The purpose of this overview of published articles on decision making in paediatric care was to identify important aspects of its possible use in clinical practice and to obtain a base for future research. A literature review was undertaken utilizing snowball sampling to identify articles because of the diversity present within the area of decision making in paediatric care. The databases PubMed and CINAHL were used. The search was limited to articles published in English during the period 1994-2004. The analysis entailed a series of comparisons across articles, focusing on major areas of enquiry and patterns of results. Various levels of decision making are described because these seem to form a basis for how decisions are made. Concepts found to be of importance for decision making are described under the following headings: competence, the child’s best interests, knowledge, values and attitudes, roles and partnership, power, and economy. Further research is suggested.
National Board of Health and Welfare . Folkhälsorapport. (Health report.)Stockholm: NBHW , 2001.
2.
United Nations . Convention on the Rights of the Child. New York: UN , 1989.
3.
Beauchamp T , Childress J.Principles of biomedical ethics, fifth edition. New York: Oxford University Press , 2001.
4.
European Community . European Convention on the Exercise of Children’s Rights. (European Treaty Series/160) Strasbourg: EC , 1996.
5.
European Community . Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with Regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine. Strasbourg: EC , 1997.
6.
EACH. European Association for Children in Hospital Charter. 2000. Retrieved 19 November, 2004, from: http://www.each-for-sick-children.org/
7.
Dockrell J , Lewis A , Lindsay G.Researching children’s perspectives: a psychological dimension. In: Lewis A , Lindsay G eds. Researching children’s perspectives, second edition. Buckingham: Open University Press , 2002: 46-58.
8.
Jenkins P.Children’s rights: a participative exercise for learning about children’s rights in England and Wales. London: Longman , 1993.
9.
Winn Oakley M.Children and young people and care proceedings. In: Lewis A , Lindsay G eds. Researching children’s perspectives, second edition. Buckingham: Open University Press , 2002: 73-85.
10.
King N , Cross A.Children as decision makers: guidelines for pediatricians . J Pediatr1996; 115: 10-16 .
11.
Bijstervelt P.Competent to refuse ? Paediatr Nurs2000; 12: 33-35 .
12.
Anderson ES , Jackson A , Wailoo MP , Petersen SA.Child care decisions: parental choice or chance . Child Care Health Dev2002; 28: 391-401 .
13.
Hallström I , Runeson I , Elander G.An observational study of the level at which parents participate in decisions during their child’s hospitalization . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 202-214 .
14.
Runeson I , Hallström I , Elander G , Hermerén G.Children’s participation in the decision-making process during hospitalization: an observational study . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 583-598 .
15.
Hallström I , Elander G.Decision-making during hospitalisation: parents’ and children’s involvement . J Clin Nurs2004; 13: 367-375 .
16.
Walker NE , Doyon T.Fairness and reasonableness of the child’s decision: a proposed legal standard for children’s participation in medical decision making . Behav Sci Law2001; 19: 611-636 .
17.
Kuther TL.Medical decision-making and minors: issues of consent and assent . Adolescence2003; 38: 343-358 .
18.
Manley RS , Smye V , Srikameswaran S.Addressing complex ethical issues in the treatment of children and adolescents with eating disorders: application of a framework for ethical decision-making . Eur Eating Disord Rev2001; 9: 144-166 .
19.
Brody JL , Scherer DG , Annett RD , Pearson-Bish M.Voluntary assent in biomedical research with adolescents: a comparison of parent and adolescent views . Ethics Behav2003; 13(1): 79-95 .
20.
Lind C , Anderson B , Oberle K.Ethical issues in adolescent consent for research . Nurs Ethics2003; 10: 504-511 .
21.
Mouradian WE.Making decisions for children . Angle Orthod1999; 69: 300-305 .
22.
Wells R , Stephenson S.Decision making about medical care in an adolescent with a life-threatening illness . Pediatrics2001; 107: 979-983 .
23.
Runeson I , Enskär K , Elander G , Hermerén G.Professionals’ perceptions of children’s participation in decision making in healthcare . J Clin Nurs2001; 10: 70-78 .
24.
Harrison C , Kenny NP , Sidarous M , Rowell M.Bioethics for clinicians: 9. Involving children in medical decisions . CMAJ1997; 156: 825-828 .
25.
Runeson I , Hermerén G , Elander G , Kristensson-Hallström I.Children’s consent to treatment: using a scale to assess degree of self-determination . Pediatr Nurs2000; 26: 455-459 .
26.
Hermerén G. Kunskapens pris. (The price of knowledge), second edition. Stockholm: Humanistisk-samhällsvetenskapliga forskningsrådets förlagstjänst, 1996.
27.
Kluge E-H.Informed consent by children: the new reality . CMAJ1995; 152: 1495-1497 .
28.
Informed consent, parental permission and assent in pediatric practice. Committee on Bioethics, American Academy of Pediatrics . Pediatrics1995; 95: 314-317 .
29.
McCabe MA.Involving children and adolescents in medical decision making: developmental and clinical considerations . J Pediatr Psychol1996; 21: 505-516 .
30.
Schuman A.Parental and institutional decision making about children’s healthy development: conflicts and interests across cultures . J Immigrant Health2000; 2(1): 43-51 .
31.
Jacobs JE , Klaczynski PA.The development of judgment and decision making during childhood and adolescence . Curr Dir Psychol Sci2002; 11: 145-149 .
32.
