Mineral deficiency and the presence of Pinus sylvestris on mires during the mid- to late Holocene: palaeoecological data from Cadogan's Bog,Mizen Peninsula,Co. Cork,southwest Ireland
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online January, 2004
Mineral deficiency and the presence of Pinus sylvestris on mires during the mid- to late Holocene: palaeoecological data from Cadogan's Bog,Mizen Peninsula,Co. Cork,southwest Ireland
Pollen records across parts of Ireland, England and northern Scotland show a dramatic collapse in Pinus pollen percentages at approximately 4000 radiocarbon years BP. This phenomenon has attracted much palaeoecological interest and several hypotheses have been put forward to account for this often synchronous and rapid reduction in pine from mid-Holocene woodland. Explanations for the ‘pine decline’ include prehistoric human activity, climatic change, in particular a substantial increase in precipitation resulting in increased mire wetness, and airborne pollution associated with the deposition of tephra. Hitherto, one largely untested hypothesis is that mineral deficiency could adversely affect pine growth and regeneration on mire surfaces. The discovery of pine-tree remains (wood pieces, stumps and trunks) within a peat located at Cadogan's Bog on the Mizen Peninsula, southwest Ireland, provided an opportunity to investigate the history of Pinus sylvestris and also to assess the importance of mineral nutrition in maintaining pine growth on mires. Pollen, plant macrofossils, microscopic charcoal and geochemical data are presented from a radiocarbon dated monolith extracted from this peat together with tree ring-width data and radiocarbon dated age estimates from subfossil wood. Analyses of these data suggest that peat accumulation commenced at the site around 6000 years BP when pine was the dominant local tree. Thereafter Pinus pollen percentages diminish in two stages, with the second decline taking place around 4160 6 50 years BP. Concomitant with this decline in Pinus pollen, there is a noticeable, short-lived increase in wet-loving mire taxa and a decrease in the concentration of phosphorus, potassium, magnesium, calcium, sodium, iron and zinc. These results suggest that increased mire surface wetness, possibly the result of a change in climate, created conditions unsuitable for pine growth c. 4000 years BP. Mire surface wetness, coupled with a period of associated nutrient deficiency, appears to be a possible explanation for a lack of subsequent pine-seedling establishment for most of the later Holocene.
Ammann, B. and Wick, L.1993: Analysis of fossil stomata of conifers as indicators of the alpine treeline fluctuations during the Holocene . Palaeoclimate Research9, 175–185 .
2.
Anderson, D.E.1995: An abrupt mid-Holocene decline in Pinus sylvestris in Glen Torridon, north west Scotland: implications for climate change. Research paper no. 52, School of Geography, Oxford University .
3.
Anderson, D.E. , Binney, H.A. and Smith, M.A.1998: Evidence for abrupt climatic change in northern Scotland between 3900 and 3500 calendar years BP . The Holocene8, 97–103 .
4.
Andrew, R.1984: A practical pollen guide to the British Flora, Technical guide 1. Cambridge: Quaternary Research Association .
5.
Baillie, M.G.L. and Pilcher, J.R.1973: A simple cross-dating program for tree-ring research . Tree-Ring Bulletin33, 7–14 .
6.
Barber, K.E.1976: History of vegetation. In Chapman, S.B. , editor, Methods in plant ecology. Oxford: Blackwell , 5–83.
7.
Barber, K.E. , Chambers, F.M. and Maddy, D.1994: Sensitive high-resolution records of Holocene palaeoclimate from ombrotrophic peat bogs. In Funnell, B.M. and Kay, R.L.F. , editors, Palaeoclimate of the last glacial/interglacial cycle, Swindon: NERC Earth Sciences Directorate Special Publication no. 94/2 , 57–60.
8.
Barnekow, L.1999: Holocene tree-line dynamics and inferred climatic changes in the Abisko area, northern Sweden, based on macrofossil and pollen records . The Holocene9, 253–267 .
9.
