The gut in later life

The GP curriculum and the gut in later life

Clinical module 3.13: Digestive health lists learning objectives required for GPs to manage digestive health in the community. In particular, GPs are expected to be able to:

Provide the primary management of patients who have a digestive problem

Clinical module 3.05: Care of older adults lists learning objectives for GPs required to manage the health of older people including:

An understanding of the physical factors, particularly diet, exercise, ambient temperature and sleep, that disproportionately affect the health of older people

Older people have habits based on a lot of gastrointestinal experience

Ask a 20-year-old about their bowels and, unless they are one of the unlucky ones with a specific condition, most will look at you with a degree of laissez-faire. They take their gastrointestinal (GI) function for granted, just like so many other aspects of their health. However, later in life when most people have weathered the misery of heartburn, gastroenteritis, constipation and all the other common problems, and really earned their toileting stripes, they tend to know what suits them. Most have a personal habit that they like to stick to: they know what they can or cannot eat, what stirs up their dyspepsia, what makes them loose or constipated. Personal habits are just that – individual and sometimes right across the spectrum of normal. I frequently hear things that make me raise an eyebrow. However, interfere with them at your peril. Although they do not always have a detailed knowledge about GI physiology, older people know their own gut, which is the best grounding for self-management even if it needs a little extra support when things go haywire. So, any consultation on a gut topic must revolve around the patient’s own perspective, values and goals if an effective management plan is to be achieved.

Age alone is rarely an issue before the ninth decade

Understanding clearly definable changes in physiology with age is fundamental to an appreciation of the problems that can develop. However, the question of what can be ascribed to ‘normal ageing’ and what is pathological is often a topic of debate. Nevertheless, in recent years evidence has accumulated to reassure us that GI physiology remains fairly reliable until well into the ninth decade of life (Hall, 2002).

There is little difference, for example, between a 20-year-old and an 80-year-old in terms of quantity and quality of biliary, pancreatic, and intestinal secretions, the absorptive capacity of the small intestine, and general nutritional requirements for height and weight (although there may be increased emphasis on certain nutrients, e.g. the amount of protein intake in the diet required to counteract sarcopenia).

Despite this, numerous age-related changes within the gut have been identified. These include, for example, degeneration of the myenteric plexus with loss of myelinated and unmyelinated nerve fibres, abnormal remyelination, and more widespread axonal atrophy (Hall, 2002). As a result, nerve conduction velocity declines, and autonomic responses are reduced. Meanwhile changes in nitric oxide and neuronal calcium regulation in local control of motility by the myenteric plexus affect smooth muscle contraction (Gomes et al., 1997). Animal models suggest that prolonged, lower-amplitude colonic contractions lead to slower gastric emptying of liquids and decreased faecal transit. However, the significance of many of these changes for healthy older people is not very clear.

Another example of age-related change, which has a more familiar significance, is increased fibrosis within the intestines and an increase in intraluminal colonic pressure, possibly as a result of a shift in the character of contractions from peristaltic to non-peristaltic (Hobson and Roberts, 2004). Along with slowing of colonic transit, these may contribute to an increased tendency to mucosal herniation, explaining the steady increase in diverticulosis with age. Is this considered normal ageing or pathology? This is debatable, and perhaps what matters most is how much the changes affect an individual. Fortunately, most people have considerable functional reserve, which means that these physiological changes tend to have little impact. Up to two thirds of people over 80 years in age have diverticulosis but only 1 in 4 of these will develop problems (Hall, 2002). However, in more extreme old age (sometimes described as the ‘oldest-old’, aged 85 years and above) physiological changes may be far more pronounced and more likely to disrupt function (Evans et al., 1998).

Even before food enters the mouth there may be hurdles to overcome

The daily process of thinking about, selecting and preparing food can become a significant challenge, especially for the oldest old. Declines in taste, smell, and appetite mean that food intake often drops with ageing (Boyce and Shone, 2006). More than 75% of people over the age of 80 years have evidence of major olfactory impairment.

