Abstract
Distinguishing abnormal electroencephalogram (EEG) waveforms from benign variants is critical for accurate interpretation of EEG. Hyperventilation (HV) is one of the basic procedures during EEG to enable activation of epileptiform activity. Rarely, HV can activate benign EEG rhythms. Herein, we illustrate two pediatric cases with bursts of rhythmic mid-temporal theta of drowsiness (RMTD), activated by hyperventilation. Continued awareness of this EEG phenomenology and its variations in pediatrics is important in avoiding misdiagnosis of epilepsy.
Introduction
Electroencephalography (EEG) serves as a vital tool in the assessment, diagnosis, and management of patients with epilepsy. Based on ILAE criteria, 1 epilepsy can be diagnosed following two unprovoked seizures or a single unprovoked epileptic seizure and an abnormality on EEG or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with a high probability that seizures could recur. Due to this emphasis on EEG as part of routine diagnostic work up for seizures, an erroneous diagnosis of epilepsy can result from a combination of inadequate history along with overreading of EEG. 2 Specifically, benign EEG variations, such as wicket spikes, hypnagogic hypersynchrony, hyperventilation-induced slowing, fragmented alpha activity, or fluctuations of sharply contoured background rhythms, can be misinterpreted as epileptiform. 3 One such variant, rhythmic mid-temporal theta of drowsiness (RMTD), seen more commonly in adults, is described as abrupt theta frequency (4-7 Hz) rhythmic bursts maximal over the mid-temporal region. This well described variant can be mistaken for a pathologic discharge due to sharply contoured rhythmic waveforms associated with it. Herein, we illustrate two pediatric cases with the uncommon phenomenon of hyperventilation activated RMTD on EEG and discuss established characteristics differentiating benign variants from abnormal epileptiform complexes.
Cases
Case I
A 5-year-old boy presented for an outpatient EEG and evaluation in the neurology clinic following a self-limited, generalized, tonic-clonic seizure out of sleep. Routine EEG showed bursts of notched and sharply contoured 4–7 Hz theta, independently in the left and right temporal regions, which were activated with hyperventilation, which persisted in drowsiness and light sleep (Fig. 1), consistent with RMTD. The bursts of RMTD lasted between 6–120 s and occurred independently as well as simultaneously in bilateral temporal regions with variable asynchrony. No further seizures were reported on follow up over the past year and patient was not on any anti-seizure prophylaxis.
EEG of the patient in case I showing RMTD in bilateral temporal regions.
Case II
A 12-year-old girl presented to the neurology clinic following an episode of loss of consciousness suspicious for new onset seizures. She had a history of a single febrile seizure at 2 years of age. Routine EEG showed 4–10 s bursts of notched and sharply contoured 5–7 Hz theta activated with hyperventilation which persisted in drowsiness and light sleep. These bursts occurred independently as well as simultaneously in bilateral temporal regions, with a relative left temporal predominance. There was no associated clinical change, and the rhythm was consistent with RMTD, without any epileptiform features. No further seizures were reported on subsequent follow up over the past 6 months and patient was referred to Cardiology for evaluation of syncope.
Discussion
Our cases highlight the importance of identification of rare benign variants like RMTD in Pediatrics and their uncommon triggers such as hyperventilation, to enable accurate identification on EEG. The bursts of RMTD while activated during hyperventilation persisted into drowsiness with stereotypical notched sharply contoured morphology in the unilateral/bilateral temporal regions without evolution, confirming the well-described pattern of this benign variant. While previous reports have described HV activated RMTD in a young adult and an adolescent (15-year-old girl),4,5 we illustrate that this rare EEG phenomenology can occur in younger children.
History and Prevalence
This rhythm first described by Gibbs et al in 1963 was first labelled “the psychomotor variant” because this was first observed in patients with “psychomotor” (temporal lobe) seizures.6,7 Lipman and Hughes renamed the pattern Rhythmic Mid- Temporal Discharges (RMTD), according to its electrographic characteristics. 8 In 1985, Klass and Westmoreland included this pattern among those that were “nonepileptogenic and epileptiform” or “patterns of uncertain significance” or “normal variants.” 9 Previous reports have described patients with RMTD and concurrent diagnoses of epilepsy, psychiatric co-morbidities, as well as mild alterations in neurocognitive function,4,6 although, no causal association with RMTD has been established. RMTD is more commonly seen in the adult population, occurring in approximately 10% of the adult population versus only 0.4–1% of the pediatric population. 3 When seen in children, RMTD is known to occur during the late teenage years with rare reports documenting rhythm in children as young as 4 years old.4,6,10
Characteristics and Localization
The morphology and frequency of RMTD is characterized by notched, sharply contoured 4–7 Hz theta frequency waveforms seen in the mid-temporal regions which can spread parasagittally. 11 Corroborating this localization with magnetoencephalography source modeling, RMTD has been shown to originate in the fissural cortex of the posterior inferior temporal region. 12 RMTD can also occur bilaterally, sometimes with a unilateral predominance similar to our cases.4,6,13 RMTD is mostly seen in drowsiness or light sleep, although it has also been reported in relaxed wakefulness,6,10 as noted in our patients. During bursts of RMTD seen in relaxed wakefulness or drowsiness, our patients continued to maintain awareness with purposeful activities. These clinical observations further favor benign variants like RMTD and are consistent with previous reports that have shown no associated clinical change or impaired function despite prolonged continuous runs.3,12,14 RMTD is also usually monomorphic, does not evolve significantly in frequency or amplitude, differentiating it from most ictal patterns. Figure 2 summarizes EEG characteristics that can help differentiate benign EEG variants from abnormal epileptiform complexes and electrographic seizures.
Knowledge gap and Need for Awareness
Currently, educational requirements for child neurology residency require competency in neurodiagnostics, but there are no specific competency requirements related to EEG. 17 Recognizing benign variants is therefore limited by education and exposure. This limitation is supported by a survey of US adult neurology residency program directors, which noted significant variation in EEG reading exposure, lack of consistency in teaching, and evaluating EEG reading milestones for neurology trainees. 18 Neurologists and epileptologists would continue to benefit from recurring discussions of EEG variants in continuing medical education programs, online/social media platforms, and reports in the literature. 19 Increasing knowledge and discussion of benign variants, such as RMTD, would greatly help in reducing the likelihood of erroneous diagnosis of epilepsy resulting from overinterpretation of EEG.
Conclusion
RMTD is a rare rhythm in pediatrics and has the potential to be misdiagnosed for pathologic epileptiform complexes or electrographic seizures. Knowledge of fundamental features of RMTD should aid in its recognition and differentiation from pathologic spikes.
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Ethics Statement
Our institution does not require ethical approval for reporting individual cases or case series less than 5 cases. Verbal informed consent was obtained from a legally authorized representative(s) for anonymized patient information to be published in this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article
