Objectives: To obtain information regarding the involvement of pre-registration house officers (PRHOs) in the discussions on bad news, and the competency and difficulties they perceive in clinical practice. Design: Structured telephone interviews. Participants: 104 PRHOs. Main outcome measures: Information about frequency and quality of involvement of PRHOs in discussions on bad news with patients and relatives, perceived competency and difficulties related to this task as well as ethical views concerning the disclosure of bad news. Results: 82 PRHOs (78.9%) had initiated the breaking of bad news to a patient at least once, whilst patients themselves had initiated discussions of bad news by asking the doctors questions (92.3%). Almost all (96.2%), indicated that they had broken bad news to relatives of a patient. The majority of the junior doctors participating in our study felt fairly or very confident (90.4%) to break bad news. ‘Often’ quoted difficulties for over a fifth of the sample included ‘Thinking I was not the appropriate person to discuss the bad news', ‘Having all the relevant information available’, ‘Dealing with emotions of patient/ relative’, ‘Lack of privacy’ and ‘Patients/relatives do not speak English’. Although 99 PRHOs (95.2%) believed that patients should be informed about a serious life threatening illness, 30.8% of the participants stated that doctors need to judge whether or not to tell a patient bad news. Factors most frequently selected by the PRHOs from a given list of possible factors contributing to a gap between theory and practice included problems with the organization of clinics (73.1%), insufficient postgraduate training (63.5%) and lack of staff (54.8%). Conclusions: The results indicate that PRHOs are frequently involved in the breaking of bad news. Whilst no claims can be made for their actual performance in practice, their perceptions of competency would indicate that the extensive and compulsory undergraduate teaching they had received on this subject has served to prepare them for this difficult task. Organizational and structural aspects need to be taken into account as factors assisting or undermining doctors in their efforts to put into practice ethically sound and skilled communication when disclosing bad news.
Baile WF , Buckman R , Lenzi R , Glober G , Beale EA , Kudelka AP . SPIKES – A six-step protocol for delivering bad news: application to the patient with cancer . Oncologist2000; 5: 302–311 .
2.
Fallowfield L . Giving sad and bad news . Lancet1993; 341: 476–478 .
3.
Meredith C , Symonds P , Webster L , Lamont D , Pyper E , Gillis CR et al. Information needs of cancer patients in west Scotland: cross sectional survey of patients' views . BMJ1996; 313: 724–776 .
4.
Cassileth BR , Zupkis RV , Sutton-Smith K , March V . Information and participation preferences among cancer patients . Ann Intern Med1980; 92: 832–836 .
5.
Novack DH , Plumer R , Smith RL , Ochitill H , Morrow GR , Bennett JM . Changes in physicians' attitudes towards telling cancer patient . JAMA1979; 241: 897–900 .
6.
Maguire P , Pitceathly C . Key communication skills and how to acquire them . BMJ2002; 325: 697–700 .
7.
Fallowfield L , Jenkins V , Farewell V , Saul J , Duffy A , Eves R . Efficacy of a cancer research UK communication skills training model for oncologists: a randomised controlled trial . Lancet2002; 23: 650–656 .
8.
Schildmann J , Vollmann J . Die Ausbildung kommunikativer Fähigkeiten in der Medizin: eine empirische Übersicht . Z Pallmed2001; 2: 99–106 .
9.
Ong LM , de Haes JC , Hoos AM , Lammes FB . Doctor–patient communication: a review of the literature . Soc Sci Med1995; 40: 903–918 .
10.
Ramirez AJ , Graham J , Richards MA , Cull A , Gregory WM . Mental health of hospital consultants: the effects of stress and satisfaction at work . Lancet1996; 347: 724–728 .
11.
Fallowfield L . An unmerciful end. Decisions not to resuscitate must not be left to junior doctors . BMJ2001; 323: 1131–1131 .
12.
Herzler M , Franze T , Dietze F , Asadullah K . Dealing with the issue ‘care of the dying’ in medical education – results of a survey of 592 European physicians . Med Educ2000; 34: 146–147 .
13.
Charlton R , Smith G . Perceived skills in palliative medicine of newly qualified doctors in the UK . J Palliat Care2000; 16: 27–32 .
14.
Dent THS , Gillard JH , Aarons EJ , Crimlisk HL , Smyth-Pigott PJ . Pre-registration house officers in the four Thames regions: 1. Survey of education and workload . BMJ1990; 300: 713–715 .
15.
General Medical Council . Tomorrow's doctors. Recommendations on undergraduate medical education. London: General Medical Council , 1993.
16.
Hargie O , Dickson D , Boohan M , Hughes K . A survey of communication skills training in UK schools of medicine: present practices and prospective proposals . Med Educ1998; 32: 25–34 .
17.
Cushing AM , Jones A . Evaluation of breaking bad news course for medical students . Med Educ1995; 29: 430–435 .
18.
Ptacek JT , Eberhardt TL . Breaking bad news. A review of the literature . JAMA1996; 276: 496–502 .
19.
Fallowfield L , Jenkins V . Communicating sad, bad, and difficult news in medicine . Lancet2004; 363: 312–319 .
20.
Bandura A . Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral change . Psychol Rev1977; 84: 191–215 .
21.
General Medical Council . Seeking patients' consent: the ethical considerations. London: General Medical Council , 1998.
22.
Schildmann J , Cushing AM , Doyal L , Vollmann J . Informed consent in clinical practice: Pre Registration House Officers' knowledge, difficulties and the need for postgraduate training. In production.
23.
Doyal L . Closing the gap between professional teaching and practice . BMJ2001; 322: 685–686 .
24.
Sherwood SJ , Start RD , Birdi KS , Cotton DW , Bunce D . How do clinicians learn to request permission for autopsies?Med Educ1995; 29: 231–234 .
25.
Abel J , Dennison S , Senior-Smith G , Dolley T , Lovett J , Cassidy S . Breaking bad news – development of a hospital-based training workshop . Lancet Oncol2001; 2: 380–384 .
26.
General Medical Council . Implementing the new doctor. London: General Medical Council , 2002.
