Mass timber construction as an alternative to concrete and steel in the Australia building industry: A PESTEL evaluation of the potential

Abstract

The present paper is the first to conceptually assess the viability of mass timber construction (MTC) as an alternative construction material/method in Australia. It fulfills an identified need to examine an innovative construction process providing much needed information concerning the technologies current position and future disruption to traditional construction methods. A common tool used in business management studies, the PESTEL model, Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental and Legal is employed to provide structure for a strategic analysis of the technology. Mass timber construction clearly demonstrates some advantages including cost savings, primarily in the reduction in on-site labour costs; a lower environmental impact and use of a renewable resource; and possibility of improved amenity and reduced running costs for owners and occupiers. The estimated market potential for MTC in Australia indicates that a local plant might be viable as the market grows, and warrants funding to underpin a full feasibility assessment.

Keywords

Mass timber construction PESTEL Cross-laminated timber Australia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aguilar

F. J.

1967. Scanning the business environment. New York: Macmillan.

Ahn

Y. H.

, Pearce

A. R.

, Wang

and Wang

2013. Drivers and barriers of sustainable design and construction: the perception of green building experience. International Journal of Sustainable Building Technology and Urban Development. 4(1): 35–45.

Australian Bureau of Statistics . 2015. Construction Work Done in Australia. Retrieved from < http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/8755.0>.

Australian Greenhouse Office . 2004. National greenhouse inventory 2002. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

Beniuk

2012. Battle against Gunns mill ‘not over’. Available at: < http://www.theage.com.au/environment/battle-against-gunns-mill-not-over-20120807-23seb.html>.

Buchanan

, Deam

, Fragiacomo

, Pampanin

and Palermo

2008. Multi-storey prestressed timber buildings in New Zealand. Structural Engineering International. 18(2): 166–173.

Burgmann

, McNaughton

and Penney

2002. Unions and the environment. Environment, Economy, and Society. 10(1): 1–36.

Byle

2012. First commercial project opens doors for CLT in US. Available at: < http://www.woodworks.org/wp-content/uploads/CLT-Milestone-Montana.pdf>.

Cashore

, Auld

and Newsom

2004. Governing through markets: forest certification and the emergence of non-state authority. New Haven: Yale University Press.

10.

CFMEU . 2009. Natural resources ministerial council meeting must act on jobs destroying, unscientific Green Building Council. Available at: < http://www.forestrystandard.org.au/files/MediaAndNews/MR_CFMEU-GBCA_051109.pdf>.

11.

Crespell

and Gagon

2010. Cross laminated timber: a primer. Available at: < https://fpinnovations.ca/media/publications/Documents/clt-primer.pdf>.

12.

Dargavel

2005. Forestry. Canberra: School of Resources, Environment and Society, Australian Catholic University.

13.

Davison

2014. Goodbye to all the pain, no gain carbon tax. The Drum. Available at: < http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-07-17/davidson-goodbye-to-the-all-pain-no-gain-carbon-tax/5597614>.

14.

Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry . 2008. Australia's state of the forests report. Available at: < http://adl.brs.gov.au/forestsaustralia/publications/sofr2008.html>.

15.

Department of Environment . 2014. Repealing the carbon tax. Retrieved from < http://www.environment.gov.au/climate-change/repealing-carbon-tax>.

16.

Depro

B. M.

, Murray

B. C.

, Alig

R. J.

and Shanks

2008. Public land, timber harvests, and climate mitigation: quantifying carbon sequestration potential on U.S. public timberlands. Forest Ecology and Management. 255(3): 1122–1134.

17.

Dewsbury

, Geard

and Fay

2013. Can mass-timber construction materials provide effective thermal capacitance in new homes? A-Sim2012 – IBPSA Asia Conference, 25-28 November 2012, Shanghai..

18.

Dunn

2015. Final report for commercial building costing cases studies: traditional design versus timber project. Melbourne, Australia: Forest and Wood Products Australia. [Report No. PNA308-1213].

19.

Fell

2013. Wood and human health. Available at: < https://fpinnovations.ca/MediaCentre/Brochures/Wood_Human_Health_final-single.pdf>.

20.

Forest and Wood Products Australia . 2012. Massive Timber Construction Systems: Cross Laminated Timber (CLT). Available at: < http://www.woodsolutions.com.au/fwpa/article_downloads/Design_Guide_16_CLT.pdf>.