Barnosky, C.W.1988: A Late-Glacial and Post-Glacial pollen record from the Dingle Peninsula, County Kerry . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy88B, 23–35 .
10.
Beltman, B. , Kooijman, A.M. , Rouwenhorst, G. and van Kerkhoven, M.1996: Nutrient availability and plant growth limitation in blanket mires in Ireland . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, 96B, 77–87 .
11.
Beltman, B. , Rouwenhorst, G. , Whilde, A. and Ten Cate, M.1992: Chemical composition of rain in western Ireland . Irish Naturalists' Journal24, 267–275 .
12.
Bennett, K.D.1984: The post-glacial history of Pinus sylvestris in the British Isles . Quaternary Science Reviews3, 133–155 .
13.
Bennett, K.D. , Whittington, G. and Edwards, K.J.1994: Recent plant nomenclatural changes and pollen morphology in the British Isles . Quaternary Newsletter73, 1–6 .
14.
Benninghoff, W.S.1962: Calculation of pollen and spore density in sediments by addition of exotic pollen in known quantities . Pollen et Spores4, 332–333 .
15.
Birks, H.H.1975: Studies in the vegetational history of Scotland. IV. Pine stumps in Scottish blanket peats . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society270B, 182–226 .
16.
Birks, H.H. , Vorren, K.-D. and Birks, H.J.B.1996: Holocene treelines, dendrochronology and palaeoclimate . Palaeoclimate Research20, 1–18 .
17.
Birks, H.J.B.1989: Holocene isochrone maps and patterns of tree-spreading in the British Isles . Journal of Biogeography16, 503–540 .
18.
Boyer, M.H.L. and Wheeler, B.D.1989: Vegetation patterns in spring-fed calcareous fens: calcite precipitation and constraints on fertility . Journal of Ecology77, 597–609 .
19.
Blackford, J.J. , Edwards, K.J. , Dugmore, A.J. , Cook, G.T. , Buckland, P.C.1992: Icelandic volcanic ash and the mid-Holocene Scots Pine (Pinus sylvestris) pollen decline in northern Scotland . The Holocene2, 260–265 .
20.
Bradshaw, R.H.W. and Browne, P.1987: Changing patterns in the post-glacial distribution of Pinus sylvestris in Ireland . Journal of Biogeography14, 237–248 .
21.
Brække, F.H.1977: Fertilization for balanced mineral nutrition of forests on nutrient-poor peatland . Suo28, 53–61 .
22.
Brække, F.H.1987: Nutrient relationships in forest stands: effects of drainage and fertilization on surface peat layers . Forest Ecology and Management21, 269–284 .
23.
Bridge, M.C. , Haggart, B.A. and Lowe, J.J.1990: The history and palaeoclimatic significance of subfossil remains of Pinus sylvestris in blanket peats from Scotland . Journal of Ecology78, 77–99 .
24.
Burke, W.1975: Fertilizer and other chemical losses in drainage water from blanket bog . Irish Journal of Agricultural Research14, 163–178 .
25.
Carey, M.L. and Hendrick, E.1986: Lodgepole pine in the Republic of Ireland I. Site types, ground preparation, and nutrition . Forest Ecology and Management15, 301–317 .
26.
Carlisle, A. and Brown, A.H.F.1968: Pinus sylvestris L . Journal of Ecology56, 269–307 .
27.
Caseldine, C. , Hatton, J. , Huber, U. , Chiverrell, R. and Woolley, N.1998: Assessing the impact of volcanic activity on mid-Holocene climate in Ireland: the need for replicate data . The Holocene8, 105–111 .
28.
Charman, D.J.1992: Blanket mire formation at the Cross Lochs, Sutherland, northern Scotland . Boreas21, 53–72 .
29.
Charman, D.J. , West, S. , Kelly, A. and Grattan, J.P.1995: Environmental change and tephra deposition: the Strath of Kildonan, Northern Scotland . Journal of Archaeological Science22, 799–809 .
