The American Dental Association (ADA) defines evidence-based dentistry (EBD) as “an approach to oral healthcare that requires the judicious integration of systematic assessments of clinically relevant scientific evidence, relating to the oral and medical condition and history, with the dentist’s clinical expertise and the patient’s treatment needs and preferences.” Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) are statements that include recommendations intended to optimize patient care that are informed by a systematic review of evidence and an assessment of the benefits and harms of alternative care options. Therefore, ADA CPGs are the most rigorous examples of EBD to inform clinical practice. CPGs should be of the highest level of quality to ensure the appropriateness and timeliness of clinical recommendations.
Objectives:
The aim of this study was to measure the methodological rigor and transparency of the ADA CPGs.
Methods:
Each ADA CPG was appraised by 4 independent assessors using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument. Quantitative quality scores were obtained for 6 domains and overall quality. In addition, assessors provided a qualitative analysis by providing comments for each item and an appraisal of the full recommendation.
Results:
A quality score of 75% was used as the threshold for high-quality guidelines. Using this metric, 6 of the current 10 current ADA CPGs were considered to be of high quality, 1 was slightly below the quality threshold, and 3 were considered marginal. Even among those evaluated to be high quality in overall assessment, certain domains did not reach the quality threshold of 75%.
Conclusion:
Overall, the ADA CPGs collectively provide high-quality guidance for the clinician. While the AGREE appraisal guidelines have been used in CPG development since 2016, there is still room for improvement in certain domains (i.e., stakeholder involvement, rigor of development, applicability, and editorial independence).
Knowledge Transfer Statement:
The results of this study summarize the methodological rigor and transparency of the 10 current ADA clinical practice guidelines. Since adoption of AGREE standards (2016), CPGs have been uniformly of high quality. The quality of older CPGs was somewhat lower but overall deemed acceptable. Thus, ADA CPGs may be used with confidence to inform practitioners of treatment options supported by rigorous evidence-based dentistry standards. However, there is still room for improvement in methodological quality.
AGREE Collaboration. 2003. Development and validation of an international appraisal instrument for assessing the quality of clinical practice guidelines: the AGREE project. Qual Saf Health Care. 12(1):18–23.
2.
AGREE Next Steps Consortium. 2017. The AGREE II Instrument (electronic version) [accessed 2021 Sept 5]. http://www.agreetrust.org
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2013. Clinical recommendations for use of professionally-applied or prescription-strength, home-use topical fluoride agents for caries prevention in patients at elevated risk of developing caries (chairside guide) [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/Files/ADA_Evidence-based_Topical_Fluoride_Chairside_Guide.pdf?la=en
5.
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2015a. Nonsurgical treatment of chronic periodontitis by scaling and root planing with or without adjuncts: clinical practice guideline (chairside guide) [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/Files/ADA_Chairside_Guide_Periodontitis.pdf?la=en
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2016. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline for the use of pit-and-fissure sealants: a report of the American Dental Association and the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (chairside guide). [Accessed 2021 September 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/Files/ADA-AAPD_2016_Guide_Sealants.pdf?la=en
8.
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2017. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline for the evaluation of potentially malignant disorders in the oral cavity: a report of the American Dental Association (chairside guide) [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/Files/r870A_Chairside_Guide_OralCancer_FINAL.pdf?la=en
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2019a. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on antibiotic use for the urgent management of pulpal- and periapical-related dental pain and intraoral swelling: a report from the American Dental Association (chairside guide—dental treatment is immediately available) [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/Files/ADA_Chairside_Guide_Antibiotics_TA.pdf?la=en
12.
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2019b. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on antibiotic use for the urgent management of pulpal- and periapical-related dental pain and intraoral swelling: a report from the American Dental Association (chairside guide—dental treatment is not immediately available) [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://ebd.ada.org/~/media/EBD/ADA_Chairside_Guide_Antibiotics_TNA.pdf?la=en
American Dental Association Center for Evidence-Based Dentistry (ADA). 2021b. Clinical practice guidelines [accessed 2021 Sept 5]. https://ebd.ada.org/en/evidence/guidelines
15.
American Dental Association Council on Scientific Affairs (ADA). 2014. Fluoride toothpaste use for young children. J Am Dent Assoc. 145(2):190–191.
16.
