Intramedullary Nailing versus Fixed Angle Blade Plating for Subtrochanteric Femoral Fractures: A Prospective Randomised Controlled Trial

Abstract

Purpose.

To compare closed intramedullary nailing to open reduction and internal fixation using a fixed angle blade plate for the management of subtrochanteric femoral fractures.

Methods.

58 patients were equally randomised to undergo either an intramedullary nailing (IN) or fixed angle blade plating (BP).

Results.

There were no significant differences between the 2 groups with regard to age, time to surgery, operating time, receipt of blood transfusions, duration of hospital stay, or fracture classification. The revision rate was 28% (8/29) in the BP group and none in the IN group; the difference was statistically significant.

Conclusion.

Internal fixation using a fixed angle blade plate for subtrochanteric femoral fractures has higher implant failure and revision rates, compared to closed intramedullary nailing.

Keywords

bone plates hip fractures internal fixators prostheses and implants

References

Seinsheimer

. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1978;60:300–6.

Craig

Sivaji

Maffulli

. Subtrochanteric fractures. A review of treatment options. Bull Hosp Jt Dis 2001;60:35–46.

Sims

. Subtrochanteric femur fractures. Orthop Clin North Am 2002;33:113–26.

Russell

Taylor

. Skeletal Trauma. Vol II. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1992:1499–501.

Velasco

Comfort

. Analysis of treatment problems in subtrochanteric fractures of the femur. J Trauma 1978;18:513–23.

Gray

. Osteology. In: Clemente

, editor. Gray's anatomy. Philadelphia: Lea and Febinger; 1985:275–82.

Sofield

. Anatomy of medullary canals. Instr Course Lect 1951;8:8–10.

Koch

. The laws of bone architecture. Am J Anat 1917;21:177.

Rybicki

Simonen

Weis

Jr . On the mathematical analysis of stress in the human femur. J Biomech 1972;5:203–15.

10.

Kinast

Bolhofner

Mast

Ganz

. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur. Results of treatment with the 95 degrees condylar blade-plate. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1989;238:122–30.

11.

Waddell

. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur: A review of 130 patients. J Trauma 1979;19:582–92.

12.

Watson

Campbell

Jr Wade

. Classification, treatment and complications of the adult subtrochanteric fracture. J Trauma 1964;60:457–80.

13.

Asher

Tippett

Rockwood

Zilber

. Compression fixation of subtrochanteric fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1976;117:202–8.

14.

Schatzker

. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur. In: Schatzker

Tile

, editors. The rationale of operative fracture care. 2nd ed. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1996:387–413.

15.

Whatley

Garland

Whitecloud

3rd Whickstrom

. Subtrochanteric fractures of the femur: Treatment with ASIF blade plate fixation. South Med J 1978;71:1372–5.

16.

Barquet

Francescoli

Rienzi

Lopez

. Intertrochanteric-subtrochanteric fractures: Treatment with the long Gamma nail. J Orthop Trauma 2000;14:324–8.

17.

Lahoud

Asselineau

Salengro

Molina

Bombart

. Subtrochanteric fractures. A comparative study between gamma nail and angular osteosynthesis with lateral cortical support [in French]. Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot 1997;83:335–42.

18.

van Doorn

Stapert

. The long gamma nail in the treatment of 329 subtrochanteric fractures with major extension into the femoral shaft. Eur J Surg 2000;166:240–6.

19.

Winquist

. Locked femoral nailing. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 1993;1:95–105.

20.

Pugh

Morgan

Gorczyca

Pienkowski

. A mechanical comparison of subtrochanteric femur fracture fixation. J Orthop Trauma 1998;12:324–9.

21.

Ware

Jr . SF-36 health survey manual: Appendix C. SF-36 health survey manual and interpretation guide. Boston: Nimrod Press; 1993.

22.

Malkawi

. Bone grafting in subtrochanteric fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1982;168:69–72.

23.

Hardy

Descamps

Krallis

Fabeck

Smets

Bertens

. Use of an intramedullary hip-screw compared with a compression hip-screw with a plate for intertrochanteric femoral fractures. A prospective, randomized study of one hundred patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1998;80:618–30.

24.

Bridle

Patel

Bircher

Calvert

. Fixation of intertrochanteric fractures of the femur. A randomised prospective comparison of the gamma nail and the dynamic hip screw. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1991;73:330–4.

25.

Sadowski

Lubbeke

Saudan

Riand

Stern

Hoffmeyer

. Treatment of reverse oblique and transverse intertrochanteric fractures with use of an intramedullary nail or a 95 degrees screw-plate: A prospective, randomized study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2002;84:372–81.