For high temperature applications, 9–12 wt-Cr steels in fossil fired power plants rely upon precipitate strengthening from (V,Nb)N MX nitrides for long term creep strength. During prolonged exposure at service temperature, another nitride precipitates: Cr(V,Nb)N Z phase. The Z phases lowly replace MX, eventually causing a breakdown in creep strength. The present paper reviews the Z phase and its behaviour in 9–12 wt-Cr steels including thermodynamic modelling, crystal structure, nucleation process and precipitation rate as a function of chemical composition. The influence of Z phase precipitation upon long term creep strength is assessed from several different 9–12wt-Cr steel grades and alloy design philosophies.
‘Avedore 2 sets new benchmarks for efficiency, flexibility and environmental impact’, Mod. Power Syst., 2000, 20, 25–36.
2.
KernT. U., StaubliM. and ScarlinB.: ‘The European efforts in material development for 650°C USC power plants – COST522’, ISIJ Int., 2002, 42, 1515–1519.
3.
StrangA. and VodarekV.: ‘Z phase formation in martensitic 12CrMoVNb steel’, Mater. Sci. Technol., 1996, 12, 552–556.
4.
YoshisawaM., IgarashiM., MoriguchiK., IsedaA., ArmakiH. G. and MaruyamaK.: ‘Effect of precipitates on long-term creep deformation properties of P92 and P122 type advanced ferritic steels for USC power plants’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2009, A510-A511, 162–168.
5.
SawadaK.. Personal communication, National Institute for Materials Science, Tsukuba, Japan.
6.
BinderW. O.: ‘Some notes on the structure and impact resistance of Colombium-bearing 18-8 steels after exposure to elevated temperatures’, ASTM STP, 1950, 110, 146–164.
7.
JackD. H. and JackK. H.: ‘Structure of Z-phase, NbCrN’, J. Iron Steel Inst., 1972, 210, 790–792.
8.
VodarekV.: ‘Creep behaviour and microstructural evolution AISI 316LN+Nb steels at 650°C’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2011, A528, 4232–4238.
9.
KurosawaF., TaguchiI., TaninoM. and MatsumotoR.: ‘Observations and analysis of nitrides in steels using the non-aqueous electrolyte-potentiostatic etching method’, J. Jpn Inst. Met., 1981, 45, 63–71.
10.
EttmayerP.: ‘Die struktur der komplexnitrideNbCrN und Ta1 − xCr1+xN’, Monatsh. Chem., 1971, 102, 858–863.
11.
KarlsonL., HenjeredA., AndrenH. O. and NordenN.: ‘Composition of crystallography of nitride precipitates in an austenitic stainless steel containing niobium and vanadium’, Mater. Sci. Technol., 1985, 1, 337–343.
SuzukiK., KumaiS., KushimaH., KimuraK. and AbeF.: ‘Heterogeneous recovery and precipitation of Z-phase during long term creep deformation of modified 9Cr-1Mo steel’, Tetsu-to-Hagane, 2000, 86, 550–557.
14.
SuzukiK., KumaiS., KushimaH., KimuraK. and AbeF.: ‘Precipitation of Z-phase and precipitation sequence during creep deformation of mod.9Cr-1Mo steel’, Tetsu-to-Hagane, 2003, 89, 691–698.
15.
SklenickaV., KucharovaK., SvobodaM., KlocL., BursikJ. and KroupaA.: ‘Long-term creep behavior of 9-12Cr power plant steels’, Mater. Char., 2003, 51, 35–48.
16.
Letofsky-PapstI., WarbichlerP., HoferF., LetofskyE. and CerjakH.: ‘On the occurrence of Z-phase in a creep-tested 10 Cr steel’, Z. Metallkd, 2004, 95, 18–21.
17.
GolpayeganiA., AndrenH. O., DanielsenH. and HaldJ.: ‘A study on Z-phase nucleation in martensitic chromium steels’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2008, A489, 310–318.
18.
ChilukuruH., DurstK., WadekarS., SchwienheerM., ScholzA., BergerC., MayerK. H. and BlumW.: ‘Coarsening of precipitates and degradation of creep resistance in tempered martensite steels’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2009, A510-A511, 81–87.
19.
