The easy availability of deadly poisons in 19th-century Britain, Western Europe, and the United States led to widespread public anxiety about the prevalence of murder by poison, resulting in what might be termed a “poison panic.” The fear was fed by well-publicized reports of trials and executions which, though not especially numerous, seemed indicative of the dangerous incidence of a unique type of homicide, one that was particularly difficult to prevent or detect. As a result, poisoning crimes stimulated the development of the earliest medicolegal specialism, forensic toxicology, and consequently the careers of some of the best known expert witnesses of the Victorian era, including Mathieu Orfila, Alfred Swaine Taylor, Thomas Stevenson, and Theodore Wormley. This article traces the history of poisoning crimes and the related medico-scientific discipline of forensic toxicology using textbooks, key trials, and crime statistics to examine and evaluate their contribution to the historical development of forensic expertise and practice.
FarrS.Elements of medical jurisprudence. London: T. Beckett; 1788. Chapter 6, On homicide; p. 72–114.
2.
DevauxJ. L’art de Faire les Raports en Chirurgie. Laurent D’Houry; 1703. Chapter 18, Des effets des venins pris interieurement, & du jugement qu’on en doit faire; p. 373-406. French.
3.
LofftC, ed. The law of evidence by Lord Chief Baron Gilbert; vol. 1. London: J. F. & C. Rivington, T. Longman, C. Dilly, W. Clarke & Son, and W. Otridge; 1791. Chapter 2, section 4, On the weighing of evidence, p. 294-302.
4.
GriffithsA. Notorious poisoners. In: The History and Romance of Crime: German and Austrian Prisons. The Grolier Society; 1900. 81–105. Chapter 3.
5.
WatsonK. Poisoned Lives: English Poisoners and Their Victims. Hambledon and London; 2004.
6.
Journal of the Assembly of the State of New York at their forty-first session. Albany: J. Buel; 1818. Pp. 25-44, 402-7, 470-1, 473.
7.
Procès Complet d’Edme-Samuel Castaing, Docteur en Médecine. Chez Pillet Ainé; 1823. French.
8.
GeeDJMasonJK. The Courts and the Doctor. The History of the Medical Witness. Oxford University Press; 1990: 14-28 (26). Chapter 2.
9.
CawthonEA. Medicine on Trial: A Sourcebook with Cases, Laws, and Documents. Hackett Publishing; 2004.
10.
BurneyIPembertonN. Murder and the Making of English CSI. Johns Hopkins University Press; 2016.
11.
TrestrailJHIII. Criminal Poisoning: Investigational Guide for Law Enforcement, Toxicologists, Forensic Scientists, and Attorneys. 2nd ed. Humana Press; 2007: p. xiv.
12.
ForbesTR. Surgeons at the Bailey: English Forensic Medicine to 1878. Yale University Press; 1985.
13.
WhortonJC. A penn’orth of poison. In: The Arsenic Century: How Victorian Britain Was Poisoned at Home, Work, & Play. Oxford University Press; 2010: 113-138. Chapter 5.
14.
WatsonKD. Criminal poisoning in England and the origins of the Marsh test for arsenic. In: Bertomeu-SánchezJRNieto-GalanA, eds. Chemistry, Medicine and Crime: Mateu JB. Orfila (1787–1853) and His Times. Science History Publications; 2006: 183–206.
15.
Parliamentary Papers 1850, No.599. Return of number of persons tried in United Kingdom for murder, and attempts to murder, by administration of poison. 1839-49:XLV.447.
16.
Parliamentary Papers 1846, No.207. Return of Murders Committed in England Since1842:XXXIV.773.
17.
Statistics of violent deaths. Wolverhampton Chronicle and Staffordshire Advertiser. 1842 May 4:4(col.7).
18.
Statistics of fatal poisoning. British Med J. 1882 June 10:889.
19.
KerrDJA. Forensic Medicine: A Textbook for Students and a Guide for the Practitioner. 2nd ed. A & C Black; 1936.
20.
MerryKJ. Murder by Poison in Scotland During the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries [Dissertation]. University of Glasgow; 2010.
21.
KildayA-M. Crime in Scotland 1660-1960: The Violent North?Routledge; 2019.
22.
Statistics of poisoning in France. Morning Advertiser. 1835 April 24: 4 (col.1). This article was widely reprinted throughout the United Kingdom.
23.
LacassagneA. De L’empoisonnement. In: Précis de Médecine Légale. Masson & Cie; 1906: p.651-710. Chapter 4. French. English translations are my own.
24.
