and their families by coordinating services from health, social and voluntary organisations (NICE, 2006).
It is not considered appropriate to screen populations for dementia and there is a lack of consensus on the value of case-finding. Nevertheless, patients with symptoms in-keeping with cognitive impairment should be investigated appropriately. Evidence suggests that despite the distress of the initial diagnosis, most people prefer to know if they have dementia (Robinson et al., 2015).
Management
Challenges to diagnosing dementia in primary care include a lack of clinician confidence and time, and belief by clinicians that there are limited treatments and interventions available (Harmand et al., 2017). However, there are several recommendations for management of the disease, and there has been some success with pharmacological agents which can be initiated under the guidance of a specialist (NICE, 2016).
There are non-pharmacological options available, particularly for behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD), such as aromatherapy, multisensory stimulation, the therapeutic use of music or dancing, animal-assisted therapy and massage. Avoidance or limitation of alcohol should be recommended, due to the exacerbating effects on cognitive impairment, particularly in the evening as it has an adverse effect on sleep.
Cholinesterase inhibitors, such as donepezil, rivastigmine and galantamine, have shown modest symptomatic benefit in Alzheimer’s disease, vascular dementia, mixed dementia, DLB and Parkinson’s disease. These are only recommended for the period in which they provide observable symptomatic relief.
The N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist memantine is thought to be neuroprotective, and to have modest disease-modifying benefits in those with moderate-to-severe Alzheimer’s disease.
There is evidence that treating vascular risk factors can slow cognitive decline.
Several therapies are still under investigation and in early use, such as vitamin E and other supplements. Antipsychotics should only be considered for severe BPSD, as they increase the risk of cerebrovascular events and cause severe adverse reactions in DLB, such as worsening of extrapyramidal features or acute, severe physical deterioration.
The priorities in primary care are to explore the psychosocial aspects of the disease, including driving, financial capacity, signposting for vulnerable adults such as those who live alone, or those at risk to themselves through wandering or displaying challenging behaviours. Support and practical advice is available through third sector services, such as Age UK and the Alzheimer’s Society. These also provide support for carers, who should be identified and monitored for carer burden and physical health complaints. Advanced care planning is essential while patients still have the capacity to express their wishes about limitations of treatment and end of life plans, with the Gold Standards Framework, an important tool for this purpose (Thomas, Stobbart Rowlands, Foulger , & National GSF Centre in End of Life Care UK, 2017).
KEY POINTS
Dementia is a rapidly growing problem with a prompt diagnosis allowing early intervention, thus empowering the patient to engage in advanced care planning while they still maintain mental capacity GPs play an important role in identifying those at risk of dementia and those with signs of cognitive impairment Numerous cognitive screening tools are available to objectively measure cognitive functioning The diagnosis of dementia should be formed through several interactions over a period of time and include collateral information about their premorbid and morbid functioning Several simple investigations can be performed in primary care to rule out reversible causes of dementia-like symptoms GPs, voluntary services and allied professionals can help patients with dementia to live well by effectively managing comorbidities, troubling symptoms, social aspects and BPSD