BrouwersMCKhoMEBrowmanGPBurgersJSCluzeauFFederGFerversBGrahamIDGrimshawJHannaSE, et al., for the AGREE Next Steps Consortium. 2010. AGREE II: advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in healthcare. CMAJ. 182(18):E839–E842.
17.
BrouwersMCKhoMEBrowmanGPBurgersJSCluzeauFFederGFerversBGrahamIDHannaSEMakarskiJ; AGREE Next Steps Consortium. 2010a. Development of the AGREE II, part 1: performance, usefulness and areas for improvement. CMAJ. 182(10):1045–1052.
18.
BrouwersMCKhoMEBrowmanGPBurgersJSCluzeauFFederGFerversBGrahamIDHannaSEMakarskiJ; AGREE Next Steps Consortium. 2010b. Development of the AGREE II, part 2: assessment of validity of items and tools to support application. CMAJ. 182(10):E472–E478.
19.
Carrasco-LabraABrignardello-PetersenRGlickMGuyattGHNeumannIAzarpazhoohA. 2015. A practical approach to evidence-based dentistry: VII: How to use patient management recommendations from clinical practice guidelines. J Am Dent Assoc. 146(5):327–336.
20.
FontanaMPilcherLTampiMPUrquhartOSlaytonRLAraujoMWBCarrasco-LabraA. 2018. Caries management for the modern age: improving practice one guideline at a time. J Am Dent Assoc. 149(11):935–937.
21.
Hoffmann-EßerWSieringUNeugebauerEAMBrockhausACMcGauranNEikermannM. 2018. Guideline appraisal with AGREE II: online survey of the potential influence of AGREE II items on overall assessment of guideline quality and recommendation for use. BMC Health Serv Res. 18(1):143–151.
22.
Institute of Medicine (IOM). 2011. Clinical practice guidelines we can trust. Washington (DC): The National Academies Press [accessed 2021 Sept 6]. https://doi.org/10.17226/13058
23.
LingenMWAbtEAgrawalNChaturvediAKCohenED’SouzaGGurenlianJKalmarJRKerrARLambertPM, et al. 2017. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline for the evaluation of potentially malignant disorders in the oral cavity: a report of the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 148(10):712–727.
24.
LingenMWTampiMPUrquhartOAbtEAgrawalNChaturvediAKCohenED’SouzaGGurenlianJKalmarJR, et al. 2017. Adjuncts for the evaluation of potentially malignant disorders in the oral cavity: diagnostic test accuracy systematic review and meta-analysis—a report of the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 148(11):797–813.e52.
25.
LockhartPBTampiMPAbtEAminoshariaeADurkinMJFouadAFGopalPHattenBWKennedyELangMS, et al. 2019. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on antibiotic use for the urgent management of pulpal- and periapical-related dental pain and intraoral swelling: a report from the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 150(11):906–921.e12.
26.
MakarskiJBrouwersMC; AGREE Enterprise. 2014. The AGREE Enterprise: a decade of advancing clinical practice guidelines. Implement Sci. 9:103.
27.
MeyerDM. 2015. Providing clarity on evidence-based prophylactic guidelines for prosthetic joint infections. J Am Dent Assoc. 146(1):3–5.
28.
MubeenSPatelKCunninghamZO’RourkeNPandisNCobourneMTSeehraJ. 2017. Assessing the quality of dental clinical practice guidelines. J Dent. 67:102–106.
29.
RethmanMPBeltrán-AguilarEDBillingsRJHujoelPPKatzBPMilgromPSohnWStammJWWatsonGWolffM, et al.; American Dental Association Council on Scientific Affairs Expert Panel on Nonfluoride Caries-Preventive Agents. 2011. Nonfluoride caries-preventive agents: executive summary of evidence-based clinical recommendations. J Am Dent Assoc. 142(9):1065–1071.
30.
SlaytonRLUrquhartOAraujoMWBFontanaMGuzmán-ArmstrongSNascimentoMMNovýBBTinanoffNWeyantRJWolffMS, et al. 2018. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on nonrestorative treatments for carious lesions: a report from the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 149(10):837–849.e19.
31.
SmileyCJTracySLAbtEMichalowiczBSJohnMTGunsolleyJCobbCMRossmannJHarrelSKForrestJL, et al. 2015a. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on the nonsurgical treatment of chronic periodontitis by means of scaling and root planing with or without adjuncts. J Am Dent Assoc. 146(7):525–535.