KauffmannF., MaileK., StraubS., MayerK. H., BauerM. and RoosE.: ‘Optimisation of long-term creep strength of martensitic steels’, Trans. Indian Inst. Met., 2010, 63, 357–361.
20.
SawadaK., BauerM., KauffmannF., MayrP. and KlenkA.: ‘Microstructural change of 9 Cr-welded joints after long-term creep’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2010, A527, 1417–1426.
21.
RojasD., GarciaJ., PratO., CarrascoC., SauthoffG. and Kaysser-PyzallaA. R.: ‘Design and characterization of microstructure evolution during creep of 12 Cr heat resistant steels’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2010, A527, 3864–3876.
22.
VodarekV.: ‘Stability of Z-phase and M6X in creep-resistant steels’, Scr. Mater., 2012, 66, 678–681.
23.
FedorovaI., KipelovaA., BelyakovA. and KaibyshevR.: ‘Microstructure evolution in an advanced 9 pct Cr martensitic steel during creep at 923 K (650 °C)’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A, 2013, 44A, 128–135.
24.
SachadelU. A., MorrisP. F. and ClarkeP. D.: ‘Design of 10Cr martensitic steels for improved creep resistance in power plant applications’, Mater. Sci. Technol., 2013, 29, 767–774.
25.
LazarP., PodlouckyR., KozeschnikE. and RedingerJ.: ‘Density functional theory study of ternary V-Cr-N compounds’, Phys. Rev. B, 2008, 78B, 134202.
26.
KocerC., AbeT. and SoonA.: ‘The Z-phase in 9-12 Cr ferritic steels: a phase stability analysis’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2009, A505, 1–5.
27.
ForsD. H. R. and WahnstromG.: ‘First-principles investigations of the stability of MN and CrMN precipitates under coherence strains in α-Fe (M = V, Nb, Ta)’, J. Appl. Phys., 2011, 109, 113709.
28.
LvZ. Q., ZhangR. H., DongF., WangB., WangZ. H. and FuW. T.: ‘Atomistic study on phase stability and electronic structures of Z phase CrNbNx (x = 1, 2, 3)’, J. Alloys Compd, 2014, 598, 89–94.
29.
DanielsenH. K. and HaldJ.: ‘Behaviour of Z-phase in 9-12Cr steels’, Energy Mater., 2006, 1, 49–57.
30.
DanielsenH. K. and HaldJ.: ‘Tantalum containing Z-phase in 12Cr martensitic steels’, Scr. Mater., 2009, 60, 811–813.
31.
DanielsenH. K. and HaldJ.: ‘A thermodynamic model of the Z-phase’, Calphad, 2007, 31, 505–514.
32.
HelisL., TodaY., HaraT., MiyazakiH. and AbeF.: ‘Effect of cobalt on microstructure and creep deformation behaviour of tempered martensitic 9 Cr steel for USC power plant’. Proc. 34th MPA Seminar, Stuttgart, Germany, October 2008, MPA Stuttgart, Paper 9.
33.
KauffmannF., ZiesG., MaileK., StraubS. and MayerK. H.: ‘Microstructure and creep properties of 9–12 Cr–steels – the influence of Co’. Proc. 34th MPA Seminar, Stuttgart, Germany, October 2008, MPA Stuttgart, Paper 4.
34.
CipollaL., DanielsenH. K., Di NunzioP. E., VendittiD., HaldJ. and SomersM. A. J.: ‘On the role of Nb in Z-phase formation in a 12Cr steel’, Scr. Mater., 2010, 63, 324–327.
35.
SawadaK., KushimaH., HaraT., TabuchiM. and KimuraK.: ‘Heat-to-heat variation of creep strength and long-term stability of microstructure in grade 91 steels’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2014, A597, 164–170.
36.
Srinivas PrasadB. S., RajkumarV. B. and Hari KumarK. C.: ‘Numerical simulation of precipitate evolution in ferritic-martensitic power plant steels’, Calphad, 2012, 36, 1–7.
37.
PratO., GarciaJ., RojasD., CarrascoC. and Kaysser-PyzallaA. R.: ‘Investigations on coarsening of MX and M23C6precipiates in 12Cr creep resistant steels assisted by computational thermodynamics’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2010, A527, 5976–5983.
38.