Older people tend to be consistently less hungry than younger people, eat smaller meals, and have fewer snacks between meals and eat more slowly (Chapman, 2004). Between 20 and 80 years in age, there is on average, a decrease in energy intake of approximately 30%. This can lead to weight loss, which is not just unwanted adipose tissue but lean skeletal muscle – a condition called sarcopenia. The loss of lean tissue is associated with reductions in muscle function, bone mass and cognitive function, anaemia, dysfunction of the immune system, slow wound healing and recovery from surgery, and consequentially an increase in both morbidity and mortality (Nowson, 2007).

Add in common problems, such as reduced mobility (not only to get out to the shops, but also even just along to the kitchen to make a meal) or cognitive issues (which interfere with the sequential processing needed to pull together a meal) and the intake of nutrients and energy may become very unreliable. Home visits often reveal a haphazard diet of easy access food – biscuits and whiskey seems to be one common combination in the affluent villages of Surrey, in my experience. Even when families do their best to stock up the freezer with meals that can be reheated, these often go unused, especially if the person is left on their own to sort out meals, rather than sharing food with a friend or relative. Its no good just asking someone how well he or she is eating – you need to root around for evidence. Our occupational therapists (OTs) on their home visits frequently discover fridges and freezers stuffed with out-of-date food, or crates of empty beer bottles.

Solutions range from lunch clubs to add a social meaning to food, to flavour enhancement or using supplements such as salt or monosodium glutamate to an improve food palatability (shown to improve immune status as determined by T- and B-cell levels and improve grip strength (Schiffman and Warwick, 1993)). However, to find an effective plan you will need to know your patient – some will embrace a lunch club whereas others will reel in horror.

Some parts of the GI tract age worse than others

The areas at greatest risk of ageing-related dysfunction are the upper GI tract, particularly the oropharynx and oesophagus, and the distal tract (colon and rectum). After midlife, swallowing and defaecation are, in practical terms, the two functions most likely to be affected.

… to issues at the bottom end of the GI tract

The list of lower GI problems that become more common in later life is lengthy and includes: constipation, diverticular disease, haemorrhoids, anal fissures, colonic polyps and cancer, volvulus, ileus, and ischaemic colitis.

Less than 1% of people in the UK report fewer than three bowel movements per week (the Rome criteria for constipation) although a recent review exploring prevalence worldwide suggested a median frequency of constipation in 16% of the adult population (Mugie et al., 2011). However, among the oldest-old constipation is almost normal, affecting nearly 1-in-2 people aged over 80 years (Gandell et al., 2013).

Many theories have been proposed to explain constipation from an older perspective, from dietary changes to autonomic neuropathy, and disorders of both the enteric nervous system and neuroendocrine system. The ability of the bowel to empty may be hampered by an increased thickness of the internal anal sphincter (possibly in compensation for age-related thinning of the external anal sphincter) and a reduction in rectal pressure maximal squeeze pressure (Hall, 2002). Pelvic floor laxity also plays a part, especially in women.

Loss of faecal continence is a significant cause of distress in late life, and is associated with increasing age, long-term illness, mobility problems, GI disease including several of those described below as causes of diarrhoea, and urinary incontinence. A postal survey in the UK of around 16 000 over-40-year-olds showed about 6% of responders had some leakage, whereas major leakage (several times a month and soiling) troubled 1.4%, and disabling faecal incontinence affected 0.7% (Perry et al., 2002). However, in my experience among older patients, it is a topic people find hard to raise. Sometimes it is easier to gauge the extent of the problem by talking to the person who does the laundry than the patients themselves.

There is also a significant change in the gut microbiota in later life, with reduced diversity of organisms, and carriage of certain important commensal species such as bacteroides, bifidobacteria and lactobacilli, while opportunistic pathogens including enterobacteria, Clostridium perfringens and Clostridium difficile are increased in elderly people (Nagpal et al., 2018). The full implications of these changes have yet to be established, but they are likely to play an important part in the development of disease and frailty. As such, approaches that encourage a healthy gut microbiota, such as a very varied diet incorporating many unprocessed foods and prebiotic fibres may play a role in preventing problems ranging from constipation to infection and cognitive decline. We eagerly await the results of research.

