This article reports a survey of nurses in different cultural settings to reveal their perceptions of ethical role responsibilities relevant to nursing practice. Drawing on the Confucian theory of ethics, the first section attempts to understand nursing ethics in the context of multiple role relationships. The second section reports the administration of the Role Responsibilities Questionnaire (RRQ) to a sample of nurses in China (n = 413), the USA (n = 163), and Japan (n = 667). Multidimensional preference analysis revealed the patterns of rankings given by the nurses to the statements they considered as important ethical responsibilities. The Chinese nurses were more virtue based in their perception of ethical responsibilities, the American nurses were more principle based, and the Japanese nurses were more care based. The findings indicate that the RRQ is a sensitive instrument for outlining the embedded sociocultural factors that influence nurses’ perceptions of ethical responsibilities in the realities of nursing practice. This study could be important in the fostering of partnerships in international nursing ethics.
Davis AJ.Are there limits to caring? Conflict between autonomy and beneficence. In: Leininger MM ed. Ethical and moral dimensions of care. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press , 1990: 25-32.
2.
MacPherson KI.A new perspective on nursing and caring in a corporate context . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1989; 11(4): 32-39 .
3.
Haylock PJ.Health policy and legislation: impact on cancer nursing and care . Semin Oncol Nurs2000; 16: 76-84 .
Mohr WK , Horton-Deutsh S.Malfeasance and regaining nursing’s moral voice and integrity . Nurs Ethics2001; 8: 19-35 .
6.
Guo ZJ.Chinese Confucian culture and the medical ethical tradition . J Med Ethics1995; 21: 239-246 .
7.
Cong YL.Ethical challenges in critical care medicine: a Chinese perspective . J Med Philos1998; 23: 581-600 .
8.
Pang MCS , Wong KST.Cultivating a moral sense of nursing through model emulation . Nurs Ethics1998; 5: 424-440 .
9.
Du ZZ.On the development of teachers of medical ethics in China . Hastings Cent Rep2000; 30(4): S37-S40 .
10.
Pang MCS.Nursing ethics in modern China: conflicting values and competing role requirements. (Value Inquiry Book Series.) Amsterdam: Rodopi , 2003.
11.
Minami H.East meets West: some ethical considerations . Int J Nurs Stud1985; 22: 311-318 .
12.
Tierney MJ , Minarik PA , Tierney LM.Ethics in Japanese health care: a perspective for clinical nurse specialists . Clin Nurse Specialist1994; 8: 235-240 .
13.
Hoshino K.Autonomous decision making and Japanese tradition . Cambr Q Healthc Ethics1995; 4: 71-74 .
14.
Lock M.Death in technological time: locating the end of meaningful life . Med Anthropol Q1996; 10: 575-600 .
15.
Konishi E , Davis AJ.Japanese nurses’ perceptions about disclosure of information at the patients’ end of life . Nurs Health Sci1999; 1: 179-187 .
16.
Smith D , Inoue T , Ushikubo M , Amano S.Nursing in Japan . Austr Nurs J2001; 9(1): 39-40 .
17.
Parker RS.Nurses’ stories: the search for a relational ethic of care . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1990; 13(1): 31-40 .
18.
Söderberg A , Norberg A.Intensive care: situations of ethical difficulty . J Adv Nurs1993; 18: 2008-2014 .
19.
Davis AJ , Aroskar MA , Liaschenko J , Drought TS.Ethical dilemmas and nursing practice, fourth edition. Stamford, CT: Appleton and Lange , 1997.
20.
Wagner N , Hendel T.Ethics in pediatric nursing: an international perspective . Int Pediatr Nurs2000; 15: 54-59 .
21.
Penticuff JH , Walden M.Influence of practice environment and nurse characteristics on perinatal nurses’ responses to ethical dilemmas . Nurs Res2000; 49(2): 64-72 .
22.
Oberle K , Hughes D.Doctors’ and nurses’ perceptions of ethical problems in end-of-life decisions . J Adv Nurs2001; 33: 707-715 .
23.
Muller JH , Desmond B.Ethical dilemmas in a cross-cultural context: a Chinese example . West J Med1992; 157: 323-327 .
24.
Hern EH , Koenig BSA , Moore LJ , Marshall PA.The difference that culture can make in end-of-life decision making . Cambr Q Healthc Ethics1998; 7: 27-40 .
25.
Bowman KW , Hui EC.Bioethics for clinicians: Chinese bioethics . Can Med Assoc J2000; 163: 1481-1485 .
26.
