Multi-echelon inventory management in supply chains with uncertain demand and lead times: Literature review from an operational research perspective

Abstract

Historically, the echelons of the supply chain, warehouse, distributors, retailers, etc., have been managed independently, buffered by large inventories. Increasing competitive pressures and market globalization are forcing firms to develop supply chains that can quickly respond to customer needs. To remain competitive and decrease inventory, these firms must use multi-echelon inventory management interactively, while reducing operating costs and improving customer service. The current paper reviews the literature, addressing multiechelon inventory management in supply chains from 1996 to 2005. The behaviour of the papers against demand and lead-time uncertainty is the key analysis point of the literature review presented here and it is conducted from an operational research point of view. Finally, directions for future research are suggested.

Keywords

supply chain multi-echelon inventory management demand uncertainty leadtime uncertainty

References

Minner

Multiple-supplier inventory models in supply chain management: A review

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 81–82, 265–279.

Routroy

Kodali

Differential evolution algorithm for supply chain inventory planning

J. Mfg Technol. Mgmt, 2005, 16(1), 7–17.

Simchi-Levi

Kaminsky

Simchi-Levi

Designing and managing the supply chain, 2000 (Irwin McGraw-Hill, Boston, MA).

Arnold

J. R. T.

Introduction to materials management, 1998 (Prentice Hall, USA).

Giannoccaro

Pontrandolfo

Scozzi

A fuzzy echelon approach for inventory management in supply chains

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2003, 149, 185–196.

Ganeshan

Managing supply chain inventories: A multiple retailer, one warehouse, multiple supplier model

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 1999, 59, 341–354.

Towill

D. R.

Industrial dynamics modeling of supply chains

Logistics Inf. Mgmt, 1996, 9, 43–56.

Rau

M.-Y.

Wee

H.-M.

Integrated inventory model for deteriorating items under a multi-echelon supply chain environment

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 86, 155–168.

Diks

E. B.

de Kok

A. G.

Optimal control of a divergent multi-echelon inventory system

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1998, 111, 75–97.

10.

Chiang

W. K.

Monahan

G. E.

Managing inventories in a two-echelon dual-channel supply chain

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2005, 162, 325–341.

11.

Moinzadeh

Aggarwal

P. K.

An information based multiechelon inventory system with emergency orders

Ops Res., 1997, 45(5), 694.

12.

Kalchschmidt

Zotteri

Verganti

Inventory management in a multi-echelon spare parts supply chain

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 81–82, 397–413.

13.

Clark

Scarf

Optimal policies for a multi-echelon inventory problem

Mgmt Sci., 1960, 6, 475–490.

14.

Bollapragada

Akella

Srinivasan

Centralized ordering and allocation policies in a two-echelon system with non-identical warehouses

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1998, 106, 74–81.

15.

Tee

Y. S.

Rossetti

M. D.

A robustness study of a multi-echelon inventory model via simulation

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2002, 80, 265–277.

16.

Dong

Lee

H. L.

Optimal policies and approximations for a serial multiechelon inventory system with time-correlated demand

Ops Res., 2003, 51(6), 969.

17.

van der Vorst

J. G. A. J.

Beulens

A. J. M.

van Beek

Modelling and simulating multi-echelon food systems

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2000, 122, 354–366.

18.

Bessler

S. A.

Veinott

A. F.

Optimal policy for a dynamic multi-echelon inventory model

Naval Res. Logistics Q., 1965, 13(4), 355–389.

19.

Eppen

Schrage

Centralized ordering policies in a multi-warehouse system with lead times and random demand. Multi-level production-inventory control systems: Theory and practice (Ed. Schwarz

L. B.

), 1981 (North-Holland, Amsterdam).

20.

van der Heijden

M. C.

Multi-echelon inventory control in divergent systems with shipping frequencies

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1999, 116, 331–351.

21.

Rosenbaum

B. A.

Service level relationships in a multiechelon inventory system

Mgmt Sci., 1981, 27(8), 926–945.

22.