Kristensson-Hallström I , Elander G.Parents’ experiences of hospitalization - different strategies for feeling secure . Pediatr Nurs1997; 23: 361-367 .
33.
Kristensson-Hallström I.Strategies for feeling secure influence parents’ participation in care . J Clin Nurs1999; 8: 586-592 .
34.
Tait AR , Voepel-Lewis T , Malviya S.Participation of children in clinical research: factors that influence a parent’s decision to consent . Anesthesiology2003; 99: 819-825 .
35.
Clayton M.Consent in children: legal and ethical issues . J Child Health Care2000; 4(2): 78-81 .
36.
Street K , Ashcroft R , Henderson J.The decision making process regarding the withdrawal or withholding of potential life-saving treatments in a children’s hospital . J Med Ethics2000; 26: 346-353 .
37.
Friedman Ross L.Children, families and health-care decision-making . J Med Ethics2000; 26: 1-3 .
38.
Hinds PS , Oakes L , Furman Wet al.Decision making by parents and healthcare professionals when considering continued care for pediatric patients with cancer . Oncol Nurs Forum1997; 24: 1523-1528 .
39.
Yeh C-H , Lin C-F , Tsai J-L , Lai Y-M , Ku H-C.Determinants of parental decisions on ‘drop out’ from cancer treatment for childhood cancer patients . J Adv Nurs1999; 30: 193-199 .
40.
Guerriere DN , McKeever P , Llewellyn-Thomas H , Berall G.Mothers’ decisions about gastrostomy tube insertion in children: factors contributing to uncertainty . Dev Med Child Neurol2003; 45: 470-476 .
41.
Higgins SS , Kayser-Jones J , Savedra M.Parental understanding of the consequences of pediatric cardiac transplantation . Progr Cardiovasc Nurs1996; 11(3): 10-16 .
42.
Hinds PS , Oakes L , Quargnenti Aet al.An international feasibility study of parental decision making in pediatric oncology . Oncol Nurs Forum2000; 27: 1233-1241 .
43.
Truog RD.‘Doctor, if this were your child, what would you do?’Pediatrics1999; 103: 153-154 .
44.
Kawik L.Nurses’ and parents’ perceptions of participation and partnership in caring for a hospitalised child . Br J Nurs1996; 5: 430-437 .
45.
Neill S.Parent participation. 1: Literature review and methodology . Br J Nurs1996; 5: 34-40 .
46.
Neill S.Parent participation. 2: Findings and their implications for practice . Br J Nurs1996; 5: 110-117 .
47.
Pyke-Grimm KA , Degner L , Small A , Mueller B.Preferences for participation in treatment decision making and information needs of parents of children with cancer: a pilot study . J Pediatr Oncol Nurs1999; 16: 13-24 .
48.
Blower K , Morgan E.Great expectations? Parental participation in care . J Child Health Care2000; 4(2): 60-65 .
49.
Tait AR , Voepel-Lewis T , Munro HM , Malviya S.Parents’ preferences for participation in decisions made regarding their child’s anaesthetic care . Paediatr Anaesth2001; 11: 283-290 .
50.
Brinchmann BS , Förde R , Nortvedt P.What matters to the parents? A qualitative study of parents’ experiences with life-and-death decisions concerning their premature infants . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 388-404 .
51.
Dalton JM.Development and testing of the theory of collaborative decision-making in nursing practice for triads . J Adv Nurs2003; 41: 22-33 .
52.
Lee P.Partnership in care: a critical exploration of how this may be applied to children attending the accident and emergency department . Accid Emerg Nurs1999; 7: 119-123 .
53.
Kristensson-Hallström I , Elander G.Parental participation in the care of hospitalized children . Scand J Caring Sci1994; 8: 149-154 .
54.
Tates K , Meeuwesen L.Let ‘mum have her say’: turntaking in doctor-patient-child communication . Patient Educ Couns2000; 40: 151-162 .
55.
Kirk S.Negotiating lay and professional roles in the care of children with complex health care needs . J Adv Nurs2001; 34: 593-602 .
56.
Shields L , Kristensson-Hallström I , Kristiansdottir G , Hunter J.Who owns the child in hospital? A preliminary discussion . J Adv Nurs2003; 41: 213-222 .
57.
Higgins SS , Kayser-Jones J , Savedra M.Parental understanding of consequences of pediatric cardiac transplantation . Prog Cardiovasc Nurs1996; 11(3): 10-16 .
58.
Wilson HV.Power and partnership: a critical analysis of the surveillance discourses of child health nurses . J Adv Nurs2001; 36: 294-301 .
59.
Ham C.Tragic choices in health care: lessons from the child B case . BMJ1999; 319: 1258-1262 .
60.
Kristensson-Hallström I , Norlund A , Malmfors G.Paediatric day care surgery - increased parental participation reduces costs . Eur J Public Health1999; 8: 247-249 .
61.
Foreman DM.The family rule: a framework for obtaining ethical consent for medical interventions from children . J Med Ethics1999; 25: 491-496 .
62.
Enskär K , von Essen L.Important aspects of care and assistance for children with cancer . J Pediatr Oncol Nurs2000; 17: 239-249 .
63.
Boylan P.Children’s voices project. Feedback from children and young people about their experience and expectations of health care. London: Commission for Health Improvement , 2004. Retrieved 19 November, 2004 from: http://www.chi.nhs.uk/childrens_voices/index.shtml.