30.
Clark, R.L.1982: Point count estimation of charcoal in pollen preparations and thin sections of sediments . Pollen et Spores24, 523–535 .
31.
Cooney, T.1996: Vegetation changes associated with Late-Neolithic copper mining in Killarney. In Delaney, C. and Coxon, P. , editors, Central Kerry. Field Guide no. 20, Dublin: Irish Association for Quaternary Studies , 28–32.
32.
Dodson, J.R. 1990: The Holocene vegetation of a prehistorically inhabited valley, Dingle, Co. Kerry . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 90B, 151–173 .
33.
Dodson, J.R. and Bradshaw, R.H.W.1987: A history of vegetation and fire, 6000 BP to present, County Sligo . Boreas16, 113–123 .
34.
Doughty, J.L.1930. Phosphate fixation by a peat soil . Soil Science84, 133–144 .
35.
Dubois, A.D. and Ferguson, D.K.1985: The climatic history of pine in the Cairngorms based on radiocarbon dates and stable isotope analysis, with an account of the events leading up to its colonisation . Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology46, 55–80 .
36.
Dupont, L.M.1986: Temperature and rainfall variation in the Holocene based on comparative palaeoecology and isotope geology of a hummock and a hollow from Bourtangerveen, The Netherlands . Review of Palaeo-botany and Palynology48, 71–159 .
37.
Dwyer, R.B. and Mitchell, F.J.G.1997: Investigation of the environmental impact of remote volcanic activity on north Mayo, Ireland, during the mid-Holocene . The Holocene7, 113–118 .
38.
Edwards, K.J.1981: The separation of Corylus and Myrica pollen in modern and fossil samples . Pollen et Spores22, 205–218 .
39.
Ellis, C.J. and Tallis, J.H.2000: Climatic control of blanket mire development at Kentra Moss, north-west Scotland . Journal of Ecology88, 869–889 .
40.
Faegri, K. , Kaland, P.E. and Krzywinski, K.1989: Textbook of pollen analysis (fourth edition). Chichester: Wiley .
41.
Field, M.H. , de Beaulieu, J.-L. , Guiot, J. and Ponel, P.2000: Middle Pleistocene deposits at La Côte, Val-de-Lans, Isère department, France: plant macrofossil, palynological and fossil insect investigations . Palaeo-geography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology159, 53–83 .
42.
Fossitt, J. 1994: Late-glacial and Holocene vegetational history of western Donegal, Ireland . Biology and Environment: Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 94B, 1–31 .
43.
Foster, I.D.L. , Dearing, J.D. , Charlesworth, S.M. and Kelly, I.A.1987: Paired lake catchment studies: a framework for investigating chemical fluxes in small drainage basins . Applied Geography7, 115–133 .
44.
Gear, A. and Huntley, B.1991: Rapid changes in the range limits of Scots Pine 4000 years ago . Science251, 544–547 .
45.
Görres, M. and Frenzel, B.1997: Ash and metal concentrations in peat bogs as indicators of anthropogenic activity . Water, Air and Soil Pollution100, 355–365 .
46.
Grimm, E.1991–93: TILIA and TILIA.GRAPH. Illinois: Illinois State Museum .
47.
Hall, V.A. , Pilcher, J.R. and McCormac, F.G.1994: Icelandic volcanic ash and the mid-Holocene Scots Pine (Pinus sylvestris) decline in the north of Ireland: no correlation . The Holocene4, 79–83 .
48.
Hall, V.A. , Pilcher, J.R. and McCormac, F.G.1996: Hekla-4 ash, the pine decline in Northern Ireland and the effective use of tephra isochrones: a reply to Edwards, Dugmore, Buckland, Blackford and Cook . The Holocene6, 496-496 .
49.
Heathwaite, A.L.1990: The effect of drainage on nutrient release from fen peat and its implications for water quality – a laboratory simulation . Water, Air, and Soil Pollution49, 159–173 .
