We investigate methods for identifying groups of patients with different prognosis. Our focus is on procedures that yield interpretable descriptions for groups of patients and corresponding regions of the predictor space. These strategies include tree-based methods and techniques which construct a single prognostic group through ‘peeling’ or refining of a larger group patients. The peeling methods are relatively new and are developed in detail. Simulations and examples for describing groups of patients with poor outcomes using data from a clinical trial for patients with multiple myeloma are presented.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Breiman L , Friedman JH , Olshen RA , Stone CJ.Classification and regression trees. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth , 1984.
2.
Gordon L , Olshen RA.Tree-structured survival analysis . Cancer Treatment Reports1985; 69: 1065-1069 .
3.
Davis R , Anderson J.Exponential survival trees . Statistics in Medicine1987; 8: 947-962 .
4.
Ciampi A , Hogg S , McKinney S , Thiffaut J.RECPAM: a computer program for recursive partition and amalgamation for censored survival data . Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine1988; 26: 239-256 .
5.
Segal MR.Regression trees for censored data . Biometrics1988; 44: 35-48 .
6.
LeBlanc M , Crowley J.Survival trees by goodness of split . Journal of the American Statistical Association1993; 88: 457-467 .
7.
Friedman J , Fisher N.Bump hunting in high dimensional data (with discussion) . Computing and Statistics1999; 9: 123-162 .
8.
Hastie T , Tibshirani R.Generalized additive models. London: Chapman and Hall , 1990.
9.
Gentleman R , Crowley J.Local full likelihood estimation for the proportional hazards model . Biometrics1991; 47: 1283-1296 .
10.
Crowley J , LeBlanc M , Jacobson J , Salmon S.Some exploratory tools for the analysis of survival data. In: The first seattle symposium in biostatistics: survival analysis. Lecture Notes in Statistics. New York: Springer , 1997, pp. 199-229.
11.
Kooperberg C , Stone CJ , Truong YK.Hazard regression . Journal of the American Statistical Association1995; 90: 78-94 .
12.
LeBlanc M , Crowley J.Adaptive regression splines in the Cox Model . Biometrics1999; 55: 204-213 .
13.
Ohno-Machado L , Musen MA.Sequential versus standard neural networks for pattern recognition: an example using the domain of coronary heart disease . Computational Biology and Medicine1997; 27: 267-281 .
14.
Ravdin PM , Clark GM , Hilsenbeck SG , Owens MA , Vendely P , Pandian MR , McGuire WL.A demonstration that breast cancer recurrence can be predicted by neural network analysis . Breast Cancer Research and Treatment1992; 21: 47-53 .
15.
Faraggi D , Simon R.A neural network model for survival data . Statistics in Medicine1994; 14: 73-82 .
16.
Faraggi D , LeBlanc M , Crowley J.Understanding neural networks using regression trees: An application to survival data . Statistics in Medicine2001; 20: 2965-2976 .
17.
Crowley J , LeBlanc M , Gentleman R , Salmon S.Exploratory methods in survival analysis . IMS Lecture Notes1995; 27: 55-77 .
18.
Cox DR.Regression models and life-tables . Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B1972; 34: 187-220 .
19.
Shipp MA , Harrington DPet al.A predictive model for aggressive Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma . New England Journal of Medicine1993; 329: 987-994 .
20.
LeBlanc M , Crowley J.Step-function covariate effects in the proportional-hazards model . Canadian Journal of Statistics1995; 23: 109-129 .
Salmon SE , Tesh D , Crowley J , Saeed S , Finley P , Milder M , Knost JA , Samhouri A , Beckord J , Stock-Novack D.Chemotherapy is superior to sequential hemibody irradiation for remission consolodation in multiple myeloma: A southwest oncology group study . Journal of Clinical Oncology1990; 8: 1575-1584 .
23.
Efron B , Tibshirani R.Improvements on cross-validation: the 0.632 bootstrap . Journal of the American Statistical Association1997; 92: 548-560 .
24.
Salmon SE , Crowley J , Grogan TM , Finley P , Pugh RP , Barlogie B.Combination chemotherapy glucocorticoids, and interferon alpha in the treatment of multiple myeloma: A southwest oncology group study . Journal of Clinical Oncology1994; 12: 2405-2414 .
25.
Ruczinski I , Kooperberg C , LeBlanc M.Logic regression . Journal of Computational Graphics and Statistics2002 (in press).