Federgruen

Zipkin

Computational issues in an infinite-horizon, multi-echelon inventory model

Ops. Res., 1984, 32, 818–836.

23.

Schwarz

L. B.

Deuermeyer

B. L.

Badinelli

R. D.

Fill rate optimization in a one-warehouse N-identical retailer distribution system

Mgmt Sci., 1985, 31(4), 488–498.

24.

Jackson

P. L.

Stock allocation in a two-echelon distribution system or “what to do until your ship comes in”

Mgmt Sci., 1988, 34, 880–895.

25.

Jackson

P. L.

Muckstadt

J. A.

Risk pooling in a two-period, two-echelon inventory stocking and allocation problem

Naval Res. Logistic Q., 1989, 36(1), 1–26.

26.

Erkip

Hausman

W. H.

Nahmias

Optimal centralized ordering policies in multi-echelon inventory systems with correlated demands

Mgmt Sci., 1990, 36(3), 381–392.

27.

Axsater

Simple solution procedures for a class of two-echelon inventory problems

Ops Res., 1990, 38, 1, 64.

28.

Verrijdt

J. H. C. M.

de Kok

A. G.

Distribution planning for a divergent depotless two-echelon network under service constraints

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1996, 89, 341–354.

29.

Thomas

D. J.

Griffin

P. M.

Coordinated supply chain management

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1996, 94, 1–15.

30.

Parker

R. P.

Kapuscinski

Optimal policies for a capacitated two-echelon inventory system

Ops Res., 2004, 52(5), 739.

31.

Hadley

Whitin

T. M.

Analysis of inventory systems, 1963 (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).

32.

Sherbrooke

C. C.

Metric: A multi-echelon technique for recoverable item control

Ops Res., 1968, 16, 122–141.

33.

Sherbrooke

C. C.

Optimal inventory modeling of systems-multi-echelon techniques, 1992 (John Wiley & Sons, New York).

34.

Moinzadeh

Lee

H. L.

Batch size and stocking levels in multi-echel on repairable systems

Mgmt Sci., 1986, 32, 1567–1591.

35.

Svoronos

Zipkin

Estimating the performance of multi-level inventory systems

Ops Res., 1988, 36, 57–72.

36.

Nahmias

Smith

S. A.

Optimizing inventory levels in a two-echelon retailer system with partial lost sales

Mgmt Sci., 1994, 40, 582–596.

37.

Aggarwal

P. K.

Moinzadeh

Order expedition in multi-echelon production/distribution systems

IIE Trans., 1994, 26, 86–96.

38.

Pyke

D. F.

Priority repair and dispatch policies for repairable-item logistics systems

Naval Res. Logistics, 1990, 37, 1–30.

39.

Dada

A two-echelon inventory system with priority shipments

Mgmt Sci., 1992, 38, 1140–1153.

40.

Alfredsson

Verrijdt

Modeling emergency supply flexibility in a two-echelon inventory system

Mgmt Sci., 1999, 45, 1416–1431.

41.

Seferlis

Giannelos

G. F.

A two-layered optimisation-based control strategy for multi-echelon supply chain networks

Computers Chem. Engng, 2004, 28, 799–809.

42.

Andersson

Melchiors

A two-echelon inventory model with lost sales

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2001, 69, 307–315.

43.

Axsater

Approximate optimization of a two-level distribution inventory system

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 81–82, 545–553.

44.

Silver

E. A.

Pyke

D. F.

Peterson

Inventory management and production planning and scheduling, third edition, 1998 (John Wiley, New York).

45.

Mitra

Chatterjee

A. K.

Echelon stock based continuous review (R;Q) policy for fast moving items. Omega, 2004a, 32, 161–166.

46.

Hariga

A single-period, multi-echelon stochastic model under a mix of assemble to order and assemble in advance policies

Naval Res. Logistics, 1998, 45, 599–614.

47.

Chen

Worst-case analysis of (R;Q) policies in a two-stage serial inventory system with deterministic demand and backlogging

Ops Res. Lett., 1999, 25, 51–58.

48.

