In recent years, national and international medical and mental-health associations typically have emphasized the potential harmfulness of professional care for unwanted same-sex attraction (SSA or homosexuality) and behavior. State legislatures in the US and legislative bodies in other countries either have passed or are considering passing laws which would penalize professionals who provide professional care for unwanted SSA—to minors and/or adults—including the loss of the license to practice. This paper was written as a response to the present situation in the UK. The paper reviews the universal ethics of all medical and mental-health professionals to avoid harm and do good (non-maleficence/non-malfeasance and beneficence); discusses the documented potential for harm when using every mental-health treatment for every presenting problem; clarifies steps taken by the Alliance for Therapeutic Choice and Scientific Integrity (Alliance), its clinical and research divisions, the National Association for Research and Therapy of Homosexuality Institute (NARTH Institute) and its international division, the International Federation for Therapeutic Choice (IFTC), to promote ethical professional care for unwanted SSA; clarifies the injustice and presumed ideological biases of the medical and mental-health associations’ warning about the potential for harm for psychotherapy only for unwanted SSA and not all psychotherapy approaches; and documents that the research purporting to show this harmfulness, in the research authors own words, does not do so. Recommendations to promote scientific integrity in the conduct and reporting of relevant research are offered.
Lay summary
There has been a lot of controversy about the potential harmfulness of professional care for unwanted same-sex attraction and behavior (SSA or homosexuality). This paper reviews the ethics of all medical and mental health professionals to avoid harm and do good; discusses the known potential for harm when using any mental health treatment for any problem; clarifies steps taken to promote ethical professional care for unwanted SSA; notes the injustice and possible biases of those who warn about the potential for harm of psychotherapy for unwanted SSA; and documents that the research said to show this harmfulness, in the research authors′ own words, does not do so.
AlankoK., SantitilaP., SatoB., JemP., JohanssonA., et al.2011. Testing causal models of the relationship between childhood gender atypical behavior and parent–child relationship. British Journal of Developmental Psychology29: 214–233.
2.
American Psychological Association (APA). 2010. Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association. http://apa.org/ethics/code/index.aspx.
3.
American Psychological Association (APA), Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation. 2009. Report of the APA task force on appropriate therapeutic responses to sexual orientation. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association. http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/therapeutic-response.pdf.
AustinS.B., JunH., JacksonB., SpiegelmanD., Rich-EdwardsJ., CorlissH.L., and WrightR.J.2008. Disparities in child abuse victimization in lesbian, bisexual, heterosexual women in the Nurses’ Health Study II. Journal of Women‘s Health17: 597–606. doi:10.1089/jwh.2007.0450.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), National Center for HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis, STD, and TB Prevention, Division of STD Prevention. 2014. Sexually transmitted disease surveillance 2012. http://www.cdc.gov/std/stats12/Surv2012.pdf.
9.
CorlissH.I., CochranS.D., and MaysV.M.2002. Reports of parental maltreatment during childhood in a United States population-based survey of homosexual, bisexual, and heterosexual adults. Child Abuse & Neglect26: 1165–1178.
10.
DehlinJ.P., GalliherR.V., BradshawW.S., HydeD.C., and CrowellK.A.2014. Sexual orientation change efforts among current or former LDS church members. Journal of Counseling Psychology, advance online publication.
11.
DiamondL.M.2009. Sexual fluidity: Understanding women's love and desire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
FarrR.H., DiamondL.M., and BokerS.M.2014. Female same-sex sexuality from a dynamical systems perspective: Sexual desire, motivation, and behavior. Archives of Sexual Behavior43: 1477–1490.
15.
FieldsS.D., MalebrancheD., and Feist-PriceS.2008. Childhood sexual abuse in black men who have sex with men: Results from three qualitative studies. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology14: 385–390.
16.
FlentjeA., HeckN.C., and CochranB.N.2013. Sexual reorientation therapy interventions: Perspectives of ex-ex-gay individuals. Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental Health17: 256–277.
17.
FriedmanM.S., MarshalM.P., GuadamuzT.E., WeiC., WongC.F., SacwycE.M., and StallR.2011. A meta-analysis of disparities in childhood sexual abuse, parental physical abuse, and peer victimization among sexual minority and sexual nonminority individuals. American Journal of Public Health101: 1481–1494.
18.
HansenN.B., LambertM.J., and FormanE.M.2002. The psychotherapy dose-response effect and its implications for treatment delivery services. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice9: 329–343.
19.
International Federation for Therapeutic Choice (IFTC). 2011. Intolerance and discrimination against medical and mental health professionals, researchers, and educators threaten the freedoms of the professionals and those whom they serve. Journal of Human Sexuality4 (November): 136–140. http://www.scribd.com/doc/174191760/Journal-of-Human-Sexuality-Vol-4.
20.
International Federation for Therapeutic Choice (IFTC). 2012. Intolerance and discrimination against medical and mental health professionals and researchers threaten the freedom of professionals to serve the health care needs of their clients; the right of clients to self-determination in choosing wanted education, guidance, and therapy; and the right of researchers to scientific and academic freedom. Journal of Human Sexuality5(December): 112–119. http://www.narth.com/#!iftc-reports/c1qbu.
21.
International Federation for Therapeutic Choice (IFTC). 2013. Legally sanctioned intolerance and discrimination threatens the freedom of medical and mental health professionals and researchers to provide—and potential patients or clients to receive—freely sought education, guidance, therapy and other professional care. Journal of Human Sexuality6, 131–143. http://www.narth.com/#!iftc-reports/c1qbu.
