Abstract
In 1990, the World Health Organisation (WHO) recognised palliative care as a distinct specialty dedicated to relieving suffering and improving quality of life for patients with life-limiting illnesses or serious injuries. Fourteen years later, the WHO in its publication ‘Global Atlas of Palliative Care at the End of Life’, projected that, ‘each year in the world, around 377 per 100,000 of the adult (over 15 years of age) population and 63 per 100,000 of the child population (under 15 years of age) will require “palliative care at the end of life’. This article will discuss what constitutes palliative care, the different elements of palliative care, the approaches to palliative care, specialist palliative care services, end of life care and where GPs fit into this area. We will also be sharing tips on providing palliative care as a GP and for GP trainees.
Clinical case scenario
Mr John Glen has requested a home visit because he is unable to cope with his back pain. He understands that his cancer has spread, is incurable and that his pain is caused by spinal metastases. He has gone through the ReSPECT form which reveals: ‘a preference for comfort over life-sustaining treatment and not for CPR’. His preferred place of care is his home. He currently lives with his wife who is also his primary carer.
The summary record reveals that John is 50 years old with a history of prostate cancer, spinal metastases, coronary artery disease and hypertension. His medication includes amlodipine, aspirin, atorvastatin, opiate analgesia, bulk laxatives and cyclizine.
Origins: From there to here
‘Notes on Nursing’, a compilation of Florence Nightingale’s notes published in 1859, affirms what we now know for a fact that ‘suffering extends beyond the physical effects of illness and that nursing can reduce suffering without treating the disease’. Palliative care in its present form owes its origins to Dame Cicely Saunders, who founded St. Christopher’s Hospice in London in 1967. Others who contributed to present day palliative care include Douglas Macmillan who founded the Society for the Prevention and Relief of Cancer (now better known as the Macmillan Cancer Support) and the founders of Marie Curie Cancer Care, a charity dedicated to alleviating suffering from cancer.
Dame Cicely Saunders brought medicine back to one of its fundamental positions, that the whole patient is the concern of the doctor and not just the illness. She established in her research that morphine given to patients with cancer pain posed no risk of addiction and achieved excellent control of pain in the majority of patients. The concept of palliative care, which Dame Cicely started, has now evolved beyond the singular concept of care for only the dying to include patients and their families, during illness and after death.
The International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care defines palliative care as: the active holistic care of individuals across all ages with serious health-related suffering due to severe illness, and especially of those near the end of life. It aims to improve the quality of life of patients, their families and their caregivers.
Attributes of palliative care.
Types of palliative care
Palliative medicine was recognised as a stand-alone specialty in the UK in 1987, and since then has built up a considerable amount of evidence locally and internationally to support the practice of palliative care. As palliative medicine offers individualised practice there is a recognised role for narrative-based evidence and stories in the practice of palliative care.
Palliative approach
The overall goal of a palliative approach is to improve an individual’s quality of life and reduce suffering. It is integral and fundamental to all good clinical care regardless of stage of illness.
Specialist palliative care
Specialist palliative care is care provided by specialised services – with professionals trained in and dedicated exclusively to palliative care – for patients with complex problems not adequately covered by other treatment options. This is needed when the patient’s care needs expand beyond the scope of the primary care team.
Primary palliative care
Primary palliative care can be defined as (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2005): the clinical management and care coordination including assessment, triage, and referral using a palliative approach for patients with uncomplicated needs associated with a life limiting illness and/or end of life care. Has formal links with a specialist palliative care provider for purposes of referral, consultation and access to specialist care as necessary
Supportive care
Supportive care was developed in oncology to describe non-chemotherapeutic palliation for those with cancer. It is not the same as palliative care, but palliative care is an essential part of it. Although developed in oncology, it has been found to be helpful in managing diseases other than oncology.
Hospice care
In the UK, ‘hospice’ usually refers to inpatient palliative care units, dedicated to those with advanced illness. They also deliver complex symptom control and psycho-social care, as well as care in the last days of life, and (sometimes) respite care.
Care in the last days of life
Care in the last days of life deals with the type of care that patients and their families receive when they are near death or are dying. It is the specific application of palliative care interventions in the last hours /days/weeks of life.
