Measuring axial forces in rail by forced vibrations: experiences from a full-scale laboratory experiment

Abstract

The longitudinal load in rail caused by thermal expansion must be regularly monitored in order to avoid buckling or rail fracture. Different methods of monitoring with benefits and drawbacks are used or suggested. In this paper one of the proposed methods is investigated by a full-scale experiment. The aim is to measure the change in wavelength of the bending wave caused by the longitudinal load. In contrast to other vibration methods, this method does not require knowledge of the boundary conditions. However, it requires very accurate measurements, advanced finite element (FE) calculations, and sophisticated data analyses. The full-scale experiment shows that this is a method with potential. On the basis of the results of the full-scale experiment the required accuracy of the different steps in the method are clarified. Influence of measurement accuracy, loosened clamps at the sleepers, FE mesh size, degree of wear of the rail, and inaccuracy in the material parameters is considered.

Keywords

rail lateral stability thermal expansion stress-free temperature forced vibration guided wave full-scale experiment longitudinal load

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kontroll av spänningsfri temperatur. Statute book BVF586.10, Swedish National Railway Administration, Sweden, 1995.

VERSE. Non-destructive stress-free temperature measuring system, brochure, Vortok International & AEA Technology Rail, Plymouth, UK, 2007.

Kish

Kalay

Hazell

Schoengart

Samavedam

‘Rail longitudinal force measurement evaluation studies using the track loading vehicle’

Am. Railw. Eng. Assoc. Bull. 742 (1993): 315–342.

Szelazek

‘Monitoring of thermal stresses in continuously welded rails with ultrasonic technique’

NDTnet 36 1998, 3(6).

European Rail Research Institute. Improved knowledge of forces in CWR track (including switches). Long term investigations of CWR track behaviour. ERRI report D202/RP8, April 1999.

European Rail Research Institute. Improved knowledge of forces in CWR track (including switches). Methods for non-destructive measurements of forces in CWR track, summary. ERRI report D202/RP9, April 1999.

Hauk

Structural and residual stress Analysis by non-destructive methods (The Netherlands: Elsevier 1997).

Towpik

‘Variability of stress and longitudinal force distributed in continuous welded rail tracks’

Arch. Civil Eng. 524 (2006): 701–709.

European Rail Research Institute. Improved knowledge of forces in CWR track (including switches). Measurements of lateral distance, longitudinal resistance and change of neutral temperature for ballasted track. ERRI report D202/DT363, vol. 1, October 1997.

10.

European Rail Research Institute. Improved knowledge of forces in CWR track (including switches). Empirical research of CWR long-term behaviour. ERRI report D202/DT364, November 1997.

11.

Harrison

H. D.

McCanney

T. O.

Doll

L. L.

‘Wayside system for measuring rail longitudinal force due to thermal expansion of continuous welded rail’

SPIE Proc. 2458 (1995): 225–231.

12.

Mau

Rail neutral temperature measurement. In Proceedings of the 6th International Heavy Haul Conference, South Africa, 6–10 April 1997.

13.

European Rail Research Institute. Improved knowledge of forces in CWR track (including switches). Theory of CWR track stability. ERRI report D202/RP3, February 1995.

14.

Livingston

Béliveau

J. G.

Huston

D. R.

‘Estimation of axial load in prismatic members using flexural vibrations’

J. Sound Vibr. 1795 (1995): 899–908.

15.

Béliveau

J. G.

Resonant frequencies of lateral vibrations in rail in compression. In Proceedings of the 1997 Annual Conference of Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, Sherbrooke, Quebec, 27–30 May 1997, vol. 4, pp. 389–398.

16.

Lancaster

Rozsa

‘Spectrum and stability of a vibrating rail supported by sleepers’

Comput. Math. Appl. 314–5 (1996): 201–213.

17.

Damljanović

Weaver

R. L.

‘Laser vibrometry technique for measurement of contained stress in railroad rail’

J. Sound Vibr. 282 (2005): 341–366.

18.

Damljanović

Guided waves technique for measurement of contained stress in uniform slender elastic bodies (2003) Doctoral Thesis, University of Urbana-Champaign, State, US, 2003.

19.

Feng

Wilcox

P. D.

‘The effect of load on guided wave propagation’

Ultrason. 471–4 (2007): 111–122.

20.

Damljanović

Weaver

R. L.

‘Propagating and evanescent elastic waves in cylindrical waveguides of arbitrary cross section’

J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 1154 (2004): 1572–1581.

21.

Damljanović

Weaver

R. L.

‘Forced response of a cylindrical waveguide with simulation of the wavenumber extraction problem’

J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 1154 (2004): 1582–1591.