22.
International Federation for Therapeutic Choice (IFTC). 2014. Unjust legal sanctions threaten the rights of children and adults to receive—and competent medical and mental-health professionals to provide—freely sought professional care to manage or change unwanted same-sex attraction (SSA). Journal of Human Sexuality, in press. http://www.narth.com/#!iftc-reports/c1qbu.
23.
JonesS.L., RosikC.H., WilliamsR.N., and ByrdA.D.2010. A scientific, conceptual, and ethical critique of the report of the APA task force on sexual orientation. General Psychologist45.2: 7–18.
24.
Katz-WiseS.L.2015. Sexual fluidity in young adult women and men: Associations with sexual orientation and sexual identity development. Psychology & Sexuality6: 189–208.
25.
Katz-WiseS.L., and HydeJ.S.2015. Sexual fluidity and related attitudes and beliefs among young adults with a same-gender orientation. Archives of Sexual Behavior44: 1459–1470.
26.
LahavotK., MolinaY., and SimoniJ.M.2012. Childhood trauma, adult sexual assault, and adult gender expression among lesbian and bisexual women. Sex Roles67: 272–284.
27.
LambertM.2013. The efficacy and effectiveness of psychotherapy. InBergin and Garfield's handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change, 6th ed. ed. LambertMichael J.Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
28.
LambertM.J., and BerginA.E.1994. The effectiveness of psychotherapy. InHandbook of psychotherapy and behavior change, 4th ed. eds. GarfieldS.L. and BerginA.E.New York: Wiley.
29.
LambertM.J., BerginA.E., and CollinsJ.L.1977. Therapist induced deterioration in psychotherapy patients. InEffective psychotherapy: A handbook of research, eds. GurmanA.S. and RazinA.M.New York: Pergamon Press.
30.
LambertM.J., and OglesB.M.2004. The efficacy and effectiveness of psychotherapy. New York: Wiley.
31.
LambertM.J., ShapiroD.A., and BerginA.E.1986. The effectiveness of psychotherapy. InHandbook of psychotherapy and behavior change, 3rd ed, eds. GarfieldS.L. and BerginA.E.New York: Wiley.
32.
LaumannE.O., GagnonJ.H., MichaelR.T., and MichaelsS.1994. The social organization of sexuality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
National Association for Research and Therapy of Homosexuality (NARTH). 2012. NARTH institute statement on sexual orientation change. Approved by the NARTH Board of Directors on January 25, 2012. http://www.narth.com/#!about1/c1wab.
36.
NelsonP.L., WarrenJ.S., GleaveR.L., & BurlingameG.M.2013. Youth psychotherapy change trajectories and early warning system accuracy in a managed care setting. Journal of Clinical Psychology69: 880–895.
PhelanJ.E.2014. Successful outcomes of sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE): An annotated bibliography. Charleston, SC: Practical Application Publications (Phelan Consultants LLC).
39.
RhodesR.H., HillC.E., ThompsonB.J., and ElliottR.1994. Client retrospective recall of resolved and unresolved misunderstanding of events. Journal of Counseling Psychology41: 473–483.
40.
RobertsA.L., GlymourM.M., and KoenenK.C.2013. Does maltreatment in childhood affect sexual orientation in adulthood?Archives of Sexual Behavior42: 161–171.
41.
RosikC.H.2012. Did the American Psychological Association's report on appropriate therapeutic responses to sexual orientation apply its research standards consistently? A preliminary examination. Journal of Human Sexuality4: 70–85. http://www.scribd.com/doc/174191760/Journal-of-Human-Sexuality-Vol-4.
42.
RosikC.H.2013a. Countering a one-sided representation of science: NARTH provides the ‘rest of the story’ for legal efforts to challenge anti-sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) legislation. Journal of Human Sexuality5: 120–164. http://media.wix.com/ugd/ec16e9_2bccb50857a04b82a1253d61f4376245.pdf.
RosikC.H.2014. The reincarnation of Shidlo and Schroeder (2002): New studies introduce anti-SOCE advocacy research to the next generation. Journal of Human Sexuality6: 22–48. Retrieve from http://www.narth.com/#!reincarnation-of-shidlo-/c1tch.
SteedJ.J., and TemplerD.I.2010. Gay men and lesbian women with molestation history: Impact on sexual orientation and experience of pleasure. Open Psychological Journal3: 36–41.
51.
StoddardJ.P., DibbleS.I., and FinemanN.2009. Sexual and physical abuse: A comparison between lesbians and their heterosexual sisters. Journal of Homosexuality56: 407–420.
TomeoM.E., TemplerD.L., AndersonS., and KotlerD.2001. Comparative data of childhood and adolescent molestation in heterosexual and homosexual persons. Archives of Sexual Behavior30: 535–541.
54.
UK Council for Psychotherapy. 2010. UKCP's ethical principles and codes of professional conduct: Guidance on the practice of psychological therapies that pathologise and/or seek to eliminate or reduce same sex attraction. http://www.psychotherapy.org.uk/resources-and-publications/standards/.
WalkerJ., ArcherJ., and DaviesM.2005. Effects of rape on men: A descriptive analysis. Archives of Sexual Behavior14: 69–80.
57.
WellsJ.E., McGeeM.A., and BeautraisA.L.2011. Multiple aspects of sexual orientation: Prevalence and sociodemographic correlates in a New Zealand National Survey. Archives of Sexual Behavior40: 155–168.