Axsater

Zhang

W.-F.

A joint replenishment policy for multi-echelon inventory control

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 1999, 59, 243–250.

49.

Nozick

L. K.

Turnquist

M. A.

A two echelon inventory allocation and distribution center location analysis

Transpn Res., Part E, 2001, 37, 425–441.

50.

K. C.

Zheng

Impact of supplier's lead-time and forecast demand updating on retailer's order quantity variability in a two-level supply chain

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 86, 169–179.

51.

Forsberg

Exact evaluation of (R, Q)-policies for two-level inventory systems with Poisson demand

Eur. J. Opl Res., 1996, 96, 130–138.

52.

Graves

S. C.

A Multiechelon inventory model with fixed replenisment intervals

Mgt Sci., 1996, 32(1), 1.

53.

Mohebbi

Posner

M. J. M.

Sole versus dual sourcing in a continuous-review inventory system with lost sales

Computers Ind. Engng, 1998, 34(2), 321–336.

54.

Dekker

Kleijn

M. J.

de Kok

A. G.

The break quantity rule's effect on inventory costs in a 1-warehouse, N-retailers distribution system

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 1998, 56–57, 61–68.

55.

Korugan

Gupta

S. M.

A multi-echelon inventory system with returns

Computers Ind. Engng, 1998, 35(1–2), 145–148.

56.

van der Heijden

M. C.

Diks

de Kok

Inventory control in multi-echelon divergent systems with random lead times

OR Spektrum, 1999, 21, 331–359.

57.

Andersson

Marklund

Decentralized inventory control in a two-level distribution system

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2000, 127, 483–506.

58.

Cachon

G. P.

Fisher

Supply chain inventory management and the value of shared information

Mgmt Sci., 2000, 46(8), 1032–1048.

59.

Axsater

Exact analysis of continuous review (R,Q) policies in two-echelon inventory systems with compound Poisson demand

Ops Res., 2000, 48(5), 686–696.

60.

Axsater

Scaling down multi-echelon inventory problems. Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2001(b), 71, 255–261.

61.

Tsiakis

Shah

Pantelides

C. C.

Design of multi-echelon supply chain networks under demand uncertainty

Ind. Engng. Chem. Res., 2001, 40, 3585–3604.

62.

Moinzadeh

A multiechelon inventory system with informaton exchange

Mgmt Sci., 2002, 48(3), 414.

63.

Tang

Grubbström

R. W.

The detailed coordination problem in a two-level assembly system with stochastic lead times

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2003, 81–82, 415–429.

64.

Chiu

H. N.

Huang

H. L.

A multi-echelon integrated JIT inventory model using the time buffer and emergency borrowing policies to deal with random delivery lead times

Int. J. Prod. Res., 2003, 41(13), 2911–2931.

65.

Mitra

Chatterjee

A. K.

Leveraging information in multi-echelon inventory systems. Eur. J. Opl Res., 2004(b), 152, 263–280.

66.

Chen

C.-L.

Lee

W.-C.

Optimization of multi echelon supply chain networks with uncertain sales prices. J. Chem. Engng Jap., 2004(b), 37(7), 822–834.

67.

Jalbar

B. A.

Gutierrez

J. M.

Sicilia

Single cycle policies for the one-warehouse N-retailer inventory/distribution system. Omega, 2005(a), in press.

68.

Seifbarghy

Jokar

M. R. A.

Cost evaluation of a two-echelon inventory system with lost sales and approximately Poisson demand. Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2005, in press.

69.

Han

Damrongwongsiri

Stochastic modeling of a two-echelon multiple sourcing supply chain system with genetic algorithm

J. Mfg Technol. Mgmt, 2005, 16(1), 87–108.

70.

Axsater

Forsberg

Zhang

W.-F.

Approximating general multi-echelon inventory systems by Poisson models

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 1994, 35, 201–206.

71.

Jönsson

Silver

E. A.

Analysis of a two-echelon inventory control system with complete redistribution

Mgmt Sci., 1987, 33, 215–227.

72.

