Self-operated video prompting and video modeling was compared when used by three secondary students with mild intellectual disabilities as they completed novel recipes during cooking activities. Alternating between video systems, students completed twelve recipes within their classroom kitchen. An alternating treatment design with a follow-up and withdrawal probe was used to illustrate the effectiveness of both systems on each student's independent task performance. Results indicated increased independence following video system use by all three students with video modeling more effective for two students and video prompting more effective for the third. Future directions for research are presented.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgranM.BlanchardC.WehmeyerM.HughesC.Increasing the problem-solving skills of students with developmental disabilities participating in general educationRemedial and Special Education23279–2882002
2.
AlbertoP. A.CihakD. F.GamaR. I.Use of static picture prompts versus video modeling during simulation instruction26327–3392005Research in Developmental Disabilities
3.
AlwellM.CobbB.Functional life skills curricular interventions for youth with disabilities. Career Development for Exceptional Individuals3282–932009
4.
AndersonC.CoxsonL.BrittM.Haugen-MclaneJ.MullinsB.Cooking to learn: Integrating reading and writing activitiesPCI Educational PublishingSan Antonio, TX1999
5.
AndersonC.CoxsonL.LamontagneC.ButeynL.ChapmanD.Cooking to learn 3: Recipes from around the worldPCI Educational PublishingSan Antonio, TX2008
6.
Apple Inc. (2010). iMovie (version 8.0.6). Cupertino, CA: Apple Inc.
7.
Arnold-ReidG. S.SchlossP. J.AlperS.Teaching meal planning to youth with mental retardation in natural settingsRemedial and Special Education18166–1731997
8.
BechardS.Students with disabilities and standards-based reform. Policy Brief: Mid-Continent Research for Education and LearningOffice of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education1–82000, Oct.
9.
BelmontJ. M.EllisN. R.Long-term memory in mental retardationInternational review of research in mental retardationAcademicNew York71966
10.
BillingsleyF.SingerG.The problem and place of functional skills in inclusive settingsThe role of functional skills and behavior instructional methods in inclusive education. The Annual Meeting for Persons with Severe HandicapsBoston, MA1997. December
11.
BillingsleyF. F.AlbertsonL. R.Finding a future for functional skillsJournal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps24298–3021999
12.
BlackorbyJ.WagnerM.Longitudinal post school outcomes of youth with disabilities: Findings from the national longitudinal transition studyExceptional Children62399–4131996
13.
BouckE. C.Exploring secondary special education for mild mental impairment: A program in search of its placeRemedial and Special Education25367–3822004
14.
BouckE. C.The state of curriculum for secondary students with mild mental retardation. Education and Training in Developmental Disabilities39169–1762004
15.
BouckE. C.Lost in translation: Educating secondary students with mild mental impairmentJournal of Disability Policy Studies1879–872007
16.
BouckE. C.BassetteL.Taber-DoughtyT.FlanaganS.SzwedK.Pentop computers as tools for teaching multiplication to students with mild intellectual disabilities. Education and Training in Developmental Disabilities44367–3802009
17.
BouckE. C.FlanaganS. M.Functional curriculum -Evidence-based education?: Considering secondary students with mild intellectual disabilities. Education and Training in Autism and Developmental Disabilities45487–4992010
18.
BrowderD.FlowersC.Ahlgrim-DelzellL.KarvonenM.SpoonerF.AlgozzineR.The alignment of alternate assessment content with academic and functional curriculaThe Journal of Special Education37211–2232004
19.
BrownL.BronstonM. B.Hamre-NietupskiS.PumpianI.CertoN.GruenewaldL.A strategy for developing chronological age-appropriate and functional curricular content for severely handicapped adolescents and young adultsJournal of Special Education1381–901979
20.
Cannella-MaloneH.SigafoosJ.O'reillyM.DeLa
21.
CruzB.EdrisinhaC.LancioniG. E.41344–3562006Training in Developmental Disabilities
22.
Charlop-ChristyM. H.DaneshvarS.Using video modeling to teach perspective taking to children with autismJournal of Positive Behavior Interventions512–212003
23.
Charlop-ChristyM. H.LeL.FreemanK. A.A comparison of video modeling with in vivo modeling for teaching children with autismJournal of Autism and Developmental Disorders30537–5522000
24.
CihakD.AlbertoP. A.Taber-DoughtyT.
25.
GamaR. I.A comparison of static picture prompting and video prompting simulation strategies using group instructional proceduresFocus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities2189–992006
26.
CihakD. F.KesslerK. B.AlbertoP. A.Generalized use of a handheld prompting systemResearch in Developmental Disabilities28397–4082007
27.
