Government policy in post-1994 South Africa, whilst upholding the principles of
community participation and development, has been firmly wedded to a neoliberal
growth agenda. This paper critically examines whether one element of that new growth
agenda, that of Spatial Development Initiatives, has catalysed both
‘bottom-up’ development and also meaningfully assisted
micro-entrepreneurs through more ‘top-down’ interventions. The
paper focuses on two specific projects, namely the Saldanha Steel Plant and the
Paternoster Fish Market, which have been components of a Spatial Development
Initiative in the Western Cape. The serious constraints faced by communities in
engaging with opportunities for socio-economic upliftment is clearly a cause for
concern, and it is suggested that a careful re-evaluation of South
Africa’s development paradigm is urgently required.
African National Congress (ANC)1994: The reconstruction and development programme: A policy
framework.
Johannesburg: Umananyo
.
2.
African National Congress (ANC)1997: Understanding GEAR; growth, employment and
redistribution. Available at:
http://www.policy.org.za/ancdocs/pubs/gear.html (last accessed 29
September 1999).
3.
Allen, C.2001:
Coega and the arms deal
. Mail and Guardian, 27 July 2001. Online. Available: at
http://www.sn.apc.org/wmail/issues/010727/OTHER20.html (last accessed 29
July 2001).
4.
Arkwright, D.
,
de Beer, G.
and
Mmatali, R.
1998:
Spatial development initiatives in South Africa - progress achieved and
future objectives
. Paper presented at Southern Africa Political Economy Series
(SAPES) Trust Colloquium, September,
Harare, Zimbabwe.
5.
Bek, D.
and
Taylor, I.2001: Evaluation of spatial development initiatives: case studies of
the Maputo development corridor and the west coast investment initiative.
Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town
, Working Paper 52, http://www.uct.ac.za/depts/dpru/wp52.htm
(last accessed 5 April 2003).
6.
Binns, T.
and
Nel, E.1999:
Beyond the development impasse: the role of local economic development and
community self-reliance in rural South Africa
. Journal of Modern African Studies37(3),
389-408
.
7.
Binns, T.
and
Nel, E.2002a:
Supporting local economic development in post-apartheid South Africa
. Local Economy17 (1),
8-24
.
8.
Binns, T.
and
Nel, E.2002b:
Devolving development: integrated development planning and developmental
local government in post-apartheid South Africa
. Regional Studies36 (8),
921-932
.
9.
Bond, P.2001: Against global apartheid: South Africa meets the World Bank,
IMF and international finance.
Cape Town: University of Cape Town Press
.
10.
Bond, P.2002: Unsustainable South Africa: environment, development and
social protest.
London: Merlin Press
.
11.
Budlender, D.
and
Shapiro, J.2001: West Coast Investment Initiative. Unpublished report
commissioned by the
Department of Trade and Industry and the Development Bank of South Africa
.
12.
Clarke, C.
and
Howard, D.1999Cities, capitalism and neoliberal regimes. In
Gywnne, R. N.
and
Kay, C.
, editors, Latin America transformed.
London: Arnold
, 305-325.
13.
Cochrane, M. 1999: Local linkages in a globalising environment: community
experiences in South Africa’s west coast peninsula. Royal Holloway,
University of London, unpublished MA dissertation.
14.
Corbridge, S.1995: Development studies: a reader.
London: Edward Arnold
.
15.
Crush, J.
and
Rogerson, C.2001:
New industrial spaces: evaluating South Africa’s spatial
development initiatives (SDI) programme
. The South African Geographical Journal83 (2),
85-92
.
16.
Department of Finance2000: Annual report.
Pretoria: Department of Finance
.
17.
Department of Trade and Industry, South Africa (DTI)1998: Spatial development initiatives (SDI) programme,
DTI, Pretoria
, unpublished document.
18.
Department of Trade and Industry, South Africa (DTI)2000: How SDIs work.
DTI, Pretoria
, unpublished document.
19.
Desai, V.
and
Potter, R. B.2001: The Arnold companion to development studies.
London: Arnold
.
20.
du Toit, J.1998: The structure of the South African economy.
Johannesburg, Halfway House: Southern Books
.
21.
Escobar, A.1992: Planning. In
Sachs, W.