32.
SmileyCJTracySLAbtEMichalowiczBSJohnMTGunsolleyJCobbCMRossmannJHarrelSKForrestJL, et al. 2015b. Systematic review and meta-analysis on the nonsurgical treatment of chronic periodontitis by means of scaling and root planing with or without adjuncts. J Am Dent Assoc. 146(7):508–524.e5.
33.
SollecitoTPAbtELockhartPBTrueloveEPaumierTMTracySLTampiMBeltrán-AguilarEDFrantsve-HawleyJ. 2015. The use of prophylactic antibiotics prior to dental procedures in patients with prosthetic joints: evidence-based clinical practice guideline for dental practitioners—a report of the American Dental Association Council on Scientific Affairs. J Am Dent Assoc. 146(1):11–16.e8.
34.
TampiMPPilcherLUrquhartOKennedyEO’BrienKKLockhartPBAbtEAminoshariaeADurkinMJFouadAF, et al. 2019. Antibiotics for the urgent management of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis, symptomatic apical periodontitis, and localized acute apical abscess: systematic review and meta-analysis—a report of the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 150(12):e179–e216.
35.
TampiMPPilcherLUrquhartOPahlkeSCO’BrienKKCarrasco-LabraA. 2019. Plain language summary for "Antibiotics for the urgent management of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis, symptomatic apical periodontitis, and localized acute apical abscess: systematic review and meta-analysis—a report of the American Dental Association. J Am Dent Assoc. 150(12):1048–1050.
36.
UrquhartOTampiMPPilcherLSlaytonRLAraujoMWBFontanaMGuzmán-ArmstrongSNascimentoMMNovýBBTinanoffN, et al. 2019. Nonrestorative treatments for caries: systematic review and network meta-analysis. J Dent Res. 98(1):14–26.
WeyantRJTracySLAnselmoTTBeltrán-AguilarEDDonlyKJFreseWAHujoelPPIafollaTKohnWKumarJ, et al.; American Dental Association Council on Scientific Affairs Expert Panel on Topical Fluoride Caries Preventive Agents. 2013. Topical fluoride for caries prevention: executive summary of the updated clinical recommendations and supporting systematic reviewJ Am Dent Assoc. 44(11):1279–1291.
39.
WilsonWRGewitzMLockhartPBBolgerAFDeSimoneDCKaziDSCouperDJBeatonAKilmartinCMiroJM, et al.; American Heart Association Young Hearts Rheumatic Fever, Endocarditis and Kawasaki Disease Committee of the Council on Lifelong Congenital Heart Disease and Heart Health in the Young; Council on Cardiovascular and Stroke Nursing; Council on Quality of Care and Outcomes Research. 2021. Prevention of viridans group streptococcal infective endocarditis: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation. 143(20):e963–e978.
40.
WilsonWTaubertKAGewitzMLockhartPBBaddourLMLevisonMBolgerACabellCHTakahashiMBaltimoreRS, et al.; American Heart Association. 2008. Prevention of infective endocarditis: guidelines from the American Heart Association: a guideline from the American Heart Association Rheumatic Fever, Endocarditis and Kawasaki Disease Committee, Council on Cardiovascular Disease in the Young, and the Council on Clinical Cardiology, Council on Cardiovascular Surgery and Anesthesia, and the Quality of Care and Outcomes Research Interdisciplinary Working Group. J Am Dent Assoc. 139(Suppl):3S–24S.
41.
WrightJTCrallJJFontanaMGilletteEJNovýBBDharVDonlyKHewlettERQuinonezRBChaffinJ, et al. 2016. Evidence-based clinical practice guideline for the use of pit-and-fissure sealants: a report of the American Dental Association and the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. J Am Dent Assoc. 147(8):672–682.e12.
42.
WrightJTHansonNRisticHWhallCWEstrichCGZentzRR. 2014. Fluoride toothpaste efficacy and safety in children younger than 6 years: a systematic review. J Am Dent Assoc. 145(2):182–189.
43.
WrightJTTampiMPGrahamLEstrichCCrallJJFontanaMGilletteEJNovýBBDharVDonlyK, et al. 2016. Sealants for preventing and arresting pit-and-fissure occlusal caries in primary and permanent molars: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials-a report of the American Dental Association and the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. J Am Dent Assoc. 147(8):631–645.e18.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
