Study of the correlation between the performances of lunar vehicle wheels predicted by the Nepean wheeled vehicle performance model and test data

Abstract

This paper describes the results of a study of the correlation between the performances of wheels for lunar vehicles predicted using the Nepean wheeled vehicle performance model (NWVPM), developed under the auspices of Vehicle Systems Development Corporation, Ottawa, Canada, and the corresponding test data presented in ‘Performance evaluation of wheels for lunar vehicles’, Technical Report M-70-2, prepared for George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), USA, by the US Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station (WES). The NWVPM was originally developed for design and performance evaluation of terrestrial off-road wheeled vehicles. The purpose of this study is to assess the potential of the NWVPM for evaluating wheel candidates for the new generation of extra-terrestrial vehicles. Two versions of a wire-mesh wheel and a hoop-spring wheel, which were considered as candidates for lunar roving vehicles for the NASA Apollo program in the late 1960s, together with a pneumatic wheel were examined in this study. The tractive performances of these wheels and of a 4×4 test vehicle with the pneumatic wheels on air-dry sand were predicted using the NWVPM and compared with the corresponding test data obtained under Earth's gravity and previously documented in the above-named report. While test data on wheel or vehicle performances obtained under Earth's gravity may not necessarily be representative of those on extra-terrestrial bodies, because of the differences in gravity and in environmental conditions, such as atmospheric pressure, it is still a valid approach to use test data obtained under Earth's gravity to evaluate the predictive capability of the NWVPM and its potential applications to predicting wheel or wheeled rover performances on extra-terrestrial bodies. Results of this study show that, using the ratio (P₂₀/W) of the drawbar pull to normal load at 20 per cent slip as a performance indicator, there is a reasonable correlation between the predictions and experimental data. This indicates that the NWVPM has the potential as an engineering tool for evaluating wheel candidates for a future generation of extra-terrestrial vehicles, provided that appropriate input data are available.

Keywords

correlation study lunar vehicle wheels simulation models terrestrial and extra-terrestrial vehicles tractive performance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asnani

V. M.

Delap

D. C.

Creager

C. M.

The development of wheels for the Lunar Roving Vehicle. J. Terramechanics, 2008 (submitted).

Wong

J. Y.

Reece

A. R.

Soil failure beneath rigid wheels. In Proceedings of the Second International Conference of the International Society for Terrain-Vehicle Systems, Toronto, Canada, 1966, pp. 425–445 (University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Ontario, Canada).

Onafeko

Reece

A. R.

Soil stress and deformations beneath rigid wheels. J. Terramechanics, 1967, 4(1), 59–80.

Wong

J. Y.

Reece

A. R.

Prediction of rigid wheel performance based on the analysis of soil- wheel stresses, part I. Performance of driven rigid wheels. J. Terramechanics, 1967, 4(1), 81–98.

Wong

J. Y.

Reece

A. R.

Prediction of rigid wheel performance based on the analysis of soil- wheel stresses, part II. Performance of towed rigid wheels. J. Terramechanics, 1967, 4(2), 7–25.

Wong

J. Y.

Behaviour of soil beneath rigid wheels. J. Agric. Engng Res., 1967, 12(4), 257–269.

Iagnemma

Kang

Brooks

Dubowsky

Multi-sensor terrain estimation for planetary rovers. In Proceedings of the Seventh International Symposium on Artificial Intelligence, Robotics and Automation in Space (i-SAIRAS 2003), Nara, Japan, 19–23 May 2003.

Yoshida

Watanabe

Mizuno

Ishigami

Slip, traction control, and navigation of a lunar rover. In Proceedings of the Seventh International Symposium on Artificial Intelligence, Robotics and Automation in Space (i-SAIRAS 2003), Nara, Japan, 19–23 May 2003.

Shibly

Iagnemma

Dubowsky

An equivalent soil mechanics formulation for rigid wheels in deformable terrain, with application to planetary exploration rovers. J. Terramechanics, 2005, 42(1), 1–13.

10.

Wong

J. Y.

Theory of ground vehicles, 4th edition, 2008 (John Wiley, New York).

11.

Wong

J. Y.

Terramechanics and off-road vehicles, 1989 (Elsevier, Amsterdam).

12.

Bekker

M. G.

Introduction to terrain-vehicle systems, 1969 (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, Michigan).

13.

Bekker

M. G.

Semonin

E. V.

Motion resistance of pneumatic tyres. J. Automotive Engineering, 1975, 6(2), 6–10.

14.

Bekker

M. G.

The effect of tire tread in parametric analysis of tire-soil system. Report 24146, National Research Council of Canada, January 1985.

15.

Freitag

D. R.

Green

A. J.

Melzer

K.-J.

Performance evaluation of wheels for lunar vehicles. Technical Report M-70-2 prepared for George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), USA, by US Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, Mississippi, USA, March 1970.

16.

Cowart

E. G.

Lunar roving vehicle: Spacecraft on wheels. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs., 1973, 187, 463–491.

17.

Wong

J. Y.

Huang

Wheel vs. tracks - a fundamental evaluation from the traction perspective. J. Terramechanics, 2006, 43(1), 27–42.

18.

Wong

J. Y.

Optimization of the tractive performance of four-wheel-drive off-road vehicles. SAE Trans., 1970, 79, 2238–2246.

19.

Wong

J. Y.

McLaughlin

N. B.

Knezevic

Burtt

Optimization of the tractive performance of four-wheel-drive tractors: Theoretical analysis and experimental substantiation. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part D: J. Automobile Engineering, 1998, 212(4), 285–297.

20.

Wong

J. Y.

Zhao

McLaughlin

N. B.

Burtt

Optimization of the tractive performance of four-wheel-drive tractors - correlation between analytical predictions and experimental data. SAE Trans. 2000, 109, section 2, J. Commercial Veh., SAE paper 2000–01-2596, 2000.