50.
Heathwaite, A.L. and Göttich, Kh.1993: Mires: process, exploitation and conservation. Chichester: Wiley .
51.
Hesse, P.R.1971: A textbook of soil chemical analysis. London: Murray .
52.
Hirons, K.R.1983: Percentage and accumulation rate pollen diagrams from east Co. Tyrone. In Reeves-Smyth, T. and Hammond, F. , editors, Landscape archaeology in Ireland, Oxford: British Archaeological Report , British Series, 116, 95–117.
53.
Hudson, H.J.1986: Fungal biology. London: Arnold .
54.
Huntley, B. and Birks, H.J.B.1983: An atlas of past and present pollen maps for Europe: 0–13000 years BP. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
55.
Ingestad, T.1962: Macro element nutrition of pine, spruce, and birch seedlings in nutrient solutions . Meedn St. SkogsforskInst. 51, 1–50 .
56.
Kaila, A.1959: Retention of phosphate by peat samples . Journal of the Scientific Agricultural Society of Finland31, 215–225 .
57.
Kaunisto, S. , Moilanen, M. and Issakainen, J.1999: Effect of apatite and phlogopite application on the needle concentrations of Pinus sylvestris (L.) on drained pine mires . Suo50, 1–15 .
58.
Lageard, J.G.A. , Chambers, F.M. and Thomas, P.A.1999: Climatic significance of the marginalization of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) c. 2500 bc at White Moss, south Cheshire, UK . The Holocene9, 321–331 .
59.
Lageard, J.G.A. , Thomas, P.A. and Chambers, F.M.2000: Using fire scars and growth release in subfossil Scots pine to reconstruct prehistoric fires . Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology164, 87–99 .
60.
Little, D.J. , Mitchell, F.J.G. , von Engelbrechten, S.S. and Farrell, E.P.1996: Assessment of the impact of past disturbance and prehistoric Pinus sylvestris on vegetation dynamics and soil development in Uragh Wood, S.W. Ireland . The Holocene6, 90–99 .
61.
Livett, E.A.1988: Geochemical monitoring of atmospheric heavy metal pollution: theory and application . Advances in Ecological Research18, 65–177 .
62.
Lynch, A.1981: Man and environment in S.W. Ireland. Oxford: British Archaeological Report , British Series 85.
63.
Malcolm, D.C. and Cuttle, S.P.1983a: The application of fertilizers to drained peat. 1. Nutrient losses in drainage . Forestry56, 155–174 .
64.
Malcolm, D.C. and Cuttle, S.P.1983b: The application of fertilizers to drained peat. 2. Uptake by vegetation and residual distribution in peat . Forestry56, 175–183 .
65.
Mallik, A.U. , Gimingham, C.H. and Rahman, A.A.1984: Ecological effects of heather burning. I water infiltration, moisture retention and porosity of the surface soil . Journal of Ecology72, 767–776 .
66.
Malmer, N. and Sjörs, H.1955: Some determinations of elementary constituents in mire plants and peat . Botaniska Notiser108, 46–80 .
67.
McAulay, I.R. and Watts, W.A.1961: Dublin radiocarbon dates. I . Radiocarbon3, 26–38 .
68.
McNally, A. and Doyle, G.J. 1984: A study of subfossil pine layers in a raised bog complex in the Irish Midlands. I. Palaeowoodland extent and dynamics . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 84B, 57–70 .
69.
McVean, D.N.1963a: Ecology of Scots pine in the Scottish highlands . Journal of Ecology51, 671–686 .
70.
McVean, D.N.1963b: Growth and mineral nutrition of Scots pine seedlings on some common peat types . Journal of Ecology51, 657–670 .
71.
Mighall, T.M. and Lageard, J.G.A.1999: The prehistoric environment. In O'Brien, W.F. , editor, Sacred ground: megalithic tombs in coastal south-west Ireland, Bronze Age Studies 4, Galway: National University of Ireland , 41–59.