, editor, The development dictionary: a guide to knowledge as
power.
London: Zed Books
, 132-145.
22.
Fitschen, A.1998:
The impact of the Saldanha steel project on the west coast economy
. Development Southern Africa15 (5),
771-785
.
23.
Fitschen, A.2001: Not another steel plant. Online. Available at:
http://www.businessday.co.za/bday/content/direct/1,3523,816290-6078-0,00.html
(last accessed 3 May 2001).
24.
Gwynne, R. N.
and
Silva, E.1999: The political economy of sustainable development.
In Gywnne, R.N. and Kay, C. Latin America transformed.
London: Arnold
, 153-179.
25.
Howorth, C.
and
O’Keefe, P.1998: Spatial development initiatives: a development approach in
post-apartheid south and southern Africa.
University of Northumbria at Newcastle, Division of Geography and
Environmental Management Department
, Occasional Papers, New Series 24.
26.
Howorth, C.
,
O’Keefe, P.
and
Moyo, S.1999: Spatial development issues in southern Africa: current
progress.
University of Northumbria at Newcastle, Division of Geography and
Environmental Management Department
, Occasional Papers, New Series 32.
27.
Industrial Development Corporation (IDC)2000: Annual report.
Sandton: IDC
.
28.
Jourdan, P.1998:
Spatial development initiatives (SDIs) - the official view
. Development Southern Africa15 (5),
717-726
.
29.
Jourdan, P.
,
Gordhan, K.
,
Arkwright, D.
and
de Beer, G.1997: Spatial development initiatives (development corridors): their
potential contribution to investment and employment creation.
DTI, Pretoria
, unpublished paper.
30.
Kenny, B.
and
Webster, E.1998:
Eroding the core: flexibility and the re-segmentation of the South African
labour market
. Critical Sociology24 (3),
216-243
.
31.
Kepe, T.2001:
Clearing the ground in the Spatial Development Initiatives (SDIs):
analysing process on South Africa’s Wild Coast
. Development Southern Africa18 (3),
279-293
.
32.
Kepe, T.
,
Ntsebeza, L.
and
Cousins, B.1998: It’s not too late for the Wild Coast.
Mail and Guardian, Johannesburg
. Online. Available at:
http://web.sn.apc.orgwmailissues980529NEWS36.html (last accessed 31
January 2001).
33.
KPMG1999: Paternoster tourism development, phase one: appraisal of
tourism potential and development.
KPMG, Client Final Draft
.
34.
Lester, A.
,
Binns, T.
and
Nel, E. L.2000: South Africa, past, present, and future: gold at the end of
the rainbow?Harlow: Pearson
.
35.
Lewis, D.
and
Bloch, R.1998:
SDIs: infrastructure, agglomeration and the region in industrial policy
. Development Southern Africa15 (5),
727-755
.
36.
Liebenberg, L.1999: The IDP experience: an analysis of two Western Cape
processes.
Cape Town: Foundation for Contemporary Research
.
37.
Lipton, M.
2000:
The role of business in South Africa: confronting a painful past;
contributing to a challenging future
. Unpublished report of a conference at Sussex
University, 12-13 July 2000.
38.
Mail and Guardian1998: The plain English guide to SDIs and IDZs. Online.
Available at: http://web.sn.apc.org/wmail/issues/980918/BUS110.html (last
accessed 3 March 2000).
39.
Marais, H.2001: South Africa: limits to change: the political economy of
transition. 2nd edition.
London: Zed Books
.
40.
May, J.
, editor 2000: Poverty and inequality in South Africa: meeting
the challenge.
London: Zed
.
41.
McEwan, C.2002: Postcolonialism. In
Potter, R.
, editor, The companion to development studies.
London: Arnold
, 127-130.
42.
McEwan, C.2003:
Bringing government to the people: women, local governance and community
participation in South Africa
. Geoforum, in press.
43.
Mhlati, V.
and
Jourdan, P.1998: Nothing wild about SDI strategy.
Mail and Guardian, Johannesburg
. Online. Available at:
htt://pweb.sn.apc.orgwnwmailissues980515NEWS34.html (last accessed 31
January 2002).
44.
Moloi, D.1998:
There’s logic in SDIs, but
.... Land and Rural Digest1 (1),
15-17
.