Fu-Chang D.How should doctors approach patients? A Confucian reflection on personhood . J Med Ethics2001; 27: 44-50 .
27.
Howard CA , Andrade SJ , Byrd T.The ethical dimensions of cultural competence in border health care settings . Fam Community Health2001; 23(4): 36-49 .
28.
Jones SF , Kessel AS.The ‘redefinition of death’ debate: western concepts and western bioethics . Sci Eng Ethics2001; 7: 63-75 .
29.
Nishimoto PW , Foley J.Cultural beliefs of Asian Americans associated with terminal illness and death . Semin Oncol Nurs2001; 17: 179-189 .
30.
Giger NJ , Davidhizar R.Culturally competent care: emphasis on understanding the people of Afghanistan, Afghanistani Americans, and Islamic culture and religion . Int Nurs Rev2002; 49(2): 79-86 .
31.
Legge J (trans). Confucian analects, The Great Learning and The Doctrine of the Mean. (Chinese text; translation with exegetical notes and dictionary of all characters.) New York: Dover , 1971.
32.
Jameton A.Nursing practice: the ethical issues. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall , 1984.
33.
International Council of Nurses . Code of ethics for nurses. Geneva: ICN , 2000. Available from: URL: http://www.icn.ch [Accessed 01-May-2002]
34.
Swider SM , McElmurry BJ , Yarling RR.Ethical decision making in a bureaucratic context by senior nursing students . Nurs Res1985; 34: 108-112 .
35.
Holly C.Critical care nurses’ participation in ethical decision making . J NY State Nurs Assoc1989; 20(4): 9-12 .
36.
Davis AJ.Clinical nurses’ ethical decision making in situations of informed consent . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1989; 11(3): 63-69 .
37.
Chambliss DF.Beyond caring, hospitals, nurses, and the social organization of ethics. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press , 1996.
38.
Pang MCS. From virtue to value: nursing ethics in modern China [Thesis]. Hong Kong: University of Hong Kong, 1999.
39.
Carroll JD.Individual differences and multidimensional scaling. In: Shepard RN , Romney AK , Nerlove SB eds. Multidimensional scaling: theory and applications in the behavioral sciences, Vol. 1. New York: Seminar Press , 1972: 105-155.
40.
Carroll JD.Models and methods for multidimensional analysis of preferential choice or other dominance data. In: Lantermann ED , Feger H eds. Similarity and choice. Bern: Huber , 1980: 234-289.
41.
Cohen A , Mallows CL.Analysis of ranking data. (Bell Laboratories Technical Memorandum.) New York: Bell Laboratories , 1980.
42.
Eckart C , Young G.The approximation of one matrix by another of lower rank . Psychometrika1936; 1: 211-218 .
43.
SAS . Getting started with the market research application. Cary, NC: SAS Institute , 1997.
44.
Chan MF , Pang MCS , Yu PLH , Sawada A , Konishi N , Olsen D.The commonality and differences of China, Japan, and US nurses’ perception of their nursing role responsibilities . Proceedings of the Thirteenth International Congress on Women’s Health Issues; 2002 Jun 26-29; Daehyun-dong, Korea; 179-179 .
45.
Beauchamp TL , Childress JF.Principles of biomedical ethics, fifth edition. New York: Oxford University Press , 2001.
46.
Parson SE.Nursing problems and obligations. Boston, MA: Whitcomb and Barrows , 1916.
47.
Fowler MDM. Ethics and nursing, 1893-1984: the ideal of service, the reality of history [Thesis]. Los Angeles, CA: University of Southern California, 1984.
48.
Primomo J.Nursing around the world: Japan - preparing for the century of the elderly . Online Journal of Issues in Nursing2000, May 31. Available from: URL: http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/topic12/tpc12_1.htm [Accessed 01-May 2002]
49.
Benner P.A dialogue between virtue ethics and care ethics. In: Thomasma DC ed. The Influence of Edmund D Pellegrino’s philosophy of medicine. Dordrecht: Kluwer , 1997: 47-61.
50.
Noddings N.Caring: a feminist approach to ethics and moral education. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press , 1984.
51.
Gilligan C , Pollak S.The vulnerable and invulnerable physician. In: Gilligan C , Ward J , Taylor V , McLean J , Bardige B eds. Mapping the moral domain: a contribution of women’s thinking to psychological theory and education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press , 1988: 245-262.
52.
Fry ST , Killen AR , Robinson EM.Care-based reasoning, caring, and the ethic of care: A need for clarity . J Clin Ethics1996; 7: 41-47 .