72.
Miller, H.G. , Cooper, J.M. and Miller, J.D.1992: Response of pole-stage Sitka spruce to applications of fertilizer nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in upland Britain . Forestry65, 15–33 .
73.
Mitchell, F.J.G.1988: The vegtational history of the Killarney Oakwoods, SW Ireland: evidence from fine spatial resolution pollen analysis . Journal of Ecology76, 415–436 .
74.
Mitchell, F.J.G.1996: Vegetation history of the Killarney Valley: an overview. In Delaney, C. and Coxon, P. , editors, Central Kerry. Field guide no. 20, Dublin: Irish Association for Quaternary Studies , 23–26.
75.
Mitchell, G.F. 1956: Post-Boreal pollen diagrams from Irish raised bogs . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 57B, 185–251 .
76.
Moore, P.D. , Webb, J.A. and Collinson, M.E.1991: Pollen analysis (second edition). London: Blackwell Scientific Publications .
77.
Mörnsjö, T.1968: Stratigraphical and chemical studies on two peatlands on Scania, South Sweden . Botaniska Notiser121, 343–360 .
78.
Munro, M.A.R.1984: An improved algorithm for crossdating tree-ring series . Tree-Ring Bulletin44, 17–27 .
79.
Nieminen, M. and Jarva, M.1996: Phosphorus adsorption by peat from drained mires in southern Finland . Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research11, 321–326 .
80.
Nilssen, E. and Vorren, K.D.1991: Peat humification and climate history . Norsk Geologisk Tiddskrift71, 215–217 .
81.
O'Brien, W.F.1994: Mount Gabriel: Bronze Age mining in Ireland. Bronze Age Studies 3, Galway: National University of Ireland .
82.
O'Brien, W.F.1999: Sacred ground: megalithic tombs in coastal south-west Ireland. Bronze Age Studies 4. Galway: National University of Ireland .
83.
O'Carroll, N. and McCarthy, R.1973: Potassium supplied by precipitation and its possible role in forest nutrition . Irish Forestry30, 88–93 .
84.
O'Sullivan, A. 1991: Historical and contemporary effects of fire on the native woodland vegetation of Killarney, S.W. Ireland. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Dublin (Trinity College).
85.
Ohlson, M. and Dahlberg, B.1991: Rate of peat increment in hummock and lawn communities on Swedish mires during the last 150 years . Oikos61, 369–378 .
86.
Paarlahti, K. , Reinikainen, A. and Veijalainen, H.1971. Nutritional diagnosis of Scots pine stands by needle and peat analysis . Communicationes Instituti Forestalis Fenniae75, 1–58 .
87.
Paavilainen, E.1984: Nitrogen and micronutrients in the refertilization of drained pine swamps . Folia Forestalia Helsinki589, 1–28 .
88.
Pakarinen, P. and Tolonen, K.1977: Distribution of lead in Finnish Sphagnum fuscum profiles . Oikos28, 69–73 .
89.
Payette, S.1984: Peat inception and climate change in northern Quebec. In Mörner, N.A. and Karlén, W. , editors, Climate changes on a yearly to millennial basis, Dordrecht: Reidel , 173–179.
90.
Pilcher, J.R. , Baillie, M.G.L. , Brown, D.M. , McCormac, F.G. , MacSweeney, P.B. and McLawrence, A.S.1995: Dendrochronology of subfossil pine in the north of Ireland . Journal of Ecology83, 665–671 .
91.
Pollett, F.C. 1972: Nutrient contents of peat soils in Newfoundland . Proceedings of the 4th International Peat Congress 3, 461–468 .
92.
Reille, M.1992: Pollen et spores D'Europe et D'Afrique du Nord. Editions du Laboratoire de botanique historique et palynologie. Marseille: Laboratoire de Botanique historique et Palynologie .
93.