45.
Myburgh, M.2001: No work on the wild side. Online. Available at:
http://www.sn.apc.org/wmail/issues/010629/OTHER63.html (last accessed 10
October 2001).
46.
National Business Initiative (NBI)1999: Annual report 1998/9.
Johannesburg: NBI
.
47.
Nel, E.
and
Binns, T.2001:
Initiating ‘develop-mental local government’ in South
Africa: evolving local economic development policy
. Regional Studies35 (4),
355-362
.
48.
Nel, E. L.1999: Regional and local economic development in South Africa: the
experience of the Eastern Cape.
Aldershot: Ashgate
.
49.
Pape, J.2001: Spatial development initiatives and industrial development
zones - part of the solution or part of the problem?International Labour Information and Research Group, University of
Cape Town
.
50.
Platzky, L.
1998:
Can South Africa’s new spatial development initiatives turn
cumulative disadvantages into competitive advantages?
Paper presented at seminar, Durham University,
28th May 1998.
51.
Platzky, L.
2000:
Reconstructing and developing South Africa: The role of spatial development initiatives
. Paper presented at International Conference on Sustainable
Regional Development, 28 October,
University of Massachusetts, Lowell.
52.
Rahnema, M.
and
Bawtree, V.1997: The post-development reader.
London: Zed
.
53.
Republic of South Africa (RSA)1998: The white paper on local government.
Pretoria: RSA
.
54.
Rogerson, C.2002:
Spatial development initiatives in South Africa
. Geography87 (1):
38-48
.
55.
Sachs, W.1992: The development dictionary: a guide to knowledge as
power.
London: Zed
.
Sidaway, J.2002: Post-development. In
Desai, V.
and
Potter, R.
, editors, The companion to development studies.
London: Arnold
, 16-20.
58.
Simon, D.2001:
Trading spaces: imagining and positioning the ‘new’
South Africa within the regional and global economies
. International Affairs77 (2),
377-405
.
59.
Simon, D.2002: Postmodernism and development. In
Desai, V.
and
Potter, R.
, editors, The companion to development studies.
London: Arnold
, 121-126.
60.
Soderbaum, F.2001: Institutional aspects of the Maputo development
corridor.
Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town
, Working Paper 47, http://www.uct.ac.za/depts/dpru/wp47.htm
(last accessed 5 April 2003).
61.
Söderbaum, F.
and
Taylor, I.2001:
Transmission belt for transnational capital or facilitator for development?
Problematising the role of the state in the Maputo Development Corridor
. The Journal of Modern African Studies39 (4),
675-695
.
62.
Statistics South Africa1999: Annual report. Available at:
http://www.statssa.gov.za./Archives/Publications/AnnualReport/AA-rep99.zip.s
(last accessed 10 October 2000).
63.
Statistics South Africa2002: Consumer price index. Statistics Release P0141.1.
Online. Available at: www.statssa.gov.za/default3.asp (last accessed 24
January 2003).
64.
Stohr, W. B.
and
Taylor, D. R. F.
, editors, 1981: Development from above or below?Chichester: John Wiley
.
65.
Sunday Times2000: The Sunday Times.
Johannesburg: Times Media Ltd.
66.
Taylor, I.2001: Public private partnerships: lessons from the Maputo
development corridor toll road.
Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town
, Working Paper 44, http://www.uct.ac.za/depts/dpru/wp44.htm
(last accessed 5 April 2003).
67.
Time Magazine 1999: 24 May.
68.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)2001: Country factsheet: South Africa in world investment report
2001: promoting linkages. Online. Available at:
http://www.unctad.org/wir/pdfs/wir01fs_za.en.pdf (last accessed 10
October 2001).
69.
Waddell, A.1998: Nelson Mandela’s keynote address to the WCII
Investors Conference, Saldanha Academy. Online. Available at:
http://www.westcoast.org.za (last accessed 10 June 2000).
70.
West Coast Investment Initiative (WCII)
1997:
West Coast investment initiative appraisal document
. WCII: document produced for Investors Conference26-27 February 1998.
71.
West Coast Investment Initiative (WCII)2000: West Coast investment initiative (WCII) integration
strategy.
Provincial Government of the Western Cape
: unpublished internal document.