However, in later life the GI tract is often not to blame for constipation

Despite efforts to explain constipation as a failure of the GI system, contributing factors unrelated to the physiology of the bowel itself are often to blame in older people. These may include changes in diet, especially a decrease in fibre intake, reduced fluid intake, diminished activity, impaired mobility (most bedridden patients are constipated and need proactive management), social factors, anxiety and depression, and especially medication, e.g. opiates; drugs with anticholinergic side effects such as neuroleptics, antihistamines; medications for Parkinson’s disease; tricyclic antidepressants; and drugs that impair calcium signalling, such as calcium channel antagonists. Attending to this soup of problems may do more for constipation than trying medication that tinkers with the gut itself.

Meanwhile patients themselves often have the possibility of a cancer at the back of their mind when discussing GI symptoms, even if they do not verbalise this fear. Although this is an important consideration that needs to be explored, initial care to discuss all the other possible contributing factors and, if indicated and the patient agrees, trying strategies such as dietary change may be better than jumping straight to referral to secondary care on the 2-week rule. Timely follow-up is critical though when there is a risk of malignancy.

…and diarrhoea is not so often due to infection

While considering causative factors, it is also important to remember that loose motions or diarrhoea is much less likely to be caused by infection than in younger adults. Diarrhoea may be secretory (actually mostly due to reduced fluid and electrolyte reabsorption than net secretion by gut, due to inhibition of reabsorption, rapid motility, bile acid malabsorption, microscopic colitis or drugs), osmotic, inflammatory, fatty (steatorrhoea) or pseudo-diarrhoea. Acute symptoms versus more chronic ones may be a clue, so after a check for an acute gastroenteritis or food poisoning, scrutinise medications, think motility disorders, diabetic neuropathy, irritable bowel syndrome, small bowel bacterial overgrowth, overflow constipation (which we see frequently in the hospital) endocrine problems (such as hyperthyroidism or Addison’s disease), cancers (including carcinoid), and vasculitis. Microscopic colitis encompassing collagenous colitis and lymphocytic colitis is increasingly recognised as a common cause of chronic diarrhea, especially in older women. Even so, older people do get gastroenteritis and although the usual pathogens are found, the risk of hospitalisation is four times higher than average for individuals aged over 75 years.

Among older people in residential or nursing homes, infectious causes become more significant, Bear in mind C.difficile infection, which is more common and spread more easily in an institutional setting (relapses are also more common in the elderly).

Symptoms in older people may be atypical or absent

A common mantra in working with older people is that the textbook symptoms and signs of many conditions may not be seen. The often-used example is fever and infection. The inflammatory response to sepsis may be very weak, and pyrexia absent, despite major infection. There may be a significant diminution of the acute response to GI inflammation and/or perforation. Increased confusion and fatigue may be the only signs of peritonitis, with traditional signs such as guarding or rigidity being absent. As a result, up to two thirds of initial emergency diagnoses of abdominal problems in this age group are found subsequently to be incorrect (Hall, 2002).

There are many other situations where textbook symptoms and signs cannot be found. Red flags are just as vital to spot in older adults, but often the flag may just be a tinge of pink, or not even waving.

Other conditions increasingly throw spanners into the creaking works

The shopping basket of co-morbidities we collect with age frequently add to the burden of GI problems, compound the physiological changes related to ageing, and drug treatments then have further consequences (see the next point). In the UK, around 50% of those over 65 years have two or more long-term conditions, and many of these can impact on GI function.

Careful thinking around co-morbidities and analysis of root causes of symptoms is vital in effective management. A myriad of diseases can impair smell and taste for example, including Alzheimer’s disease (which also reduces thirst or simply the motivation to eat or drink), epilepsy, head trauma, Parkinson’s disease (where olfactory impairment is increasingly recognised as an early symptom), cancer and its treatment, sinusitis, nasal polyps, hypothyroidism, diabetes and many other endocrine problems.