ClarkG. M.FieldS.PattonJ. R.BrolinD. E.SitlingtonP. L.Life skills instruction: A necessary component for all students with disabilities. A position statement of the Division on Career Development and TransitionCareer Development for Exceptional Individuals17125–1241994
28.
CollinsB. C.BransonT. A.HallM.Teaching generalized reading of cooking product labels to adolescents with mental disabilities through the use of key words taught by peer tutorsEducation and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities3065–761995
29.
CollinsC. B.StinsonD. M.Teaching generalized reading of product warning labels to adolescents with mental disabilities through the use of key wordsExceptionality5163–1811995
30.
CoxsonL.AndersonC.Cooking to learn 2: Integrating reading and writing activitiesPCI Educational PublishingSan Antonio, TX2001
31.
CroninM. E.Life skills curricula for students with learning disabilities: A review of the literatureJournal of Learning Disabilities291996
32.
D'atenoP.MangiapanelloK.TaylorB. A.Using video modeling to teach complex play sequences to a preschooler with autismJournal of Positive Behavior Interventions55–112003
33.
DennyP. J.TestD. W.The One-More-Than technique to teach money counting to individuals with moderate mental retardation: A systematic replicationEducation and Treatment of Children18422–4321995
34.
DunnL. M.DunnLloyd M.Ed(An overviewExceptional children in the schools: Special education in transitionHolt, Rinehart and WinstonNew York1973nd ed.
35.
EdgarE.Secondary programs in special education: Are many of them justifiable?Exceptional Children53555–5611987
36.
EdyburnD. L.Fact retrieval by students with and without learning handicaps using print and electronic encyclopediasJournal of Special Education Technology1175–901991
37.
FazioB. B.PolsgroveL.An evaluation of the effects of training special educators to integrate microcomputer technology into match curriculaJournal of Special Education Technology1025–131989
38.
GeigerK. B.LeblancL. A.DillonC. M.BatesS. L.An evaluation of preference for video and in vivo modelingJournal of Applied Behavior Analysis43279–2832010
39.
GravesT. B.CollinsB. C.SchusterJ. W.KleinertH.Using video prompting to teach cooking skills to secondary students with moderate disabilitiesEducation and Training in Developmental Disabilities4034–462005
40.
HitchcockC.MeyerA.RoseD.JacksonR.Providing new access to the general curriculum: Universal design for learningTeaching Exceptional Children3528–172002
41.
HutchersonK.LangoneJ.AyersK. M.CleesT.Computer assisted instruction to teach item selection in grocery stores: Assessment of acquisition and generalizationJournal of Special Education Technology1933–422004
42.
Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act of 2003, 31 U.S.C. (2004)
43.
KayeH. S.Disability Statistics Rehabilitation Research and Training Center, University of CaliforniaDisability statistics abstract: Education of children with disabilities, Number 19San Francisco, CA; San Francisco1997, July
44.
KennedyC. H.Single-case designs for educational researchPearson/Allyn and BaconBoston2005
45.
KennedyC. H.ItkonenT. L.LindquistK.Modality effects during equivalence class formations: An extension of sight word reading and concept developmentJournal of Applied Behavior Analysis27673–6841994
KrantzP. J.MacduffG. S.WadstromO.Mc-ClannahanL. E.DowrickP. W.Using video with developmentally disabled learnersA practical guide to using video in the behavioral sciencesJohn Wiley & SonsNew York1991
48.
LancioniG. E.DijkstraA. W.O'reillyM. F.GroenewegJ.Van Den HofE.Frequent versus nonfrequent verbal prompts delivered unobtrusively: Their impact on the task performance of adults with intellectual disabilityEducation and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities35428–4332000
49.
LancioniG. E.Van Den HofE.BoelensH.RochaN.SeedhouseP.A computerbased system providing pictorial instructions and prompts to promote task performance in persons with severe developmental disabilitiesBehavioral Interventions13111–1221998
50.
LancioniG. E.Van Den HofE.FurnissF.O'reillyM. F.CunhaB.Evaluation of a computer-aided system providing pictorial task instructions and prompts to people with severe intellectual disabilityJournal of Intellectual Disability4361–661999
51.
LinA.PodellD. M.ReinN.The effects of CAI on word recognition in mildly mentally handicapped and nonhandicapped learnersJournal of Special Education Technology11116–251991
52.
LuckassonR.Borthwick-DuffyS.BuntinxW.BuntinxH. E.CoulterD. L.CraigE. M.Definitions, classifications, and support systemsAmerican Association on Mental RetardationWashington, DC2002th ed.
53.