Components of an ideal specialist palliative care programme
To ensure that the palliative needs of patients are met in their different locations and at the times when it is needed each locality needs:
A hospital-based palliative care consultation service A daycare service and/or specialist palliative care ambulatory clinic A palliative care in-patient unit or dedicated palliative care hospital beds A bereavement programme Training for both specialist palliative care professionals and professionals who do not specialise in palliative care, such as GPs and district/community nurses Research to support palliative care development and innovation
Over the years, the need for palliative care has been rising steadily and has not been adequately met. Due to slow policy development and insufficient resources, there has been an increasing push to include palliative care in national policies to increase access, resources, and delivery. The national End of Life Care Strategy in 2008 was one of the first national strategy statements in the UK extended to end of life care.
In 2015, the UK was ranked number 1 in the Economic Intelligence Unit’s Quality of Death ranking. This was based on the UK’s ‘comprehensive national policies, the extensive integration of palliative care into the National Health Service, and a strong hospice movement’.
As of 2015 the UK had:
223 hospice and adult palliative care in-patient units 3200 hospice and palliative care beds 291 home care services 129 hospice-at-home services 275 daycare centres 346 hospital support services 43 children hospice in-patient units with 338 hospice beds
Who needs palliative care?
Requirements for the palliative care provider.
The palliative care team
The palliative care team is made up of both general and specialist care professionals. The general care professionals include, but are not limited to:
The GP The district or community nurses Social workers Care workers Spiritual care professionals
They will refer to the specialist team if the need arises. Getting to know your local specialist palliative care professionals is invaluable, as a phone call or conversation can often address any issues quickly.
The specialist care professionals include:
Palliative care doctors Nurses and nurse specialists Counsellors and psychologists Specialist health professionals, such as physiotherapists, occupational therapists, dieticians, social workers and chaplains
Symptom management in palliative care
Common symptoms in palliative care.
The syringe driver is a battery-powered pump that delivers a continuous dose of medication subcutaneously over 24 hours. It is used extensively in palliative care to achieve optimal symptom control, especially towards end of life; however, they are used at other stages as well. The syringe driver is most commonly used in the following symptoms:
Pain Feeling sick and vomiting Seizures (fits) Agitation Excess respiratory secretions Breathlessness
Indications for the use of a syringe driver.
Pain
Pain can be intractable and will vary depending on site, cause and type of pain. Understanding these different characteristics of pain makes it easier to manage. It is important to recognise each pain; most cancer patients, for example, will have more than one type of pain, and each needs assessing separately if symptom control is to be effective. The WHO analgesic ladder is a great resource in deciding which analgesic, at what time and when to escalate treatment appropriately.
Nausea and vomiting
Nausea and vomiting are more often associated with cancer and its treatment modalities, but are also seen in other diseases especially towards the end of life. The aetiology of nausea varies greatly, so knowing the cause will help the choice of effective treatments. Possible causes of nausea and vomiting include medication side effects, infection, dysmotility, brain metastases and hypercalcemia. It is also known that constipation exacerbates nausea and vomiting.
Constipation
Constipation is a common presentation, especially in elderly patients, so prevention is always the best strategy, e.g. prescribing laxatives for individuals on opioids. Constipation can be caused by:
Reduced eating and drinking Impaired/ reduced mobility Drugs that impair gut motility including opioids Complicating medical conditions e.g. haemorrhoids
A rectal examination should always be performed to rule out faecal impaction, which can cause urinary retention. It is important to address rectal loading by using rectal interventions such as suppositories and enemas, and to start laxatives to prevent a recurrence of the constipation. As a general measure, bulk-forming fibre agents have little role in palliative care, due to their tendency to be difficult to take when fluid intake is reduced.
Dyspnoea
Dyspnoea is a subjective feeling of breathing discomfort; it is common to those illnesses with an underlying primary or secondary respiratory component. The aetiology is usually multifactorial, but any underlying reversible cause should be sought and treated. Common causes include infection, malignancy, fluid overload, pleural effusion, anxiety, and muscle weakness. Treatment should adopt the Breathing, Thinking, Functioning (BTF) approach, if the patient is well enough to understand and work with this. The BTF approach is based on three predominant cognitive and behavioural reactions to breathlessness that, by causing a vicious cycle, can maintain and worsen the symptom, irrespective of the underlying disease that triggered the breathlessness initially
The vicious cycle is made up of:
Breathing: Increased respiratory rate, inappropriate accessory muscle use and dynamic hyperinflation, which can lead to inefficient breathing, and increased work of breathing Thinking: Attention to the sensation of breathlessness, memories of past experiences, misconceptions and thoughts about dying. This can lead to anxiety, feelings of panic, frustration, anger and low mood Functioning: Reduced activity, social isolation and reliance on help, which can lead to cardiovascular and muscular deconditioning
By engaging patients, this approach aims to turn these vicious cycles that can lead to breathlessness into cycles of improvement.