Bowel diaries can be extremely useful to pinpoint complex interactions, but often the issue is simple. For example, osteoarthritis may limit mobility and restrict a person’s ability to respond to the call to the toilet. Treating pain and stiffness effectively may be the key to improving incontinence (although of course, opiate painkillers often bring their own GI hazards).

However, teasing out the underlying causes of GI symptoms, and how they should be managed, is complex. Problems are often dynamic, fluctuating in time and with the state of other co-morbidities, and rarely answered by a single strategy.

And medicines, drugs, tablets and tinctures add grit to the grind

A patient’s list of medication can quickly grow with passing years, and it is not unusual on our wards to admit older people who are on as many as 25 different drugs, that result in dozens of daily doses. Many drugs have significant GI side effects, often more pronounced in older people. Some examples are shown in Table 1. Fortunately, many drug-induced effects will regress or heal on cessation of treatment.

OPEN IN VIEWER

Table 1.

Some examples of common GI side effects from medication.

Drug	Side effect
• NSAIDs	• Peptic ulcers • Lichen planus in the mouth • Oesophageal inflammation and strictures • Small bowel/colonic ulcers and strictures • Acute diarrhea • Microscopic colitis • Acute pancreatitis
• Alendronate	• Oesophageal ulcers
• Calcium antagonists	• Gum hyperplasia
• Antibiotics	• Pseudomembranous colitis (C.difficile colitis)
• Furosemide • Sodium valproate	• Acute pancreatitis
• Serotonin antagonists	• Ischaemic colitis
• Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) • Antacids • Antiarrhythmics • Antihypertensives • Colchicine • Vitamin and mineral supplements • Stimulant laxatives	• Secretory diarrhoea

The STOPP START Tool (Gallagher et al., 2008) is a very useful medication review tool designed for use in older patients to help identify where the risks of a certain medication outweighs the benefits (and vice versa). STOPP screens out inappropriate medicines whereas START indicates medicines that should be considered for people over 65 years in age. Boxes 1 and 2 give some examples from the STOPP START Tool.

OPEN IN VIEWER

Box 1.

Examples of when to consider stopping particular medication being used for GI disease in older patients.

STOP

Metoclopramide and prochlorperazine

• With parkinsonism (risk of exacerbating symptoms)

• After maximum treatment time of 5 days (metoclopramide)

Domperidone

• For treatment other than nausea and vomiting

• After maximum treatment time of a week

• In patients with serious underlying heart conditions

• If receiving other medications known to prolong the QT intervals or potent CYP3A4 inhibitors

PPIs

• When used for uncomplicated peptic ulcer disease at full therapeutic dosage after 1–2 months. Offer low-dose maintenance treatment if the patient chooses, or use on an as required basis. Review at least annually

Medication likely to cause constipation

• Examples include anticholinergic drugs, oral iron, opioids, aluminium antacids in patients with chronic constipation where non-constipating alternatives are available

If there is diarrhoea of an unknown cause and the possibility of C.difficile infection is suspected: STOP

• Motility drugs

• Antibiotics if appropriate

• PPI use if unnecessary

In dyspepsia or reflux, encourage the patient to stop known precipitants such as:

• Smoking

• Alcohol

• Coffee

• Chocolate

• Fatty foods

Source: Gallagher et al. (2008)

OPEN IN VIEWER

Box 2.

Examples of advice about what to consider starting in the management of GI disease in those over 65 years in age.

Start

A PPI or alternative gastric protection

• In severe oesophagitis or stricture requiring dilation, at full dose, long term (initial 8 weeks and review)

• For those on medication with a risk of GI bleeding such as antiplatelet therapy, steroids, NSAIDs, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, venlafaxine

Fibre supplements (e.g. bran, ispaghula)

• For diverticulosis when there is a history of constipation

Encourage patient to start lifestyle modification (e.g. healthy eating, weight reduction)

• In reflux or dyspepsia

Source: Gallagher et al. (2008).

KEY POINTS

In the absence of GI disease, GI physiology can remain fairly predictable until well into the ninth decade of life; however, many common co-morbidities interfere with GI function much earlier