LynchE. C.BeareP. L.The quality of IEP objectives and their relevance to instruction for students with mental retardation and behavioral disordersRemedial and Special Education1148–551990
54.
MargalitM.Effects of social skills training for students with an intellectual disabilityInternational Journal of Disability, Development and Education4275–851995
55.
MechlingL.Effects of multimedia, computer-based instruction on grocery shopping fluencyJournal of Special Education Technology1923–342003
56.
MechlingL.The effect of instructor-created video programs to teach students with disabilities: A literature reviewJournal of Special Education Technology2025–362005
57.
MechlingL. C.GastD. L.BartholdS.Multimedia computer-based instruction to teach students with moderate intellectual disabilities to use a debit card to make purchasesExceptionality11239–2542003
58.
MechlingL. C.GastD. L.LangoneJ.Computer-based video instruction to teach persons with moderate intellectual disabilities to read grocery aisle signs and locate itemsJournal of Special Education35224–2402002
59.
NewmanL.Family involvement in the educational development of youth with disabilitiesSRI InternationalMenlo Park, CA2005
60.
NewmanL.WagnerM.CametoR.KnokeyA. M.The post-high school outcomes of youth with disabilities up to 4 years after high schoolNCSER 2009 -3017A report of findings from the National Longitudinal Transition StudySRI InternationalMenlo Park, CA2009
61.
NietupskiJ.Hamre-NietupskiS.CurtinS.ShrikanthK.A review of curricular research in severe disabilities from 1976 to 1995 in six selected journalsJournal of Special Education3136–551997
62.
NikopoulosC. K.KeenanM.Effects of video modeling on social initiations by children with autismJournal of Applied Behavior Analysis3793–962004
63.
Pub. L. No. 107-110, 115 Stat2001
64.
PattonJ. R.PollowayE. A.SmithT. E CEducating students with mild mental retardationFocus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities1580–892000
65.
PattonJ. R.CroninM. E.JairrelsV.Curricular implications of transition: Lifeskills as an integral part of transition educationRemedial and Special Education18294–3061997
66.
PollowayE. A.A eulogy for MMIDDD Express141–82004
67.
PollowayE. A.HooverJ. J.HillsR.University of ColoradoMild retardation: The status of a category of exceptionality21 st century issues in special education: Meeting diverse needsBUENO CenterBoulder35–462005
68.
PollowayE. A.Mild mental retardation: A concept in search of clarity, a population in search of appropriate education and supports, a profession in search of advocacyExceptionality14183–1902006
69.
PollowayE. A.PattonJ. R.SmithT. E CBuckG. H.Mental retardation and learning disabilities: Conceptual and applied issuesJournal of Learning Disabilities30297–3081997
70.
ReschlyD. J.Change dynamics in special education assessment: Historical and contemporary patternsPeabody Journal of Education77117–1362002
71.
SpitzH. H.EllisN. R.Consolidating facts into the schematized learning and memory of educable retardatesInternational Review of Research in Mental RetardationAcademic PressNew York6149–1681973
72.
StephensW. E.Equivalence formation by retarded and nonretarded children at different mental agesAmerican Journal of Mental Deficiency77311–3131972
73.
Taber-DoughtyT.Considering student choice when selecting instructional strategies: A comparison of three prompting systemsResearch in Developmental Disabilities26411–4322005
74.
Taber-DoughtyT.PattonS. E.BrennanS.Simultaneous and delayed video modeling: An examination of system effectiveness and student preferencesJournal of Special Education Technology2312–182008
75.
ThomasG. E.Teaching students with mental retardation: A goal curriculum planning guideMerrillColumbus, OH1996
76.
Van LaarhovenT.JohnsonJ. W.Van Laarhoven-MyersT.GriderK. L.GriderK. M.The effectiveness of using a video iPod as a prompting device in employment settingsJournal of Behavioral Education18119–1412009
77.
Van LaarhovenT.Van Laarhoven-MyersT.Comparison of three video-based instructional procedures for teaching daily living skills to persons with developmental disabilities. Education and Training in Developmental Disabilities41365–3812006
78.
WertB. Y.NeisworthJ. T.Effects of video self-modeling on spontaneous requesting in children with autismJournal of Positive Behavior Interventions530–342003
79.
ZeamanD.HouseB. J.EllisN. R.The role of attention in retardate discrimination learningHandbook of mental deficiency: Psychological theory and researchErlbaumHillsdale, NJ159–2231963
80.
ZeamanD.HouseB. J.EllisN. R.A review of attention theoryHandbook of mental deficiency: Psychological theory and researchErlbaumHillsdale, NJ63–1201979