21.

Forestry and Development . 2012. Australian senate passes illegal logging bill. Available at: < http://forestryanddevelopment.com/site/2012/12/10/australian-senate-passes-illegal-logging-bill/>.

22.

Forestry Innovation Investment and Binational Softwood Lumber Council . 2014. Survey of international tall wood buildings. Available at: < http://www.rethinkwood.com/sites/default/files/wood-resourse-pdf/Survey%20Tall%20Wood_REPORT%20WITHOUT%20APPENDICIES_web.pdf>.

23.

Forestry Innovation Investment . 2012. Assessing the impact of the Japanese wood first act on demand for PFC in the public non-residential market in Japan. Available at: < www.bcfii.ca>.

24.

Frumkin

2001. Beyond toxicity: human health and the natural environment. American Journal of Preventative Medicine. 20(3): 234–240.

25.

Gagon

and Pirvu

2011. CLT handbook: cross laminated timber. FPInnovations and Binational Softwood Lumber Council, Quebec, Canada.

26.

Green Building Council of Australia . 2011;. Available at: < http://www.gbca.org.au/gbc_scripts/js/tiny_mce/plugins/filemanager/green_building_agenda.pdf>.

27.

Gulbrandsen

L. H.

2005. The effectiveness of non-state governance schemes: a comparative study of forest certification in Norway and Sweden. International Environmental Agreements. 5: 125–149.

28.

Housing Institute of Association . 2015. HIA housing forecast. Available at: < https://hia.com.au/∼/media/HIA%20Website/Files/IndustryBusiness/Economic/forecasts/Feb2015_Forecasts.ashx>.

29.

Illegal Logging Prohibition Act of 2012, No. 166. Retrieved from < https://www.comlaw.gov.au/Details/C2012A00166>.

30.

International Trade Union Confederation . 2009. ‘What's Just Transition?’. Available at: < http://www.ituc-csi.org/what-s-just-transition.html>.

31.

Johansson

and Lidestav

2010. Can voluntary standards regulate forestry? Assessing the environmental impacts of forest certification in Sweden. Forest Policy and Economics. 13: 191–198.

32.

Karacabeyli

and Douglas

2013. Cross Laminated Timber (CLT) handbook. Available at: < http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/cs/groups/pan/@pan/documents/web_informational/dpds021903.pdf>.

33.

Kelz

, Grote

and Moser

2011. Interior wood use in classroom reduces pupils’ stress levels. Presented at the 9th Biennial Conference on Environmental Psychology, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.

34.

Lawson

2012. Illegal logging and related trade: indicators of the global response. Energy, Environment and Resources Governance. 7: 1–8. Retrieved from: < http://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/files/chathamhouse/public/Research/Energy,%20Environment%20and%20Development/0710bp_illegallogging.pdf>

35.

Leaman

and Bordass

2007. Are users more tolerant of ‘green’ buildings? Building Research and Information. 35(6): 662–673.

36.

Legifrance . 2010. Décret n° 2010-273 du 15 mars 2010 relatif à l'utilisation du bois dans certaines constructions. Available at: < http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte = JORFTEXT000021979658>.

37.

Lehmann

and Fitzgerald

G. B.

2012. Sustainable urban infill development using low-carbon prefabricated timber construction systems: wood in the city. Sustainability. 4: 2707–2742.

38.

Lenzen

and Treloar

2002. Embodied energy in buildings: wood versus concrete – reply to Borjesson and Gustavsson. Energy Policy. 30(3): 249–255.

39.

Make it Wood . 2014. Timber as a sustainable building material. Available at: < http://makeitwood.org/documents/doc-692-timber-as-a-sustainable-material.pdf>.

40.

Mohammad

, Gagnon

, Karacabeyli

and Popovski

2011. Innovative mid-rise timber structures offer new opportunities for designers. Available at: < http://clients.cyberimpact.ca/public/fe9f5b3d-15d0-4b26-916a-1a10980d78a6/files/Solutions_WP_dec2011/Manuscript_SEAOC_Las_Vegas.pdf>.

41.

Nachmany

, Frankhauser

, Townsend

, Collins

, Landesman

, Matthews

, Pavese

, Rietag

, Schleifer

and Setzer

2014. The GLOBE climate legislation study: a review of climate change legislation in 66 countries. 4th edn. London: The London School of Economics and political Science.