Dekker

Frenk

J. B. G.

Kleijn

M. J.

de Kok

A. G.

Piersma

On the use of break quantities in multi-echelon distribution systems. Inventory Modelling (Ed. Bogataj

), Lecture Notes of the International Postgraduate Summer School, vol. 1, Budapest, ISIR, 1995.

73.

Wang

Cohen

M. A.

Zheng

Y.-S.

A two-echelon repairable inventory system with stocking-center-dependent depot replenishment lead times

Mgmt Sci., 2000, 46(11), 1441–1453.

74.

Iida

The infinite horizon non-stationary stochastic multi-echelon inventory problem and near-myopic policies

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2001, 134, 525–539.

75.

Chen

Song

J. S.

Optimal policies for multiechelon inventory problems with Markov-modulated demand

Ops Res., 2001, 49(2), 226.

76.

Chen

F. Y.

Feng

Simchi-Levi

Uniform distribution of inventory positions in two-echelon periodic review systems with batch-ordering policies and interdependent demands

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2002, 140, 648–654.

77.

Minner

Diks

E. B.

de Kok

A. G.

A two-echelon inventory system with supply lead time flexibility

IIE Trans., 2003, 35, 117–129.

78.

Johansen

S. G.

Base-stock policies for the lost sales inventory system with Poisson demand and Erlangian lead times

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2005, 93–94, 429–437.

79.

W. K.

Piplani

Viswanathan

Simulation workbench for analysing multi-echelon supply chains

Integrated Mfg Syst., 2003, 14(5), 449.

80.

Martel

Policies for multi-echelon supply; DRP systems with probabilistic time-varying demands

ABI/INFORM Global, 2003, INFOR 41(1), 71.

81.

Kiesmüller

G. P.

de Kok

T. G.

Smits

S. R.

van Laarhoven

P. J. M.

Evaluation of divergent N-echelon (s,nQ)-policies under compound renewal demand

OR Spectrum, 2004, 26, 547–577.

82.

Liberopoulos

Koukoumialos

Tradeoffs between base stock levels, numbers of Kanbans, and planned supply lead times in production/inventory systems with advance demand information. Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2005, in press.

83.

Axsater

A Framework for decentralized multiechelon inventory control. IIE Trans., 2001(a), 33, 91–97.

84.

Lau

A. H. L.

Lau

H.-S.

Effects of a demand-curve's shape on the optimal solutions of a multi-echelon inventory/pricing model

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2003, 147, 530–548.

85.

Yoo

Y.-J.

Kim

W.-S.

Rhee

J. T.

Efficient inventory management in multi-echelon distribution systems

Computers Ind. Engng, 1997, 33(3–4), 729–732.

86.

Jalbar

B. A.

Gutierrez

J. M.

Sicilia

Integer-ratio policies for distribution/inventory systems. Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2005(b), 93–94, 407–415.

87.

Liang

W.-Y.

Huang

C. C.

Agent-based demand forecast in multi-echelon supply chain. Decision Support Systems, 2005, in press.

88.

Köchel

Nielander

Simulation-based optimisation of multi-echelon inventory systems

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2005, 93–94, 505–513.

89.

Sleptchenko

van der Heijden

M. C.

van Harten

Effects of finite repair capacity in multiechelon, multi-indenture service part supply systems

Int. J. Prod. Econ., 2002, 79, 209–230.

90.

Braun

M.W.

Rivera

D. E.

Flores

M. E.

Carlyle

W.M.

Kempf

K. G.

A model predictive control framework for robust management of multi-product, multi-echelon demand networks

Ann. Rev. Control, 2003, 27, 229–245.

91.

Chen

C.-L.

Lee

W.-C.

Multi-objective optimization of multi-echelon supply chain networks with uncertain product demands and prices. Computers Chem. Engng, 2004(a), 28, 1131–1144.

92.

Chandra

Grabis

Application of multi-steps forecasting for restraining the bullwhip effect improving inventory performance under autoregressive demand

Eur. J. Opl Res., 2005, 166, 337–350.