Ross, S.1988: The use of peat chemistry to interpret past wetland environments. In Murphy, P. and French, C. , editors, The exploitation of wetlands, Oxford: British Archaeological Report(British Series) 186, 25–43.
94.
Shotyk, W.1988: Review of the inorganic geochemistry of peats and peatland waters . Earth Science Reviews25, 95–176 .
95.
Shotyk, W.1996: Peat bog archives of atmospheric metal deposition: geo-chemical evaluation of peat profiles, natural variations in metal concentrations, and metal enrichment factors . Environmental Reviews4, 149–183 .
96.
Shotyk, W. , Nesbitt, W. and Fyfe, W.S.1992: Natural and anthropogenic enrichments of trace metals in peat profiles . International Journal of Coal Geology20, 49–84 .
97.
Silfverberg, K. and Hartman, M.1999: Effects of different phosphorus fertilizers on the nutrient status and growth of Scots pine stands on drained peatlands . Silva Fennica33, 187–206 .
98.
Stace, C.1991: New flora of the British Isles. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
99.
Stewart, C. and Fergusson, J.E.1994: The use of peat in the historical monitoring of trace metals in the atmosphere . Environmental Pollution86, 243–249 .
100.
Stockmarr, J.1971: Tablets with spores used in absolute pollen analysis . Pollen et Spores13, 615–621 .
101.
Stuiver, M. and Reimer, P.J.1993: A computer program for radiocarbon age calibration . Radiocarbon35, 215–230 .
102.
Stuiver, M. , Reimer, P.J. , Bard, E. , Beck, J.W. , Burr, G.S. , Hughen, K.A. , Kromer, B. , McCormac, F.G. , van der Plicht, J. and Spurk, M.1998: INTCAL98 radiocarbon age calibration 24,000–0 cal BP . Radio-carbon40, 1041–1083 .
103.
Tallis, J.H. and Switsur, V.R.1983: Forest and moorland in the South Pennine uplands in the mid-Flandrian period . Journal of Ecology71, 585–600 .
104.
Telford, M.B. 1977: Glenveagh National Park: the past and present vegetation. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Dublin (Trinity College).
105.
Timpany, S. 2001: Palaeoecological changes during the Holocene on the Mizen Peninsula, southwest Ireland. Unpublished MSc thesis, Coventry University.
106.
Trautmann, W.1953: Zur Unterscheidung fossiler Spaltöffnungen der mitteleuropaïschen Coniferen . Flora140, 523–533 .
107.
Troels-Smith, J.1955: Characterisation of unconsolidated sediments. Danmarks Geologiske UnderspgeoseSeries IV(3), 73-73 pp.
108.
Turner, J.1970: Surface sample analyses from Ayrshire, Scotland . Pollen et Spores6, 583–592 .
109.
Tyers, I.1999: Dendro for windows programme guide (second edition). Archaeological Research and Consultancy at the University of Sheffield (ARCUS) report 500, University of Sheffield .
110.
Vokes, E. 1966: The Late and Post-Glacial vegetational history of Killarney, Co. Kerry in south-west Ireland. Unpublished MSc thesis, University of Dublin (Trinity College).
111.
Walsh, T. and Barry, T.A. 1958: The chemical composition of some Irish peats . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 59, 305–328 .
112.
Watts, W.A.1984: The Holocene vegetation of the Burren, western Ireland. In Haworth, E.Y. and Lund, J.W.G. , editors, Lake sediments and environmental history, Leicester: Leicester University Press , 359–376.
113.
Waughman, G.J.1980: Chemical aspects of the ecology of some South German peatlands . Journal of Ecology68, 1025–1046 .
114.
Wells, E.D. and Miller, H.G.1994: Effects of refertilization on growth and nutrition of Lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta Dougl.) planted on a minerotrophic peatland in Central Newfoundland . Forestry67, 149–164 .
115.
Wilkins, D.A.1984: The Flandrian Woods of Lewis (Scotland) . Journal of Ecology72, 251–258 .