In latter stages of illness, pharmaceutical management is the main option.
Eating problems
Eating problems are seen in people with swallowing difficulties, including patients with stroke, dementia, Parkinson’s disease, head and neck malignancies, oesophageal or gastric cancers or other conditions that affect swallowing. In this situation treatment is usually with enteral feeding either through a nasogastric/jejunal tube or percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy, radiologically inserted gastrostomy tube.
Agitation/restlessness
Agitation is a poorly defined, but well recognised, symptom of dying. It has a multifactorial cause and the choice of medication depends on other symptoms described. Common causes include drugs, cerebral pathology, infection and constipation, among others.
The role of the GP
Primary care physicians have an important role to play in the palliative care of patients in the community. In secondary care the patient’s prognosis has usually been discussed with the patient, if appropriate. Knowing the prognosis helps patients to plan appropriately for their treatment and possible death (Gold Standard Framework, 2011). The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) advocates the use of a prognostic indicator guideline. The guideline is part of the Gold Standards Framework and aims to optimise the care of people nearing the end of life and cared for in the community. It includes asking the question ‘Would you be surprised if this patient were to die in the next 6 to 12 months?'
The task of communicating prognosis accurately to patients and their families without giving false hope or mixed information can be very challenging and this can harm the doctor–patient relationship (Ngo-Metzger et al., 2008). Hence, it is worth mentioning that there are risks associated with assessing prognosis. It is therefore important to emphasise to patients and their families that an estimate of prognosis is not a guarantee of future outcomes. Some of these risks include overestimating or underestimating the length of survival. It is often better to sensitively explore the patient’s own understanding and wish to know these details. Many have their own sense of how their illness is changing, and what time might be left. Some do not want to know the details. It is important to avoid a fixed prognosis that is almost invariably wrong. In general, talking in terms of ‘days’, ‘weeks’ or ‘months’ (as appropriate) is a better approach, saying ‘short days’ or ‘short weeks’ etc. if you want to communicate a shorter time.
Since palliative care involves medical treatment and the holistic management of patients (Watson et al., 2019), NICE has outlined different areas that physicians should address to achieve the aim of holistic care (NICE, 2020). The psycho-social aspect of palliative care is important. The majority of patients receiving palliative care services has a diagnosis of cancer, and up to one-third of these patients suffers some form of psychological distress, and those with non-cancer conditions also often need emotional support.
The prevalence of distress rises by 50% in patients with end-stage cancers and in the year after diagnosis, 10% of people have symptoms that require specialist intervention by psychiatric or psychology services (Hotopf et al., 2002; NICE, 2004). Hence, NICE has strongly recommended that physicians look out for symptoms that may indicate some form of psychological distress in patients during the time of diagnosis, around treatment episodes, as treatments end, at the time of a relapse, and when death is approaching. Clinicians should refer patients or their carers to specialist psychological care services if they have significant levels of psychological distress. Tools such as the hospital anxiety depression scale, patient health questionnaire, Beck depression inventory or simply asking the patient if they are depressed can all be used.
Another important aspect of palliative care is addressing patients’ and carers’ social needs. Assessing what social needs can be difficult at the initial stage, as patients may not know early on in their journey what support they may eventually require. It is left for the physicians to help patients identify and address these needs. NICE encourages offering patients and their carers informed professional assistance to obtain benefits for which they are eligible. It is also important to mention that they can obtain help with, for example, respite or day-care, support groups, volunteer visitors, assisted transport and bereavement care (from local authorities, NHS, or a non-governmental organisation such as Cruse).
Resources for healthcare professionals.
End of life care
End of life care is support for people in the last days/weeks/months of life. To diagnose that a person is approaching the last few days of life is challenging and often hampered by co-morbidities and chronic illnesses making prediction of disease trajectory difficult. This is why excellent communication and shared decision making are so important in the care of patients.
Good communication and open discussion enables patients to express their preferences for type of care and place of care, for example. Advance care planning aims to achieve an understanding, encapsulated in a document that clearly frames the patient’s priorities and wishes for future care and treatment, particularly apt in advance of the deterioration in a patient’s condition preventing clear communication of wants and wishes. Examples of advance care planning documents include:
Advance statements
Advance statements are not legally binding, but should be considered carefully when future decisions are being made. They can include any information the person considers important to their health and care.