SeptonMI. Le crime d’empoisonnement selon la statistique judiciaire: essai d’analyse quantitative. In: Les Femmes et le Poison: L’empoisonnement devant les Juridictions Criminelles en Belgique, XIXe Siècle 1795-1914 [Dissertation]. Marquette University; 1996: 123-201. Part 2, chapter 1. French.
25.
MohrJC. Medical jurisprudence and American society, 1820-1850. In: Doctors and the Law: Medical Jurisprudence in Nineteenth-Century America. Johns Hopkins University Press; 1993: 57-75 (66). Chapter 5.
26.
EssigM. Poison murder and expert testimony: doubting the physician in late nineteenth-century America. Yale J Law Human. 2002;14(1):177–210.
27.
PilarczykIC. Family Violence and the Law in Montreal, 1825-1850 [Dissertation]. McGill University; 2003.
28.
WestveerAETrestrailJHIIIPinizzottoAJ. Homicidal poisonings in the United States: an analysis of the uniform crime reports from 1980 through 1989. Am J Forensic Med Path. 1996;17(4):282–288.
29.
Easy Access to the FBI’s Supplementary Homicide Reports: 1980-2016 [Internet]. National Center for Juvenile Justice; 1980. Accessed January 3, 2020. https://www.ojjdp.gov/ojstatbb/ezashr/
30.
CooperASmithEL. Homicide Trends in the United States, 1980-2008. The Bureau of Justice Statistics (US); 2011. Report No.: NCJ 236018.
31.
FarrellM. Healthcare serial poisoning. In: Criminology of Serial Poisoners. Palgrave Macmillan; 2018: 93-114. Chapter 5.
32.
WitthausRA. Manual of Toxicology. 2nd ed. William Wood; 1911: 5-29. Chapter 1, Introduction.
33.
More poisoning with arsenic. The Suffolk Chronicle; or Weekly General Advertiser & County Express; 1854 Aug 19:7 (col.4).
34.
TaylorAS. Poisoning by saline substances. In: On Poisons in Relation to Medical Jurisprudence and Medicine. 3rd ed. J & A Churchill; 1875: 260-274. Chapter 30.
35.
EmsleyJ. The Elements of Murder: A History of Poison. Oxford University Press; 2005.
36.
Daily consular and trade reports. Government Printing Office; 1912. Report No. 220.
37.
Rough on rats. Derbyshire Times and Chesterfield Herald; 1882 Sep 2:3 (col. 6).
MohrJC. The Schoeppe trials and the Wharton case. In: Doctors and the Law: Medical Jurisprudence in Nineteenth-Century America. Johns Hopkins University Press; 1993: 180-196. Chapter 13.
45.
ReeseJJ. A Manual of Toxicology. JB Lippincott; 1874. viii.
46.
ReeseJJ. Text-Book of Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology. P. Blakiston; 1884.
47.
WitthausRA. Toxicology. In: WitthausRABeckerTC, eds. Medical Jurisprudence, Forensic Medicine and Toxicology. Vol. 4. William Wood; 1896.
48.
NiyogiSK. Historic development of forensic toxicology in America up to 1978. Am J Forensic Med Path. 1980;1(3):249–264.
49.
SellersLMWatsonKD. The Construction of Forensic Knowledge in Victorian Yorkshire: Dr. Thomas Scattergood and his Casebooks, 1856-1897. In: AdamA, ed. Crime and the Construction of Forensic Objectivity from 1850. Palgrave Macmillan; 2020:189–210.
50.
WillcoxPHA. The Detective-Physician: The Life and Work of Sir William Willcox. William Heinemann Medical Books; 1970.
51.
AdamA. Forensic science careers and self-images. In: A History of Forensic Science: British Beginnings in the Twentieth Century. Routledge; 2016: 155-183. Chapter 5.
52.
KolarALyallMWillsS. The history and current practice of forensic pathology in the United Kingdom. In: MadeaB, ed. History of Forensic Medicine. Lehmanns Media; 2017:328–354.
53.
OdellR. Medical Detectives: The Lives and Cases of Britain’s Forensic Five. The History Press; 2013.
54.
SmithS. Forensic Medicine: A Text-Book for Students and Practitioners. 8th ed. J & A Churchill; 1943. Preface to the first edition, p. v-vi.
55.
FreimuthHC. Alexander Oscar Gettler 1883-1968. Publication of the Society of Forensic Toxicologists; 1983;7(2):1–2.
56.
Legal medicine in America. British Med J. 1938 April 16:847.
57.
GonzalesTAVanceMHelpernM. Legal Medicine and Toxicology. D. Appleton-Century Company; 1937.