42.

Nordin

, Oberg

, Kollberg

and Nord

2010. Building a new supply chain position: an exploratory study of companies in the timber housing industry. Construction Management and Economics. 28: 1071–1083.

43.

North

2013. What is thermal bridging?. Available at: < http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/guest-blogs/what-thermal-bridging>.

44.

Nowak

D. J.

and Crane

D. E.

2002. Carbon sequestration by urban trees in the USA. Environmental Pollution. 116(3): 381–389.

45.

Nunery

J. S.

and Keeton

W. S.

2010. Forest carbon storage in the north eastern United States: net effects of harvesting frequency, post-harvest retention, and wood products. Forest Ecology and Management. 259(8): 1363–1375.

46.

Parliament of Australia . 2012. Illegal logging prohibition bill 2012. Available at: < http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId = r4740>.

47.

Parliament of British Columbia . 2009. Wood first act. Available at: < http://www.leg.bc.ca/39th1st/1st_read/gov09-1.htm>.

48.

Parry-Husbands

and Parker

2014. Wood naturally better: media advertising & consumer research. Available at: < http://www.fwpa.com.au/images/webinars/FWPA-Webinar-presentation-Final.pdf>.

49.

Passer

, Cresnik

, Schulter

and Maydl

2007. Life Cycle Assessment of buildings comparing structural steelwork with other construction techniques. Available at: < http://www.lcm2007.org/paper/300.pdf>.

50.

Robertson

A. B.

, Lam

F. C.

and Cole

R. J.

2012. A comparative cradle-to-gate lifecycle assessment of mid-rise office building construction alternatives: Laminated timber or reinforced concrete. Buildings. 2(3): 245–270.

51.

Sagheb

, Vafaeihosseini

and Ramancharla

P. K.

2011. The role of building construction materials on global warming: lessons for architects. In: National Conference on Recent Trends in Civil Mechanical Engineering. Available at: < www.researchgate.net%2Fprofile%2FPradeep_Ramancharla%2Fpublication%2F269031946_The_Role_of_Building_Construction_Materials_on_Global_Warming_Lessons_for_Architect>.

52.

Snell

and Fairbrother

2011. Toward a theory of union environmental politics: unions and climate action in Australia. Labour Statistics Journal. 36(1): 83–103.

53.

Snell

, Fairbrother

and Hart

2009. Blue-green alliances: Union capacities and prospects as environmental actors. Paper presented: The Annual Conference of the Australian Sociological Association, Canberra. Available at: < http://www.tasa.org.au/conferences/conferencepapers09/papers/Snell,%20Darryn%20and%20Fairbrother,%20Peter.pdf>.

54.

Sustainable Forestry Initiative . 2009. Australia's green star program accepts FSC and PEFC. Available at: < http://sfiprogram.org/newsroom/?p = 216>.

55.

Thompson

and Kelly

2007. Australia's forest industry in the year 2020. Australia: Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.

56.

Timber Development Association . 2013. Environmentally credentials. Available at: < http://www.woodsolutions.com.au/Why-Wood/Environmental-Credentials/>.

57.

Tufts

2011. Climate change and labour union strategy in the accommodation sector: opportunities and contradictions. Available at: < http://warming.apps01.yorku.ca/wp-content/uploads/WP_S.-Tufts_Feb-2011-AIRAANZ_.pdf>.

58.

Van De Kuilen

J. W. G.

, Ceccotti

, Xia

and He

2011. Very tall wooden buildings with cross laminated timber. Procedia Engineering. 14: 1621–1628.

59.

Van De Kuilen

J. W. G.

, Ceccotti

, Xia

, He

and Li

2010. Wood concrete skyscrapers. World Timber Engineering Conference. Available at: < http://www.ewpa.com/Archive/2010/june/Paper_492.pdf>.

60.

Walsh

2013. Lend Lease's wooden Forte in Melbourne Docklands reaches halfway sales point. Available at: < http://www.propertyobserver.com.au/design/lend-lease-s-wooden-forte-in-melbourne-docklands-reaches-halfway-sales-point>.

61.

Yates

, Linegar

and Dujic

2008. Design of an 8 storey residential tower from KLH cross laminated solid timber panels. Available at: < http://www.ewpa.com/Archive/2008/june/Paper_299.pdf>.