Lasting power of attorney
A lasting power of attorney involves giving one or more people legal authority to make decisions about health and welfare. There is a separate lasting power of attorney that covers property and finances.
Advance decisions
Advance decisions concern decisions to refuse specific medical treatments and are legally binding. Too often the approach in these discussions is focused more on what not to do e.g. avoiding resuscitation and neglect rather than what needs to be done actively to support patients and families through the end of life process. Ideally advance care planning should happen in the earlier stages of the disease, the Mental Capacity Act provides a legal framework for this process in the United Kingdom.
Anticipatory prescribing/just-in-case medications
Anticipatory medications are ‘medication prescribed in anticipation of symptoms, (they are) designed to enable rapid relief at whatever time the patient develops distressing symptoms’ (NICE 2017). The approach to just-in-case medications are individualised, but there are certain common symptoms that can be anticipated in a dying patient. These include: agitation, nausea/vomiting, pain and increased respiratory secretions. Commonly prescribed drugs include morphine, midazolam, hyoscine butyl bromide and levomepromazine. The drugs are prescribed either by the hospital doctor, specialist nurse or GP after reviewing the patient’s illness and symptoms. In the community, the prescription is made on a community drug chart stating the dose, route, frequency, indication(s), limits, and when to seek advice.
The Gold Standards Framework
The Gold Standards Framework (GSF) is an evidence-based approach to optimise the care of patients nearing the end of life in the community, see Fig. 1. It was developed in 2001 based on experiences in primary care and is aimed at improving collaboration between primary palliative care and specialist care. In 2004, the programme was adapted for use in care homes and is now the largest UK programme undertaken to improve end of life care in care homes. The key tasks of the framework are captured in the 7 C’s: Communication, co-ordination, control of symptoms, continuity including out of hours, continued learning, carer support and care in the dying phase
The Gold Standard Framework.
The GSF in care homes is aimed at:
Improving the quality of care for people nearing the end of life in care homes Improving collaboration between care homes, GPs/primary care teams and specialist palliative care teams Reducing the number of admissions to hospital in the last stages of life and enable more to die in the care home.
Preferred priorities for care
Developed by the Lancashire and South Cumbria cancer services network and formerly called Preferred Place of Care (PPC), it is a patient record designed to facilitate patient choice in relation to end of life issues. It records a patient’s preferences with respect to different aspects of care including preferred place of care and death.
It is now a nationally recognised tool for all palliative care patients as recommended by NICE in its guidance on supportive and palliative care for adults with cancer (NICE, 2004). As with other tools the PPC also records the available services and reasons for any changes in the care pathway.
Recommended summary plan for emergency care and treatment (ReSPECT)
Popularly known as the ReSPECT form, this was developed to replace the DNACPR (Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation) form as it was found to have limitations that led to misunderstandings and miscommunication between patients and healthcare personnel. The ReSPECT form, when used correctly, can provide an individualised shared plan between the clinician and the patient, and covers treatments that may or may not be necessary when the patient deteriorates or is not in a position to make a clear treatment choice. It also helps first responders to determine which treatments are necessary and which are not. It can be complementary to a wider process of advance/anticipatory care planning. The ReSPECT process can be for anyone but will have increasing relevance for people who have complex health needs, people who are likely to be nearing the end of their lives, and people who are at risk of sudden deterioration or cardiac arrest. Some people will want to record their care and treatment preferences for other reasons” (Resuscitation Council UK).
Conclusion
Palliative care should be part and parcel of holistic medicine, which involves looking after the whole individual and not just the individual’s disease. In most, if not all, aspects of healthcare, healthcare practitioners will have contact with patients nearing the end of life or with advanced disease. Good care of these patients requires professional competence and acquiring the necessary knowledge and skills is of paramount importance for GPs. Each person is more than the sum of their illnesses.
So, open your eyes, nurse
Open and see,
Not a crabbit old woman,
Look close - See ME
Phyllis McCormack, Crabbit Old Woman, 1966.
KEY POINTS
Palliative care is a key competence for healthcare professionals Palliative care is much more than the care of the dying The GP is an essential part of the community palliative care team Shared decision making is of utmost importance in having conversations about palliative care, advanced care planning etc. Palliative care can go on synchronously with active treatment Knowledge, skills and the right attitude will make you relevant to patients needing palliative care