SawadaK., KushimaH. and KimuraK.: ‘Z-phase formation during creep and aging in 9–12Cr heat resistant steels’, ISIJ Int., 2006, 46, 769–775.
39.
SawadaK., KushimaH., TabuchiM. and KimuraK.: ‘Effect of creep deformation on Z phase formation in Gr. 91 steel’, Mater. Sci. Technol., 2014, 30, 12–16.
40.
DanielsenH. K., HaldJ., GrumsenF. B. and SomersM. A. J.: ‘On the crystal structure of Z-phase Cr(V,Nb)N’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A, 2006, 37A, 2633–2640.
41.
CipollaL., DanielsenH. K., VendittiD., Di NunzioP. E., HaldJ. and SomersM. A. J.: ‘Conversion of MX nitrides to Z-phase in a martensitic 12 Cr steel’, Acta Mater., 2010, 58, 669–679.
42.
SawadaK., KushimaH., TabuchiM. and KimuraK.: ‘Microstructural degradation of Gr.91 steel during creep under low stress’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2011, A528, 5511–5518.
43.
DanielsenH. K., Di NunzioP. E. and HaldJ.: ‘Kinetics of Z-phase precipitation in 9 to 12 pct Cr steels’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A, 44A, 2013, 2445–2452.
44.
SawadaK., KushimaH., KimuraK. and TabuchiM.: ‘TTP diagrams of Z-phase in 9-12 Cr heat-resistant steels’, ISIJ Int., 2007, 47, 733–739.
45.
SawadaK., SuzukiK., KushimaH., TabuchiM. and KimuraK.: ‘Effect of tempering temperature on Z-phase formation and creep strength in 9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb-N steel’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2008, A480, 558–563.
46.
DanielsenH. K. and HaldJ.: ‘On the nucleation and dissolution process of Z-phase Cr(V,Nb)N in martensitic 12Cr steels’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2009, A505, 169–177.
47.
DanielsenH. K., HaldJ. and SomersM. A. J.: ‘Atomic resolution imaging of precipitate transformation from cubic TaN to tetragonal CrTaN’, Scr. Mater., 2012, 66, 261–264.
48.
DanielsenH. K., KadkhodazadehS., GrumsenF. B. and SomersM. A. J.: ‘New amorphous interface for precipitate nitrides in steel’, Philos. Mag., 2014, 94, 2339–2349.
49.
MitoY., MikiK., AzumaT., IshiguroT., TamuraO., MurataY. and MorinagaM.: ‘Effects of Cr and W content in high Cr ferritic heat-resistant steels on long-term creep rupture strength’, Proc. 7th Int. Conf. on ‘Advances in materials technology for fossil power plants’, Waikoloa, HI, USA, October 2013, ASM International627–636.
50.
TaneikeM., AbeF. and SawadaK.: ‘Creep-strengthening of steel at high temperatures using nano-sized carbonitride dispersions’, Nature, 2003, 424, 294–296.
51.
SawadaK., TaneikeM., KimuraK. and AbeF.: ‘Effect of nitrogen content on microstructural aspects and creep behavior in extremely low carbon 9Cr heat-resistant steel’, ISIJ Int., 2004, 44, 1243–1249.
52.
AbeF.: ‘Long-term, stabilization of creep-resistant 9Cr steel by boron for high efficient low emission power plant at 650°C’, Rev. Metall./Cah. Inf. Tech., 2006, 103, 247–256.
53.
SchneiderA., SubanovicM. and AbellanJ. P: ‘Long-term evolution of microstructure in VM12-SHC’, Proc. 7th Int. Conf. on ‘Advances in materials technology for fossil power plants’, Waikoloa, HI, USA, October 2013, ASM International, 1093–1103. 2013.
54.
‘New creep resistant stable steel for USC power (CRESTA)’, Final report, http://bookshop.europa.eu; 2014.
55.
DanielsenH. K. and HaldJ.: ‘Influence of Z-phase on long-term creep stability of martensitic 9 to 12 Cr steels’, VGB PowerTech., 2009, 5, 68–73.
56.
DanielsenH. K.: ‘Precipitation process of Z-phase in 9–12Cr steels’, Proc. 7th Int. Conf. on ‘Advances in materials technology for fossil power plants’, Waikoloa, HI, USA, October 2013, ASM International, 1104–1115.
