Performance assessment is an integral part of young musicians’ development. Students enrolled in music programs frequently participate in adjudication festivals and many audition for select ensembles. Outcomes of such events are deemed consequential among all concerned: students, parents, teachers, and administrators. Furthermore, the number of all-state applicants for some individual instruments in many states exceeds 100 and in some states approaches or exceeds 200. This is an inordinate number of recordings or live auditions for individuals or judging panels to evaluate. It seems paramount to utilize an efficient yet fair and accurate audition process to assess large numbers of performances in a short period of time. To explore ways of addressing this issue, the authors designed a prescreening rubric with the goal of reducing the number of full-length recordings heard by judges to a more manageable number. The authors then compared ratings of listeners who used the rubric and heard only the étude portion of the audition to scores of trained and experienced judges who heard the entire audition.
Abeles, H.F. ( 1973). Development and validation of a clarinet performance adjudication scale. Journal of Research in Music Education , 21, 246-255.
2.
Barnes, G.V., & McCashin, R. ( 2002). All-state orchestras: A survey of practices and procedures . UPDATE: Applications of Research in Music Education, 20(2), 16-20.
3.
Bergee, M.J. ( 1988). Use of an objectively constructed rating scale for the evaluation of brass juries: A criterion-related study. Missouri Journal of Research in Music Education, 5(5), 6-15.
4.
Bergee, M.J. ( 2003). Faculty interjudge reliability of music performance evaluation . Journal of Research in Music Education, 51, 137-150.
5.
Bergee, M.J., & Platt, M.C. ( 2003). Influence of selected variables on solo and small-ensemble festival ratings. Journal of Research in Music Education, 51, 342-353.
6.
Burnsed, V., Hinkle, D., & King, S. ( 1985). Performance evaluation reliability at selected concert band festivals. Journal of Band Research, 21, 22-29.
7.
Byo, J.L. ( 1993). The influence of textural and timbral factors on the ability of music majors to detect performance errors. Journal of Research in Music Education, 41, 156-167.
8.
Byo, J.L., & Crone, L.J. ( 1989). Adjudication by nonmusicians: A comparison of professional and amateur performances. Missouri Journal of Research in Music Education, 26, 60-73.
9.
Cooksey, J.M. ( 1977). A facet-factorial approach to rating high school choral music performance. Journal of Research in Music Education , 25, 100-114.
10.
Doerksen, P.F. ( 1999). Aural-diagnostic and prescriptive skills of preservice and expert instrumental music teachers. Journal of Research in Music Education, 47, 78-88.
11.
Duerksen, G.L. ( 1972). Some effects of expectation on evaluation of recorded musical performance. Journal of Research in Music Education , 20, 268-272.
12.
Dugger, R. ( 1997). Inter-judge reliability for the 1994 Oklahoma all-state band auditions based on an Olympic style judging system. Journal of Band Research, 32(2), 66-75.
13.
Fiske, H. ( 1975). Judge-group differences in the rating of secondary school trumpet performances. Journal of Research in Music Education , 23, 186-196.
14.
Fiske, H. ( 1977). Relationship of selected factors in trumpet performance adjudication reliability. Journal of Research in Music Education , 25, 256-263.
15.
Fiske, H. ( 1983). Judging musical performance: Method or madness?UPDATE: Applications of Research in Music Education, 1(3), 7-10.
16.
Geringer, J.M., & Johnson, C.M. ( 2007). Effects of excerpt duration, tempo, and performance level on musicians’ ratings of wind band performances. Journal of Research in Music Education, 55, 289-301.
17.
Hewitt, M.P. ( 2007). Influence of primary performance instrument and education level on music performance evaluation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 55, 18-30.
18.
Hewitt, M.P., & Smith, B.P. ( 2004). The influence of teaching career level and primary performance instrument on the assessment of music performance. Journal of Research in Music Education, 52, 314-327.
19.
Jones, H. ( 1986). An application of the facet-factorial approach to scale construction in the development of a rating scale for high school solo vocal performance (Doctoral dissertation, University of Oklahoma, 1986). Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 1230A.
20.
Mills, J. ( 1987). Assessment of solo musical performance: A preliminary study. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education , 91, 119-125.
21.
Nichols, J.P. ( 1991). A factor analysis approach to the development of a rating scale for snare drum performance. Dialogue in Instrumental Music Education, 15, 11-31.
22.
Norris, C.E., & Borst, J.E. ( 2007). An examination of the reliabilities of two choral festival adjudication forms. Journal of Research in Music Education , 55, 237-251.
23.
Perkins, D.W., & Allen, M.L. ( 1991). An investigation of interjudge reliability of the Texas music educators association all-state orchestra string auditions. Texas Music Education Research, 21-23.
24.
Price, H.E. ( 2007). Effect of keyboard ownership on keyboard performance in a music fundamentals course. International Journal of Music Education, 25(1), 49-54.
25.
Saunders, T.C., & Holahan, J.M. ( 1997). Criteria-specific rating scales in the evaluation of high school instrumental performance. Journal of Research in Music Education, 45, 259-272.
26.
Smith, B.P. ( 2004). Five judges’ evaluation of audiotaped string performance in international competition. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 160, 61-69.
27.
Smith, B.P., & Barnes, G.V. ( 2007). Development and validation of an orchestra performance rating scale. Journal of Research in Music Education, 55, 268-280.
28.
Thompson, S., & Williamon, A. ( 2003). Evaluating evaluation: Music performance assessment as a research tool. Music Perception, 21(1), 21-41.
29.
Vasil, T. ( 1973). The effects of systematically varying selected factors on music performing adjudication. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut, Storrs.
30.
Wapnick, J., Flowers, P., Alegant, M., & Jasinskas, L. ( 1993). Consistency in piano performance evaluation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 41, 282-292.
31.
Wapnick, J., Ryan, C., Campbell, L., Deek, P., Lemire, R., & Darrow, A.A. ( 2005). Effects of excerpt tempo and duration on musicians’ ratings of high-level piano performances. Journal of Research in Music Education, 53, 162-176.
32.
Winter, N. ( 1993). Music performance assessment: A study of the effects of training and experience on the criteria used by music examiners. International Journal of Music Education, 22, 34-39.
33.
Zdzinski, S.F., & Barnes, G.V. ( 2002). Development and validation of a string performance rating scale. Journal of Research in Music Education, 50, 245-255.
